The Crippling Long Term Effects Of The First World War | The Long Shadow Full Series | Timeline

Timeline - World History Documentaries

8 Mar 2022147:15

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe video script delves into the profound and enduring impact of World War I on the global stage, particularly in Europe. It explores how the war sparked a surge in nationalism, leading to the reconfiguration of borders and the formation of new states from the ruins of empires like Austria-Hungary. The script also examines the peace treaties, particularly the Treaty of Versailles, and how they were influenced by the nationalistic fervor of the time. It discusses the rise of ideologies such as communism, fascism, and democracy in the post-war era, which would go on to shape the political landscape of the 20th century. The narrative further reflects on the personal and societal transformations that occurred, from the democratization of Britain to the aggressive nationalism that led to World War II. The script also touches upon the complex aftermath of the war, including the struggle for independence in Ireland and the European Union's efforts to reconcile and unite nations. It concludes with the observation that the Great War continues to influence contemporary politics and national identities, illustrating the far-reaching consequences of this historical event.

Takeaways

📺 The script is a narration for a documentary series exploring the impact and legacy of World War I, indicating its far-reaching effects on history.
🌟 Dan Snow introduces History Hit TV, a platform similar to Netflix, dedicated to history with a special offer for fans of the Timeline series.
🏰 The Great War is often remembered in Britain as a pointless slaughter, with a focus on the mud and blood of the trenches, rather than any clear achievement.
📚 There is a paradox in remembering the Great War: it was a static and futile conflict, yet it unleashed dynamic forces that shaped the century since 1914.
🏟️ The memory of the Great War is not fixed but has shifted over time, with different countries remembering it in different ways, influencing future events.
🕊️ The British Commonwealth forces returning from France faced difficulty in coming to terms with the enormity of the war and the experiences of the soldiers.
🏛️ The Cenotaph in London was commissioned as a monument to remember the war, symbolizing an empty tomb and allowing individuals to project their own memories and emotions.
🌼 The Unknown Warrior was buried with reverence, and the gravestones designed by Rudyard Kipling aimed to give every soldier a named grave, reflecting the desire for honor and remembrance.
⚖️ Post-war, there was a significant debate over the standardized headstone, with some seeing it as a Prussian imposition, but it represented the survivors' grand apology.
🎭 The play 'Journey's End' and the Peace Ballot in Britain reflected a desire for peace and a reflection on the war's reality, indicating a willingness to risk war in the hope of maintaining peace.
🌍 World War II and its aftermath reshaped the memory of World War I, with the latter often seen as a failed attempt to end war, leading to the term 'First World War'.

Q & A

What is History Hit TV and what does it offer to viewers?
-History Hit TV is a platform likened to Netflix for history enthusiasts, offering hundreds of exclusive documentaries and interviews with the world's leading historians. It provides a deep dive into historical events and figures, and it has a special offer for fans of Timeline who use a specific code to avail of an introductory offer.
How is the perception of World War I viewed in Britain?
-In Britain, World War I is often viewed as a pointless slaughter characterized by mud and blood. It is commonly seen as a conflict that resulted in a terrible sacrifice for no clear purpose, with its memory often invoked through poignant war poetry and solemn remembrance rituals.
What is the significance of the Unknown Warrior and the Cenotaph in British memory and how were they established?
-The Unknown Warrior and the Cenotaph are significant monuments in British memory as they represent the many soldiers who have no known grave. The Cenotaph, designed by Edwin Lutyens, was initially a temporary wooden structure for a victory parade in 1919 and later made permanent in stone. It serves as a simple yet abstract memorial where people can project their own memories and emotions, while the Unknown Warrior represents the many missing soldiers and is buried with reverence.
How did the memory of World War I shift over time and how did different countries remember it differently?
-The memory of World War I has shifted repeatedly over time and is not fixed. Different countries remember the war in different ways, with a significant contrast between the memory of the war in Britain and Germany. These varying memories would have a substantial impact on the years that followed the war.
What was the role of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission and how was it established?
-The Commonwealth War Graves Commission was established as a result of the efforts of Fabian Ware, who advocated for each soldier to have their own named grave, regardless of rank or nationality. The Commission maintains nearly a thousand cemeteries and memorials, providing a respectful resting place for the fallen and a means for the living to remember them.
How did the British state handle the repatriation of soldiers' remains after World War I?
-The British state decided against repatriating the remains of soldiers due to the prohibitive cost and the fact that many men had been blown to bits. Instead, their bodies were carefully collected along the Western Front, buried with reverence, and commemorated with striking architecture.
What was the impact of the play 'Journey's End' on the British public's perception of World War I?
-The play 'Journey's End', written by RC Sherriff, who had served as an officer on the Western Front, brought the reality of the war to the British public in a profound way. The play, set in a gloomy dugout, depicted soldiers' experiences in a realistic manner. Its impact was significant, as it ended in a silence that was described as eerie and unreal, followed by cheers and a long run in the West End. It was interpreted by some as a stark warning about the horror of war and a plea for peace.
How did the interwar years shape the perception of the future and the desire for peace?
-The interwar years were marked by a strong desire for peace, with the hope that the horrors of World War I would never be repeated. This hope was focused on the establishment of the League of Nations, an international body aimed at maintaining peace. The 1920s were a time of new music, fashions, and a general willingness to forget the war and look towards a hopeful future.
What was the role of Robert Cecil in the establishment of the League of Nations?
-Robert Cecil was a key architect and champion of the League of Nations in Britain. He was driven by a deep Christian conscience and a desire to prevent future wars. Cecil saw the League as essential machinery to prevent states from going to war and believed in democratic decisions open to public scrutiny. He was also involved in the push for international agreements to reduce armaments.
How did the British public's attitude towards peace and potential military sanctions change in the 1930s?
-In the 1930s, the British public's attitude towards peace was significantly shaped by the Peace Ballot, which showed that over 90% of respondents supported Britain's continued membership in the League of Nations and backed international agreements to reduce armaments. Even more remarkably, 60% were willing to support military sanctions against aggressor states, indicating a willingness to risk war in the hope of keeping the peace.
How did World War II change the perception of World War I and its significance?
-World War II, with its clear-cut evil in the form of the Nazi regime and its unprecedented global scale, led to a shift in the perception of World War I. The earlier war began to be seen as less significant and more inconclusive, especially as the world recognized the noble sacrifice made in the second war. This shift was reflected in the renaming of World War I to the First World War, highlighting the idea that it was a failed attempt to end all wars.

Outlines

00:00

🎥 Introduction to History Hit TV

Dan Snow introduces History Hit TV, a platform similar to Netflix that offers a plethora of exclusive documentaries and interviews with renowned historians. He mentions a special offer for fans of the Timeline series and encourages viewers to check out History Hit TV. The video then transitions into a discussion about the Great War, its impact on memory and history, and the importance of understanding its true significance beyond the common perception of a futile and inconclusive conflict.

05:06

🏙️ The Architecture of Remembrance

This paragraph discusses how Britain and the Commonwealth commemorated the dead from World War I through architectural monuments like the Cenotaph in London and the Menin Gate in Ieper, Belgium. It highlights the设计理念 of these memorials, which allowed individuals to project their own memories and emotions. The narrative also touches on the controversy surrounding the standardized headstones and the eventual acceptance of these memorials as a way to honor the dead and remember the war.

10:08

📚 Public Grief and the Journey's End Play

The focus shifts to the 10th anniversary of the war's end and how it triggered a wave of public grief and reflection. New books and memoirs, along with the play 'Journey's End' by R.C. Sherriff, contributed to a deeper understanding of the soldiers' experiences. The play, in particular, was seen as a plea for peace and was significant in bringing the reality of the war to the British public, despite initially receiving an eerie silence from its audience.

15:09

🕊️ The Post-War Yearning for Peace

The narrative explores the post-war sentiment of 'never again' and the hope for a lasting peace, symbolized by the establishment of the League of Nations. Robert Cecil, one of the League's key architects, is introduced as a champion of this cause. The inter-war years are depicted as a time of hope, with an emphasis on peace and the prevention of future conflicts, in stark contrast to the horrors of the recent war.

20:10

🇩🇪 Germany's Different Path and the Rise of Hitler

This section contrasts the British and German experiences after World War I. While Britain focused on peace, Germany, under the Treaty of Versailles, felt humiliated and aggrieved. Adolf Hitler's rise to power is examined, including his manipulation of the war's memory to fuel nationalist sentiment and his eventual withdrawal from the League of Nations. The paragraph also highlights the stark difference between the British and German approaches to the war's legacy.

25:10

🗳️ The Peace Ballot and British Response to Hitler

The account of Charles Bormann's local campaign against Hitler's aggression leads to the nationwide Peace Ballot, which engaged half a million volunteers and garnered over 11 million responses. This peaceful movement demonstrated the British public's support for the League of Nations and a willingness to risk war to maintain peace. However, the British government's approach to foreign policy, particularly regarding Mussolini's invasion of Abyssinia, revealed a more complex and less idealistic stance behind the scenes.

30:12

🎭 The Shift in Public Mood and Chamberlain's Munich Agreement

The narrative describes the changing public sentiment in the late 1930s, moving towards appeasement of Italy and Germany. Neville Chamberlain's efforts to prevent war through the Munich Agreement are detailed, along with the ultimate failure of this policy. Chamberlain's actions are contextualized within the broader fear of another global conflict and the lingering impact of World War I on the British psyche.

35:13

🏛️ The Legacy of World War I and the Rise of New Ideologies

The post-war political landscape is explored, focusing on the rise of communism, republicanism, and fascism in the wake of the Great War. The paragraph discusses how these ideologies polarized Europe and led to significant political changes, with leaders like Lenin, Wilson, and Mussolini offering distinct visions for the future. The British monarchy's rebranding and its role in maintaining political stability are also highlighted.

40:17

🌐 The Impact of World War I on Global Politics

The final paragraph examines the long-term effects of World War I on global politics, emphasizing the war's role in enabling mass democracy and the rise of extremist ideologies. It discusses how the war led to the fall of monarchies, the spread of communism, and the emergence of fascism, shaping the political dynamics of Britain and the world up to the present day. The narrative concludes with a reflection on the ongoing struggle to manage the force of democracy in the aftermath of the war.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡History Hit TV

History Hit TV is a subscription-based streaming service that specializes in history content, offering hundreds of exclusive documentaries and interviews with leading historians. It is mentioned in the script as a platform similar to Netflix, but focused on historical topics. The channel is used as an example to illustrate the wealth of historical knowledge and diverse perspectives available to modern audiences interested in history.

💡Great War

The Great War, also known as World War I, is a central theme in the video. It refers to the global war that lasted from 1914 to 1918, involving many of the world's major powers. The video discusses the impact of the war, the public's memory of it, and how it shaped the 20th century. The term 'Great War' is used to highlight the significance and the scale of the conflict, as well as to contrast it with World War II, which is sometimes considered a more 'just' war due to the nature of the opposing forces.

💡Remembrance

Remembrance is the act of remembering and honoring those who died in war, particularly focusing on the fallen soldiers of the Great War. The video references various rituals and monuments, such as the Cenotaph and Menin Gate, which serve as focal points for remembrance. The concept is integral to the video's exploration of how societies commemorate and mourn their war dead, and how these practices have evolved over time.

💡Nationalism

Nationalism is a political ideology that involves a strong identification with one's country and the promotion of its interests, particularly with the aim of gaining or maintaining self-governance. In the context of the video, nationalism is portrayed as a powerful force that emerged from the Great War and subsequently influenced the political landscape of Europe, leading to the creation of new states and the redrawing of borders. The video also discusses the dark side of nationalism, such as the aggressive form espoused by Adolf Hitler and the ethnic tensions it can cause.

💡Peace Movement

The peace movement refers to the collective efforts of individuals and groups who advocate for peaceful resolution of conflicts and oppose warfare. The video mentions the Peace Ballot, a British initiative that sought public opinion on matters of war and peace, reflecting a widespread desire to avoid further conflict following the Great War. This keyword is significant as it demonstrates the public's engagement with political issues and their willingness to participate in shaping their nation's path towards peace.

💡League of Nations

The League of Nations was an international organization founded after the Great War with the aim of maintaining world peace. It is mentioned in the script as an example of post-war efforts to prevent future conflicts through collective security and international cooperation. The League's failure to prevent World War II and its eventual replacement by the United Nations highlight the challenges of enforcing global peace.

💡Fascism

Fascism is a far-right political ideology characterized by dictatorial power, strong nationalism, and a focus on ethnic purity. The video discusses the rise of fascist leaders like Benito Mussolini and Adolf Hitler, who capitalized on the discontent following the Great War to seize power. Fascism is portrayed as a direct response to the perceived failures of liberal democracy and the economic hardships of the interwar period.

💡World War II

World War II, the global conflict that began in 1939, is discussed in the video as a tragic outcome of unresolved issues from the Great War. It is used to contrast with the Great War, particularly in terms of public perception and the nature of the conflict. World War II is often viewed as a 'necessary' or 'good' war against the evils of fascism and Nazism, which influenced the way the Great War was subsequently remembered and commemorated.

💡Irish Independence

Irish Independence refers to the movement and eventual achievement of freedom from British rule. The video discusses the Easter Rising in 1916 and the subsequent struggle for independence, which was deeply influenced by the events of the Great War. The fight for Irish independence is used as an example of nationalist movements that were both inspired and complicated by the global conflicts of the early 20th century.

💡European Union

The European Union (EU) is a political and economic union of European countries, established to foster cooperation and prevent future wars. The video mentions the EU as a modern form of empire that has helped to contain the destructive forces of nationalism that have plagued Europe. The EU represents a shift from the 'us versus them' mentality that characterized much of the 20th century, towards a more integrated and cooperative approach to national identity.

💡Sudetenland

The Sudetenland refers to a region that was part of Czechoslovakia with a significant ethnic German population. It is mentioned in the context of Adolf Hitler's annexation of the region, which was a pretext for the invasion of Czechoslovakia and a trigger for the escalation of World War II. The Sudetenland crisis is an example of how unresolved ethnic tensions and nationalistic claims from the Great War era contributed to the outbreak of further conflict.

Highlights

Dan Snow introduces History Hit TV, a platform similar to Netflix but dedicated to history, offering hundreds of exclusive documentaries and interviews with leading historians.

An exclusive offer is available for fans of Timeline who visit History Hit TV and use the code 'timeline' to get a special introductory offer.

The Great War, also known as World War I, is often remembered as a static, futile, and inconclusive conflict, but it also unleashed dynamic forces that shaped the 20th century.

The memory of the Great War is not fixed; it has shifted over time, with different countries remembering the conflict in different ways.

The British Commonwealth forces that returned from France in 1918 faced difficulty in coming to terms with the enormity of the war and the experiences of the soldiers.

The Cenotaph, an empty tomb, was commissioned as a monument to remember the war dead, symbolizing an abstract space for people to project their memories and emotions.

Fabian Ware, who was too old to fight, volunteered as an ambulance driver and later initiated the project to give every soldier a named grave, leading to the creation of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission.

The concept of 'Known unto God' was coined by Rudyard Kipling for those soldiers who were missing and had no known grave.

The memorial project led by Ware and Kipling was controversial at the time, with many opposing the standardized headstone and the centralized control of the dead by the British state.

The 1920s were a time of new music, fashions, and a desire to forget the Great War, with the younger generation keen to consign it to history.

The play 'Journey's End' and its author R.C. Sheriff brought the reality of the war's trenches to life on stage, offering a stark warning about the horror of war.

The interwar years were marked by hope for 'never again', with the establishment of the League of Nations to prevent future conflicts.

Robert Cecil, a key figure in the League of Nations, worked to prevent another war through international cooperation and democratic decision-making.

The British public's attitude towards the League of Nations and the concept of military sanctions against aggressor states was revealed through the Peace Ballot, which saw a significant majority supporting international peace efforts.

The 1930s saw a rise in extremist politics, with figures like Benito Mussolini and Adolf Hitler leveraging nationalist sentiments to gain power.

The British monarchy was rebranded to serve as a symbol of national unity and stability during the turbulent post-war period.

The Great War's legacy included the rise of mass democracy, with political leaders like Stanley Baldwin and Ramsay MacDonald helping to shape Britain's democratic future.

The aftermath of the war saw the emergence of new ideologies such as communism, fascism, and republicanism, which would have a profound impact on global politics.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

WWI: How The Scars Of The Great War Changed The 20th Century | Long Shadow: Parts 1-3 | War Stories

Understanding The Global Unease After WW1 | Impossible Peace | Timeline

1919-1939: The Treaty of Versailles, a truce that led to another war

The Treaty of Versailles, Explained [AP Euro Review—Unit 8 Topic 4]

How Did World War 1 Start?

6 Key Steps to World War One