This pattern breaks, but for a good reason | Moser's circle problem

3Blue1Brown

1 Jul 202316:13

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe script explores Moser's circle problem, a mathematical curiosity where adding points to a circle and connecting them creates an unexpected pattern of regions. Initially seeming to double with each point added, the pattern breaks at the sixth point, deviating from powers of two. The explanation delves into combinatorics, Euler's formula, and Pascal's triangle to uncover the underlying reason for this phenomenon, offering a deeper understanding of mathematical patterns and their limits.

Takeaways

🔍 The script introduces Moser's circle problem, a cautionary tale in mathematics that challenges the assumption of patterns without proof.
📐 It explains the process of dividing a circle into regions by adding points and connecting them with chords, observing the pattern of regions doubling with each new point until it breaks.
📈 The script highlights the importance of considering the generic case where no three lines intersect, which is more likely when points are chosen randomly.
🎼 The narrator's personal connection to the problem is shared through a poem and song written about it, emphasizing the problem's intriguing nature.
🧩 The 'strong law of small numbers' is mentioned, illustrating the limitations of small numbers in meeting the demands of mathematical patterns.
📝 The script encourages problem-solving by suggesting warm-up questions related to counting total chords and intersection points within the circle.
🔢 The concept of 'n choose k' is introduced to count distinct pairs or quadruplets of points, which is fundamental to solving the problem.
📚 Euler's characteristic formula (v - e + f = 2) is explained as a tool for counting regions in a planar graph, adapted for the circle problem by considering intersection points as vertices.
📉 The formula for the number of regions in the circle is derived as 1 + n choose 2 + n choose 4, providing a closed-form solution to the problem.
📊 Pascal's triangle is connected to the problem, showing how the sum of certain rows corresponds to powers of 2 and explaining the deviation from this pattern at n = 6.
🤔 The script concludes with a challenge to explore whether there are more instances of powers of 2 in the problem, inviting further investigation into the nature of mathematical coincidences.

Q & A

What is Moser's circle problem?
-Moser's circle problem is a mathematical cautionary tale that demonstrates how adding points to a circle and connecting them with chords can divide the circle into regions, seemingly following a pattern of powers of two until it breaks at a certain point.
How does the number of regions change when adding points to a circle in Moser's circle problem?
-Initially, adding points to the circle and connecting them with chords divides the circle into a number of regions that follows the pattern of powers of two. However, after adding the sixth point, the number of regions is one less than a power of two, breaking the pattern.
What is the significance of the 'strong law of small numbers' in the context of Moser's circle problem?
-The 'strong law of small numbers' refers to the idea that small numbers cannot meet the many demands made of them in mathematical patterns. In Moser's circle problem, this is evident as the pattern of powers of two breaks down unexpectedly.
What mathematical concept is used to calculate the number of distinct pairs of points on a circle?
-The mathematical concept used to calculate the number of distinct pairs of points on a circle is 'n choose two', which counts the number of distinct pairs that can be chosen from a set of n items where order doesn't matter.
How can you determine the number of intersection points of chords within a circle?
-The number of intersection points of chords within a circle can be determined by calculating 'n choose four', which counts the number of distinct quadruplets of points that can be chosen from a set of n points, as each intersection point is uniquely associated with a quadruplet of points.
What is Euler's characteristic formula, and how is it applied in Moser's circle problem?
-Euler's characteristic formula is v - e + f = 2, where v is the number of vertices, e is the number of edges, and f is the number of regions in a planar graph. In Moser's circle problem, it is adapted to count the number of regions by considering intersection points as vertices and adjusting for the total number of edges.
How does the formula for the number of regions in Moser's circle problem relate to Pascal's triangle?
-The formula for the number of regions, which is 1 + n choose 2 + n choose 4, can be visualized within Pascal's triangle as the sum of the 0th, 2nd, and 4th terms of a row. This connection helps explain why the pattern of powers of two appears and when it breaks.
What is the role of Pascal's triangle in understanding the pattern of regions in Moser's circle problem?
-Pascal's triangle provides a visual and mathematical framework to understand the pattern of regions in Moser's circle problem. The sums of certain rows in the triangle correspond to powers of two, which helps explain the initial pattern and the point at which it deviates.
Why does the pattern of regions in Moser's circle problem break at the sixth point?
-The pattern breaks at the sixth point because when relating the formula for the number of regions to the previous row in Pascal's triangle, the sum of the first five elements does not cover the entire row, falling short by exactly one, which is why the number of regions is one less than a power of two.
What is the challenge problem mentioned in the script regarding Moser's circle problem?
-The challenge problem is to determine if there are any other instances where the number of regions in Moser's circle problem results in a power of two, and if so, to provide a proof or explanation for when this occurs.

Outlines

00:00

📚 Introduction to Moser's Circle Problem

This paragraph introduces Moser's circle problem, a famous mathematical puzzle involving the placement of points on a circle and the resulting division into regions by connecting chords. It explains the initial pattern of the number of regions doubling with each additional point, which seems to follow powers of two until it breaks at the sixth point. The speaker also mentions the importance of considering only the generic case where no three lines intersect, and the significance of this problem in understanding the 'strong law of small numbers'. The paragraph sets the stage for a deeper exploration into the pattern and the mathematical principles behind it.

05:01

🔍 Warm-up Questions and Planar Graph Theory

The second paragraph delves into two warm-up questions that serve as a foundation for solving the main problem. It discusses counting the total number of chords as 'n choose two' and the number of intersection points as 'n choose four', using combinatorial reasoning. The paragraph then introduces Euler's characteristic formula from graph theory, which relates the number of vertices, edges, and regions in a planar graph, and explains how it can be adapted to solve the circle problem by considering intersection points as vertices and the chords as edges.

10:02

🌐 Euler's Formula Application and Region Counting

This paragraph applies Euler's formula to the modified graph where intersection points are treated as vertices, allowing for the calculation of the total number of regions created by the chords. It explains the process of counting vertices and edges in the context of the circle problem, including the addition of arcs on the circle's boundary. The paragraph concludes with the formula for the number of regions, which is expressed as one plus 'n choose two' plus 'n choose four', providing a direct answer to the original question.

15:02

📊 Pascal's Triangle and the Pattern Behind Powers of Two

The final paragraph explores the connection between the formula derived for the number of regions and Pascal's triangle. It explains how the formula's terms correspond to the elements of Pascal's triangle and how the sum of these elements in each row equals powers of two. The paragraph discusses the reason behind the pattern's deviation at n equals 6 and the occurrence of another power of two at n equals 10. It also poses a challenge to the audience to investigate further occurrences of powers of two in the sequence. The summary concludes by reflecting on the deeper understanding that can be gained from what might initially seem like coincidences.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Moser's circle problem

Moser's circle problem is a mathematical curiosity that explores the number of regions a circle is divided into when chords are drawn between points on its circumference. The video uses this problem to illustrate the deceptive nature of patterns in mathematics. It is a cautionary tale about the limitations of inductive reasoning and the importance of proof in mathematics.

💡Chords

In the context of the video, a chord refers to a line segment whose endpoints lie on the circumference of a circle. The script discusses how adding points to a circle and connecting them with chords increases the number of regions within the circle, which is central to understanding Moser's circle problem.

💡Regions

The term 'regions' in the script refers to the separate areas created within the circle as more points are added and connected by chords. The number of regions is the core of Moser's circle problem, and the video discusses how this number initially follows a pattern of powers of two before deviating.

💡Pascal's triangle

Pascal's triangle is a triangular array of numbers where each number is the sum of the two numbers directly above it. The video script relates the pattern observed in Moser's circle problem to the rows of Pascal's triangle, showing how the sums of certain elements in the triangle correspond to powers of two.

💡Combinatorial mathematics

Combinatorial mathematics involves the study of counting, arrangement, and combination of objects. The script uses combinatorial concepts such as 'n choose k' to calculate the number of chords and intersection points, which are essential for solving Moser's circle problem.

💡Euler's characteristic formula

Euler's characteristic formula, v - e + f = 2, is a fundamental principle in graph theory that relates the number of vertices (v), edges (e), and faces (f) in a planar graph. The video applies a variant of this formula to determine the number of regions in Moser's circle problem by considering intersection points as vertices.

💡Intersection points

Intersection points are the points within the circle where chords cross each other. The script explains how to calculate the number of these points using 'n choose 4' and how they contribute to the total number of regions in the circle.

💡Strong law of small numbers

The strong law of small numbers, as mentioned in the script, is a concept introduced by mathematician Richard Guy, which humorously points out that there are not enough small numbers to satisfy all the mathematical demands made of them. The video uses this concept to highlight the unexpected deviations from patterns in Moser's circle problem.

💡Inductive reasoning

Inductive reasoning is the process of making generalizations based on observations. The script warns against relying solely on inductive reasoning by demonstrating how the pattern of powers of two in Moser's circle problem breaks down without formal proof.

💡Graph theory

Graph theory is the study of graphs, which are mathematical structures used to model pairwise relations between objects. The video applies principles from graph theory, such as Euler's formula, to analyze the structure created by chords in Moser's circle problem and determine the number of regions.

💡Diaphantine equations

Diaphantine equations are polynomial equations where only integer solutions are sought. The script poses a challenge to the viewer to investigate whether the pattern of powers of two in Moser's circle problem continues beyond the observed cases, potentially using diaphantine equations to prove or disprove this.

Highlights

Introduction to Moser's circle problem, a famous cautionary tale in mathematics.

Demonstration of how adding points to a circle and connecting them with chords divides the circle into regions.

Observation that the number of regions increases in a pattern resembling powers of two until it breaks at the sixth point.

Discussion on the dependency of the pattern on the placement of points, and the generic case assumption of no three lines intersecting.

The strong law of small numbers by Richard Guy, highlighting the limitations of small numbers in mathematical patterns.

The importance of the initial powers of two pattern and its significance beyond coincidence in the problem.

Warm-up questions about the total number of chords and intersection points within the circle.

Explanation of 'n choose two' as a method to count the total number of chords.

The challenge of counting intersection points and the unique association with quadruplets of points.

Introduction of 'n choose four' as the function to calculate the number of intersection points.

Use of Euler's characteristic formula to relate vertices, edges, and regions in a planar graph.

Application of Euler's formula to the circle problem by considering intersection points as vertices.

Derivation of the formula for the number of regions in the circle based on vertices and edges.

Connection between the circle problem's formula and Pascal's triangle, explaining the pattern of powers of two.

The reason behind the deviation from powers of two at n equals 6, and the specific case of n equals 10.

Challenge problem presented to find if there are more instances of powers of two in the pattern.

Summary of the process from counting chords and intersection points to applying Euler's formula and connecting with Pascal's triangle.

Reflection on Moser's circle problem as both a cautionary tale and an opportunity for deeper understanding.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Math String Art (Measuring)

Introduction to Calculus (2 of 2: First Principles)

Physics 60 Interference of Light (4 of 8) Young's Double Slit

Vi and Sal talk about the mysteries of Benford's law | Logarithms | Algebra II | Khan Academy

PROBLEM SOLVING INVOLVING CIRCLES

Distance Formula