India's Slave Brides |101 East | भारत का दास दुल्हन

Al Jazeera English
16 Nov 201626:00
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe video script highlights the severe gender imbalance in India, particularly in the state of Haryana, where a preference for male children has led to a scarcity of women for marriage. This has resulted in a thriving trade in human trafficking, with young girls being sold to desperate men as brides. The narrative follows the stories of trafficked women, their struggles, and the efforts of NGOs and law enforcement to rescue and empower them. The script also touches upon the social and cultural factors that contribute to this issue, including the lack of respect for women and the need for comprehensive anti-trafficking laws to address the root causes and protect the victims.

Takeaways
  • 🇮🇳 A preference for male children in India has led to a severe gender imbalance, with a shortage of women causing a rise in human trafficking for the purpose of marriage.
  • 💔 The lack of value for girls in India is evident not just in sex selection but also in infanticide and the general mistreatment of girls from birth.
  • 🤵🏼 In Haryana, it has become normalized for men to buy brides from other states due to the extreme shortage of local women willing to marry.
  • 📊 A survey of 10,000 households in Haryana revealed that over 9,000 married women were trafficked from other states, highlighting the scale of the issue.
  • 🚫 The women trafficked into marriage are often treated as commodities rather than respected partners, facing multiple sales and severe abuse.
  • 👧 Trafficked girls are sometimes sold multiple times, with villagers derogatorily referring to them as 'parrots', indicating their status as purchased goods.
  • 😢 The emotional and physical abuse faced by these women is immense, with many feeling they have no self-respect and are treated like animals.
  • 🆘 Rescue missions are challenging due to illiteracy, language barriers, and the powerful connections traffickers often have within communities.
  • 👮‍♀️ Local authorities and NGOs are working to empower trafficked women and bring traffickers to justice, but the journey for these women is long and fraught with difficulties.
  • 🏡 Many trafficked women yearn to return home, but face significant barriers including social stigma, lack of legal rights, and the threat of further abuse.
  • 📜 The Indian government is drafting comprehensive anti-trafficking laws, but changing deep-rooted social norms and attitudes towards the value of women is crucial for long-term success.
Q & A
  • What is the primary cause of the gender imbalance in India mentioned in the script?

    -The preference for male babies in India has led to a severe gender imbalance due to sex selection, infanticide, and a general lack of value for girls.

  • What has the shortage of women for marriage led to in some parts of India?

    -The shortage of women for marriage has led to the trafficking of young girls to men desperate to marry, particularly in the state of Haryana.

  • What is the derogatory term used by villagers for trafficked women in the script?

    -The derogatory term used by villagers for trafficked women is 'parrots', implying that they are being purchased.

  • What is the term used to describe the act of buying brides from other states in Haryana?

    -The act is referred to as 'sex trafficking' by Poonam Matraja, a government advisor on family issues.

  • What is the situation regarding women who are trafficked and married multiple times?

    -Some trafficked women are sold to men not just once, but two or three times, leading to a cycle of abuse and mistreatment.

  • What challenges do trafficked women face in terms of legal rights and justice?

    -Trafficked women face challenges such as illiteracy, language barriers, and a lack of community support, making it difficult for them to seek and obtain justice.

  • How does the geographical location and environmental conditions of Assam contribute to the vulnerability of girls and women?

    -Assam's location and its susceptibility to catastrophic flooding displace families and make them vulnerable to traffickers, who exploit their desperate circumstances.

  • What is the role of NGOs in helping trafficked women?

    -NGOs work to empower trafficked women, provide them with support, and assist in rescue missions to help them escape from abusive situations.

  • What is the impact of social norms and the lack of respect for women on the trafficking issue?

    -Social norms and the lack of respect for women contribute significantly to the demand for trafficked brides and perpetuate the cycle of abuse and trafficking.

  • What is the Indian government doing to address the issue of trafficking?

    -The Indian government is drafting the country's first comprehensive anti-trafficking laws to combat the issue more effectively.

  • What is the emotional and psychological impact on trafficked women and their families?

    -The emotional and psychological impact is severe, with feelings of despair, helplessness, and a longing to return home. The trauma endured by trafficked women can take a long time to heal.

  • Why is it important for trafficked women to be accepted back into their families and communities?

    -Acceptance is crucial for the recovery and reintegration of trafficked women into society. It helps to restore their dignity and provides a support system for healing and rebuilding their lives.

Outlines
00:00
😔 Gender Imbalance and Bride Trafficking in India

The first paragraph discusses the severe gender imbalance in India, particularly in Haryana, where a preference for male babies has led to a shortage of women for marriage. This has resulted in the trafficking of young girls, sold to desperate men. Steve Chow investigates this issue on '101 East', highlighting the tragic lives of trafficked women who are treated as commodities rather than respected partners. The government advisor, Poonam Matraja, explains that due to the shortage, it's become common for men to buy brides from other states. A survey reveals that over 9,000 married women in Haryana are from elsewhere, with some being sold multiple times. Sanjeta's story is shared, detailing her kidnapping at age 10 and subsequent forced marriage and captivity.

05:08
👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Aftermath of Trafficking: Family Life and Advocacy

The second paragraph follows Sanjida, who, despite being trafficked, has a family that treats her kindly. She now works for an NGO to empower trafficked women. The narrative then shifts to McLisha, a girl trafficked at 12, who endured abusive marriages and is now under police protection. The local district chief magistrate, Narendra Singh, addresses the challenges trafficked brides face in seeking justice due to illiteracy and language barriers. The police attempt to arrest McLisha's violent second husband, highlighting the ongoing efforts to combat trafficking.

10:15
🌾 Vulnerability and the Role of Poverty in Trafficking

The third paragraph delves into the origins of many trafficked girls, starting with the northeastern state of Assam. The region's poverty, coupled with natural disasters like flooding, makes families vulnerable to traffickers' promises of financial assistance and job opportunities. A social worker recounts his experiences with over 100 rescue missions, and we meet a mother whose daughter was trafficked after her father's death. The mother's despair at her inability to rescue her daughter without funds is palpable.

15:15
📞 The Struggle for Family Reunification

The fourth paragraph continues with stories of families searching for their trafficked daughters. Majida, a mother with three young children, is unable to afford the search for her daughter. Another family recounts their six-year search for their 13-year-old daughter, who disappeared six years prior. The narrative also includes a 14-year-old girl who was one of the fortunate few to be found after being trafficked and sold into marriage, now living with her grandmother.

20:17
🚨 Police Intervention and the Complexities of Rescue

The fifth paragraph describes Majida's journey to Haryana to find her daughter, with the help of the police and necessary documents. The rescue mission, although successful in locating the daughter, ends with a heart-wrenching scene where Majida's daughter is torn between her mother and her husband. The husband denies that money was exchanged for the bride, but the police believe he paid for her. The situation underscores the complexities of trafficking cases and the emotional distress they cause.

25:17
🏛️ The Need for Comprehensive Anti-Trafficking Laws

The sixth and final paragraph addresses the Indian government's initiative to draft the country's first comprehensive anti-trafficking laws. It emphasizes that while laws are necessary, changing social norms and attitudes towards the value of women is crucial. Sanjida, now focused on her daughters' education, hopes for a better life for them, free from the suffering she endured.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Gender Imbalance
Gender imbalance refers to a discrepancy in the number of males compared to females in a population. In the context of the video, it is a severe issue in India, particularly in Haryana, where a preference for male babies has led to a skewed gender ratio and a shortage of women for marriage.
💡Human Trafficking
Human trafficking is the illegal trade of people for exploitation or forced labor. The video discusses how the shortage of women to marry in Haryana has led to the trafficking of young girls from other states and even other countries, who are sold into marriage against their will.
💡Patriarchal Society
A patriarchal society is one in which men hold primary power and are dominant in roles of political leadership, moral authority, and social privilege. The video highlights how the patriarchal norms in Haryana contribute to the devaluation of women and the practice of buying brides.
💡Infanticide
Infanticide is the act of killing an infant. The video mentions infanticide as part of the continuum of the lack of value for girls in Haryana, where female babies are not only undesired before birth but also face neglect and danger after birth.
💡Commodification of Women
Commodification of women refers to treating women as objects or commodities to be bought and sold. In the video, it is shown that women who are trafficked into marriage are not treated as respected partners but rather as commodities that can be resold, highlighting a deep lack of respect for women.
💡NGO (Non-Governmental Organization)
An NGO is a non-profit organization that operates independently of any government, typically to address social or humanitarian issues. In the video, Sanjida works for a local NGO to empower trafficked women, showing that NGOs play a crucial role in supporting and advocating for the victims of trafficking.
💡Legal Rights
Legal rights are the rights granted to individuals by law. The video discusses the challenges trafficked brides face in accessing legal rights due to illiteracy, language barriers, and the power of traffickers within communities. The local district chief magistrate is an advocate for these women, emphasizing the importance of legal support.
💡Poverty
Poverty is the state of being extremely poor. The video explains that poverty in the northeastern state of Assam makes families vulnerable to traffickers, as they may be more likely to agree to offers that promise financial assistance or a better life for their daughters.
💡Cultural Differences
Cultural differences refer to the variations in customs, beliefs, and practices among different societies. The video contrasts the culture of Assam with that of Haryana, highlighting how girls from Assam, who are accustomed to a different landscape and way of life, end up in Haryana as a result of trafficking.
💡Anti-Trafficking Laws
Anti-trafficking laws are legislative measures designed to combat human trafficking. The Indian government is drafting comprehensive anti-trafficking laws, as mentioned in the video, which are necessary to address the issue but must be accompanied by changes in social norms to be effective.
💡Rescue Missions
Rescue missions are operations aimed at saving individuals from dangerous or harmful situations. The video describes the efforts of social workers and police in conducting rescue missions to save trafficked girls and bring them back to their homes, although the process is often fraught with emotional and legal challenges.
Highlights

In India, a preference for male babies has created a severe gender imbalance, leading to a shortage of women for marriage

Traffickers sell young girls to men desperate to marry in India's Haryana state, which has the worst gender ratio in the country

The lack of value for girls in India is a continuum - they are not valued before or after birth

Men in Haryana often buy brides from other states due to the shortage of women to marry

Trafficked women are treated as commodities that can be recycled and resold, rather than respected married partners

A survey found over 90% of married women in Haryana came from other states, with many trafficked into marriage multiple times

Trafficked women in Haryana are derogatorily called 'parrots', implying they are purchased

Sanjeeta was kidnapped at age 10 and sold into marriage after 4 years in captivity

Sanjeeta's father found her after she was already 3 months pregnant, and she now works to empower trafficked women

Mclisha was sold to a 70-year-old man at age 12, and then遭受了abuse by her second husband

Many trafficked girls come from the impoverished, flood-prone state of Assam in northeast India

Traffickers exploit the vulnerability of poor families in Assam, offering financial assistance in exchange for their daughters

Majida's 16-year-old daughter went missing after going to buy a notebook and was later found trafficked to Haryana

Some families reject trafficked daughters upon their return due to the 'honor' stigma

The Indian government is drafting its first comprehensive anti-trafficking laws to address the issue

Changing social norms and attitudes towards girls is key to ending the demand for trafficked brides in India

Sanjeeta is now focused on educating her daughters so they do not have to suffer the same fate as their mother

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: