The TRUTH About VOX's Video: "The gun solution we're not talking about"

Colion Noir
22 Nov 201916:42
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe video script deconstructs Vox's stance on gun control, arguing against universal background checks and advocating for the Second Amendment rights. It criticizes the inefficacy of background checks in preventing criminals from obtaining firearms and highlights the potential infringement on rights through licensing systems. The speaker emphasizes the importance of an armed population as a deterrent against government tyranny, and warns against the slippery slope of gun control measures, which they view as a culture war against constitutional rights.

Takeaways
  • 🔎 The video discusses the recurring call for universal background checks following mass shootings in the U.S., with some politicians and the public supporting the idea.
  • 🚫 The speaker argues that the existing background check system is flawed, highlighting that it does not cover all gun sales, such as those at gun shows or private sales.
  • 🔍 The Department of Justice statistics are cited to show that criminals rarely obtain guns from gun shows, with less than 1% doing so.
  • 🇺🇸 There is a strong public support for background checks, as indicated by a Gallup poll conducted after the Las Vegas shooting, although the question's wording may have influenced the response.
  • ❌ The speaker contends that universal background checks will not solve America's gun crisis, emphasizing that the majority of gun deaths are suicides, not homicides.
  • 🔑 The Second Amendment is emphasized as being about the right to protect against a tyrannical government, not just for hunting or sport.
  • ⏱️ The FBI's instant background check system is described as quick, but the speaker questions its effectiveness due to outdated databases and missing records.
  • 🚨 The speaker points out that background checks can fail to prevent dangerous individuals without a criminal record from obtaining guns.
  • 🏥 The process for obtaining a gun in Massachusetts, which includes a safety course, application, and background check, is detailed as an example of a more comprehensive system.
  • 📉 Studies from Johns Hopkins are mentioned, suggesting that licensing systems, rather than just background checks, can be effective in reducing gun violence.
  • 🤔 The video concludes with a critique of gun licensing as an overly burdensome process that infringes on constitutional rights and could lead to a de facto gun registry.
Q & A

  • What is the main argument presented in the Vox video being deconstructed?

    -The main argument presented in the Vox video is that universal background checks for gun purchases are necessary and supported by the majority of Americans to address gun violence.

  • Why does the speaker believe that the existing background check system is flawed?

    -The speaker believes the existing background check system is flawed because it does not require background checks for private sales or purchases at venues like gun shows, which can lead to criminals obtaining firearms.

  • According to the script, where do criminals typically obtain their guns?

    -The Department of Justice found that less than 1% of criminals obtain their guns from gun shows, suggesting that gun stores and gun shows are not the primary sources for criminals to get firearms.

  • What is the speaker's stance on the Second Amendment?

    -The speaker emphasizes that the Second Amendment is about protecting people's ability to fight off a tyrannical government, not just for hunting or sport.

  • What is the average time taken by the FBI's instant background check system to respond?

    -The FBI's instant background check system takes an average of 108 seconds to respond.

  • Why does the speaker argue that universal background checks will not solve America's 'gun crisis'?

    -The speaker argues that universal background checks will not solve the 'gun crisis' because over 65% of gun deaths are suicides, and gun violence is not even in the top 10 leading causes of death in America.

  • What is the difference between the current background check system and the proposed universal background check system?

    -The difference is that under the universal background check system, anyone buying a gun, whether in a store or through a private sale, would have to be checked through the FBI database, whereas currently, background checks are not required for private sales or at venues like gun shows.

  • What is the issue with the FBI database according to the speaker?

    -The issue with the FBI database is that it is outdated and missing millions of records, which can lead to people with criminal records being able to purchase firearms.

  • What is the alternative to universal background checks proposed in the script?

    -The alternative proposed in the script is a licensing system, which involves a more comprehensive background check, including local law enforcement checks and a waiting period.

  • What is the speaker's view on the effectiveness of licensing systems in reducing gun violence?

    -The speaker argues that licensing systems are more effective because they can properly identify and screen out people who shouldn't have guns and reduce impulsive gun purchases.

  • How does the speaker describe the process of obtaining a gun license in Massachusetts?

    -In Massachusetts, one must take a firearm safety course, apply at the police department with references and fingerprints, undergo a background check by the FBI and local law enforcement, and wait for approval, which can take up to three months.

  • What is the speaker's opinion on the necessity of the 'I will not comply' and 'Keep America Tactical' movements?

    -The speaker supports these movements as a counter to what they see as an infringement on Second Amendment rights, advocating for the protection of the right to bear arms without restrictions.

Outlines
00:00
🔎 Scrutinizing Vox's Gun Control Argument

The paragraph deconstructs a Vox video advocating for universal background checks for gun purchases in the US. It challenges the notion that gun stores are the only places requiring background checks, clarifying that they are also required at gun shows when buying from licensed dealers. The speaker refutes the claim that criminals frequently acquire guns from gun shows, citing Department of Justice statistics showing less than 1% do so. The paragraph argues that universal background checks won't solve America's 'gun crisis,' pointing out that over 65% of gun deaths are suicides and that gun violence isn't a top cause of death. It emphasizes the Second Amendment's purpose as a protection against a tyrannical government, not merely for hunting, and criticizes the portrayal of instant background checks as a quick solution, highlighting the existing issues with the FBI's database and the process's ineffectiveness in stopping dangerous individuals from obtaining firearms.

05:01
🚫 Flaws in the Background Check System

This section criticizes the existing background check system for its inadequacies, such as the outdated FBI database which lacks millions of records, leading to instances where individuals with criminal histories can legally purchase firearms. It points out specific cases where background checks failed due to human error and missing records, arguing that these are not people problems but systemic ones. The paragraph also disputes the effectiveness of universal background checks in addressing gun violence, referencing studies that show no significant impact on firearm-related deaths. It further discusses the limitations of background checks in identifying potential future criminals, as they only screen for past criminal activity, and introduces the concept of a licensing system as an alternative that could be more effective.

10:01
📚 The Licensing System as a Solution

The paragraph introduces a licensing system as a more comprehensive solution to gun control, detailing the process in Massachusetts as an example. It explains the steps involved, such as firearm safety courses, applications, background checks, and contact with local law enforcement and mental health departments. The speaker argues that this system can prevent impulsive gun purchases and delay or deter individuals who may pose a risk. However, it also points out the potential downsides, such as the lengthy process and the subjective nature of the approval process, which could lead to denial based on perceived risk rather than actual criminal activity.

15:03
🗳️ Public Opinion and the Future of Gun Laws

The final paragraph discusses the public's perception of gun licensing and its political implications. It mentions studies showing that voters, particularly those living in households with guns, support such measures. The speaker warns against the erosion of Second Amendment rights through incremental restrictions and calls for vigilance against what they perceive as a culture war against gun ownership. The paragraph concludes with a call to action for viewers to support the message of protecting gun rights and offers resources for further engagement on the topic.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Background Checks
Background checks are a process used to screen individuals before they are allowed to purchase a firearm. In the context of the video, it is a central theme where the speaker discusses the inadequacy and inefficacy of the current system, pointing out that it does not prevent criminals from obtaining guns and suggesting that universal background checks might not solve America's gun-related issues. The video mentions that the FBI's database, which is used for these checks, is outdated and missing millions of records.
💡Gun Control
Gun control refers to regulations imposed on the sale, distribution, and possession of firearms. The video's theme revolves around the debate on gun control in the United States, particularly focusing on the push for universal background checks and the argument that such measures do not effectively address gun violence. The speaker uses the term to critique policies that he believes infringe upon Second Amendment rights.
💡Second Amendment
The Second Amendment is part of the United States Constitution that protects the right of the people to keep and bear arms. In the video, the speaker emphasizes the importance of this constitutional right and argues against any measures that could be seen as an infringement upon it, such as universal background checks and licensing systems.
💡Universal Background Checks
Universal background checks refer to a proposed system where every gun purchase, regardless of the seller, would require a background check. The video discusses the concept as a proposed solution to gun violence, but the speaker argues that it would not be effective and could lead to a national gun registry.
💡Gun Shows
Gun shows are events where firearms are bought and sold, often by private sellers and dealers. The script mentions gun shows as a place where it is falsely believed that criminals easily obtain guns. However, the speaker refutes this by citing Department of Justice statistics that less than 1% of criminals acquire guns from gun shows.
💡Gun Licensing
Gun licensing is a system where an individual must obtain a license to purchase and own firearms. The video contrasts this with background checks, suggesting that licensing systems like those in Massachusetts involve a more comprehensive process, including safety courses and fingerprinting, and may be more effective in preventing gun violence.
💡Criminal Acquisition
Criminal acquisition refers to the process by which criminals obtain firearms. The video discusses how background checks are intended to prevent this but often fail, as evidenced by cases where individuals with criminal records were still able to pass checks and purchase guns.
💡Mental Illness
Mental illness is a term used to describe a wide range of mental health conditions. In the context of the video, it is mentioned as one of the factors that the background check system is supposed to screen for, to prevent individuals with certain mental health issues from purchasing firearms.
💡Domestic Violence
Domestic violence refers to violent or aggressive behavior within the context of a family or intimate relationship. The video mentions it as a criterion that the background check system aims to identify, to prevent individuals with a history of domestic violence from obtaining guns.
💡Constitutional Right
A constitutional right refers to a power or privilege granted to individuals by a country's constitution. In the video, the speaker argues that the right to bear arms, as outlined in the Second Amendment, is a constitutional right that should not be unduly burdened by restrictive gun control measures.
💡Licensing System
A licensing system is a regulatory framework that requires individuals to obtain a license before they can engage in certain activities, such as purchasing firearms. The video discusses the licensing system as an alternative to background checks, suggesting it may be more effective in preventing gun violence but also more restrictive.
Highlights

The video discusses the call for universal background checks following mass shootings in America.

Some Republicans support free background checks, acknowledging the existing system's flaws.

Contrary to popular belief, background checks are required at gun shows when buying from a dealer.

Criminals rarely obtain guns from gun shows, with less than 1% doing so according to the Department of Justice.

A Gallup poll after the Las Vegas shooting showed 96% support for background checks, but the question was changed from the 2015 version.

Universal background checks are not a solution to America's gun crisis, with over 65% of gun deaths being suicides.

The Second Amendment is about protecting citizens' ability to fight off a tyrannical government, not just hunting.

The FBI's instant background check system takes an average of 108 seconds to respond.

Background checks fail to stop prohibited individuals from obtaining firearms due to an outdated FBI database.

Studies show that universal background checks do not affect the actual gun crisis in America.

Licensing systems, like in Massachusetts, involve a more comprehensive background check and can take up to three months.

Licensing systems can delay or deter impulsive gun purchases, potentially preventing harm to self or others.

Connecticut saw a drop in gun homicides and suicides after implementing a licensing system.

Missouri experienced a spike in gun homicides and suicides after getting rid of its licensing system.

Licensing is seen as evidence-based and effective, with states like Connecticut reporting significant drops in gun violence.

The push for gun licensing is seen by some as a more sinister move towards creating a national gun registry.

The video argues against the idea of 'reasonable gun laws,' stating that there is no compromise, only continuous restrictions.

The video calls for support in spreading the message to protect the Second Amendment rights.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Heated Gun Debate Between Colion Noir & Co-Founder of Gun Control Organization

The gun solution we're not talking about

Debunking & Exposing The Orchestrated Viral Vice Gun Debate

Colion Noir: Gun Nuts | Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO)

California Court Rules There is No Quota on Your Second Amendment Rights

The Truth About GUN VIOLENCE by the Numbers

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Gun ControlBackground ChecksSecond AmendmentAmerican PoliticsFirearm RightsCriminal AcquisitionGun LicensingConstitutional RightsPublic SafetyMental HealthLobbying