Is the DPOY award a SHAM?
TLDRThis video script delves into the intricacies of the NBA's Defensive Player of the Year (DPOY) award, questioning the objectivity of the selection process. It contrasts the DPOY with the more quantifiable MVP selection, highlighting that DPOY often relies on the 'eye test' rather than counting stats like steals and blocks. The script discusses the importance of defensive rating and team defense, using examples like Miles Turner and Hassan Whiteside who led in blocks but received little recognition. It emphasizes the role of communication and smart play in defense, citing Jared Dudley and Draymond Green as examples of impact defenders. The video also points out the narrative and team success influence on DPOY, with Rudy Gobert's scrutiny and the rare case of Hakeem Olajuwon winning all major awards in one season. The script concludes by noting the award's significance in a player's legacy and the short window top players have to win DPOY due to physical decline.
Takeaways
- 🏆 The Defensive Player of the Year (DPOY) award is less objective compared to the MVP, as it heavily relies on the voters' eye test and less on counting stats like steals, blocks, and defensive rebounds.
- 🧐 The eye test is crucial, as a player might lead the league in blocks but still not be recognized with an all-defense team, like Miles Turner and Hassan White.
- 📊 Defensive rating is a key stat in determining the DPOY, as it reflects how many points the opposing team scores in 100 possessions, with lower ratings indicating better defense.
- 🧠 Smart defense, like that of Jared Dudley, is valued, as it involves positioning, understanding the game, and knowing the details of effective on-ball defense.
- 🤝 Defense is not just about individual skills; it also involves communication and teamwork, as a significant part of defense is about how well a team plays collectively.
- 🧐 Draymond Green's leadership on defense is not just about stats, but also about his ability to read the game and instruct his teammates, making the defense more effective as a whole.
- 🔍 The DPOY award can be influenced by narrative and team success, as a player's role in their team's success can play a part in their recognition as the best defender.
- 🏅 The DPOY award has been won by defensive specialists, like Charles Barkley, Hakeem Olajuwon, and Giannis Antetokounmpo, indicating that the award tends to go to players who excel in defensive roles.
- 🤔 The DPOY award can be controversial, as it can be seen as a 'sham' if a player who has been second-team all-defense has won the DPOY, like Tyson Chandler and Marcus Camby.
- 🏆 Winning the DPOY, along with the MVP and Finals MVP in the same year, is a rare achievement, with only a few players like Hakeem Olajuwon and LeBron James having done so.
- 📉 As players age, they may lose the ability to play on both offense and defense as effectively, which can affect their contention for the DPOY.
Q & A
What is the main topic of the video?
-The main topic of the video is the Defensive Player of the Year (DPOY) award in the NBA and how it is decided by voters.
Why is the MVP award considered more obvious than the DPOY award?
-The MVP award is considered more obvious because there are clear metrics such as team's overall wins, player stats, and advanced metrics that can be used to evaluate a player's performance without even watching a game.
What is the significance of defensive rating in determining the DPOY?
-Defensive rating is significant because it measures how many points the opposing team scores in 100 possessions, reflecting the effectiveness of a team's defense and indirectly the individual defender's contribution.
How does the video describe the difference between a player leading in blocks and receiving defensive accolades?
-The video points out that leading in blocks does not necessarily correlate with receiving defensive accolades, as demonstrated by players like Miles Turner and Hassan Whiteside who have led in blocks but have not received significant recognition.
What is the role of team defense in the evaluation of a player's defensive capabilities?
-Team defense plays a crucial role as it involves communication and organization among players. A player's defensive ability is partly a reflection of their own skills and partly of how well they contribute to the team's overall defense.
How does Jared Dudley exemplify the importance of smart defense over athleticism?
-Jared Dudley is highlighted as an example of a player who, despite not being the most athletic, was a great defender due to his intelligence, positioning, and understanding of the game, which allowed him to be in the right place at the right time.
What is the significance of the 'eye test' in evaluating a player's defense?
-The 'eye test' is significant because it is based on the subjective assessment of a player's defensive performance, focusing on their presence on the court and their ability to impact the game through smart plays and positioning.
How does the video describe the strategy of letting a player go past for a potential block?
-The video describes this strategy as working smarter, not harder, by allowing an opponent to attempt a layup, then positioning oneself for a block when the player is not expecting it.
What is the role of leadership in Draymond Green's defensive impact?
-Draymond Green's leadership comes from his ability to see the court well, predict the offense's moves, and direct his teammates effectively, which contributes to his status as an impactful defender.
Why do some players not win the DPOY despite being great defenders?
-Some players may not win the DPOY because the award often goes to players who are perceived as defensive specialists and fits the narrative of the season, which includes team success and the player's role in that success.
What is the significance of the DPOY award in the context of a player's career?
-The DPOY award is significant as it adds to a player's resume and is often a mark of distinction for great NBA players, especially when considering that many all-time greats have won the award.
Why is the DPOY award sometimes considered a 'sham'?
-The DPOY award is sometimes considered a 'sham' because there have been instances where the winner was not even recognized as one of the top five defenders in the league, as indicated by their placement on the All-Defense teams.
How does the video address the challenge of evaluating defense in basketball?
-The video addresses the challenge by discussing the various factors that contribute to good defense, such as individual ability, team communication, and the impact on the scoreboard over the course of a game.
Outlines
🏀 The Complexity of the Defensive Player of the Year Award
The script discusses the intricacies of selecting the NBA's Defensive Player of the Year (DPOY), contrasting it with the more quantifiable MVP award. It points out that traditional defensive statistics like steals, blocks, and defensive rebounds are not the primary factors for DPOY voters. Instead, the 'eye test' and a player's impact on team defense are more significant. The script uses examples of players like Miles Turner and Hassan Whiteside, who led the league in blocks but did not receive defensive accolades, to illustrate this point. It also explains the concept of defensive rating and its importance in evaluating defensive prowess. The discussion moves on to the role of communication and organization in team defense, using Jared Dudley as an example of a player who excelled defensively due to his basketball IQ and understanding of defensive positioning. The video also highlights the importance of smart defensive plays and the difference between working hard and working smart on the court.
🏆 Narrative and Narrative Influence on DPOY Selection
This paragraph delves into the narrative and storytelling aspect that influences the DPOY award selection. It argues that the award is not solely based on objective criteria but is also heavily influenced by the story being told about a player's defensive contributions. The script uses the example of Rudy Gobert, who has won the award multiple times but faced scrutiny, particularly after a playoff series against the Clippers where his defensive style was less effective against a perimeter-oriented team. The paragraph also touches on the fact that the DPOY award often goes to defensive specialists, but there have been instances where all-time greats have won the award as well, such as Michael Jordan, David Robinson, and Giannis Antetokounmpo. It concludes by noting that some players, like Kobe Bryant, LeBron James, and Chris Paul, have a limited window to win the DPOY due to the physical demands of playing at a high level on both ends of the court. The paragraph ends with a historical fact about Hakeem Olajuwon winning the DPOY, NBA MVP, and Finals MVP in the same year, a rare feat in the league.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Defensive Player of the Year (DPOY)
💡Defensive rating
💡Eye test
💡Blocks
💡Steals
💡Defensive communication
💡On-ball defense
💡Rim protector
💡Team defense
💡Narrative
Highlights
The Defensive Player of the Year (DPOY) award is subjective and differs from the MVP selection process.
MVP candidates can be objectively assessed through team wins, player stats, and advanced metrics.
DPOY voters rely less on counting stats like steals, blocks, and defensive rebounds.
The 'eye test' plays a significant role in DPOY voting, often overlooking statistical leaders.
Myles Turner and Hassan Whiteside, despite leading in blocks, have not received defensive accolades.
Defensive rating measures points conceded per 100 possessions, indicating a team's defensive effectiveness.
Team defense and communication are crucial for individual defensive success.
Jared Dudley exemplifies smart defense through positioning and understanding of team dynamics.
Modern basketball emphasizes the importance of positioning for blocks and rebounds.
Derrick White's defensive IQ and strategic play make him a significant on-court presence.
Draymond Green's leadership and court vision make him a standout defender, despite not leading in blocks.
Defensive impact is often subtle and cumulative, affecting the scoreboard over many possessions.
Narrative and team success influence the perception of a player's defensive prowess.
Rudy Gobert's DPOY wins have been scrutinized, highlighting the award's narrative-driven nature.
The DPOY award is often given to defensive specialists, but also to all-time greats with diverse accolades.
Great players have a limited window to win DPOY due to physical decline and shifting focus to offense.
Hakeem Olajuwon uniquely won the DPOY, NBA MVP, and Finals MVP in the same year (1994).
Transcripts
Browse More Related Video
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Thanks for rating: