Evidence-Based Reasoning

Bozeman Science
18 Nov 202311:43
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis educational video script focuses on evidence-based reasoning, guiding viewers through the process of constructing explanations for observed phenomena. It uses the examples of an unstable red block and a worn-out calculator to demonstrate how to analyze and prioritize evidence, formulate a hypothesis, and connect the evidence logically to the explanation. The script encourages active learning by inviting viewers to apply these reasoning skills to other scenarios, such as uneven tire wear or tilapia growth in different ponds.

Takeaways
  • 🧩 The script is a mini-lesson on constructing explanations with evidence-based reasoning, akin to solving a puzzle in science.
  • 🔍 It emphasizes the importance of examining various pieces of evidence to determine their relevance to the phenomena being studied.
  • 📚 The lesson uses the example of a red and green block to illustrate the process of evidence-based reasoning to explain why the red block is unstable.
  • 📉 The video script highlights the need to differentiate between helpful and unhelpful evidence when constructing an explanation.
  • 📝 It suggests writing down the phenomena and the question to be answered as the first step in the reasoning process.
  • 🔑 The script demonstrates how to organize and prioritize evidence, focusing on what is most important for explaining the phenomena.
  • 💡 It provides a step-by-step guide on formulating an explanation based on the evidence gathered, rather than mere assumptions.
  • 📈 The lesson includes the example of a worn-out calculator to further illustrate the process of evidence-based reasoning in a different context.
  • 🔗 The script stresses the importance of connecting the explanation with the evidence through logical reasoning.
  • 📝 It concludes by encouraging viewers to practice evidence-based reasoning with additional examples, such as worn tires or tilapia growth in different ponds.
  • 🔑 The key takeaway is that evidence-based reasoning involves starting with evidence, formulating an explanation, and then connecting the evidence to the explanation with sound reasoning.
Q & A

  • What is the main theme of the video script?

    -The main theme of the video script is evidence-based reasoning, focusing on how to construct explanations for observed phenomena using evidence.

  • What does the icon for explanations represent in the script?

    -The icon for explanations represents solving a puzzle, which is a metaphor for the scientific process of figuring out the causes of observed phenomena.

  • What is the first step in constructing an explanation according to the script?

    -The first step is to identify the phenomena or the effect that needs to be explained.

  • Why does the script mention the red and green blocks?

    -The red and green blocks are used as an example to demonstrate the process of evidence-based reasoning, specifically to explore why the red block is unstable compared to the green block.

  • What evidence is considered most important for explaining the instability of the red block?

    -The most important evidence includes the block's floating behavior in water, the presence of a magnetic attachment point on the red block's arm, and the photograph showing the red block balanced on the green block.

  • How does the script suggest connecting evidence to an explanation?

    -The script suggests organizing the evidence, writing down an explanation, and then providing reasoning that logically connects the evidence to the explanation without merely restating the evidence.

  • What is the second example used in the script to illustrate evidence-based reasoning?

    -The second example is a worn-out calculator, which is used to demonstrate how to analyze various pieces of evidence to determine the cause of its wear.

  • What evidence from the calculator example suggests its use in a 99 Cent Store?

    -The evidence includes the worn-out '9' button, stickers from a 99 Cent Store on the back of the calculator, and a flyer from the store indicating items priced at 99 cents.

  • What is the proposed explanation for the worn-out calculator in the script?

    -The proposed explanation is that the calculator was used for checkout at a 99 Cent Store, which led to its wear over time.

  • How does the script emphasize the importance of reasoning in evidence-based explanations?

    -The script emphasizes that reasoning should provide a logical connection between the evidence and the explanation, ensuring that the explanation is not just a restatement of the evidence but a coherent argument based on it.

Outlines
00:00
🔍 Analyzing Phenomena through Evidence-Based Reasoning

In this video segment, Mr. Anderson introduces the concept of constructing explanations using evidence-based reasoning, akin to solving a puzzle in science. The focus is on identifying the phenomena, such as the instability of a red block compared to a green block of similar dimensions, and then examining various pieces of evidence to deduce the cause. Key evidence includes the blocks' behavior in water, magnetic attachment points, and the possibility of the red block being balanced on the green one. The process involves listing relevant evidence, formulating an explanation, and then connecting the evidence to the explanation with logical reasoning.

05:00
📝 Developing Evidence-Based Reasoning with a Calculator Example

This paragraph continues the theme of evidence-based reasoning, applying it to a worn-out calculator. The task is to identify the phenomena, which is the calculator's wear, and then to gather and assess evidence such as the state of the buttons, stickers on the back, and promotional materials from a 99 cent store. The evidence suggests that the calculator was likely used for checkout at a 99 cent store, with the '9' button being particularly worn due to frequent use. The reasoning connects the evidence, such as the worn '9' button and the store's pricing strategy, to support the explanation that the calculator's wear is a result of its use in a checkout process where items are priced in 99 cent increments.

10:02
🧩 Applying Evidence-Based Reasoning to Other Phenomena

The final paragraph of the script concludes with a summary of the evidence-based reasoning process and encourages viewers to apply this method to other phenomena, such as worn tires or the growth of tilapia in different ponds. The summary emphasizes the importance of starting with evidence, formulating an explanation, and then using reasoning to connect the evidence to the explanation. This approach is presented as a valuable tool for understanding and explaining various phenomena based on the evidence at hand.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Evidence-based reasoning
Evidence-based reasoning is a process where conclusions are drawn based on the evaluation of evidence. In the context of the video, it refers to the method of constructing explanations by analyzing available evidence rather than relying on assumptions or conjecture. The video demonstrates this by examining the stability of a red block and the wear on a calculator, using evidence to form a hypothesis about the cause of the observed phenomena.
💡Phenomenon
A phenomenon is an observable event or fact. In the video, the term is used to describe the effect that the presenter is trying to understand, such as the instability of the red block and the wear on the calculator. The phenomenon is the starting point for evidence-based reasoning, prompting the investigation into its underlying cause.
💡Cause
The cause is the underlying reason or mechanism that produces an effect or brings about a result. In the video, the presenter seeks to identify the cause of the observed phenomena, such as the red block's instability being potentially due to a metal weight in its arm, and the calculator's wear being a result of frequent use at a 99 Cent Store.
💡Explanation
An explanation is a set of statements usually describing a set of related facts which elucidates the causes, nature, or principles of something. In the video, the presenter builds explanations for the phenomena observed by correlating the evidence collected, such as the red block's instability being due to a heavy arm and the calculator's wear being from its use in a checkout process.
💡Red block
The red block is a physical object used in the video to illustrate the process of evidence-based reasoning. It is described as unstable, falling over when released, which becomes the central phenomenon for the presenter to investigate. The red block's behavior is the basis for the presenter's exploration of evidence and subsequent explanation of its instability.
💡Green block
The green block serves as a control in the video's demonstration, standing in contrast to the red block. It remains stable when released, unlike the red block. This stability is part of the evidence that helps the presenter to hypothesize about the cause of the red block's instability.
💡Magnetic attachment points
Magnetic attachment points are areas on the blocks where a magnet can adhere. In the video, the presenter notes differences in the magnetic attachment points between the red and green blocks, which serves as evidence suggesting a metal weight in the red block's arm, contributing to its instability.
💡Worn out calculator
The worn out calculator is another example used in the video to demonstrate evidence-based reasoning. It shows signs of heavy use, with particular wear on the '9' button, which leads the presenter to hypothesize that the calculator was used in a checkout scenario at a 99 Cent Store.
💡Stickers
Stickers in the video are used as evidence of the calculator's environment and usage. The presence of 99 Cent Store stickers on the calculator suggests its setting and contributes to the presenter's explanation that the calculator was used for checkout purposes at such a store.
💡99 Cent Store
The 99 Cent Store is a type of retail establishment that sells items for 99 cents each. In the video, the presenter uses the context of a 99 Cent Store to explain the heavy wear on the calculator's '9' button, reasoning that items costing 99 cents would require frequent pressing of this button during checkout.
Highlights

The icon for explanations is solving a puzzle, symbolizing the scientific process of understanding phenomena.

The video discusses constructing explanations based on evidence, not just personal assumptions.

The phenomena is the effect we are trying to understand, and the cause is the explanation.

Examples given include uneven tire wear on a car and tilapia growth in different ponds.

The red and green block experiment is used to demonstrate how to look at evidence.

The red block's instability is the phenomena being investigated.

Evidence such as block paint colors and brands is deemed not helpful in this context.

A photograph of the blocks in water shows they float differently, which is considered helpful evidence.

Block masses, volumes, and densities are similar, indicating they might not be the cause of the instability.

Magnetic attachment points on the blocks suggest a difference that could be significant.

Block external dimensions are similar, suggesting they are not the cause of the instability.

A photograph shows the red block balanced on the green block, indicating a possible solution to its instability.

The explanation for the red block's instability is a metal weight in its arm.

Evidence is organized to support the explanation, emphasizing the importance of the red block's arm.

The reasoning connects the evidence to the explanation, explaining why the red block's arm is heavier.

The calculator example introduces a new phenomena: a worn-out calculator.

Evidence from the calculator's front and back is considered, including worn buttons and stickers.

The 99 cent store flyer and stickers suggest the calculator was used in a checkout context.

The worn-out nine key on the calculator is a key piece of evidence in the explanation.

The explanation for the calculator's wear is that it was used in a 99 Cent Store for checkout.

Reasoning is provided to connect the evidence, such as the worn nine key, to the explanation.

The process of evidence-based reasoning is summarized, emphasizing the steps from evidence to explanation.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Claim, Evidence, and Reasoning, Oh My!

How to Make a Claim

Literary Analysis - Claims, Evidence, Reasoning

Analyzing the Argument - Part 2 of 2 (Evaluating the Evidence)

Evaluating a source’s reasoning and evidence | Reading | Khan Academy

CER (Claim, Evidence, Reasoning) in Biology

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Evidence-BasedReasoningScienceExplanationPuzzle-SolvingPhenomenonCause-EffectTire-WearTilapia-GrowthCalculator-WearMagnetism