RMF Security Control Testing Hands On (Using SP 800-53 and 800-53A)

KamilSec
26 Dec 202082:47
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis script outlines a comprehensive approach to control testing, emphasizing the importance of examining documentation, testing configuration settings, and interviewing personnel. It details the process of planning, executing, and documenting tests for various controls, highlighting the need for thoroughness and clarity in assessments.

Takeaways
  • πŸ˜€ The process of control testing involves examining control artifacts, testing configurations, and interviewing personnel within the organization.
  • πŸ” When examining documentation, the term 'examine if' is used to denote the verification of control artifacts related to documentation.
  • πŸ–₯️ For configuration settings, the term 'testing' is used to refer to the verification of control artifacts that involve system settings or screenshots.
  • πŸ—£οΈ The term 'interview' is used when personnel within the organization are interviewed as part of the control testing process.
  • πŸ“š The importance of understanding the language and presentation of results in control testing is emphasized, as it is crucial for effective communication of findings.
  • 🚫 A disclaimer is provided regarding the use of proprietary information in teaching, highlighting the limitations in accessing and utilizing certain evidence for educational purposes.
  • πŸ“ˆ The concept of the 'test case' or 'requirement traceability metric' is introduced as a key document in the control testing process.
  • πŸ”‘ The assignment of controls to testers is based on their level of technical expertise, with senior testers handling more technical controls and junior testers focusing on operational and management controls.
  • πŸ“‚ The organization of test cases and evidence in a structured manner, such as in a SharePoint folder, is crucial for efficient testing and review.
  • πŸ” The detailed examination of access control policies and procedures is highlighted, emphasizing the need to verify that all aspects of the control are adequately addressed in the organization's documentation.
  • πŸ”’ The demonstration of how access control settings are configured and enforced in a system, such as through group policy management, is used to illustrate the practical application of control testing.
Q & A
  • What are the three primary areas to consider when performing control testing?

    -The three primary areas to consider when performing control testing are examining documentation, testing configuration settings or system screenshots, and conducting interviews with personnel within the organization.

  • What is the significance of the term 'examine if' in the context of control testing?

    -'Examine if' is used to indicate that during control testing, the assessor should verify the existence and adequacy of control artifacts such as documentation.

  • Can you explain the importance of 'testing' in control assessment?

    -The term 'testing' refers to the process of evaluating whether the controls are operating effectively within the organization. It is crucial for ensuring that the control measures are adequately safeguarding the system.

  • Why is it necessary to interview personnel within the organization during control testing?

    -Interviewing personnel is necessary to gain insights into the practical implementation and effectiveness of controls. It helps assessors understand the human aspect of control mechanisms and can provide evidence of control operation.

  • What is the purpose of the 'test case' or 'requirement traceability matrix' in control testing?

    -The 'test case' or 'requirement traceability matrix' serves as a document that outlines the specific controls to be tested. It helps organize and plan the testing process, ensuring that all relevant controls are assessed systematically.

  • How should a control tester approach the assignment of testing different control families?

    -A control tester should plan their work based on the number of controls within each family they are assigned to test. They should create multiple copies of the test case template, one for each control, and organize them according to the specific control family.

  • What is the role of SharePoint in the context of control testing?

    -SharePoint acts as a centralized repository where all necessary evidence for control testing is uploaded and organized. It allows for efficient access to and sharing of documentation among the assessment team.

  • Why is it not recommended to send evidence through email during control testing?

    -Sending evidence through email is not recommended because it is not the best practice for secure and organized information sharing. SharePoint or similar platforms provide a more structured and secure way to manage and review evidence.

  • Can you provide an example of how to document the testing of a control like AC-1?

    -To document the testing of a control like AC-1, one must first identify the control requirement from the catalog, then craft an assessment procedure detailing how the control will be tested, and finally, examine the provided evidence to determine if the control is implemented as required.

  • What is the importance of planning work before starting to write in the test case document?

    -Planning work before writing in the test case document is crucial for efficiency and organization. It helps the tester to understand the scope of work, prepare the necessary test cases, and avoid omissions or duplications in the testing process.

  • How does the script differentiate between policy and procedure within a control?

    -The script differentiates between policy and procedure by stating that the policy is a high-level statement of intent and the procedure outlines the specific steps to implement the policy. For example, in access control, the policy might state the need for an access control system, while the procedure details how to manage user accounts and privileges.

Outlines
00:00
πŸ“š Introduction to Control Testing

The speaker introduces the concept of control testing, emphasizing the importance of examining control artifacts, testing configurations, and interviewing personnel. They mention that while they cannot test all 1200 controls, they will focus on key ones and use evidence from the 'student product' for assignments. The speaker also highlights the importance of understanding how to present test results and clarifies that proprietary information cannot be used without authorization.

05:01
πŸ“ˆ Planning and Organizing Control Testing

The speaker discusses the process of planning control testing, explaining how to create multiple copies of test cases based on the number of controls to be tested. They stress the importance of organizing these copies by control family and avoiding mixing different families. The speaker also mentions the use of SharePoint for evidence storage and retrieval, detailing how evidence should be accessed and managed during testing.

10:03
πŸ” Understanding Control Testing Procedures

The speaker delves into the specifics of control testing procedures, explaining how to document the testing process. They discuss the importance of detailing the control activity or requirement and how to craft the assessment procedure. The speaker also provides an example of how to document the testing of AC1, highlighting the need for clarity and precision in documenting the testing process.

15:04
πŸ“ Documenting Control Testing Results

The speaker explains how to document the results of control testing, focusing on the need to present findings clearly. They discuss the importance of stating the control number, name, and the specific control activity being tested. The speaker also provides an example of how to write the assessment procedure and results, emphasizing the need to reference the evidence used in the testing.

20:04
πŸ”— Reviewing and Updating Control Policies

The speaker discusses the process of reviewing and updating control policies, focusing on the frequency of reviews. They explain how to determine if an organization reviews and updates its access control policies annually, using the example of a policy from North Carolina State. The speaker also highlights the importance of reading the entire document to ensure all aspects of the control are addressed.

25:04
πŸ”’ Testing Access Control Procedures

The speaker provides a detailed example of testing access control procedures, specifically focusing on AC7, which deals with unsuccessful login attempts. They explain how to document the testing process, including the system's enforcement of a limit on consecutive invalid login attempts and the automatic locking of accounts. The speaker also discusses how to verify the system's configuration settings through screenshots and group policy management.

30:05
πŸ–₯️ Configuring and Enforcing Access Controls

The speaker demonstrates how access controls are configured and enforced in a virtual server environment. They show how to create and manage user accounts, enforce password policies, and handle account lockouts. The speaker also explains how group policies are used to push configuration settings across an organization's network, ensuring uniform enforcement of access controls.

35:05
πŸ“‹ Verifying and Documenting Control Evidence

The speaker discusses the process of verifying and documenting control evidence, using the example of AC7. They explain how to reference the evidence used in testing, such as screenshots and group policy settings, and how to document the findings. The speaker emphasizes the importance of accuracy and detail in documenting the testing process, including the use of specific language to indicate that no exceptions were noted.

40:07
πŸ”Ž Finalizing Control Testing

The speaker concludes the discussion on control testing by explaining how to finalize the process. They discuss how to document the testing results, including any issues noted and the overall satisfaction of the control. The speaker also emphasizes the importance of reviewing and approving the testing documentation, ensuring that all controls have been adequately tested and documented.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘Control Testing
Control Testing refers to the process of evaluating the effectiveness of an organization's internal controls, which are policies and procedures put in place to ensure the accuracy and reliability of information. In the video, the theme revolves around the steps and methodologies used in control testing, emphasizing the importance of examining documentation, system settings, and interviewing personnel to verify compliance with established controls.
πŸ’‘Artifact
In the context of the video, an 'artifact' is any piece of evidence or documentation that can be examined to assess the presence and effectiveness of a control within an organization. The script mentions control artifacts in relation to documentation and system configuration settings, which are crucial for understanding how controls are implemented and maintained.
πŸ’‘Configuration Settings
Configuration Settings are the specific parameters set within a system or application that dictate how it operates. The video discusses the importance of examining these settings as part of control testing to ensure that they align with the organization's policies and contribute to the effectiveness of the control being tested, such as the limit on unsuccessful login attempts.
πŸ’‘Screenshot
A screenshot in the video serves as a visual representation of the system's configuration settings or the state of a control at a given moment. It is used as evidence during control testing to demonstrate that the system is set up correctly to enforce the required controls, as illustrated by the example of the account lockout policy after three unsuccessful login attempts.
πŸ’‘Interview
An 'interview' in the context of control testing is a method of gathering information by directly communicating with personnel within the organization. The video script mentions interviews as a tool to clarify certain aspects of controls or to gain further insights that may not be evident from documentation or system settings alone.
πŸ’‘Policy and Procedure
Policy and Procedure are written documents that outline the rules and steps to be followed within an organization. In the video, the terms are used to describe the documents that need to be examined and tested to ensure that they are developed, documented, and disseminated according to the organization's access control policies, which is a key aspect of control testing.
πŸ’‘Access Control
Access Control refers to the selective restriction of resources or information in a system. The video focuses on access control policy and procedure testing, which is crucial for ensuring that only authorized personnel have access to sensitive information and systems, thereby maintaining security and compliance.
πŸ’‘Evidence Folder
An 'Evidence Folder' is a repository where all the artifacts and documentation related to control testing are stored and organized. The script mentions this folder as a place where assessors can access the necessary evidence, such as screenshots and policy documents, to perform their testing effectively.
πŸ’‘Test Case
A 'Test Case' is a set of defined steps and expected outcomes used in testing to determine if a particular control meets its intended requirements. The video script discusses the creation and use of test cases as a fundamental part of the control testing process, highlighting their importance in planning and executing tests.
πŸ’‘SharePoint
SharePoint is a collaboration platform that the video script uses as an example of where evidence and test cases can be stored and shared among team members during control testing. It serves as a central location for all assessors to access and upload relevant documentation and findings.
πŸ’‘ISO
In the context of this video, an 'ISO' refers to an Information Security Officer, who is responsible for the overall security of an organization's information assets. The script mentions ISO in relation to their role in defining and implementing security policies and procedures, which are then subject to control testing.
Highlights

Introduction to control testing and the importance of understanding the process.

Explanation of the three key areas used in control testing: examine if, testing, and interview.

Discussion on the limitations of testing all 1200 controls within a system and the focus on key controls.

Emphasis on the importance of understanding how to present test results effectively.

Clarification on the use of proprietary information and the need for authorization when using material for teaching.

Introduction to the test case or requirement traceability metric and its significance in control testing.

Demonstration of how to prepare and organize test cases for different control families.

Guidance on planning work as an assessor and the importance of knowing the number of controls to test.

Explanation of how to use a shared drive or SharePoint for evidence management during control testing.

Discussion on the best practices for submitting and reviewing test results through a shared platform.

Detailed walkthrough of testing AC1 control, including accessing and examining policy and procedure documents.

How to craft assessment procedures and the importance of detailing the testing process.

Demonstration of how to write assessment results and present findings based on examined documents.

Explanation of the process for testing AC7 control, focusing on unsuccessful login attempts.

How to verify system configurations and settings for controls through screenshots and server access.

Discussion on the use of group policy management in enforcing system controls and the role of administrators.

Final steps in control testing, including documenting evidence, writing assessment results, and closing controls.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: