Stability of Negative Charges Acids and Bases

The Organic Chemistry Tutor

19 Feb 202328:06

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis educational video explores the stability of negative charges in organic chemistry, comparing various ions like alkoxide and thiolate to determine which are weaker bases and more stable. Factors such as atomic size, electronegativity, resonance stabilization, inductive effects, solvation, aromaticity, and hybridization are discussed, with examples illustrating how these elements influence the stability of a negative charge. The video also touches on the relationship between the strength of an acid and its conjugate base, using PKA values to compare stability.

Takeaways

🔬 The stability of negative charges in chemical compounds is influenced by factors such as atomic size, electronegativity, and the ability to delocalize charge.
🌐 Larger atomic size, like that of sulfur compared to oxygen, can better stabilize a negative charge due to a larger surface area for charge distribution.
⚛️ Electronegativity plays a crucial role in charge stabilization; more electronegative atoms like oxygen can stabilize negative charges more effectively than less electronegative ones like nitrogen.
🔁 Resonance stabilization, or electron delocalization, increases the stability of a negative charge by spreading it over a larger area or more atoms.
📉 The PKa values of compounds can indicate the strength of an acid and its conjugate base; a lower PKa value signifies a stronger acid and a weaker conjugate base.
🏜 Steric effects, such as those caused by bulky groups, can reduce solvent interactions and thus affect the stability of a negative charge on a molecule.
🌀 The presence of an electron-withdrawing group like fluorine can stabilize a negative charge by pulling electron density away from the atom bearing the charge.
💧 Solvent effects are significant in stabilizing negative charges; more solvent interactions lead to increased stability of the charge.
🔶 The formation of an aromatic ring system through the delocalization of a negative charge significantly enhances the stability of that charge.
📍 Hybridization states of orbitals also impact charge stability; an sp hybridized carbon with more s character holds electrons closer to the nucleus, making it less reactive and a weaker base.
📚 The video script provides a comprehensive overview of factors affecting the stability of negative charges, offering insights into organic chemistry concepts such as PKa values, electronegativity, and resonance.

Q & A

Which ion is more stable, the alkoxide ion or the thiolate ion, and why?
-The thiolate ion is more stable because sulfur, being larger than oxygen, can better stabilize the negative charge due to its larger atomic size, allowing the charge to be spread out over a larger surface area.
What is the relationship between the stability of a base and its position on the periodic table?
-Bases that are positioned lower on the periodic table, such as sulfur compared to oxygen, tend to be weaker bases and more stable due to their larger atomic size and ability to better stabilize a negative charge.
How does the pKa value of ethanol compare to that of ethane thiol, and what does this indicate about their acid strength?
-Ethanol has a pKa of 15.9, while ethane thiol typically has a pKa around 10. This indicates that ethanol is a weaker acid (and thus its conjugate base is stronger) compared to ethane thiol, which is a stronger acid (and its conjugate base is weaker).
Why is the alkoxide ion more stable than the amide ion when comparing the two?
-The alkoxide ion is more stable because oxygen is more electronegative than nitrogen, and despite their similar atomic sizes, the negative charge is better stabilized on the more electronegative atom, making the alkoxide ion a weaker base.
What is the significance of electronegativity in determining the stability of a negative charge on an atom?
-Electronegativity is significant because an atom with higher electronegativity, such as oxygen, can better stabilize a negative charge. The higher electronegativity means the atom has a greater attraction for electrons, thus stabilizing the charge more effectively.
How does resonance stabilization contribute to the stability of a negative charge in a molecule?
-Resonance stabilization, or electron delocalization, contributes to the stability of a negative charge by allowing the charge to be spread across multiple atoms, reducing the concentration of the charge and making the molecule more stable.
What is the effect of an electron-withdrawing group like fluorine on the stability of a negative charge?
-An electron-withdrawing group like fluorine stabilizes a negative charge by pulling electron density away from the atom bearing the charge, making the charge less concentrated and the molecule more stable.
How does the presence of a carbonyl functional group affect the pKa of an amide?
-The presence of a carbonyl functional group greatly decreases the pKa of an amide, making the amide hydrogen more acidic. This is due to resonance stabilization of the conjugate base, which allows for electron delocalization and increased stability.
What is the impact of hybridization on the stability of a negative charge on a carbon atom?
-Hybridization impacts the stability of a negative charge on a carbon atom by determining the electron density around the atom. An sp hybridized carbon, with more s character, holds electrons closer to the nucleus, making the negative charge more stable compared to an sp3 hybridized carbon.
How do solvent effects influence the stability of a negative charge on an oxygen atom in a molecule?
-Solvent effects can greatly influence the stability of a negative charge on an oxygen atom by either stabilizing or destabilizing the charge based on the solvent's ability to interact with the molecule. More solvent interactions lead to better stabilization of the negative charge.
What is the role of aromaticity in stabilizing a negative charge in a conjugated cyclic system?
-Aromaticity plays a significant role in stabilizing a negative charge in a conjugated cyclic system by allowing the charge to be part of the aromatic ring system. This results in the charge being delocalized over the entire ring, leading to increased stability.

Outlines

00:00

🔬 Stability of Negative Charges: Atomic Size and Electronegativity

This paragraph discusses the factors that influence the stability of negative charges, focusing on atomic size and electronegativity. It explains that larger atoms, like sulfur compared to oxygen, can better stabilize a negative charge due to their larger surface area. The paragraph also highlights the concept of electronegativity, where more electronegative atoms, such as oxygen over nitrogen, can more effectively handle a negative charge. The discussion includes examples of pKa values for ethanol and ethane thiol, illustrating the principle that weaker acids have stronger conjugate bases.

05:01

🌀 Resonance Stabilization and the Effect of Electron Withdrawing Groups

The second paragraph delves into the concept of resonance stabilization, where the negative charge can be delocalized over multiple atoms, leading to increased stability. It contrasts the stability of nitrogen and oxygen-based anions, explaining that the ability to form a resonance structure with oxygen makes it a weaker base. Additionally, the paragraph touches on the influence of electron withdrawing groups, such as fluorine, which can make an oxygen atom less negative and thus stabilize the negative charge on the carbon atom to which it is attached.

10:02

🌐 Solvent Effects and Steric Factors in Base Stability

This paragraph explores how solvent interactions and steric factors can affect the stability of a base. It uses the example of terbutoxide and ethoxide to illustrate that a more sterically hindered base has fewer solvent interactions, making it a stronger base, whereas a less hindered base, like ethoxide, has more solvent interactions, making it a weaker base. The paragraph also provides pKa values for terbutanol and ethanol to emphasize the impact of solvent effects on acidity and base strength.

15:03

🔶 Aromaticity and Hybridization's Role in Charge Stability

The fourth paragraph discusses the impact of aromaticity and hybridization on the stability of a negative charge. It explains that a lone pair involved in an aromatic ring system is highly stable, using the example of cyclopentadiene, which is more acidic than cyclopentane due to resonance stabilization and the formation of an aromatic system upon deprotonation. The paragraph also touches on the concept of hybridization, noting that an sp hybridized carbon with a negative charge is a weaker base compared to an sp3 hybridized carbon because the electrons are held more tightly closer to the nucleus.

20:04

📚 Summary of Factors Affecting Negative Charge Stability

In this paragraph, the video script provides a summary of the factors discussed so far that affect the stability of negative charges. It revisits the importance of atomic size, electronegativity, resonance stabilization, inductive effects, and solvation effects. The paragraph emphasizes that larger atoms, more electronegative atoms, delocalized charges, electron-withdrawing groups, and solvent interactions all contribute to the stabilization of negative charges. It also mentions the significance of hybridization, where orbitals with more s character result in a more stable negative charge.

25:04

📘 Accessing Extended Organic Chemistry Resources

The final paragraph shifts focus to providing information on how viewers can access extended organic chemistry videos and resources. It mentions a Patreon membership program and a YouTube membership program, offering full-length videos on various organic chemistry topics. The paragraph also discusses the availability of worksheets for some videos, allowing viewers to work through problems offline. It invites viewers to share their preferences between watching extended videos or using printouts of worksheets for studying.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Stability of Negative Charges

The term 'stability of negative charges' refers to the ability of an atom or molecule to maintain a negative charge without undergoing reactions that would neutralize it. In the video, this concept is central to understanding the relative strength of bases and their ability to donate protons. For instance, the alkoxide and thiolate ions are compared based on their stability, with the latter being more stable due to sulfur's larger atomic size, allowing for better charge distribution.

💡Alkoxide Ion

An 'alkoxide ion' is a negatively charged species derived from an alcohol, where the hydroxyl group has lost a proton. In the context of the video, the stability of an alkoxide ion is compared to other anions, such as the thiolate ion. The comparison is made to illustrate the principle that larger atoms can stabilize negative charges more effectively, making the alkoxide ion less stable than the thiolate ion.

💡Thiolate Ion

A 'thiolate ion' is similar to an alkoxide ion but derived from a thiol (a compound containing a -SH group). The video emphasizes that the thiolate ion is a weaker base and more stable than the alkoxide ion because sulfur, being lower in the periodic table than oxygen, has a larger atomic size that facilitates better stabilization of the negative charge.

💡Atomic Size

In the video, 'atomic size' is discussed as a key factor in the stabilization of negative charges. Larger atoms, like sulfur compared to oxygen, can disperse the negative charge over a greater volume, leading to increased stability. This principle is applied when comparing the stability of the alkoxide and thiolate ions.

💡Electronegativity

'Electronegativity' is the ability of an atom to attract electrons towards itself in a chemical bond. The video explains that atoms with higher electronegativity, such as oxygen compared to nitrogen, can better stabilize a negative charge. This is demonstrated when comparing the stability of alkoxide and amide ions.

💡Resonance Stabilization

'Resonance stabilization' refers to the phenomenon where the negative charge on a molecule can be delocalized over several atoms, leading to increased stability. The video uses this concept to explain why certain ions, like the one derived from an amide, are more stable when the negative charge can be spread out over multiple atoms, as in the case of resonance structures.

💡pKa

The 'pKa' value is a measure of the acidity of a substance, defined as the negative logarithm of the acid dissociation constant. In the video, pKa values are used to compare the strength of acids and the stability of their conjugate bases. For example, ethanol and ethane thiol are compared based on their pKa values to illustrate the concept that a stronger acid has a weaker conjugate base.

💡Inductive Effect

The 'inductive effect' is a phenomenon where the presence of certain groups in a molecule influences the reactivity of other parts of the molecule. In the video, the inductive effect is discussed in the context of electron-withdrawing groups like fluorine, which can stabilize a negative charge by pulling electron density away from the atom bearing the charge.

💡Solvating Effects

'Solvating effects' refer to the interactions between a solute and solvent molecules. The video explains how these effects can influence the stability of a negative charge, with more solvent interactions leading to greater stabilization. The comparison between terbutoxide and ethoxide illustrates how steric hindrance can reduce solvating effects and thus affect the strength of a base.

💡Hybridization

The term 'hybridization' describes the concept where atomic orbitals combine to form new hybrid orbitals that are suitable for bonding. The video discusses how the hybridization state of an atom, such as SP or SP3, can affect the stability of a negative charge, with orbitals closer to the nucleus (more S character) leading to a more stable situation.

💡Aromatic Ring System

An 'aromatic ring system' is a ring of atoms with delocalized electrons that follow Hückel's rule (4n+2 π electrons), which confers special stability. The video explains that if a negative charge is part of an aromatic system, as with cyclopentadiene, it is highly stabilized due to resonance and the formation of the aromatic system, making the conjugate acid more acidic.

Highlights

The video discusses the stability of negative charges in chemical compounds, comparing the stability of alkoxide and thiolate ions.

Sulfur is identified as a weaker base than oxygen due to its larger atomic size, which allows better stabilization of the negative charge.

The pKa values of ethanol and ethane thiol are compared to illustrate the concept of weaker acids having stronger conjugate bases.

Atomic size and electronegativity are key factors in determining the stability of negative charges on oxygen and nitrogen in alkoxide and amide ions.

Resonance stabilization and electron delocalization are explained as methods for increasing the stability of negative charges.

The presence of a carbonyl functional group significantly decreases the pKa of an amide, making it a stronger acid and weaker conjugate base.

The effect of electron-withdrawing groups like fluorine on the stability of negative charges is discussed, showing they make the charge more stable.

Solvating effects and steric factors are shown to influence the stability of negative charges, with more solvent interactions leading to greater stability.

The aromatic ring system's role in stabilizing negative charges through resonance is highlighted, especially when a lone pair is part of the system.

Hybridization impacts the stability of negative charges, with SP hybridized carbons forming weaker bases due to electrons being closer to the nucleus.

The pKa values of acetylene and ethane are compared to demonstrate the effect of hybridization on the strength of acids and their conjugate bases.

A summary of factors affecting the stability of negative charges, including atomic size, electronegativity, resonance stabilization, inductive effects, solvating effects, and the presence of aromatic rings.

The video provides a comprehensive guide on how to determine the stability of negative charges in various chemical scenarios.

The importance of considering atomic size in stabilizing negative charges is emphasized, with larger atoms providing more stability.

Electronegativity is shown to be crucial, with more electronegative atoms better handling negative charges.

The concept of resonance stabilization is related to atomic size, with the ability to spread out negative charge over a larger area increasing stability.

Inductive effects are explained, where electron-withdrawing groups stabilize negative charges, while electron-donating groups have the opposite effect.

Solvating effects due to solvent and steric factors are detailed, with more solvent interactions leading to increased negative charge stability.

The presence of an aromatic ring system significantly stabilizes negative charges, especially when the charge is due to a lone pair within the system.

Hybridization's role in the stability of negative charges is underscored, with SP hybridized orbitals leading to more stable charges due to their proximity to the nucleus.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Using Charge to Rank Acid Base Strength in Organic Chemistry

Carbocation Stability - Hyperconjugation, Inductive Effect & Resonance Structures

Acidity: Crash Course Organic Chemistry #11

22.2 Basicity of Amines | Organic Chemistry

Acids and Bases - Basic Introduction - Organic Chemistry

Carbanion Stability

Related Tags

Organic Chemistry Base Stability Atomic Size Electronegativity Resonance Electron Delocalization Inductive Effect Solvating Effects Hybridization Aromaticity