Resonance Structures/Assigning Formal Charge

Professor Dave Explains
4 Jan 201512:31
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn this educational video, Professor Dave delves into the concept of resonance in organic chemistry, explaining how pi electrons and lone pairs participate in resonance. He reviews how to determine formal charges by comparing an atom's electron contribution to its valence electrons. The video clarifies that while individual resonance structures are theoretical, the actual state of a molecule is a composite resonance structure with delocalized electron density. This tutorial also touches on the impact of electronegativity on the distribution of formal charges in resonance structures and emphasizes the importance of valid Lewis dot structures in resonance.

Takeaways
  • 🔬 Resonance is a fundamental concept in organic chemistry, involving the delocalization of pi electrons in molecules.
  • 📚 Pi electrons are involved in resonance because they are part of the double or triple bonds in molecules, which are formed by the overlap of p orbitals.
  • 🌐 The sp2 hybridization of carbon atoms in double bonds allows for the formation of pi bonds through the unhybridized p orbitals.
  • ⚡ Formal charge is determined by comparing the number of electrons an atom contributes to a Lewis structure with its typical valence electron count.
  • 🔍 Resonance structures are drawn to help understand molecular behavior, but in reality, only a composite resonance structure exists, representing the actual distribution of electron density.
  • 📉 Sigma electrons are not delocalizable due to direct orbital overlap, unlike pi electrons which can be rearranged to form stable resonance structures.
  • 🔄 The convention for representing resonance structures is to list them in brackets with a double-headed arrow, indicating the delocalization of electrons.
  • 🚫 Not all resonance structures contribute equally; some are more stable due to factors like electronegativity and the ability of atoms to accommodate charges.
  • 🌀 The composite resonance structure shows a distribution of electron density that may be skewed towards atoms that are more electronegative or electropositive.
  • 🚫 Resonance structures must adhere to the rules of Lewis dot structures, meaning atoms cannot have an invalid number of bonds.
  • 👨‍🏫 The video script provides a tutorial on understanding resonance and formal charge, encouraging viewers to subscribe for more educational content.
Q & A

  • What is resonance in the context of organic chemistry?

    -Resonance is a concept in organic chemistry that describes the phenomenon where the electrons in certain molecules, particularly those in pi bonds or lone pairs, can be distributed in more than one equivalent position, leading to multiple possible structures known as resonance structures.

  • Why are pi electrons significant in resonance?

    -Pi electrons are significant in resonance because they are the ones that participate in resonance. They are found in pi bonds, which are formed by the lateral overlap of p orbitals, and can be delocalized within a structure, allowing for the formation of resonance structures.

  • What is the difference between a sigma and a pi bond in terms of electron distribution?

    -A sigma bond involves a direct overlap of orbitals, typically along the axis connecting two atoms, and is associated with a single bond. A pi bond, on the other hand, is formed by the lateral overlap of p orbitals and is associated with double or triple bonds. Sigma electrons are not delocalizable, while pi electrons can be delocalized and participate in resonance.

  • How are sp2 hybridized orbitals related to the formation of pi bonds?

    -In sp2 hybridization, an atom's atomic orbitals are mixed to form three sp2 hybrid orbitals and one unhybridized p orbital. The sp2 orbitals form sigma bonds with adjacent atoms, while the unhybridized p orbital can overlap with another p orbital to form a pi bond.

  • What is the simplest way to determine if an atom has a formal charge?

    -The simplest way to determine if an atom has a formal charge is to compare the number of electrons the atom is contributing to a Lewis dot structure with its typical valence electron count. If the numbers are different, the atom bears a formal charge.

  • Why do we consider formal charges when drawing resonance structures?

    -Formal charges are considered when drawing resonance structures because they help us understand the distribution of electrons and the stability of different resonance forms. Atoms with formal charges can participate in resonance by shifting electrons to achieve more stable configurations.

  • What is the convention for representing resonance structures?

    -The convention for representing resonance structures is to list them in brackets with a double-headed arrow between them, indicating that the structures are in resonance and that the actual molecule is a hybrid of these forms.

  • Why don't individual resonance structures exist in reality?

    -Individual resonance structures do not exist in reality because the actual molecule is a hybrid of all possible resonance forms, with the electrons distributed in a way that represents a composite of all the structures, rather than any single one.

  • How do resonance structures with formal charges differ from those without?

    -Resonance structures with formal charges involve the distribution of electrons such that some atoms bear a positive or negative charge. These structures are often less stable than those without formal charges, where all atoms are neutral, and the electron density is more evenly distributed.

  • What is the significance of electronegativity in determining the distribution of formal charges in resonance structures?

    -Electronegativity is significant in determining the distribution of formal charges in resonance structures because more electronegative atoms can better accommodate negative charges, while more electropositive atoms can better accommodate positive charges. This affects the stability and contribution of different resonance forms.

  • Why is it important to draw electron-pushing arrows correctly in resonance structures?

    -It is important to draw electron-pushing arrows correctly in resonance structures because they represent the movement of electrons that leads to the formation of resonance structures. The arrows must go from electron-rich areas to electron-poor areas, accurately depicting the delocalization of electrons.

  • How do we know which resonance structure contributes more significantly to the composite structure?

    -The resonance structure that contributes more significantly to the composite structure is the one that is more stable, which is often determined by factors such as the atom's electronegativity, the presence of formal charges, and the overall distribution of electron density.

Outlines
00:00
🔬 Understanding Resonance and Formal Charge in Organic Chemistry

Professor Dave introduces the concept of resonance structures and formal charge in organic chemistry. He explains that pi electrons, which are part of double or triple carbon-carbon bonds, are crucial to resonance. These electrons, along with lone pairs, can participate in resonance, leading to multiple valid structures for a molecule. The video delves into the hybridization of carbon atoms in alkenes and the formation of pi bonds through the overlap of p orbitals. The professor also reviews how to determine the formal charge of an atom by comparing its valence electrons to the number of electrons it contributes in a Lewis dot structure, using examples from polyatomic ions.

05:00
🔍 Delocalization of Pi Electrons and Resonance Structures

This section explores the delocalization of pi electrons and how they can rearrange to form stable resonance structures. The video clarifies that sigma electrons, involved in direct orbital overlap, are not delocalizable. It uses examples to illustrate how a negative charge can be moved to different atoms within a molecule, forming equally valid resonance structures. The convention for representing resonance structures with brackets and a double-headed arrow is explained. The video emphasizes that individual resonance structures are theoretical constructs; the actual state of a molecule is a composite resonance structure with delocalized electron density, as demonstrated with the nitrate ion example.

10:02
📊 The Impact of Electronegativity on Resonance Structures

In this part, the video discusses how electronegativity influences the distribution of formal charges in resonance structures. It explains that atoms with a higher electronegativity, like oxygen, can better accommodate negative charges, while more electropositive atoms, such as carbon, are more suited to positive charges. The video uses examples to show how the composite resonance structure may skew the electron density towards atoms that can better accommodate the charge. It also highlights that resonance structures with all neutral atoms are more contributing than those with formal charges and stresses the importance of valid Lewis dot structures in drawing resonance structures.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Resonance Structures
Resonance structures refer to the different possible arrangements of electrons in a molecule that can be drawn without violating the rules of valence. They are used to describe the delocalized electrons, particularly in pi bonds. In the video, resonance structures are central to understanding how pi electrons can be rearranged to form stable configurations, with examples given such as the negative charge distribution in the nitrate ion.
💡Formal Charge
Formal charge is a concept used to determine the charge an atom would have if all the electrons in a molecule were distributed evenly among the atoms, based on the Lewis structure. The video explains how to calculate formal charge by comparing the number of valence electrons an atom should have to the number it is shown to have in a Lewis structure, as seen with the oxygen atom in the nitrate ion example.
💡Pi Electrons
Pi electrons are the electrons that occupy the pi bonds in a molecule, which are formed by the lateral overlap of p orbitals. The video emphasizes that pi electrons are crucial for resonance because they are delocalizable and can participate in the formation of resonance structures, unlike sigma electrons which are involved in direct orbital overlap and are not delocalizable.
💡Sigma Bond
A sigma bond is a covalent bond formed by the overlap of atomic orbitals along the axis connecting the nuclei of two atoms. In the script, the sigma bond is described as the bond in a carbon-carbon double bond that is directly between the two carbon atoms, as opposed to the pi bond which is formed by the overlap of p orbitals above and below the plane of the sigma bond.
💡Sp2 Hybridization
Sp2 hybridization is a type of hybridization that occurs when one s orbital and two p orbitals of an atom mix to form three sp2 hybrid orbitals. The video describes how carbon atoms involved in a double bond are sp2 hybridized, allowing them to form three sigma bonds with other atoms and leaving one unhybridized p orbital for pi bond formation.
💡Lone Pair
A lone pair refers to a pair of electrons that are not involved in bonding and are located on an atom. In the video, lone pairs are mentioned as participants in resonance, as they can be converted into a pi bond, contributing to the formation of resonance structures.
💡Delocalization
Delocalization is the concept that electrons are spread out over a larger region of space rather than being localized between two atoms. The video discusses how pi electrons are delocalized in resonance structures, leading to a distribution of electron density that does not correspond to any single resonance structure but rather a composite of all possible structures.
💡Electronegativity
Electronegativity is a measure of the tendency of an atom to attract a bonding pair of electrons. The video explains that oxygen is more electronegative than carbon, which affects how resonance structures distribute formal charges, with more electropositive atoms better able to accommodate positive charges.
💡Lewis Dot Structure
A Lewis dot structure is a graphical representation of the valence electrons of an atom, used to show how these electrons are arranged in a molecule. The video uses Lewis dot structures to illustrate the concept of formal charge and to show how resonance structures must adhere to the rules of Lewis structures, such as not allowing an atom to have more than eight electrons in its valence shell.
💡Composite Resonance Structure
A composite resonance structure represents the average distribution of electrons in a molecule, taking into account all possible resonance structures. The video emphasizes that while individual resonance structures are useful for understanding, the actual electron distribution in a molecule is a composite of all possible resonance forms, as seen in the examples of the nitrate ion and the enolate anion.
Highlights

Resonance structures and formal charge assignment are key concepts in organic chemistry.

Pi electrons, involved in resonance, are crucial for understanding organic chemistry.

A carbon-carbon double bond consists of one sigma bond and one pi bond, with sp2 hybridization of carbons.

Unhybridized p orbitals overlap to generate pi bonds in carbon-carbon double bonds.

Electrons in pi bonds and lone pairs are the ones that participate in resonance.

Formal charge can be determined by comparing the number of electrons in a Lewis structure to the typical valence of an atom.

An oxygen atom with seven electrons in a Lewis structure has a formal negative charge.

A nitrogen atom with four electrons in a Lewis structure has a formal positive charge.

Pi electrons are delocalizable within a structure, leading to resonance structures.

Sigma electrons are not delocalizable due to direct orbital overlap.

Resonance structures are listed with brackets and a double-headed arrow to denote their equivalence.

The actual state of a molecule is a composite resonance structure representing the distribution of pi electron density.

Resonance structures with formal charges should be analyzed based on the atom's ability to accommodate the charge.

Electronegative atoms, like oxygen, can better accommodate negative charges in resonance structures.

Resonance structures with all neutral atoms contribute more than those with formal charges.

Any valid resonance structure must adhere to the rules of Lewis dot structures, avoiding violations like a carbon with five bonds.

Understanding resonance and formal charge is essential for grasping how molecules behave in organic chemistry.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Resonance Structures, Basic Introduction - How To Draw The Resonance Hybrid, Chemistry

2.4 Resonance | Organic Chemistry

How To Calculate The Formal Charge of an Atom - Chemistry

What is Resonance -Understanding Orgo Resonance Structures Vid 1 by Leah Fisch

8.2 Lewis Dot Structures | High School Chemistry

General Chemistry Review for Organic Chemistry Part 2

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Resonance StructuresFormal ChargeOrganic ChemistryPi ElectronsLewis StructuresElectronegativityDelocalizationMolecular OrbitalsChemical BondsEducational Tutorial