Functional Parsing - Computerphile

Computerphile
5 Feb 202022:45
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn this educational live coding session, the presenter delves into functional parsing or combinator parsing, a topic they contributed to in early research. They define a parser as a program converting character strings into structured trees, illustrating with arithmetic expressions. The session introduces basic parsing primitives and combining forms, demonstrating how to build parsers in Haskell with a library that emphasizes the approach's simplicity and power. A step-by-step guide shows how to create parsers for natural numbers, integers, and arithmetic expressions, highlighting the close relationship between grammar rules and parser code.

Takeaways
  • πŸ“š A parser is defined as a program that takes a string of characters as input and produces a tree that represents the structure of the input string.
  • 🌳 The purpose of the tree output by a parser is to make explicit the structure within the input string, such as numbers and arithmetic operators in an arithmetic expression.
  • πŸ” Parsers can be implemented in various programming languages, and the concept of functional parsing or combinator parsing is not specific to any one language like Haskell.
  • πŸ”§ The basic type of a parser in functional programming is a function that takes a string and returns a list of pairs, where each pair consists of a value and the unconsumed part of the input string.
  • πŸ› οΈ Parsers can be built using basic primitives and combining forms, similar to building with Lego bricks, where primitives are the basic building blocks and combining forms allow for constructing more complex parsers.
  • πŸ”’ The script demonstrates a simple digit parser and a character parser, showing how they can succeed or fail based on the input string.
  • πŸ”„ The concept of 'some' is introduced as a parsing combining form that applies a parser one or more times, consuming as many instances as possible of the pattern being parsed.
  • πŸ”€ Choice operators are used to make decisions in parsing, allowing a parser to try one option and, if it fails, to try another.
  • πŸ“ˆ The 'do' notation is used for sequencing parsers, allowing multiple parsers to be run in sequence, which is crucial for building parsers that handle complex structures like arithmetic expressions.
  • πŸ”§ The script concludes with an example of building a parser for arithmetic expressions, demonstrating how the parser can evaluate expressions as it parses them, and how it can handle different levels of operator precedence.
Q & A
  • What is a parser according to the speaker?

    -A parser is a program that takes a string of characters as input and produces a tree as output, where the tree represents the structure within the input string.

  • Why is the concept of functional parsing or combinator parsing close to the speaker's heart?

    -The concept is close to the speaker's heart because they wrote some of the early papers on it many years ago.

  • Can you explain the example given in the script to illustrate the concept of a parser?

    -The example given is the string '2 + 3 * 4'. The parser recognizes the structure in this string, creating a tree that shows the numbers as leaves and the arithmetic operators as nodes, reflecting the order of operations (multiplication before addition).

  • What is the basic function of a parser in terms of input and output?

    -The basic function of a parser is to take a string as input and produce a tree or some other form of structured output that represents the input's structure.

  • Why is it necessary for a parser to return not just a tree, but also the unconsumed part of the input string?

    -It is necessary because when chaining parsers, one might need to parse further with the remaining input that was not consumed by the initial parser.

  • What does the speaker mean by a parser 'might not always succeed'?

    -A parser might not always succeed if it fails to recognize the structure in the input string, such as when trying to parse a number but encountering a non-numeric character.

  • How does the speaker refine the basic parser type to make it more practical for programming?

    -The speaker refines the basic parser type by allowing it to return a list of results, where each result is a pair consisting of a value of type 'a' and the unconsumed part of the input string, and by acknowledging that parsers might not consume all of the input.

  • What is the advantage of using a parser combinator library in implementing parsers?

    -A parser combinator library provides basic building blocks and combining forms that allow for the creation of parsers in a modular and flexible way, making it easier to implement complex parsers without writing extensive amounts of code.

  • How does the speaker describe the process of building a parser for natural numbers?

    -The speaker describes it as using sequencing with 'do' notation, parsing 'some digits', converting the string of digits into a number using the 'read' function, and then returning the number.

  • What is the significance of the 'do' notation used in the script?

    -The 'do' notation is significant as it represents the sequencing of parsers, allowing multiple parsing actions to be performed in order, and is a feature of monadic programming which parsers exemplify.

  • How does the speaker implement the parser for arithmetic expressions?

    -The speaker implements the parser for arithmetic expressions by translating the grammatical rules into parser notation using the primitives and combining forms provided by the parsing library.

  • What is the final output of the parser when parsing the expression '2 + 3 * 4'?

    -The final output of the parser for the expression '2 + 3 * 4' is 14, following the order of operations (multiplication before addition).

  • Why does the speaker mention that parsers can return multiple results?

    -The speaker mentions that parsers can return multiple results to account for the potential ambiguity in some languages, such as English, where sentences can have multiple interpretations.

  • What is the role of the 'some' combinator in parsing?

    -The 'some' combinator is used for repetition, allowing a parser to apply another parser one or more times, consuming as many instances as possible of the pattern being parsed.

  • How does the speaker demonstrate the concept of choice in parsers?

    -The speaker demonstrates the concept of choice using a choice operator that attempts to parse a digit or a letter, showing how the parser can attempt different options if the first fails.

  • What is the purpose of the 'char' primitive in the parsing library?

    -The 'char' primitive is used to parse a specific character from the input string, and it is one of the basic building blocks for constructing more complex parsers.

Outlines
00:00
πŸ“š Introduction to Functional Parsing

The speaker introduces the concept of functional parsing, also known as combinator parsing, a topic they have contributed to through early papers. They define a parser as a program converting a string of characters into a structured tree, using the example of a simple arithmetic expression to illustrate the process. The speaker emphasizes the importance of recognizing the inherent structure in input strings and outlines the plan to demonstrate the implementation of a parser in Haskell, a general-purpose programming language, ensuring that the concepts presented are applicable beyond Haskell.

05:02
🌟 Parsing Basics and Haskell Implementation

The speaker delves into the fundamentals of parser creation in Haskell, starting with the definition of a 'Parser' type as a function from strings to trees. They refine this definition to account for partial input consumption and the possibility of failure, resulting in a parser that returns a list of pairs, each containing a tree and the unconsumed input. The speaker then introduces the flexibility of parsers to handle ambiguous input by returning multiple parse results. They also replace the specific tree type with a generic type 'a' to accommodate various data structures, leading to a final parser type that is a function from strings to a list of pairs of type 'a' and strings.

10:05
πŸ” Parser Combinators and Primitives

The speaker explains the concept of parser combinators, which are basic building blocks for creating parsers, using a library they have written. They demonstrate simple primitives like parsing a single digit or character and show how these can succeed or fail based on the input. The speaker also introduces combining forms like 'some' for repetition and a choice operator for making decisions between different parsing options. They illustrate how these can be used to parse strings of digits and letters, emphasizing the ease of creating complex parsers from simple components.

15:06
πŸ”— Sequencing and Choice in Parsing

The speaker discusses the importance of sequencing and choice in constructing parsers, showing how to use 'do' notation for sequencing multiple parsing actions and the 'or' operator for making choices between different parsing options. They provide examples of parsing natural numbers and integers, explaining how to combine basic parsers to handle more complex structures. The speaker also touches on the concept of parsers being monadic, relating them to the 'do' notation used in their examples and suggesting that understanding monads can provide deeper insights into parser construction.

20:08
πŸ›  Building an Arithmetic Expression Parser

The speaker presents a practical example of building a parser for arithmetic expressions, starting with a simple grammar that defines the structure of such expressions. They translate this grammar into a functional parser using the primitives and combining forms introduced earlier. The speaker demonstrates how to parse terms, factors, and the entire expression, including handling operator precedence and parentheses. They highlight the elegance of this approach, where the structure of the parser closely mirrors the grammar rules, making it intuitive to understand and implement.

πŸ“ˆ Testing the Arithmetic Expression Parser

The speaker concludes the session by testing the implemented arithmetic expression parser with various examples to ensure its correctness. They demonstrate the parser's ability to handle simple and complex expressions, including those with nested parentheses and multiple operations. The speaker also shows how the parser deals with input that does not conform to the expected format, either by returning partial results or indicating failure. The successful tests validate the effectiveness of the functional parsing approach and its applicability to real-world problems.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘Parser
A parser is a program that takes a string of characters as input and produces a structured output, typically in the form of a tree. In the context of the video, a parser is essential for understanding and processing the syntax of a given language or expression. The script discusses the concept of a parser in relation to functional parsing, where it is used to identify and represent the structure within a string of characters, such as an arithmetic expression.
πŸ’‘Functional Parsing
Functional parsing, also known as combinator parsing, is a method of creating parsers using functional programming principles. The script emphasizes the author's historical connection to this method and delves into how it can be implemented in Haskell. Functional parsing is highlighted as a way to build parsers from basic building blocks or primitives and combining them using specific forms to create more complex parsers.
πŸ’‘Combinator
In the context of parsing, a combinator is a function that takes one or more parsers as input and produces a new parser as output. The script introduces the concept of combinators as a way to combine simple parsers to form more complex ones. This is a key aspect of functional parsing, allowing for the creation of sophisticated parsing logic from basic elements.
πŸ’‘Tree Structure
A tree structure is a hierarchical representation used to visualize and organize data. In the script, the tree structure is used to represent the parsed output of a string, making explicit the hierarchical relationships within the input, such as the order of operations in an arithmetic expression.
πŸ’‘Arithmetic Expression
An arithmetic expression is a combination of numbers and arithmetic operators that can be evaluated to a single number. The script uses the example of an arithmetic expression '2 plus 3 times 4' to illustrate the process of parsing and the importance of operator precedence.
πŸ’‘Operator Precedence
Operator precedence is the rule that determines the order in which operators in an expression are evaluated. In the script, it is mentioned that multiplication has a higher precedence than addition, which is a fundamental concept in parsing arithmetic expressions correctly.
πŸ’‘Grammar
A grammar is a set of rules that define the structure of a language. In the script, a simple grammar is used to describe the syntax of arithmetic expressions, consisting of rules for expressions, terms, and factors. This grammar is then directly translated into a parser using functional parsing techniques.
πŸ’‘Monad
In programming, a monad is a design pattern that allows for computations to be chained together, often used in functional programming. The script mentions that parsers form an example of a monad, indicating that they can be used to sequence computations in a particular order, which is crucial for the 'do' notation used in the parser implementation.
πŸ’‘Do Notation
Do notation is a syntactic sugar in Haskell that allows for a more readable and sequential representation of monadic operations. In the script, do notation is used to sequence the steps of parsing and evaluation within the parser, making the code easier to understand and write.
πŸ’‘Haskell
Haskell is a standardized, general-purpose purely functional programming language, with non-strict semantics and strong static typing. The script uses Haskell to demonstrate the implementation of functional parsers, highlighting its suitability for this type of programming due to its support for functions as first-class citizens and its expressive type system.
πŸ’‘Expression Evaluation
Expression evaluation is the process of calculating the value of an expression. The script not only discusses parsing expressions but also evaluates them as part of the parsing process, showing how functional parsing can be used to both understand and compute the result of an expression.
Highlights

Introduction to functional parsing or combinator parsing, a topic close to the speaker's heart.

Definition of a parser as a program that takes a string of characters and produces a tree representing the structure.

Example of parsing the arithmetic expression '2 + 3 * 4' to demonstrate the concept of a parser.

Explanation of how a parser recognizes and structures the input string into a tree format.

Introduction to the idea of parsers not always consuming all input and the need for accessing remaining input.

Discussion on the possibility of parsers failing and the representation of failure through empty lists.

Introduction to the 'Parser' type in Haskell, defined as a function from strings to lists of pairs.

Rationale for using lists in parsers to allow for multiple parse results in ambiguous cases.

Replacement of specific tree type with a generic type 'a' for flexibility in parser outputs.

Description of a parser as a function from strings to lists of pairs of 'a' and strings.

Introduction to a parsing library with basic primitives and combining forms for building parsers.

Demonstration of a digit parser and its ability to consume single numeric digits from a string.

Explanation of the 'some' combinator for repetition in parsing, consuming as many instances as possible.

Introduction to the choice operator for making decisions in parsing, trying one parser or another.

Example of combining parsers to parse a string of digits and letters using repetition and choice.

Introduction to sequencing in parsers, using 'do' notation to run parsers in sequence.

Example of parsing natural numbers using sequencing to first parse digits and then convert them to a number.

Explanation of parsing integers, combining negative and positive number parsers using choice.

Demonstration of a complete parser for arithmetic expressions, showing the direct translation from grammatical rules to parser code.

Testing the parser with examples, including handling of brackets and operator precedence.

Discussion on the simplicity and power of functional parsing, where parsers can be written to closely resemble the grammar they parse.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: