Claim, Evidence, and Reasoning, Oh My!

Brittany Walker
25 Jan 202004:00
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis video script teaches viewers how to construct a compelling argument by defining and using claims, evidence, and reasoning effectively. It emphasizes the importance of a clear claim, factual evidence, and logical reasoning to support arguments in writing, providing examples to illustrate the process.

Takeaways
  • πŸ“š A claim, also known as a thesis statement, is a response to a prompt or question and serves as the backbone of your writing.
  • πŸ“ The claim should be placed at the end of the introduction paragraph and should be a clear, statement-like sentence, not a question.
  • 🚫 Avoid starting your claim with phrases like 'I think', 'I believe', or 'I feel' to ensure it sounds like a statement of fact.
  • πŸ“ˆ Evidence supports the claim and consists of information, data, or observations. It should be factual and cited properly, not an opinion.
  • πŸ” The claim and evidence should be included in the introduction, with the claim typically followed by the main points of the argument.
  • 🧠 Reasoning is crucial in connecting the evidence to the claim. It explains how the evidence supports the claim and is often longer than the claim itself.
  • πŸ“š The reasoning section is one of the most important parts of an argumentative essay as it helps to prove the claim.
  • πŸ“ An example provided in the script is the claim that 'dogs are better than cats', backed by data from a study, illustrating the use of evidence.
  • πŸ“š The script emphasizes the importance of structuring an argumentative essay with a clear claim, supported evidence, and thorough reasoning.
  • πŸ“ˆ The script provides a multi-paragraph example of how to integrate claim, evidence, and reasoning in an argumentative essay format.
Q & A
  • What is the main focus of the video?

    -The video focuses on teaching viewers how to argue better by explaining the concepts of claim, evidence, and reasoning, and how to use them in writing.

  • What is a claim in the context of the video?

    -A claim, also known as a thesis statement, is a response to a prompt or question, representing the writer's stance or what they want to argue in their paper.

  • Where should the claim or thesis statement typically be placed in an argument paper?

    -The claim or thesis statement is usually placed at the end of the introduction paragraph in an argument paper.

  • Why is it important for a claim to be a statement and not a question?

    -A claim should be a statement to clearly convey the writer's position and to avoid sounding like an opinion, which should be supported by evidence rather than personal belief.

  • What should a claim avoid starting with to maintain its factual nature?

    -A claim should avoid starting with phrases like 'I think,' 'I believe,' or 'I feel' to ensure it sounds like a statement of fact that can be proven.

  • What is the role of evidence in supporting a claim?

    -Evidence is the information or data that supports the claim, such as numbers, observations, or quotations from texts, and it must be cited to ensure credibility.

  • What is reasoning in the context of argument writing?

    -Reasoning is the explanation of how the evidence supports the claim, connecting the dots for the reader and proving the claim through logical arguments.

  • Why is reasoning considered one of the most important parts of an argument essay?

    -Reasoning is crucial because it demonstrates the logical connection between the evidence and the claim, proving the claim's validity and persuading the reader.

  • Can the example of 'dogs are better than cats' be considered a strong claim?

    -The example of 'dogs are better than cats' is a simple claim that can be debated, but it needs to be supported by evidence and reasoning to be considered strong in an argument paper.

  • What is the purpose of including main points in the thesis statement according to the video?

    -Including main points in the thesis statement helps outline the argument's structure, providing the reader with a clear roadmap of the writer's main arguments.

  • How should the evidence and reasoning be presented in an argument paper?

    -In an argument paper, the evidence and reasoning should be presented throughout the body paragraphs, with the claim or thesis introduced in the introduction and supported by factual evidence and logical reasoning.

Outlines
00:00
πŸ“ Understanding the Basics of Argumentative Writing

This paragraph introduces the core components of argumentative writing: claim, evidence, and reasoning. The claim, also known as the thesis statement, is a clear response to a prompt or question, serving as the backbone of the argument. It should be a statement of fact, not an opinion, and placed at the end of the introduction. The paragraph emphasizes the importance of supporting the claim with evidence and reasoning to effectively argue the point.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘Claim
In the context of the video, a 'claim' is a statement or thesis that the speaker intends to argue or prove in their writing. It serves as the backbone of the argument and is typically placed at the end of the introduction paragraph. The claim should be a clear statement, not a question, and should be something that can be supported by evidence. For example, the video script uses the claim 'dogs are better than cats' to illustrate how a claim should be made.
πŸ’‘Evidence
Evidence in the video refers to the information, data, or observations that support the claim. It is not an opinion and must be cited. Evidence is crucial in an argumentative paper as it provides the factual basis for the claim. The script mentions using data from a study as an example of evidence to back up the claim that 'dogs are better than cats'.
πŸ’‘Reasoning
Reasoning is the process of explaining how the evidence supports the claim. It is one of the most important parts of an argumentative essay, as it helps connect the dots for the reader. Reasoning is not merely stating facts but interpreting them in a way that logically supports the claim. The video emphasizes that without reasoning, the claim cannot be proven.
πŸ’‘Thesis Statement
A 'thesis statement' is synonymous with a 'claim' in the video. It is a clear, concise statement that presents the main argument or point of view of the paper. The thesis statement is typically placed at the end of the introduction and guides the reader on what to expect in the rest of the essay. The video script uses the example of 'dogs are better than cats' as a thesis statement.
πŸ’‘Argument Paper
An 'argument paper' is a type of academic writing where the author presents a claim and supports it with evidence and reasoning. The video is focused on teaching how to write an argument paper effectively by using a clear claim, solid evidence, and logical reasoning. The script provides examples and guidelines for structuring such a paper.
πŸ’‘Introduction Paragraph
The 'introduction paragraph' is the opening section of an argument paper where the author introduces the topic and presents the thesis statement or claim. According to the video, the claim or thesis should be placed at the end of this paragraph to clearly state the author's position on the topic.
πŸ’‘Support
In the context of the video, 'support' refers to the act of backing up the claim with evidence. A claim must be supported by facts, data, or observations that can be cited, and it should not be based on personal opinions or feelings. The video emphasizes the importance of using evidence to support the claim effectively.
πŸ’‘Citation
A 'citation' is the act of acknowledging the source of the evidence used in an argument paper. It is important to cite sources to give credit to the original authors and to provide a basis for the evidence presented. The video script mentions that evidence must be cited, indicating the importance of proper citation in academic writing.
πŸ’‘Body Paragraphs
In an argument paper, 'body paragraphs' are the sections following the introduction where the evidence and reasoning are presented in detail. The video script suggests that while the example provided combines claim, evidence, and reasoning in one paragraph, typically, these elements are spread across multiple body paragraphs in a full essay.
πŸ’‘Brett Favre
Brett Favre is mentioned in the video as an example in a hypothetical argument paper. His mention serves to illustrate how the principles of claim, evidence, and reasoning can be applied to different subjects, even in the context of sports or personal achievements.
Highlights

The video teaches how to argue better by using claim, evidence, and reasoning in writing.

A claim, also known as a thesis statement, is a response to a prompt or question and serves as the backbone of writing.

The claim should be a clear statement, not a question, and should be placed at the end of the introduction paragraph.

A claim should not sound like an opinion and should not start with phrases like 'I think', 'I believe', or 'I feel'.

The claim should be a statement of fact that can be supported by evidence.

Evidence is the information or data that supports the claim and should be factual, not an opinion.

Evidence must be cited and can include numbers, observations, or quotations from texts.

Reasoning is crucial in explaining how the evidence supports the claim.

Reasoning helps connect the dots for the reader and is one of the most important parts of an argumentative essay.

An example of a claim is 'Dogs are better than cats', which needs to be backed up with evidence.

The claim should be bold and should be supported by main points, ideally three of them.

An example of evidence supporting the claim about dogs is a piece of data from a study.

The reasoning part of the argument should be longer than the claim, as it explains the connection between the evidence and the claim.

The video provides an example of how to combine claim, evidence, and reasoning into one paragraph.

In a full argument paper, the claim or thesis is typically in the introduction, with evidence and reasoning throughout the body paragraphs.

The video emphasizes the importance of making a clear claim, supporting it with factual evidence, and explaining the connection with reasoning.

Another example given is about Brett Favre, illustrating how claim, evidence, and reasoning can be used in a multi-paragraph essay.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: