Why the BRICS Failed

Whatifalthist

28 Feb 202342:48

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis video script explores the rise and fall of the BRICS nations—Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa—once hailed as the future global powers. It delves into how these countries have faced economic recessions, demographic crises, and political challenges, contrasting their trajectories with the continued dominance of the United States. The script critiques the hype around BRICS, highlighting the importance of long-term investment strategies over quick gains, and underscores the enduring strength of established powers despite temporary setbacks.

Takeaways

🌍 The BRICS nations (Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa) were once seen as the rising powers set to overtake Western dominance but have since faced significant challenges.
📉 Contrary to early predictions, most BRICS countries are now experiencing economic recessions, with some facing the worst in their history, along with potential famine and state collapse.
🏆 The United States has maintained its position of economic, population, cultural, political, and technological predominance, outperforming the BRICS nations.
💡 The concept of BRICS was initially promoted by Goldman Sachs as an investment opportunity, highlighting how financial interests can shape global narratives.
🤝 The BRICS countries lack a unified coalition or alliance similar to NATO or the European Union, with complex and often conflicting relationships among themselves.
💔 The BRICS narrative was driven by financial interests, Western academics, and developing world elites, but lacked a counter-narrative to challenge its assumptions.
📚 The script emphasizes the importance of understanding a country's history and cultural context when predicting its future success or failure.
📉 Brazil's economy was heavily dependent on resource exports, particularly to China, and suffered when the Chinese economic slowdown occurred.
🛑 Russia's economy is marked by corruption, inequality, and a lack of industrial competitiveness, with its future further jeopardized by its international isolation.
💼 India stands out among the BRICS with a more moderate path and fewer immediate crises, although it faces significant social and economic challenges.
🏢 China's rapid growth has stalled due to demographic issues, economic mismanagement, and geopolitical tensions, leading to a predicted social and economic collapse.
🇿🇦 South Africa was added to BRICS more for symbolic reasons than economic strength, and it faces severe internal divisions and economic challenges.

Q & A

What was the general perception of BRICS countries around 15 years ago?
-Around 15 years ago, the perception was that the BRICS countries (Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa) were rising to rule the world, displacing the old western powers such as the United States and the European Union.
How has the economic situation of BRICS countries evolved since the early 2000s?
-Since the early 2000s, a majority of the BRICS countries have faced economic challenges, including severe recessions, mass famine, population decline, and state collapse. These issues have significantly deviated from the initial expectations of their rise to dominance.
What is the current status of the United States in comparison to the BRICS countries?
-In contrast to the BRICS countries, the United States has experienced economic and population growth, maintaining its cultural, economic, political, military, and technological predominance without significant decline.
What was the initial purpose behind the formation of the BRICS grouping?
-The initial idea behind the BRICS grouping was promoted by the chairman of Goldman Sachs in 2001 as a way to encourage investment in those countries, which was hoped to be done through Goldman Sachs.
What are the main reasons for the failure of the BRICS countries according to the script?
-The main reasons for the failure of the BRICS countries include their overvaluation by special interest groups, lack of actual alliance or cooperation comparable to Western organizations like NATO, and individual systemic issues within each country that have led to economic and social challenges.
How does the script describe the relationship between BRICS countries and the United States?
-The script describes the relationship between BRICS countries and the United States as complex and multi-sided, with some BRICS countries having significant ties to the U.S., such as Brazil being an American ally and India being Russia's top ally while also having strong connections with the U.S.
What are the three interest groups that pushed the narrative of BRICS success?
-The three interest groups that pushed the narrative of BRICS success are financial types who sought investment returns, self-hating Western academics who saw the West as fundamentally broken, and developing world elites who benefited from the perception of being a strong, unified front.
What is the script's perspective on the future of Brazil?
-The script suggests a grim future for Brazil, with economic collapse, corruption, political instability, and demographic challenges leading to a dim economic outlook.
How does the script analyze the situation in Russia?
-The script analyzes Russia's situation as being similar to Brazil's in terms of corruption and resource dependency, but with a more tragic history of lost potential due to Soviet policies and current issues like population decline and international isolation.
What does the script suggest about the role of hype in the perception of the BRICS countries?
-The script suggests that hype played a significant role in the perception of the BRICS countries, with short-term growth and potential being overemphasized, leading to a shock when these countries failed to meet the high expectations set for them.
What alternative countries are mentioned in the script as having sustainable growth and bright futures?
-The script mentions countries like Mexico, Colombia, Poland, the Baltic states, Czechia, Hungary, Romania, Vietnam, Ethiopia, and Kenya as having sustainable growth and bright futures, in contrast to the BRICS countries.
How does the script conclude about the United States' position in the world?
-The script concludes that despite narratives suggesting the decline of the United States, it remains preeminent in every field, experiencing rapid re-industrialization and having the healthiest demographic future of any developed country.

Outlines

00:00

🌍 The Rise and Fall of BRICS

This paragraph discusses the concept of BRICS, which grouped Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa as emerging global powers. It highlights the initial optimism around these nations as potential world leaders, only to point out their current struggles, including recessions, famine, and state collapse. The United States, in contrast, continues to show economic and population growth, maintaining its global dominance. The paragraph delves into the flawed investment in BRICS, the rise of the Contemporary Art Market, and the geopolitical realities that undermine the unity and strength of these nations.

05:01

💡 The Illusion of BRICS Unity

The paragraph explores the origins and the flawed perception of BRICS as a cohesive bloc. It clarifies that these countries have complex, often conflicting relationships and are not united by a common goal or alliance, unlike organizations like NATO or the European Union. The text also examines the individual relationships each BRICS country has with one another and the outside world, emphasizing the lack of a shared coalition and the overvaluation of these nations by various interest groups.

10:02

🏛️ The Historical and Cultural Underpinnings of BRICS

This section delves into the historical and cultural reasons behind the BRICS nations' push for global influence. It discusses the psychological aspects of former colonial countries, the desire for recognition and power, and the role of shame and collectivism in these societies. The paragraph also touches on the concept of 'face' and the tendency of these countries to overcompensate for colonialism by projecting strength and unity, despite the lack of substance behind such claims.

15:05

📉 The Economic Downturn of Brazil

The focus shifts to Brazil, outlining its economic history and the factors that led to its downturn. The paragraph discusses Brazil's reliance on raw material exports, the impact of China's economic slowdown on commodity prices, and the corruption scandals that rocked the country. It also touches on the political instability and the election of Jair Bolsonaro, drawing parallels with the situation in the United States and the challenges faced by the country.

20:06

📊 Brazil's Socioeconomic Challenges and Missed Opportunities

The paragraph examines Brazil's missed opportunities for investment and development during the commodity boom of the early 2000s. It discusses the systemic problems inherent in Brazilian society, including corruption, inefficiency, and cultural attitudes towards work. The text also addresses the long-term economic prospects for Brazil, considering demographic trends and the potential for a continued decline in economic growth.

25:06

🌐 Russia's Geopolitical and Economic Isolation

This section focuses on Russia, highlighting its historical trajectory from a rapidly industrializing nation to its current state of geopolitical and economic isolation. The paragraph discusses the impact of Soviet rule, the post-Soviet era, and the leadership of Vladimir Putin. It also touches on Russia's demographic challenges and the potential for social unrest and state collapse in the coming years.

30:09

🇮🇳 India's Unique Path and Future Prospects

The paragraph discusses India's unique position among the BRICS nations, with a relatively stable political and economic path. It explores India's complex history, its caste system, and the impact of modernization on its society. The text also addresses the potential for social crises in India, considering factors such as overpopulation, unemployment, and the growing wealth gap.

35:11

🏗️ China's Economic Growth and Upcoming Challenges

This section provides an overview of China's remarkable economic growth and the challenges it faces. The paragraph compares China's trajectory with that of Japan, highlighting the risks of economic bubbles and demographic shifts. It also discusses China's manufacturing relationship with the United States, the country's move towards totalitarianism, and the potential for social unrest and economic instability.

40:11

🇿🇦 South Africa's Inclusion and Future Concerns

The focus turns to South Africa, the last country to be added to the BRICS group. The paragraph examines the country's history, its racial and social divisions, and the challenges it faces as a unified nation. It also discusses South Africa's economic prospects, its lack of competitiveness, and the potential for social and economic collapse in the coming decades.

🚫 Lessons from the BRICS Experience

The final paragraph reflects on the lessons that can be learned from the BRICS experience. It emphasizes the importance of ignoring hype and applying common sense when evaluating long-term investments. The text also highlights the success of countries that were overlooked in favor of the BRICS nations and concludes with a reminder that long-standing success and failure have underlying reasons that do not change rapidly.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡BRICS

BRICS is an acronym referring to the group of five major emerging national economies: Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa. The term is used to represent these countries' potential to become dominant players on the global stage. In the video, it is mentioned that around 15 years ago, people thought BRICS would rise to rule the world, displacing the old Western powers. However, the script argues that as of 2023, most of these countries have failed in one way or another, with many facing economic recessions and other challenges.

💡Economic recession

Economic recession refers to a period of temporary economic decline during which trade and industrial activity are reduced. In the context of the video, it is noted that a majority of the BRICS countries are currently in horrifying recessions, some of the worst in their historical records, indicating a significant downturn in their economic performance.

💡Cultural, economic, political, military, and technological predominance

This concept encompasses the various aspects of influence and superiority a nation can have on the global stage. The video script highlights that the United States continues to outstrip the BRICS countries in these areas, maintaining its position at the top with barely wavered predominance, despite the earlier predictions of decline.

💡Investment

Investment, in the context of the video, refers to the act of committing money or resources with the expectation of achieving a profit or benefit in the future. The script discusses how the BRICS were initially seen as a bad investment by those seeking quick returns and not understanding the value of long-term investing.

💡Contemporary Art Market

The Contemporary Art Market is a segment of the art world that deals with the buying and selling of artworks created by living artists. The video mentions that this market outpaced the S&P 500 in 2022, appreciating on average 35 percent, and presents an alternative investment opportunity to the BRICS.

💡Masterworks

Masterworks is a platform that allows individuals to invest in the Contemporary Art Market. The video script highlights that Masterworks paid out tens of millions of dollars to their investors in the previous year, indicating it as a successful and profitable investment avenue.

💡Diplomacy

Diplomacy refers to the practice of conducting negotiations, maintaining relations, and handling issues between countries in a peaceful and non-confrontational manner. The video discusses the complexity of diplomacy, particularly in the context of the BRICS countries, emphasizing that diplomatic talks or alliances do not necessarily equate to strong and impactful relationships.

💡Geopolitical

Geopolitical relates to the influence of geography, culture, and politics on international relations. The video uses the term to describe the strategic positioning and influence of countries such as Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa, and how their geopolitical situations contribute to their current states of affairs.

💡Population decline

Population decline refers to a reduction in the number of people in a country or region, often due to factors such as lower birth rates, higher death rates, or emigration. The video script mentions that many of the BRICS countries are facing massive population decline, which is a significant demographic challenge.

💡State collapse

State collapse refers to the failure of a country's political system or government, often leading to the disintegration of the state's ability to function effectively. The video warns of the potential for state collapse in some of the BRICS countries due to various crises, including economic and demographic issues.

💡Self-hating Western academics

The term 'self-hating Western academics' is used in the video to describe a group of Western intellectuals who are critical of their own societies and often view non-Western countries as having inherent cultural and systemic advantages. This perspective, according to the video, contributed to the overvaluation of the BRICS countries' potential.

💡Collectivism

Collectivism is a social, political, or economic ideology that emphasizes the interdependence of individuals and the importance of the group over the individual. The video mentions that collectivist societies, like those in the BRICS countries, tend to downplay their weaknesses and overplay their strengths in the public view, which can lead to a skewed perception of their capabilities and progress.

💡Overpopulation

Overpopulation refers to a situation where the number of people in a region exceeds the carrying capacity of that area, leading to resource scarcity and other problems. The video contrasts past predictions of overpopulation with the current reality of mass depopulation, highlighting the unpredictability of demographic trends.

💡Resource-based economies

Resource-based economies are those that primarily rely on the extraction and export of natural resources for their economic growth and income. The video discusses how countries like Brazil and Russia, which are resource-based economies, experienced economic booms when resource prices were high but faced crashes when those prices fell.

💡Industrialization

Industrialization is the process by which a country develops its industry and manufacturing sectors, leading to economic growth and modernization. The video notes that while countries like Brazil and Russia have not successfully industrialized, others like Mexico and Vietnam have become industrial powerhouses, setting them up for more sustainable growth.

💡Totalitarianism

Totalitarianism refers to a political system where the state holds total authority over the society and seeks to control all aspects of public and private life. The video mentions China's shift from

Highlights

The BRICS nations (Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa) were once predicted to dominate the world economy but have largely failed to meet expectations.

Majority of BRICS countries are currently facing severe recessions, mass famine, population decline, and state collapse.

The United States maintains its economic, population growth, and global predominance despite the challenges faced by BRICS nations.

Investment in BRICS was driven by a desire for quick returns rather than long-term value, leading to disappointment.

The Contemporary Art Market outperformed the S&P 500 in 2022, offering an alternative investment opportunity.

The BRICS concept was never a formal alliance, lacking the structure and impact of organizations like NATO or the European Union.

Diplomatic relations among BRICS nations are complex and often contradictory, undermining the idea of a unified group.

The idea of BRICS was promoted by financial interests, Western academics, and developing world elites, each with their own motivations.

BRICS nations have diverse and often conflicting relationships with each other and other global powers.

Brazil's economy is heavily dependent on resource exports, making it vulnerable to fluctuations in commodity prices.

Russia's economy is burdened by its history under the Soviets, with a lack of social institutions and an over-reliance on the secret police.

India's growth has been concentrated in the service sector, with a complex social structure and a history of poverty and famine.

China's rapid economic growth is threatened by demographic challenges, an overblown housing sector, and increasing totalitarianism.

South Africa was added to BRICS largely for symbolic reasons, despite its lack of economic competitiveness and social challenges.

The BRICS narrative has been largely debunked, with many overlooked nations experiencing more sustainable growth.

The United States continues to outperform BRICS nations, maintaining its position as a global leader across various fields.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

How the U.S. and China Compete in Planes, EVs, Chips and More | WSJ U.S. vs. China

What If WW2 Was a Three Way War?

The War Aims of the Great Powers in WWI

The Power Hungry Podcast: Peter Zeihan

Prof. Robert Weiner: The Origins of World War II

ECONOMY in the INTERWAR Period [AP World History] Unit 7 Topic 4 (7.4) [REUPLOAD]

Related Tags

BRICS Geopolitics Economic Growth US Dominance Global Power Investment Analysis Market Trends Cultural Impact Demographic Shifts Future Predictions