Borders at the French Riviera - Europe between freedom and flight | DW Documentary

DW Documentary
22 Sept 202321:44
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe video script explores the complexities of cross-border relations in the French-Italian Alps, particularly focusing on the town of Breil-sur-Roya and its connection with Italy through the ALCOTRA EU project, which aims to foster cross-border cooperation. Despite the project's goals, the area faces challenges due to France's strict border control, especially concerning undocumented migrants and refugees, predominantly from African countries, who are often turned away. The narrative delves into the humanitarian efforts by local volunteers and charities, such as the Catholic Caritas, to support those in need. It also touches on the impact of natural disasters, like Storm Alex, on the region and the resilience shown through community rebuilding efforts. The script highlights the historical significance of the border region, its importance in trade and as a refuge during World War II, and draws parallels to current refugee situations. It concludes with a call for humanity and empathy in addressing the migration issue, reflecting on the values that Europe was founded upon.

Takeaways
  • 🏰 The town of Breil-sur-Roya in France is part of the ALCOTRA EU project, which aims to foster cross-border cooperation between French and Italian municipalities.
  • 🌐 ALCOTRA focuses on the 'Southern Alps - Côte d'Azur' region, promoting a border-free aspect within the European Union for the involved communities.
  • 🌍 The area relies heavily on cross-border relations, with shared resources like beaches in Ventimiglia, Italy, and skiing in Limone, Italy.
  • 📚 Historically, the region was a significant trade route and saw border disputes until the mid-20th century, with remnants of Italian fortresses still present.
  • 🛃 Despite the EU's internal border policy of no passport checks, France enforces strict border controls between Ventimiglia, Italy, and Menton, France.
  • 🚨 The French border police have facilities to detain undocumented migrants for up to 24 hours, reflecting a heightened security response to refugee and migrant arrivals, primarily from African countries.
  • 🏙️ In Ventimiglia, homeless refugees, many of them young, have been living on the streets for years, hoping to cross the border.
  • 🍽️ The Catholic Caritas charity and volunteers, including those from nearby churches, provide food and support to the homeless and migrants in Ventimiglia.
  • 🌪 "Storm Alex" caused significant damage in the Roya Valley, highlighting the need for cross-border cooperation, particularly for disaster relief.
  • 💰 The European Union has invested over 200 million euros into the border region for tourism, nature conservation, and cross-border cooperation, but physical border connections remain challenging due to infrastructure damage.
  • 🤝 The story of twin towns Breil-sur-Roya and Borgo San Dalmazzo exemplifies the historical and cultural ties between the French and Italian communities, as well as their joint efforts to recover from natural disasters and the pandemic.
Q & A
  • What is the significance of the town Breil-sur-Roya in the context of the ALCOTRA EU project?

    -Breil-sur-Roya is significant as it is one of the ten picturesque communities in the 'Southern Alps - Côte d'Azur' region, which is part of the ALCOTRA EU project. The project aims to subsidize cross-border cooperation between French and Italian municipalities, further dismantling the border between them.

  • How does the ALCOTRA project affect the relationship between France and Italy?

    -The ALCOTRA project is designed to enhance cross-border cooperation and collaboration between French and Italian municipalities. It aims to create a border-free part of Europe by subsidizing joint initiatives in tourism, nature conservation, and community development in the shared region.

  • What historical importance does the border region between France and Italy have?

    -The border region was historically significant as the most important trade route from Piedmont to the Mediterranean, especially for transporting valuable salt until the 19th century. During World War II, the northern Roya Valley was part of Italy, and the border was disputed until 1947.

  • How has the presence of refugees and migrants impacted the French-Italian border?

    -The presence of refugees and migrants, mainly from African countries, has led to an increased security presence at the French-Italian border. France has expanded its border post to include a facility for detaining undocumented migrants for up to 24 hours, reflecting a more stringent enforcement of border controls.

  • What is the current situation regarding the reception center for migrants in Ventimiglia?

    -The only reception center in Ventimiglia was closed three years ago during the Covid pandemic due to infection fears and has not been reopened since. As a result, homeless migrants have been relying on the support of charities like the Catholic Caritas and volunteers from nearby churches.

  • How does the local community in Ventimiglia support the homeless migrants?

    -The local community, primarily through volunteers from nearby churches, provides support to homeless migrants. The Catholic Caritas charity hands out food for two hours in the morning, and volunteers cook for the homeless in the early evening. They also share information to warn migrants about human traffickers.

  • What is the impact of Storm Alex on the Roya Valley and the communities within it?

    -Storm Alex caused a natural disaster in the Roya Valley, leading to severe flooding that destroyed access roads, monuments, churches, and city halls. It disrupted the direct road connection across the border and affected the communities' ability to recover their tourism industry.

  • How are the twin towns of Breil-sur-Roya and Borgo San Dalmazzo working together post-Storm Alex?

    -The twin towns are collaborating to rebuild and restore their communities after the storm. They are focusing on reconstruction efforts, aiming to revive tourism with the help of EU funding, and maintaining strong ties despite the difficult circumstances.

  • What is the significance of the monument in Borgo San Dalmazzo?

    -The monument in Borgo San Dalmazzo commemorates over 300 Jewish people from across Europe who were deported from the area to Auschwitz during World War II. It serves as a reminder of the history of flight and refuge and is used to inspire reflection on contemporary issues of migration and xenophobia.

  • How do the experiences of past and present refugees differ in terms of community response?

    -In the past, when the region was dealing with its own war-related devastation, local people would open their doors to strangers, hide, and protect them. In contrast, the present situation sees a more complex response, with some locals helping migrants and refugees, while others are involved in human trafficking or are indifferent due to the challenges posed by the migrants' presence.

  • What is the role of the EU's Dublin Regulation in the current migrant situation?

    -The Dublin Regulation requires refugees and migrants to remain in the first EU country where they arrived. While this regulation allows for a temporary suspension of deportation for humanitarian reasons, it also restricts migrants from traveling to other EU countries, effectively creating a hard border for them.

Outlines
00:00
🗺️ Cross-Border Cooperation in the French-Italian Alps

This paragraph introduces Sebastien Olharan, the mayor of Breil-sur-Roya, a town in the Southern Alps near the French-Italian border. It discusses the ALCOTRA EU project, which aims to foster cross-border cooperation between French and Italian municipalities. The region's reliance on cross-border relations for tourism and activities like skiing is highlighted. The historical importance of the area as a trade route and the changes in the border's status over time are also mentioned. The paragraph concludes with the current situation where the border is largely open for locals but heavily guarded for migrants and refugees, particularly from Africa.

05:02
🍽️ Solidarity and Support for Migrants in Ventimiglia

The second paragraph focuses on the challenges faced by migrants in Ventimiglia, Italy, near the French border. It describes the lack of state support and the reliance on charity, such as the Catholic Caritas, to provide food and assistance to the homeless and migrants. The narrative includes personal stories of volunteers like Filippo Lombardo, who cooks for the migrants weekly. Despite the guarded border, the paragraph notes that many migrants still manage to cross into France. It also touches on the impact of Storm Alex on the region and the EU's financial support for tourism and cross-border cooperation, which has been disrupted by the storm and the pandemic.

10:03
🎉 Cultural Unity and Recovery After Disaster

This paragraph discusses the cultural ties and joint efforts for recovery between the French town of Breil-sur-Roya and its Italian twin town, Borgo San Dalmazzo, after the natural disaster caused by Storm Alex. It highlights the historical significance of the region, including the deportation of Jewish people to Auschwitz during World War II, and draws parallels to the current refugee crisis. The paragraph emphasizes the importance of remembering history and maintaining humanitarian values when addressing migration issues. It also mentions the efforts of volunteers like Filippo Lombardo, who cooks for migrants in Ventimiglia, and their attempts to warn migrants about human traffickers.

15:04
🚸 The Humanitarian Border Situation and Migrant Journeys

The fourth paragraph delves into the experiences of migrants, particularly those from Sudan, who are stuck at the border due to the Dublin Regulation, which requires them to remain in the country where they first entered the EU. It discusses the migrants' reasons for leaving their home countries, the risks they face, and the challenges they encounter, including exploitation by human traffickers. The paragraph also describes the efforts of volunteers who provide meals and support to migrants in Ventimiglia, emphasizing the importance of solidarity and collective responsibility.

20:06
🤝 Lessons from History and Community Support for Refugees

The final paragraph reflects on the historical response of local communities to refugees in the past and suggests that contemporary society can learn from these examples. It mentions the assistance provided to refugees during the war when locals would open their doors to strangers. The paragraph also addresses the ongoing presence of the border for migrants and refugees, despite EU funding aimed at uniting communities in the French-Italian Alps. It concludes with rumors of locals in Ventimiglia knowing secret routes and sometimes guiding travelers, indicating a continued spirit of compassion and assistance within the community.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡ALCOTRA EU project
The ALCOTRA EU project stands for the 'Southern Alps - Côte d'Azur' region and is a European Union initiative that subsidizes cross-border cooperation between French and Italian municipalities. It aims to dismantle the border between the two countries in the region, fostering closer ties and integrated development. In the video, the project is highlighted as a symbol of unity and collaboration, particularly important for the town of Breil-sur-Roya, which relies heavily on its connection with Italy.
💡Cross-border relations
Cross-border relations refer to the interactions and connections between different regions or countries that share a border. In the context of the video, these relations are vital for the town of Breil-sur-Roya, as it relies on its proximity to Italy for tourism, trade, and cultural exchange. The video emphasizes the importance of these relations by discussing the impact of the ALCOTRA project and the historical significance of the border region.
💡Refugees and migrants
Refugees and migrants are individuals who have been forced to leave their home country due to various reasons such as war, persecution, or economic hardship. The video discusses the plight of these individuals, particularly those from African countries, who face challenges in crossing the border from Italy to France. It highlights the humanitarian crisis and the inhumane treatment they receive, as well as the efforts of volunteers and charities to provide aid.
💡European Union's internal borders
The European Union's internal borders refer to the borders between countries that are members of the EU, which are typically characterized by the free movement of people, goods, and services. The video discusses how these borders have been affected by the refugee crisis and the re-implementation of border controls in certain areas, such as the border between France and Italy near Ventimiglia.
💡Humanitarian reasons
Humanitarian reasons pertain to the motivation to assist or provide aid to individuals or groups in need, often in crisis situations. In the video, it is mentioned that Italian authorities grant a suspension of deportation to migrants for humanitarian reasons, allowing them to temporarily remain in Italy. This reflects the video's broader theme of compassion and support for those fleeing difficult circumstances.
💡Dublin Regulation
The Dublin Regulation is an EU law that determines which EU member state is responsible for processing an asylum application. It generally states that the first country of arrival is responsible. The video mentions this regulation in the context of migrants not being allowed to travel to other EU countries, highlighting the challenges and restrictions faced by those seeking refuge.
💡Catholic Caritas charity
Catholic Caritas is a charitable organization that provides assistance to those in need, often with a focus on the teachings and values of the Catholic Church. In the video, Caritas is shown providing food to homeless individuals in Ventimiglia, demonstrating the role of faith-based organizations in offering support and aid to vulnerable populations.
💡Human trafficking
Human trafficking involves the illegal trade of people for exploitation or forced labor. The video discusses how human traffickers prey on refugees at the Ventimiglia train station, charging them large sums of money for information on how to cross the border. This highlights the predatory nature of the trafficking industry and the dangers faced by migrants.
💡Twin towns
Twin towns are two towns in different countries that are paired for the purpose of cultural exchange, mutual understanding, and cooperation. In the video, Breil-sur-Roya and Borgo San Dalmazzo are mentioned as twin towns, collaborating through the ALCOTRA program and supporting each other in times of crisis, such as the aftermath of Storm Alex.
💡Storm Alex
Storm Alex was a severe weather event that caused significant damage in the Roya Valley, affecting French communities and disrupting their connection with neighboring Italian towns. The video discusses the impact of the storm on the region, the efforts to rebuild, and the role of cross-border cooperation in the recovery process.
💡Xenophobia and anti-Semitism
Xenophobia is the fear or dislike of people from other countries or cultures, while anti-Semitism is prejudice against Jewish people. The video touches on these themes in the context of historical and contemporary attitudes towards refugees and migrants. It suggests that the same fears and prejudices that led to the persecution of Jewish people in the past are still present today, particularly in the treatment of migrants.
Highlights

The French-Italian border region is a unique example of cross-border cooperation, with the ALCOTRA EU project promoting collaboration between French and Italian municipalities.

The area is home to picturesque communities like Breil-sur-Roya, which rely on close connections with neighboring Italy for tourism and other activities.

The border region has a rich history, having been an important trade route and experiencing changes in control during events like World War II.

Despite the EU promoting a border-free Europe, France enforces strict border controls with Italy, particularly to deter undocumented migrants and refugees.

The Italian government and locals in Ventimiglia criticize France's handling of the migrant crisis, believing a more equitable distribution of refugees across Europe is necessary.

The closure of the only reception center in Ventimiglia during the Covid pandemic left many homeless and without support.

Catholic Caritas and other volunteers provide essential aid like food to homeless individuals, highlighting the lack of government support.

Despite political and logistical challenges, cross-border cooperation continues, as seen in the twinning of Breil-sur-Roya and Borgo San Dalmazzo.

The natural disaster 'Storm Alex' caused significant damage, but also brought out solidarity and cross-border aid, particularly from the Italian community.

Mayor Sebastien Olharan of Breil-sur-Roya is focused on reconstruction and reviving tourism with the help of EU funding.

The closure of the connecting road due to tunnel works post-Storm Alex hinders the progress of cross-border cooperation.

Volunteers like Filippo Lombardo provide meals to migrants in Ventimiglia, offering a lifeline and support in the absence of formal structures.

The migrants' journey is fraught with danger and exploitation, with human traffickers operating in the area.

The local community in Ventimiglia is aware of secret migration routes and some even assist travelers, reflecting a history of aiding those in need.

Exhibition director Roberto Bianco draws parallels between the past and present, emphasizing the importance of learning from history and treating migrants humanely.

The EU's Dublin Regulation places a significant burden on countries like Italy, where migrants are not allowed to travel to other EU nations.

Volunteers and local communities provide crucial support to migrants, highlighting the need for more comprehensive and humane EU migration policies.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: