New Religions of the 21st Century | Yuval Harari | Talks at Google

Talks at Google
8 Feb 201583:14
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRYuval Harari, a professor at the University of Jerusalem, discusses the rise and potential fall of liberalism in the 21st century. He explains that liberalism, the dominant ideology of our time, is based on the sanctity of individual freedom and the ability of humans to make decisions based on their inner feelings and rationality. However, Harari argues that advancements in the life sciences and data algorithms are challenging the core of liberalism. As we understand more about the biochemical processes that create our feelings and as technology develops more sophisticated algorithms, there is a shift in authority from individual intuition to external data. This shift could lead to the emergence of a new 'data religion,' where decisions, even profoundly personal ones, are guided by data rather than human emotions or traditional religious texts. Harari also addresses questions about the historical rise of patriarchy, the role of social interactions in decision-making, and the influence of ideologies like communism, suggesting they function similarly to religions by providing a framework for societal norms and laws.

Takeaways
  • πŸ“š Yuval Harari, a professor at the University of Jerusalem, initially wrote a book to simplify his students' lives by compiling his lecture notes, which unexpectedly became a bestseller.
  • 🌍 The book's success spread globally, being translated into 30 languages and achieving top nonfiction status in many European countries and Canada, before making its way to the US.
  • πŸ” Harari's focus as a historian is on the history of ideas, ideologies, mythology, and religion, with a particular interest in how Silicon Valley is shaping new religions of the 21st century.
  • 🧐 Liberalism, the dominant ideology of the modern era, is centered on the individual human and their inner voice as the source of all authority and meaning.
  • πŸ†“ Liberalism values individual freedom and believes that each person has the ultimate authority to make decisions for themselves, whether in politics, economics, art, or ethics.
  • πŸ€” Harari challenges the audience to consider the future of religion and questions the relevance of traditional religions in the face of new technological and economic challenges.
  • πŸ› In the past, the Vatican was a hub of innovation, but traditional religions have since become reactive rather than proactive, responding to changes initiated by others.
  • πŸ€– The rise of data and algorithms in decision-making processes could potentially shift authority away from individual feelings to external data-driven insights.
  • 🧬 Harari suggests that life sciences are increasingly showing humans to be collections of biochemical algorithms, which challenges the liberal belief in individualism and free will.
  • βš–οΈ The potential for external algorithms to understand humans better than they understand themselves could lead to a new 'data religion,' where data and information become the ultimate source of authority.
  • 🌟 Despite the rise of data and technology, Harari acknowledges the 'hard problem' of consciousness, which is not yet fully understood or explained by science.
Q & A
  • What was the initial motivation behind Professor Harari compiling his lecture notes into a book?

    -Professor Harari decided to compile his lecture notes into a book to make the lives of his students a bit easier by providing them with a comprehensive resource for his introductory history class.

  • How did the book by Professor Harari perform in terms of sales and translations?

    -The book became a bestseller in Israel, topped the nonfiction charts for several months, and was translated into 30 languages, achieving great success across Europe, Canada, and the United States.

  • Why does Professor Harari consider Silicon Valley to be the most interesting place in the world in religious terms?

    -Professor Harari views Silicon Valley as the birthplace of new religions that will shape the future, as it is where innovative ideas and ideologies are currently being formulated.

  • What does liberalism believe about the source of authority and meaning in the universe?

    -Liberalism believes that the source of all authority and meaning in the universe lies in the individual human being, emphasizing the importance of the individual's inner voice or consciousness.

  • How does liberalism manifest in the political sphere?

    -In politics, liberalism translates into a democratic system with elections, where the authority to make decisions lies with the voters, each of whom is expected to listen to their inner voice when voting.

  • What is the liberal perspective on art and aesthetics?

    -Liberal art and aesthetics posit that beauty is subjective and lies in the eyes of the beholder. It suggests that art is whatever the viewer or customer defines as art, and the value of a piece of art is determined by individual perception and market acceptance.

  • How does the concept of liberal education differ from traditional forms of education?

    -Liberal education emphasizes the student as the highest authority, encouraging independent thinking and self-directed learning, rather than relying solely on the teacher or professor for knowledge and guidance.

  • What challenges does Professor Harari foresee for the dominance of liberalism in the future?

    -Professor Harari suggests that the dominance of liberalism could be challenged by advancements in the life sciences, which may undermine the concept of individual freedom and the sanctity of personal feelings by revealing them to be biochemical algorithms.

  • What is the potential shift in authority that Professor Harari discusses in the context of external algorithms?

    -Professor Harari discusses a potential shift in authority from individual feelings to external algorithms, particularly as seen in the field of medicine. As we develop better electronic algorithms that understand human bodies and feelings more accurately than we do ourselves, the decision-making process may move away from personal intuition and towards data-driven insights.

  • How does Professor Harari describe the process of decision-making in terms of survival for animals?

    -Professor Harari describes the process as a complex calculation of probabilities based on various factors such as the availability and ripeness of food, the threat level of predators, and the physical condition of the animal itself. These calculations are made instantaneously by the animal's body, which acts as a calculator, with the result manifesting as an emotion that guides the animal's action.

  • What is the 'hard problem of consciousness' that Professor Harari refers to?

    -The 'hard problem of consciousness' refers to the challenge of understanding how and why certain arrangements of matter (specifically, the brain) give rise to conscious experiences. Despite advancements in correlating brain activity with experiences, we still do not know how electrochemical signals in the brain create subjective experiences.

  • Why does Professor Harari argue that ideologies like communism can be considered as religions?

    -Professor Harari argues that ideologies like communism can be considered as religions because they serve a similar functional role in society. They provide a framework that gives legitimacy to human laws and norms by connecting them to a higher, superhuman authority, whether it's a god, natural law, or in the case of communism, the inevitable march of historical progress.

  • What is the main point of contention regarding the comparison between humans and algorithms?

    -The main point of contention is whether humans, with their consciousness and subjective experiences, can be reduced to mere algorithms as suggested by life sciences. While there is a dogmatic belief that future scientific advancements will bridge this gap, currently, there is no explanation for how algorithms can create the rich tapestry of human experiences.

Outlines
00:00
πŸ“š Professor Harari's Journey to Bestseller

The speaker introduces Professor Harari, a respected academic from the University of Jerusalem, who initially authored a book to ease the workload of his students by compiling his lecture notes. Unexpectedly, the book soared to bestseller status in Israel and was translated into 30 languages, garnering international acclaim. This success led to Harari's invitation to speak at Google, where he discusses the rise of new religions in Silicon Valley and the dominance of liberal humanism in the 21st century.

05:02
🌍 Liberalism's Core Tenets and Practice

Harari delves into the principles of liberalism, emphasizing the importance of the individual and their inner voice as the ultimate source of authority and meaning. He outlines liberalism's belief in individual freedom, derived from an inner space of complete freedom, and the notion that only the individual can truly understand themselves. This belief system translates into various aspects of society, including politics, economics, art, and ethics, where the customer, voter, and individual's feelings are paramount.

10:02
🎨 The Subjectivity of Art and the Liberal Perspective

The discussion shifts to the realm of art and aesthetics, where Harari highlights the liberal view that beauty is subjective and determined by the viewer's perception. He recounts the provocative example of Marcel Duchamp's 'Fountain', a urinal presented as art, to illustrate the point that in liberal art, the audience's opinion is the highest authority, challenging traditional and objective definitions of art.

15:06
🌱 The Dominance and Challenges of the Liberal Package

Harari examines the current global ideological landscape, asserting that the liberal package, encompassing human rights, individualism, and liberal democracy, is the dominant force. Despite social protests advocating for better implementation of liberal values, he notes the lack of viable alternatives. He also addresses potential alternatives like China's economic rise and radical Islam, critiquing their inability to offer relevant solutions to contemporary challenges.

20:06
🧬 Biotechnology and the Future of Human Life

The conversation turns to the profound questions posed by advancements in biotechnology, which could potentially lead to biological disparities between the rich and the poor, and even the emergence of different human castes or species. Harari emphasizes the urgency of these issues and criticizes ideologies like radical Islam for failing to provide insights or solutions to such modern challenges.

25:08
β›“ The Historical Impact of Religions and Ideologies

Harari reflects on the historical impact of religions and ideologies, contrasting the significant influence of the Industrial Revolution with the relative obscurity of religious fundamentalist movements of the 19th century. He underscores the transformative power of a few individuals in technology and finance over the masses engaged with religious texts, and highlights the rise of socialism and communism as ideologies that did shape the modern world.

30:09
πŸ’‘ The Emergence of Techno-Religions

The speaker identifies communism as a 'techno-religion' that promised prosperity and paradise on Earth through technology rather than divine power. He suggests that this shift from traditional religious questions to a focus on technology and economics redefined ideological discourse. Harari also predicts a future where data and information could become the central authority, surpassing individual human experiences.

35:10
🧠 The Life Sciences and the Challenge to Liberalism

Harari discusses the challenge that life sciences pose to liberalism, arguing that humans are not individuals but collections of biochemical algorithms. He suggests that life sciences undermine the concept of free will and the liberal emphasis on personal feelings as the ultimate source of authority. As scientists decode these algorithms and computers create superior ones, authority may shift from individual feelings to external algorithms.

40:10
πŸ” The Future of Decision-Making and Data Religion

The speaker envisions a future where decisions, even profoundly personal ones like marriage, may be guided by data and algorithms rather than individual feelings or religious teachings. He describes a potential 'data religion' where information itself becomes the ultimate source of authority. Harari also raises the possibility of a merger between humans and computers, as opposed to a conflict, and questions the validity of life sciences in explaining consciousness and subjective experiences.

45:13
πŸ€” Open Questions and Audience Interaction

The session concludes with an audience Q&A where Harari addresses queries about the historical emergence of patriarchy, the role of social interactions in decision-making, the comparison of ideologies to religions, and the influence of societal frameworks on scientific advancements. He also reflects on his personal biases as an author and the importance of objective historical analysis.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘Liberal Humanism
Liberal humanism, or liberalism, is a worldview that posits the individual human being as the source of all authority and meaning in the universe. It emphasizes individualism, freedom, and the belief that each person has an inner voice that should guide their decisions. In the context of the video, liberalism is presented as the dominant ideology of the modern world, influencing politics, economics, art, and ethics.
πŸ’‘Individualism
Individualism is the idea that each person is an autonomous entity with their own unique identity and that their individual rights and freedoms are of primary importance. The video discusses how liberalism champions individualism, suggesting that every person has an indivisible inner core that should be respected and protected.
πŸ’‘Silicon Valley
Silicon Valley is a region in California known for its high-tech innovation and development. In the video, it is referred to as a special place for historians because it is seen as the epicenter for the formulation of new religions and ideologies that may shape the future, indicating a shift from traditional religious centers.
πŸ’‘Biochemical Algorithms
Biochemical algorithms refer to the natural processes and mechanisms within living organisms that can be described in terms of computational algorithms. The video suggests that life sciences view humans not as individual entities but as complex collections of these algorithms, challenging the liberal humanist view of individualism.
πŸ’‘Data Religion
Data religion is a hypothetical concept introduced in the video that suggests a future shift in authority from individual feelings to external data and algorithms. It implies that as technology advances, decisions in various aspects of life, including personal health and relationships, may be guided by data-driven insights rather than personal intuition or traditional religious teachings.
πŸ’‘Determinism
Determinism is the philosophical concept that all events, including moral choices, are determined by previously existing causes. The video touches on determinism in the context of life sciences, suggesting that human behaviors and decisions are not free but are determined by biochemical processes or random chance.
πŸ’‘Survival and Reproduction
The concepts of survival and reproduction are central to the video's discussion of life sciences. It is suggested that human feelings and emotions are essentially algorithms calculating the probabilities of survival and reproduction. This challenges the liberal view that places feelings at the center of decision-making.
πŸ’‘Techno-Religion
Techno-religion, as mentioned in the video, is a term used to describe ideologies like communism that are based on technological advancement and economic theory, rather than traditional religious beliefs. It is suggested that such ideologies offer solutions to societal problems through technological means, reflecting the changing nature of societal structures and belief systems.
πŸ’‘Consciousness
Consciousness, particularly the 'hard problem of consciousness,' refers to the challenge of understanding how and why certain physical processes in the brain give rise to subjective experiences. The video highlights this as a potential gap in the life sciences' reductionist approach to human beings, as it questions whether subjective experiences can be reduced to algorithms.
πŸ’‘Matriarchy
Matriarchy is a social structure in which women hold the primary power. The video briefly discusses the historical debate about whether there were matriarchal societies, particularly referencing the Minoan culture. It contrasts with the more widely documented history of patriarchy in the last 10,000 years.
πŸ’‘Subjective Experiences
Subjective experiences are personal, inner experiences such as feelings, sensations, and consciousness that differ from objective reality. In the video, the concept is used to challenge the notion that life can be entirely reduced to information processing, as there is currently no scientific explanation for how physical processes create these subjective experiences.
Highlights

Professor Harari's book, initially intended to simplify students' lives, unexpectedly became a bestseller in Israel and was translated into 30 languages.

Silicon Valley is considered the epicenter for the formulation of new religions that will shape the future.

Liberal humanism, or liberalism, is identified as the dominant ideology of the 21st century, emphasizing individual human autonomy.

Liberalism posits that the individual's inner voice, informed by a space of complete freedom, is the ultimate source of authority and meaning.

In liberal politics, the concept of democracy with elections is seen as allowing each individual's inner voice to guide collective decision-making.

Liberal economics supports the idea that the customer is always right, with market choices reflecting the best products.

In art and aesthetics, liberalism suggests that beauty is subjective, with the viewer's perception defining what is considered art.

Ethics in a liberal context is determined by individual feelings, with no external authority to dictate what is good or evil.

Liberal education encourages students to be the highest authority on their learning, fostering independent thought.

The liberal package, including human rights and individualism, is seen as the dominant but not uncontested global ideology.

China, despite its economic power, is viewed as an ideological dwarf, lacking a compelling alternative to the liberal package.

Radical Islam, while opposing liberalism, is perceived as not offering a viable alternative relevant to 21st-century challenges.

The rise of data religion is predicted as technology and algorithms potentially outperform human decision-making based on feelings.

Biological insights that once supported liberalism may undermine it as scientists decode the biochemical algorithms of human behavior.

The potential merger of human biochemical algorithms with artificial intelligence and machine learning could redefine human authority and decision-making.

The 'hard problem' of consciousness remains a challenge to the notion that life is merely information processing.

Ideologies, like religions, can become globally dominant without being factually correct, as their power lies in their ability to provide a coherent narrative.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: