Behavior and Belief

Vsauce
9 Jan 201928:27
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn this episode of Mind Field, Michael explores the power of belief by conducting a human Skinner Box experiment, 'Victory Vault,' to study superstitious behaviors. He then performs a sham reverse exorcism, using a combination of religious and scientific symbols to induce mystical experiences, demonstrating how beliefs can be manipulated to create powerful, transformative experiences.

Takeaways
  • 😀 The video explores the human tendency to form beliefs and superstitions as a way to deal with uncertainty and the unknown.
  • 🧐 It discusses the idea that humans often believe in things that aren't entirely true because proving absolute truth can be difficult.
  • 🔬 The script describes a Skinner Box experiment adapted for humans, called 'Victory Vault,' to study how people develop superstitious behaviors in response to random rewards.
  • 🏆 'Victory Vault' was designed as a fake game show to test whether people would create rituals they believe influence the outcome, similar to Skinner's pigeons.
  • 🎬 The experiment involved creating an elaborate set with various props to influence the subjects' behaviors and beliefs about winning money.
  • 🤔 Subjects in the 'Victory Vault' experiment developed various superstitious rituals based on their preconceived notions and the environment.
  • 📉 The experiment showed that when the reward schedule changed, subjects' beliefs and rituals also changed, indicating the flexibility of human belief systems.
  • 🔮 The video then shifts to discuss a 'reverse exorcism' experiment, aiming to induce a sense of possession through belief and suggestion.
  • 🧙‍♂️ The 'reverse exorcism' used a combination of religious iconography and scientific props to manipulate the participants' expectations and experiences.
  • 👥 Actors played various roles, including a fake priest and nurse, to enhance the credibility of the ritual and experiment.
  • 🌟 Some participants reported profound experiences during the 'reverse exorcism,' suggesting the power of belief and suggestion, even when they know the context is artificial.
Q & A
  • What is the main theme of the 'Mind Field' episode featuring Michael?

    -The main theme of the episode is the exploration of belief and how it influences behavior, particularly focusing on the formation of superstitions and the power of belief in shaping experiences.

  • Why does Michael visit Dr. Aaron Blaisdell at UCLA?

    -Michael visits Dr. Aaron Blaisdell to discuss and study belief and behavior, specifically how people form beliefs about what causes their actions, and to replicate B.F. Skinner's superstitious behavior experiment with humans.

  • What is a Skinner Box and how is it used in psychology?

    -A Skinner Box is a chamber used in psychological experiments to isolate animals and expose them to controlled stimuli. It was invented by B.F. Skinner to study behavior and reinforcement, and is likened to a test tube for a psychologist.

  • What did B.F. Skinner discover about pigeons in his Skinner Box experiments?

    -Skinner discovered that pigeons developed 'superstitious behavior', repeating certain actions they happened to be doing just before food was delivered, as if those actions caused the food to appear, despite there being no actual connection.

  • What is the 'Victory Vault' and how does it relate to the Skinner Box?

    -The 'Victory Vault' is a fake game show created by Michael and Dr. Blaisdell as a human version of a Skinner Box. It is designed to study whether people develop superstitious rituals or beliefs in response to random rewards, similar to Skinner's pigeons.

  • How does the 'Victory Vault' experiment differ from Skinner's original experiment with pigeons?

    -The 'Victory Vault' experiment differs by using humans as subjects instead of pigeons, and by incorporating elements of a game show to observe if people develop their own superstitious rituals or beliefs in response to the environment and the rewards system.

  • What role does Rebecca play in the 'Victory Vault' experiment?

    -Rebecca is the first subject in the 'Victory Vault' experiment. She participates in the game show, trying to figure out how to collect money, and ends up creating her own superstitious rituals based on her beliefs about what actions cause the rewards.

  • What psychological concept does the 'Victory Vault' experiment demonstrate?

    -The experiment demonstrates the psychological concept of operant conditioning, where behavior is influenced by consequences, and the formation of superstitious beliefs as people try to make sense of random events and feel a sense of control.

  • What is the purpose of the 'reverse exorcism' that Michael wants to perform?

    -The purpose of the 'reverse exorcism' is to explore whether, by leveraging preexisting beliefs and the power of suggestion, Michael can make people believe they are being possessed by a spirit, even though it is all a placebo.

  • How does the 'reverse exorcism' experiment utilize the power of suggestion and belief?

    -The 'reverse exorcism' uses a combination of religious and scientific iconography, a controlled environment, and suggestive language to manipulate the participants' beliefs and induce experiences that they interpret as spiritual or supernatural.

  • What ethical considerations did Michael take into account when planning the 'reverse exorcism'?

    -Michael considered the ethics of not wanting to tell someone they are possessed by a demon, which led him to create a 'reverse exorcism' that induces a feeling of possession without making any actual claims about the individual's spiritual state.

  • What was the role of Dr. Veissiére in the 'reverse exorcism' experiment?

    -Dr. Veissiére played a crucial role in designing the 'reverse exorcism' ritual, using his knowledge of behavioral psychology and the power of suggestion to influence the participants' experiences during the experiment.

  • What were some of the surprising outcomes reported by the participants of the 'reverse exorcism'?

    -Some participants reported feeling a presence, experiencing sensations of numbness or decapitation, feeling everlasting joy and peace, seeing a glowing figure or wings, and even having an out-of-body experience where they saw a deceased loved one.

  • How does the 'reverse exorcism' experiment relate to the broader understanding of belief and the placebo effect?

    -The experiment highlights how strong beliefs, even in a placebo context, can lead to real and transformative experiences. It shows that the brain is a belief-making machine that can create powerful reactions and experiences based on expectations and suggestions.

Outlines
00:00
😄 Introduction to Belief and Behavior

The video starts with a playful introduction by Michael, who humorously pretends to be Vanessa before revealing his true identity. He discusses the human fascination with lies and the concept of belief, emphasizing that complete proof of anything is often elusive. Michael introduces the topic of the episode: exploring how belief can turn a lie into a truth. He visits Dr. Aaron Blaisdell at UCLA to discuss the formation of beliefs about what causes our behavior. They decide to replicate Skinner's experiment on superstitious behavior, but with humans instead of pigeons, using a Skinner Box. The experiment aims to see if people will develop their own superstitious rituals or beliefs.

05:05
🎥 The 'Victory Vault' Experiment

Michael and Dr. Blaisdell set up a fake game show called 'Victory Vault' to conduct a human Skinner Box experiment. They create a staged environment with a button, a door, and an ATM slot that dispenses money at regular intervals, all designed to study how people react to the environment and form beliefs about what actions cause the rewards. Rebecca, the first subject, enters the room and starts exploring the environment, quickly forming a superstitious ritual involving the door and the button. As the money continues to be dispensed regardless of her actions, she adjusts her beliefs and behaviors, demonstrating the process of extinction and the formation of new superstitions.

10:05
🤔 Human Superstitions and Expectations

The video continues to explore how different subjects in the 'Victory Vault' experiment develop their own unique superstitions based on their preconceived notions and expectations. Some participants believe they need to perform for the camera or make the producers laugh, while others think being different is the key. The experiment reveals that humans are susceptible to forming superstitious beliefs when faced with uncertainty, despite the lack of any real connection between their actions and the rewards. The diversity of behaviors and beliefs among the participants highlights the role of individual expectations in shaping their responses.

15:06
👻 The Sham Reverse Exorcism

Michael introduces a new experiment inspired by his interest in horror movies: a sham reverse exorcism. Unlike a traditional exorcism, which aims to remove a spirit, a reverse exorcism would involve inducing the belief that a spirit has been placed inside someone. Michael collaborates with Dr. Veissiére to design the experiment, which involves using elements from both religion and science to manipulate the participants' beliefs. They plan to use props, actors, and a carefully crafted ritual to make the participants feel as though they are being possessed by a spirit.

20:10
🧙‍♂️ The Power of Suggestion

The video delves into the details of the sham reverse exorcism experiment, highlighting the use of hypnosis and suggestion to induce the feeling of possession. The experiment is set up with a fake lab, actors playing the roles of a nurse, a priest, and a scientist, all designed to create a believable and immersive experience. The participants are subjected to a ritual that combines religious iconography and medical equipment, aimed at relaxing their critical minds and making them more susceptible to suggestion. The experiment tests the power of belief and the extent to which external cues can influence internal experiences.

25:11
🌟 The Impact of Belief

The final segment of the video discusses the profound effects of the sham reverse exorcism on the participants, despite the fact that all elements of the ritual were fabricated. Participants reported vivid experiences, including feelings of presence, visions of deceased loved ones, and sensations of being possessed. The experiment demonstrates the power of belief and the ability of the human mind to create real experiences based on suggestions and expectations. Michael reflects on the implications of these findings, questioning the difference between their staged ritual and the practices of actual religious ceremonies, and pondering the philosophical questions raised by the power of belief.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Belief
Belief refers to the acceptance that a statement or concept is true, often without empirical evidence. In the video, belief is central to understanding how people form superstitions and rituals based on their expectations and experiences. For instance, participants in the 'Victory Vault' experiment developed beliefs about what actions would trigger monetary rewards, even though the outcomes were not influenced by their behaviors.
💡Superstitious Behavior
Superstitious behavior is a type of action that is performed with the false belief that it will lead to a favorable outcome. In the context of the video, B.F. Skinner's experiments with pigeons and the 'Victory Vault' experiment with humans demonstrate how superstitious behaviors can arise from coincidental reinforcement, such as Rebecca's belief that her actions with the door and button were causing money to appear.
💡Skinner Box
A Skinner Box is an experimental apparatus used in psychology to study the behavior of animals through operant conditioning. In the video, it is mentioned as a starting point for understanding belief and behavior. The 'Victory Vault' is a human version of a Skinner Box, where participants' behaviors and beliefs about cause and effect are observed in a controlled environment.
💡Placebo Effect
The placebo effect is a psychological phenomenon where a person experiences a perceived improvement in their condition due to their belief in the effectiveness of an inert treatment. The video explores the placebo effect by conducting a 'reverse exorcism,' where participants' beliefs lead to real experiences and sensations, despite the absence of any real spiritual intervention.
💡Exorcism
Exorcism is a religious or spiritual practice aimed at expelling demons or evil spirits from a person or an area they are believed to have possessed. In the video, the concept of a 'reverse exorcism' is introduced, which is a fictional scenario where a spirit is suggested to be put into a person, rather than removed, to study the power of belief.
💡Ritual
A ritual is a series of actions or behaviors performed according to a prescribed order, often for religious or cultural reasons. The video discusses the creation of a fake ritual in the 'reverse exorcism' experiment, which is designed to manipulate participants' beliefs and elicit psychological responses.
💡Suggestion
Suggestion is the act of proposing an idea or plan, or influencing another's thoughts or actions. In the video, the power of suggestion is utilized in the 'reverse exorcism' ritual to induce specific experiences and sensations in participants, highlighting the influence of belief on perception and experience.
💡Control
Control, in this context, refers to the perceived ability to influence outcomes or events. The video's experiments explore how people's beliefs can make them feel a sense of control, even when their actions have no actual impact on the results, such as in the 'Victory Vault' where participants believed their rituals influenced the dispensing of money.
💡Reinforcement
Reinforcement is a concept in psychology where a behavior is strengthened by being followed by a reward or a reduction in an aversive stimulus. In the video, 'adventitious reinforcement' is discussed as a mechanism by which superstitious behaviors are formed, such as when Rebecca's door manipulation coincidentally led to the appearance of money.
💡Extinction
Extinction in psychology is the process by which a conditioned response is eliminated by ceasing to apply the reinforcement. In the video, the term is used to describe the moment when Rebecca's previously reinforced behavior (her ritual with the door and button) no longer resulted in the expected outcome, leading her to explore new actions.
💡Empirical Evidence
Empirical evidence refers to information that is based on observation and experimentation. The video contrasts the empirical approach of science with the experiential and belief-driven approach of religion, highlighting the different ways people understand and interpret the world around them.
Highlights

Humans have a natural inclination towards believing in unproven things due to the difficulty in completely proving certain aspects of reality.

The concept of belief is explored as an intermediate between knowledge and faith, suggesting that what we think we know is often based on belief rather than absolute certainty.

The Skinner Box experiment is introduced as a method to study the formation of beliefs and behaviors in both animals and humans.

B.F. Skinner's experiments with pigeons demonstrated how they developed 'superstitious behavior' based on coincidental reinforcement, which is a key insight into how beliefs can form without causality.

A human version of the Skinner Box experiment, called 'Victory Vault', is created to test whether people develop superstitious rituals or beliefs in response to random rewards.

The 'Victory Vault' experiment showed that participants developed various superstitious behaviors, suggesting that humans are susceptible to forming beliefs based on perceived patterns, even in the absence of causality.

Participants' pre-existing beliefs and expectations influenced the types of superstitions they developed during the 'Victory Vault' experiment.

The placebo effect is discussed as a real phenomenon where belief alone can induce physical changes, drawing parallels to the power of belief in the context of the experiments.

A 'reverse exorcism' concept is introduced, aiming to use belief and suggestion to induce the feeling of being possessed by a spirit, highlighting the potential of belief to alter perception and experience.

The use of religious and scientific iconography in the 'reverse exorcism' experiment is intended to leverage the power of suggestion and increase the effectiveness of the belief manipulation.

The 'reverse exorcism' experiment resulted in participants reporting vivid and personal spiritual experiences, despite the artificial nature of the ritual and setting.

The power of belief was demonstrated to be so strong that even in the absence of any real causal link, participants experienced profound psychological effects.

The experiment raises questions about the difference between the psychological manipulation of belief and genuine spiritual experiences, challenging the nature of belief and its impact.

The potential for belief and suggestion to be used in therapeutic settings is hinted at, suggesting practical applications for the insights gained from the experiments.

The ethical considerations of manipulating people's beliefs for experimental purposes are acknowledged, highlighting the responsibility that comes with understanding the power of belief.

The conclusion emphasizes the human brain's propensity for creating beliefs as a means of exerting control over an uncertain world, even when those beliefs may not be grounded in reality.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: