6.1 N Dimensional Search Procedures

rubinhlandau
31 Aug 202039:12
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis video script discusses the application of trial and error searching methods in solving complex problems, such as bridge construction. It demonstrates the process using a physical model of a bridge with varying weights and lengths, highlighting how angles and tensions change with different mass distributions. The script then delves into the analytical approach, introducing geometric and Newton's law constraints, leading to a system of equations. The focus shifts to solving these equations using an extended Newton-Raphson method in multiple dimensions, emphasizing the use of computer programs to handle the complexity. The script concludes with an encouragement to experiment with the equations, adjust parameters, and understand the solution's robustness, including an optional challenge to generalize the problem for three masses.

Takeaways
  • πŸ˜€ The video discusses trial and error searching methods, emphasizing their application in solving complex scientific problems, such as bridge construction.
  • πŸ” A demonstration is presented using a model to represent the problem of building a bridge upside down, illustrating how tension and angles change with varying masses.
  • πŸ“ The importance of geometry and Newton's laws of statics are highlighted in formulating the problem, leading to a system of equations with unknown tensions and angles.
  • 🧩 The video explains that the problem involves six unknowns (three tensions and three angles) and requires at least six equations to solve.
  • πŸ“š The equations are derived from geometric constraints and Newton's second law for static equilibrium, resulting in a system of nonlinear equations.
  • πŸ”’ The video introduces the concept of transcendental equations, which are difficult to solve analytically, and suggests the use of numerical methods or computers.
  • πŸ–₯️ The Newton-Raphson method is extended to multiple dimensions to solve the system of equations, involving the use of partial derivatives and matrix operations.
  • πŸ“‰ The process involves making an initial guess, calculating corrections using a Taylor expansion, and iteratively improving the solution until the equations are satisfied.
  • πŸ“ The script mentions the use of matrix equations and the need for their inversion or the application of Gaussian elimination techniques for finding the solution.
  • πŸ’‘ The video emphasizes the power of abstraction in mathematics, showing that the one-dimensional Newton-Raphson method is conceptually the same as its multi-dimensional counterpart.
  • πŸ“˜ The script encourages viewers to engage with the material by experimenting with the equations, checking the reasonableness of solutions, and exploring the effects of different parameters.
Q & A
  • What is the main topic of the video script?

    -The main topic of the video script is trial and error searching, with a focus on demonstrating how these techniques can be applied to solve complex scientific problems, such as constructing a bridge.

  • What is the purpose of the demonstration involving a spaniel mentioned in the script?

    -The purpose of the demonstration involving a spaniel was to illustrate the concept of trial and error searching in a real situation. However, due to space limitations, the idea was adapted to a different problem.

  • What is the significance of the bridge-building scenario in the script?

    -The bridge-building scenario is used to demonstrate how trial and error searching techniques can be applied to practical engineering problems, emphasizing the importance of understanding angles, tensions, and the structural integrity of the bridge.

  • What are the key variables in the bridge-building demonstration?

    -The key variables in the bridge-building demonstration include the masses (weights), the lengths of the strings, the angles the strings make, and the tensions in the strings.

  • Why is it important to ensure that tensions are positive in the bridge model?

    -It is important to ensure that tensions are positive because negative tensions would imply that the string is not under tension but rather pushing inwards, which is not physically possible for a string in a bridge model.

  • What is the role of Newton's laws in the script's problem-solving approach?

    -Newton's laws, specifically the second law for statics, are used to establish the equilibrium conditions for the bridge model. These laws help formulate the equations necessary to solve for the unknown tensions and angles in the system.

  • How many unknowns are there in the bridge model problem presented in the script?

    -There are six unknowns in the bridge model problem: three unknown tensions (t1, t2, t3) and three unknown angles (theta1, theta2, theta3).

  • What mathematical technique is extended to solve the multi-dimensional problem presented in the script?

    -The Newton-Raphson method is extended to multi-dimensions to solve the problem, allowing for the simultaneous solution of multiple non-linear equations.

  • What is the significance of the Jacobian matrix in the context of the script?

    -The Jacobian matrix is significant as it contains the partial derivatives of the system's equations with respect to each variable. It is used in the multi-dimensional Newton-Raphson method to approximate the solution for the unknowns.

  • How does the script suggest dealing with the complexity of solving nine simultaneous equations?

    -The script suggests using matrix equations and leveraging computer algorithms to solve the nine simultaneous equations, emphasizing the efficiency and practicality of computational methods over manual calculations.

  • What is the role of the inverse Jacobian matrix in solving the system of equations?

    -The inverse Jacobian matrix is used to transform the system of equations into a form that can be solved for the unknowns (delta x's). It effectively maps the known function values to the corrections needed for the current guess.

  • Why is it suggested to use Gaussian elimination instead of the inverse Jacobian matrix for solving the equations?

    -Gaussian elimination is suggested because it is often more efficient and accurate for solving systems of equations. It systematically eliminates variables and is more robust against potential numerical inaccuracies.

  • What is the final advice given in the script regarding the application of the concepts learned?

    -The final advice is to engage with the material by experimenting with the equations, checking the reasonableness of solutions, and exploring how changes in variables affect the outcomes. Additionally, attempting to break the code by providing extreme values or poor initial guesses can provide insights into the robustness of the solution method.

Outlines
00:00
πŸ”¬ Introduction to Trial and Error Searching in Complex Structures

The speaker introduces the concept of trial and error searching in the context of complex problem-solving, like constructing a bridge. They set the stage for a demonstration involving a model bridge with weights and strings to illustrate the principles of tension and angles in a real-world scenario. The emphasis is on understanding the scientific method behind solving such problems, even when they appear complicated.

05:02
πŸ“ Demonstrating the Physics of Bridge Building with Tension and Angles

This paragraph delves into a practical demonstration of the physics involved in bridge construction. The setup includes a model with a river, canyon, and a bridge with weights and strings. The focus is on the angles formed by the strings and the tension within them as weights are adjusted. The speaker explains how changing the mass affects the angles and tension, highlighting the importance of positive tension for structural integrity.

10:05
πŸ“ Formulating the Bridge Building Problem with Equations

The speaker transitions to the mathematical formulation of the bridge problem, identifying unknown tensions and angles that need to be solved. They explain that six unknowns require at least six equations, derived from geometric constraints and Newton's laws for static equilibrium. The paragraph outlines the process of writing down these equations, emphasizing the importance of understanding each component for successful problem-solving.

15:05
πŸ” Analyzing the Complexity of the Bridge Equations

In this section, the speaker breaks down the complexity of the equations involved in the bridge problem. They discuss the challenge of solving non-linear equations with transcendental functions and the impracticality of finding an analytical solution by hand. The speaker introduces the concept of using numerical methods and computers to find solutions to such complex systems of equations.

20:05
πŸ€– Solving Non-Linear Equations with Multi-Dimensional Search Techniques

The speaker introduces the extension of the Newton-Raphson method to multi-dimensional problems, which is essential for solving complex equations like those in the bridge model. They explain the process of turning the non-linear equations into a form that can be solved using numerical methods, emphasizing the role of computers in handling the complexity and the iterative nature of the search for solutions.

25:08
πŸ”„ Applying the Newton-Raphson Method to Multi-Variable Equations

This paragraph explains how to apply the Newton-Raphson method to the multi-variable equations derived from the bridge problem. The speaker details the process of making an initial guess, using a Taylor expansion to approximate the corrections needed for the guess, and then solving for these corrections using matrix equations. The emphasis is on the iterative process and the use of partial derivatives to update the guess.

30:08
πŸ“š Understanding the Matrix Formulation and Solving for Unknowns

The speaker further elaborates on the matrix formulation of the problem, explaining how to express the system of equations in a compact form using matrices and vectors. They discuss the process of evaluating the partial derivatives and using numerical methods to approximate them, leading to a solvable matrix equation for the unknown corrections. The paragraph also touches on the practical aspects of solving such matrix equations using computer libraries.

35:08
πŸ› οΈ Encouraging Exploration and Experimentation with the Equations

The speaker concludes by encouraging the audience to engage with the equations, experiment with different values, and understand the impact on the solution. They suggest trying to 'break' the code to see how it fails with poor initial guesses and to explore enhancements like back-tracking. For those interested, they propose an extension of the problem to include three masses, offering a more complex challenge.

πŸŽ“ Reflecting on the Power of Abstraction in Mathematics

In the final paragraph, the speaker reflects on the power of mathematical abstraction, showing how the one-dimensional Newton-Raphson method is fundamentally the same as the multi-dimensional matrix equation. They discuss the formal solution involving the inverse of the Jacobian matrix and highlight the importance of understanding the underlying principles rather than just the computational techniques.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘Trial and Error Searching
Trial and error searching is a problem-solving method where solutions are found by trying out various possibilities and learning from the outcomes of each attempt. In the video, this concept is applied to complex problems such as bridge building, where the method helps in finding the optimal angles and tensions in the structure's components.
πŸ’‘Newton-Raphson Method
The Newton-Raphson method is an iterative numerical technique used to find the roots of a real-valued function. In the context of the video, it's extended to multi-dimensional problems for solving complex equations related to the physical model of a bridge, illustrating how traditional methods can be adapted for more intricate scenarios.
πŸ’‘Equilibrium
Equilibrium in this video refers to a state where the sum of forces acting on a system is zero, resulting in no acceleration. It is a fundamental concept in physics, particularly in statics, and is crucial for understanding how the bridge model remains stable under varying conditions of mass and tension.
πŸ’‘Tension
Tension is the force experienced by a string or cable when it is pulled tight by opposite ends. In the video, tension is a key variable in the bridge model, with the goal of ensuring that the tensions remain positive and do not exceed the breaking point of the materials, which is essential for structural integrity.
πŸ’‘Geometric Constraints
Geometric constraints are the limitations or conditions imposed by the physical dimensions and arrangement of a system. In the script, these constraints are used to formulate equations that relate the lengths and angles of the bridge model components, ensuring that the model adheres to the given dimensions.
πŸ’‘Transcendental Functions
Transcendental functions, such as sine and cosine, are involved in the equations of the bridge model. They are called transcendental because they cannot be expressed algebraically. In the video, these functions introduce complexity into the equations, making them non-linear and challenging to solve analytically.
πŸ’‘Matrix Equations
Matrix equations are used to represent systems of linear equations in a compact form. In the context of the video, the complex equations modeling the bridge are transformed into matrix equations, which are then solved using computational methods to find the unknown tensions and angles.
πŸ’‘Partial Derivatives
Partial derivatives are used to measure how a multivariable function changes with respect to one variable while others are held constant. In the video, partial derivatives are essential for the Newton-Raphson method in multiple dimensions, helping to approximate the changes needed to reach a solution.
πŸ’‘Jacobi Matrix
The Jacobi matrix, mentioned in the context of solving the matrix equation, is a matrix whose elements are the partial derivatives of a set of functions. It is used to linearize the system of equations around an initial guess, which is a step in the iterative process of finding the solution.
πŸ’‘Gaussian Elimination
Gaussian elimination is a systematic method for solving linear systems of equations by transforming the system's matrix into an upper triangular form, making it easier to solve. In the video, it is suggested as a more efficient and robust alternative to using the inverse of the matrix for finding the solution.
πŸ’‘Abstraction in Mathematics
Abstraction in mathematics refers to the process of generalizing specific concepts into more universal forms. The video script discusses how the one-dimensional Newton-Raphson method can be abstracted to a multi-dimensional context, showing that the fundamental principles remain the same despite the increase in complexity.
Highlights

Introduction to trial and error searching with a scientific approach.

Demonstration of trial and error searching using a bridge-building scenario.

Explanation of how changing mass affects angles and tensions in a structure.

Importance of positive tensions in structural integrity.

The significance of initial guesses in solving complex problems.

Formulation of geometric and physical constraints in problem-solving.

Use of Newton's second law for statics in equilibrium problems.

Conversion of trigonometric equations into a system of linear equations.

Application of the Newton-Raphson method to multi-dimensional problems.

The challenge of solving non-linear equations with transcendental functions.

Utilization of partial derivatives in the Newton-Raphson method.

Matrix representation of the system of equations for computer solving.

The concept of a Jacobian matrix in solving multi-dimensional equations.

Comparison of different computational methods for solving equations.

Encouragement to experiment with the equations to understand their behavior.

Optional challenge to extend the problem to three masses for advanced learners.

The power of abstraction in mathematics for solving complex phenomena.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: