WWI: How The Scars Of The Great War Changed The 20th Century | Long Shadow: Parts 1-3 | War Stories

War Stories

1 Dec 2021147:02

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe video script explores the profound and lasting impact of World War I on the collective memory, politics, and national identities across Europe. It delves into how the war shaped the 20th century, from the rise of ideologies like communism and fascism to the redrawing of national borders and the struggle for self-determination. The narrative highlights the paradox of the Great War, which, despite not being caused by deep political divisions, ended up creating them, leading to a century marked by the rise of mass democracy, the spread of nationalism, and the eventual formation of the European Union as a response to nationalist conflicts. The script also touches on the personal sacrifices and the shift in public memory of the war over time, influenced by events like the Cuban Missile Crisis and the Cold War, reflecting on the ongoing challenge of reconciling national identities with a shared European heritage.

Takeaways

📜 The Great War (1914-1918) had a profound and lasting impact on the collective memory and national identities of the nations involved, shaping the course of the 20th century.
🏰 The aftermath of the war saw the collapse of old empires, such as the Austro-Hungarian Empire, and the rise of new nation-states, leading to a reshaping of European borders and political landscapes.
🗽 The peace treaties and the establishment of the League of Nations were attempts to prevent future conflicts, but they also sowed the seeds for nationalist movements and further unrest.
🏺 The memory of the Great War was commemorated through monuments, rituals, and the arts, with different countries remembering the conflict in varied ways, reflecting their unique experiences and narratives.
🌐 The war catalyzed political change, leading to the rise of ideologies such as communism, fascism, and democratic socialism, which would polarize Europe and set the stage for World War II.
👥 The experiences of ordinary soldiers were often overshadowed by the narratives of political leaders and generals, but the voices of poets like Wilfred Owen and Siegfried Sassoon brought a human perspective to the cost of war.
🌿 The British Commonwealth forces returned home to a nation struggling to comprehend the scale of the conflict and its impact on individuals and society, leading to a complex interplay between public commemoration and private grief.
🏛 Sir Edwin Lutyens' design of the Cenotaph in London and the emphasis on individual graves for fallen soldiers reflected a desire to honor the dead while also grappling with the scale of loss.
📊 The Peace Ballot of the 1930s in Britain demonstrated a public appetite for collective memory and a desire to avoid another war, indicating a complex relationship between memory, democracy, and international relations.
📚 The reinterpretation of the Great War in the 1960s, influenced by the threat of nuclear war and the horrors of World War II, led to a renewed focus on the futility and moral lessons of the earlier conflict.
🏞 The European Union, born out of the ashes of two world wars, represents a concerted effort to resolve nationalistic conflicts through economic and political integration, offering a model for peaceful coexistence.

Q & A

How did the Great War impact the British view of war and sacrifice?
-The Great War led to a view of the conflict as a pointless slaughter, with a focus on the mud and blood of the trenches. It resulted in a sense of futility and a belief that the sacrifices made were for nothing, as Britain did not gain any significant advantage from the war.
What was the significance of the Cenotaph and the Unknown Soldier?
-The Cenotaph and the Unknown Soldier represented a new form of commemoration that allowed the British people to remember the war in their own way. The Cenotaph, an empty tomb, served as an abstract space onto which people could project their memories and emotions, while the Unknown Soldier symbolized all the missing and unidentified men who died in the war.
How did the memory of the Great War shift over time?
-The memory of the Great War shifted from a focus on the horror and sacrifice of the conflict to a broader understanding of its long-term impacts. Over time, the war came to be seen not just as a tragic event, but as a transformative force that shaped the entire 20th century.
What was the impact of World War II on the perception of the Great War?
-World War II had a significant impact on the perception of the Great War. The second war was seen as a clear struggle against evil, which made the first war's sacrifices seem more futile and its causes less justifiable. This led to a renaming of the Great War to the First World War, emphasizing that it was a failed attempt to end all wars.
How did the aftermath of the Great War influence the rise of extremist ideologies?
-The aftermath of the Great War created a political vacuum that allowed extremist ideologies like communism and fascism to rise. The economic and social instability that followed the war provided fertile ground for these ideologies, which promised radical solutions to the problems facing Europe.
What was the role of the League of Nations in the post-war period?
-The League of Nations was established as an international body to prevent future wars by promoting diplomacy and cooperation between nations. It was a key part of the post-war settlement and represented an idealistic attempt to create a more peaceful world order.
How did the Great War affect the political landscape of Europe?
-The Great War led to the collapse of several major empires and the rise of new nation-states. This redrawing of national borders and the emergence of new political entities led to a period of political instability and conflict across Europe.
What was the significance of the Peace Ballot in Britain in the 1930s?
-The Peace Ballot was a unique and massive public opinion survey conducted by the League of Nations Union in Britain. It demonstrated strong public support for peace, international cooperation, and the League of Nations, and it showed that a majority of the British population was willing to risk war in the hope of preserving peace.
How did the experience of the Great War influence the British approach to the threat of another war in the 1930s?
-The experience of the Great War made the British public and government wary of another large-scale conflict. This led to a focus on appeasement and a desire to find peaceful solutions to the rising tensions in Europe during the 1930s, even as rearmament began in response to the growing threat from Germany.
What was the impact of the Great War on the British monarchy and its role in the country?
-The Great War led to a rebranding of the British monarchy as a symbol of national unity and resilience. Despite the challenges of the post-war period, the monarchy managed to adapt to the changing political landscape and remained a keystone of political stability in Britain.
How did the Great War shape the political ideologies and movements that emerged in the 20th century?
-The Great War was a catalyst for the rise of new political ideologies and movements, including communism, fascism, and democratic socialism. The war created conditions that allowed these ideologies to gain traction, as people sought solutions to the social and economic problems that emerged in its aftermath.

Outlines

00:00

😔 The Legacy of the Great War and Its Impact on Memory and Perception

This paragraph discusses the commemoration of the Great War, highlighting the annual rituals and the struggle to understand its significance. It reflects on the common perception of the war as a senseless slaughter and the paradox of remembering a conflict that was distant yet had profound effects. The speaker aims to reassess the conflict's impact on Britain and the world, considering how memories of the war have evolved and the different ways countries remember it, especially contrasting Britain and Germany's memories.

05:00

🏰 The Architectural Legacy and the British Mourning Process

The paragraph delves into the British Commonwealth forces' return from France and the difficulty of comprehending the war's scale and its impact on soldiers. It discusses the creation of monuments, such as the Cenotaph, and the controversy surrounding the standardized headstones for fallen soldiers. The narrative also touches on the work of Sir Edwin Lutyens and Rudyard Kipling in honoring the dead and the public's reaction to these memorials.

10:04

🎭 The Cultural Aftermath: Art, Literature, and the Great War

This section explores how the 10th anniversary of the war's end triggered private grief and public debate, with new books and memoirs revealing the soldiers' experiences. It highlights the impact of the play 'Journey's End' and how it brought the reality of the war to life for the British public. The paragraph also discusses the desire for peace in the 1920s and 1930s and the role of the League of Nations in this hope.

15:04

🕊️ The Pursuit of Peace and the League of Nations

The focus here is on the push for peace and the establishment of the League of Nations, with a particular emphasis on Robert Cecil's role. It outlines Cecil's background, his efforts to ensure every soldier had a named grave, and the controversy surrounding the state-imposed remembrance. The paragraph also touches on the post-war generation's desire to move on and the resurgence of discussions about the war's meaning during anniversaries.

20:04

🗣️ Public Opinion and the Rise of Dictatorships

The narrative shifts to the manipulation of public memory by political figures like Adolf Hitler and the stark contrast between the British Legion's peaceful veterans and Nazi paramilitaries. It discusses Hitler's political rise, the economic depression's impact, and the British public's response to the escalating arms race. The paragraph also highlights Charles Borman's local campaign against Hitler and the significant response it garnered.

25:05

✍️ The Peace Ballot and the British Public's Stance on Peace

This section details the Peace Ballot, a nationwide survey conducted by the League of Nations Union to gauge public opinion on peace and the League's role. It describes the public's overwhelming support for continued membership in the League and the willingness to risk war for peace. The results of the ballot are presented, showing a clear preference for peace and international cooperation.

30:06

🌐 The Global Impact of the Great War and the Interwar Years

The paragraph discusses the global impact of the Great War, the fear of total war, and the political climate leading to World War II. It outlines the British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain's attempts to prevent war through appeasement and the ultimate failure of this policy. The narrative reflects on how the second war reshaped the memory of the first, leading to a change in how the Great War was commemorated.

35:08

📚 Reinterpreting the Great War in the 1960s

This section focuses on the reinterpretation of the Great War in the 1960s, influenced by events like the Cuban Missile Crisis and the 50th anniversary of the war's outbreak. It discusses the shift in public memory and the emergence of new perspectives on the war's significance, including the work of Fritz Fischer and the cultural impact of 'Oh! What a Lovely War.'

40:10

🏆 The Transformation of War Memory Through Poetry

The paragraph examines the influence of war poetry, particularly Wilfred Owen's works, on the public memory of the Great War. It contrasts the public perception of Owen as an anti-war poet with the more complex reality of his experiences and beliefs. The narrative also touches on the way Owen's poetry was repackaged in the 1960s to fit an anti-war narrative.

45:12

🌍 The Lasting Resonance of the Great War

The final paragraph reflects on the enduring impact of the Great War, emphasizing the need to understand it as history rather than just poetry or a morality play. It discusses the paradox of the war creating political and ideological divisions in its wake and the rise of mass democracy. The speaker calls for a deeper exploration of the war's meaning and legacy, beyond the clichés of mud, death, and poppies.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Great War

The Great War, also known as World War I, was a global conflict that lasted from 1914 to 1918. It involved many of the world's major powers, organized into two opposing alliances: the Allies and the Central Powers. The war was characterized by trench warfare and resulted in significant political changes, including the fall of several European monarchies and a reordering of the map of Europe. In the video, the Great War is discussed as a pivotal event that unleashed dynamic forces shaping the 20th century, including the rise of new ideologies and the redrawing of national borders.

💡Nationalism

Nationalism is a political ideology that involves a strong identification of a group of individuals with a country or nation. It can inspire loyalty and passion but also lead to conflict when different nationalistic groups come into competition. The video explores how the Great War intensified nationalistic feelings across Europe, leading to the creation of new states and the redrawing of borders, which in turn sowed the seeds for future conflicts.

💡League of Nations

The League of Nations was an international organization founded after the Great War with the intention of preventing future wars through collective security and disarmament. It was the first major attempt at creating a global governing body to address international issues. The video discusses the League as a key architect in the post-war peace efforts and as a symbol of the hope for a peaceful future following the devastation of World War I.

💡Total War

Total War is a term used to describe a large-scale war that involves the mobilization of all citizens and resources of the warring nations, with the aim of completely defeating the enemy. It is characterized by its devastating impact on society and the economy. In the context of the video, Total War refers to the all-encompassing nature of the Great War, which required the participation of entire societies and had far-reaching consequences.

💡Treaty of Versailles

The Treaty of Versailles was a peace treaty signed on June 28, 1919, by the victorious Allied Powers and defeated Germany, marking the official end of World War I. The treaty had severe consequences for Germany, including significant territorial losses, military restrictions, and heavy reparations. It is mentioned in the video as a symbol of the punitive peace that contributed to the rise of resentment and the conditions that eventually led to World War II.

💡Fascism

Fascism is a far-right, authoritarian political ideology characterized by dictatorial power, forcible suppression of opposition, and strong regimentation of society and the economy. The video discusses the rise of fascist leaders like Benito Mussolini and Adolf Hitler, who capitalized on the unrest and dissatisfaction following the Great War to gain power and推行 aggressive, expansionist policies that contributed to the outbreak of World War II.

💡Communism

Communism is a social, political, and economic ideology that seeks to establish a classless society in which the means of production are owned and controlled by the community as a whole. The video highlights the role of communism, particularly in Russia, where the Bolsheviks under Vladimir Lenin seized power during the Great War, leading to the establishment of the Soviet Union and the spread of communist ideology as an alternative to capitalist democracy.

💡Home Rule

Home Rule refers to a form of self-government where a subordinate state, colony, or region has the power to govern itself without the interference of a larger entity, often retaining some degree of autonomy while still belonging to a larger political framework. In the video, Home Rule is discussed in the context of nations and regions, such as Ireland and Scotland, seeking greater autonomy or independence in the wake of the Great War.

💡Easter Rising

The Easter Rising was an armed insurrection that took place in Ireland during Easter Week in April 1916. The Rising was launched by Irish republicans against British rule in Ireland with the aim of establishing an independent Irish Republic. The video describes the Rising as a pivotal event that contributed to the subsequent Irish War of Independence and the partition of Ireland, casting a long shadow over Irish and British history.

💡World War II

World War II was a global war that began in 1939 and lasted until 1945. It involved the vast majority of the world's nations, including all of the great powers, organized into two opposing military alliances: the Allies and the Axis. The video mentions World War II in the context of how the unresolved issues and the political climate created by the aftermath of the Great War contributed to the rise of totalitarian regimes and the outbreak of another global conflict.

💡European Union

The European Union (EU) is a political and economic union of 27 member states that are located primarily in Europe. Established by the Maastricht Treaty in 1993, the EU was intended to foster economic cooperation and prevent future wars by integrating European economies and politics. The video discusses the EU as a modern form of empire that has helped to contain the beast of nationalism that had ravaged Europe in the 20th century.

Highlights

The Great War led to a reevaluation of the conflict's impact on Britain and the world, challenging the traditional view of it as a static, futile, and inconclusive conflict.

The series aims to explore the dynamic forces unleashed by the war that shaped the entire 20th century.

The memory of the Great War is not fixed but has shifted repeatedly over time, with different countries remembering it in various ways.

The British Commonwealth forces' return from France highlighted the difficulty of comprehending the soldiers' experiences and the enormity of the war.

The Cenotaph, designed by Sir Edwin Lutyens, became a symbol of national grief and a means for the British to remember the war in their own way.

The Commonwealth war graves and memorials, designed by Lin, bear the names of the missing, reflecting the respect and honor given to the fallen soldiers.

The concept of 'known unto God', coined by Rudyard Kipling, provided a poignant tribute to those soldiers whose bodies were never found.

The Peace Ballot of 1935 in Britain showed a majority supporting international agreements to reduce armaments and the League of Nations.

The rise of extremist ideologies like communism and fascism in the wake of the Great War led to political polarization and conflict across Europe.

Britain's unique path after the war, with the emergence of a socialist party and a rebranded royal family, contrasted sharply with the rise of fascist regimes on the continent.

The Great War's legacy included the rise of mass democracy, the extension of voting rights, and the emergence of new political ideologies.

The 1960s saw a shift in the perception of the war, with a focus on the experiences of ordinary soldiers and a questioning of the war's purpose and consequences.

The renaming of the 'Great War' to the 'First World War' reflected a change in its significance and the belief that it was a failed attempt to end all wars.

The post-war period saw the rise of the League of Nations and the hope for a lasting peace, symbolized by the efforts of Robert Cecil and the British public's support for international cooperation.

The play 'Journey's End' and the poetry of Wilfred Owen became powerful reminders of the war's realities and the plea for peace, shaping cultural memory and public perception.

The Great War's aftermath saw the rise of new nations and the redrawing of borders, leading to ethnic tensions and nationalist struggles that would influence European politics for decades.

The European Union, born out of the desire to prevent further nationalist conflicts, represents a modern attempt to tame the beast of nationalism through cooperation and shared identity.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

The Crippling Long Term Effects Of The First World War | The Long Shadow Full Series | Timeline

The Cold War - OverSimplified (Part 2)

The Truly Horrific Consequences Of WW1 | The Great War In Numbers | Real History

How did WW1 Start? | Causes of the First World War

Unresolved Tensions After WWI [AP World History] Unit 7 Topic 5 (7.5)

AP European History: Unit 9 Review

Related Tags

World War I European History Nationalism Political Legacy Czechoslovakia British Empire Ireland Fascism Communism European Union