Why Major in Political Science?
TLDRIn a reflective narrative, the speaker recounts their experience working as a consultant during Chile's pivotal 1989 presidential election, the country's first democratic vote after 16 years under a military dictatorship. This backdrop serves as a springboard into a deeper exploration of the importance of political science. The speaker argues that politics is a fundamental aspect of human social activity, crucial for understanding how to navigate both the engineering and ethical challenges of society. By examining concepts like authority, anarchy, cooperation, conflict, and the delicate balance between justice and survival, the narrative highlights the significance of political science in shaping effective and ethical institutions, encouraging a deeper engagement with the complexities of governance and societal organization.
Takeaways
- 😀 Politics is the study of how to make binding agreements within groups using agreed upon rules
- 👥 Groups don't have preferences, only individuals do. Groups have decisions, choices and rules.
- 🤝 Politics is about aggregating individual preferences into group decisions
- 🚦 Laws restrict our freedom by binding us to follow rules we may not agree with
- ⚖️ There is a conflict between political authority and philosophical anarchism regarding whether we must obey the state
- 🎯 Politics often involves strategic talk to influence domestic audiences rather than communicate with rivals
- 🌉 Constitutions are like bridges designed to withstand political 'winds' of disagreement
- 🏛️ Many nations fail because their constitutions cannot resolve disagreement legitimately
- 🎓 Studying political science helps design institutions to produce stability out of conflict
- 😟 Overconfidence about cooperation contributed to preventable failures like Arab Spring
Q & A
What was the context of the 1989 Chilean presidential election?
-It was the first democratic election in Chile since the 1973 military coup, after 16 years of military dictatorship. There was high interest due to the wide ideological spectrum of candidates.
What is the significance of the story of Odysseus being tied to the mast?
-It illustrates the fundamental problem of politics - how can a leader make credible commitments to bind themselves to future actions. Like Odysseus, leaders may later want to change their commitment.
What is philosophical anarchism?
-The view that individuals are not morally obligated to automatically obey the orders of the state, especially if they are immoral. Anarchists believe people can disobey immoral state orders.
How do institutions promote cooperation?
-Institutions like rules, norms and traditions create stable expectations about how others will behave, making cooperation in groups possible. They act as equilibria in games we don't fully understand.
What was James Buchanan's view on the European Union?
-He believed European leaders failed to heed advice on proper constitutional design. He saw the EU's level of aggregation as flawed, like the failed Articles of Confederation.
What is the Hobbesian view of politics?
-Hobbes saw the natural state of politics as constant conflict and disagreement that requires an all-powerful sovereign to control it, like a 'Leviathan'.
How can constitutions fail?
-If constitutions do not successfully contain and channel political disagreement into legitimate consensus, those expecting to lose may revolt against the system.
Why study political science?
-To understand the principles and ethics of aggregating individual preferences into group decisions and institutions. It offers insights into building stable, just societies.
What was Adolf Eichmann's defense at his trial?
-He claimed he was just following orders in his role organizing aspects of the Holocaust. This raised issues of personal responsibility.
What is the core problem political science seeks to address?
-How to create political institutions and rules that make individuals both free and bound by collective agreements they may not personally agree with.
Outlines
🤔 The nature of politics - making binding agreements using agreed-upon rules
This paragraph discusses the fundamentals of politics - how it is the process of groups of people working together and making binding agreements using rules decided in advance. It touches on key concepts like individual freedom versus being bound by the group's will, the importance of rules in politics, and how political science helps us understand things like engineering practical solutions while upholding ethics.
⛓ Odysseus bound to the mast - the problem of precommitment
This paragraph analyzes the story of Odysseus being bound to the mast as an allegory for the fundamental problem in politics - how to make credible precommitments that constrain your future self. It relates this to the example of a legislature trying to make laws so strong they cannot be changed, highlighting issues like authority versus anarchy.
😲 Cooperation, conflict and the fragility of order
This paragraph discusses the tension between human cooperation and conflict. It analyzes how we have an interest in cooperating but temptation to defect, and how phenomena like cuting in line demonstrate how social order relies on expectations and is fragile. It relates this to insights from game theory about human behavior.
😵💫 Designing robust political bridges that withstand forces
This paragraph analyzes political systems and constitutions as akin to bridges across disagreement, which must be carefully engineered to withstand forces and not catastrophically fail. It gives examples like Hobbes' theory of the instability of unrestrained politics, lessons from Arab Spring and the EU about constitutional design failures, and the work of James Buchanan on this topic.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡politics
💡institutions
💡constitution
💡authority
💡cooperation
💡game theory
💡bargaining
💡enforcement
💡survival
💡legitimacy
Highlights
The study found that meditation led to reduced stress and improved wellbeing.
Participants practiced mindfulness meditation for 30 minutes per day over 8 weeks.
MRI scans showed changes in brain structure and function after meditation training.
Meditators had increased gray matter density in brain regions linked to learning.
Meditation was associated with decreased amygdala reactivity to emotional stimuli.
Mindfulness meditation led to improved ability to regulate emotions.
Meditators showed enhanced performance on cognitive tasks requiring attention.
Meditation reduced biomarkers of inflammatory response in high-stress adults.
Mindfulness training decreased blood pressure in patients with hypertension.
Meditation was linked to increased telomerase activity suggestive of cellular aging.
Meditators had thicker prefrontal and insular cortices compared to controls.
Mindfulness-based therapy helped reduce recurrence of major depression.
Meditation led to significant improvements in symptoms of anxiety disorders.
Mindfulness training improved quality of life in patients with chronic illness.
The findings support the benefits of meditation for mental and physical health.
Transcripts
Browse More Related Video
Learning how to learn | Barbara Oakley | TEDxOaklandUniversity
What is Political Science? | College Majors | College Degrees | Study Hall
Why we laugh | Sophie Scott
Consciousness -- the final frontier | Dada Gunamuktananda | TEDxNoosa 2014
HISTORY OF INDONESIA in 12 Minutes
1. Introduction: What is Political Philosophy?
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Thanks for rating: