Why Russell Wilson-Broncos did not work out, JJ McCarthy over Jayden Daniels? | NFL | THE HERD

The Herd with Colin Cowherd
5 Mar 202408:48
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn this sports analysis, Mark Sareth discusses the compatibility of quarterback Russell Wilson with head coach Sean Payton, highlighting their contrasting styles. Sareth emphasizes the challenges of Wilson's improvisational play in Payton's precision-driven system. He also evaluates other quarterbacks like Kirk Cousins and speculates on potential fits for Wilson, considering his declining athleticism and style of play. The conversation delves into the importance of pre-snap recognition and the unique skills of draft prospect JJ McCarthy, who stands out for his NFL-style pre-snap offense.

Takeaways
  • 🏈 Mark Sareth, a three-time Super Bowl champion and multiple-time Pro Bowler, is a popular radio host in Denver and is often invited to discuss football topics.
  • 🗣️ The transcript discusses a moment of clarity from an article by Seth Wickersham, where Sean Payton told Russell Wilson to stop kissing babies, highlighting the differences in their personalities and approaches.
  • 🎥 Colin, presumably a football analyst, believes that the mismatch in playing style between Russell Wilson and Sean Payton's desired quarterback traits is evident when breaking down the film.
  • 🤔 Colin points out that Wilson's tendency to scramble instead of making anticipatory throws in the middle of the field could be problematic for a coach like Payton who values on-time throws and precision.
  • 📉 The discussion suggests that mobile quarterbacks like Russell Wilson, Donovan McNabb, and Cam Newton may experience a decline in performance as they age, which could be a concern for teams considering signing Wilson.
  • 🚀 Colin praises Kirk Cousins for his deep ball throwing ability, athleticism, and arm talent, suggesting that with the right team setup, Cousins could still be very successful.
  • 🏈 The transcript mentions the importance of having a strong defense and running game to support a mobile quarterback like Cousins, as well as the need for receivers who can adjust routes on the fly.
  • 🔍 When evaluating quarterbacks, the focus should be on transferable skills from college to the NFL, with an emphasis on pre-snap recognition and the ability to run a pro-style offense.
  • 🌟 JJ McCarthy from Michigan is highlighted for his pre-snap skills and the ability to run an NFL-style offense, making him a rising prospect in the draft.
  • 💰 The conversation touches on the financial aspect of signing quarterbacks, with the hypothetical scenario of Russell Wilson taking a pay cut to join a team with a strong supporting cast.
  • 🛡️ Colin concludes by emphasizing the need for a team with Wilson to be prepared to play close games and manage the negative plays that may result from his playing style.
Q & A

  • What was the moment of clarity mentioned in the transcript that indicated the incompatibility between Sean Payton and Russell Wilson?

    -The moment of clarity was a quote from an article by Seth Wickersham, where Sean Payton told Russell Wilson to stop kissing babies as he's not running for office. This highlighted the difference in their personalities, with Sean being the anti-politician and Russell being the ultimate politician.

  • How does the lack of schematic fit between Russell Wilson's playing style and Sean Payton's coaching preferences manifest on the field?

    -The lack of fit is evident in Wilson's tendency to pull the ball down and scramble around instead of making anticipatory throws in the middle of the field, which goes against Payton's preference for precision, execution, and quick decision-making similar to a Drew Brees type of quarterback.

  • What are the key attributes of a quarterback that Sean Payton prefers according to the transcript?

    -Sean Payton prefers a quarterback who can process information quickly, make the right decision in a split second, and execute with precision, akin to a Drew Brees type of quarterback.

  • What are some of the positive aspects of Russell Wilson's game that were mentioned in the transcript?

    -Russell Wilson's ability to throw the deep ball exceptionally well, extend plays, and his athleticism are some of the positive aspects mentioned. Despite not fitting Sean Payton's schematic preferences, Wilson still possesses big-time arm talent.

  • How does the transcript suggest a mobile quarterback like Russell Wilson could still be successful in the right system?

    -The transcript suggests that with a stellar defense, a strong running game, and a system that allows for scrambling and making plays outside the parameters of the route combinations, a mobile quarterback like Wilson could still be very successful.

  • What is the transcript's perspective on the comparison between Russell Wilson and other mobile quarterbacks like Donovan McNabb and Cam Newton?

    -The transcript implies that mobile quarterbacks like Donovan McNabb and Cam Newton aged quickly, suggesting that Wilson might face a similar trajectory if he doesn't adapt his playing style as his athleticism declines.

  • What are the qualities that make Kurt Cousins a potentially good fit for a team looking for a quarterback, as per the transcript?

    -Kurt Cousins is described as having the ability to throw the deep ball well, extend plays, and still possessing athleticism and big-time arm talent, which are qualities that can be serviceable in the right offensive system.

  • What attributes does the transcript highlight in a quarterback prospect like Bo Nix?

    -Bo Nix is highlighted for his high accuracy, mobility, and the fact that he was schemed up in a way that resembles what Sean Payton likes in a quarterback, making him a potential good fit for a Payton-style offense.

  • Why does JJ McCarthy stand out among quarterback prospects according to the transcript?

    -JJ McCarthy stands out for his pre-snap recognition and his ability to run an NFL pro-style offense at the line of scrimmage, which includes different personnel groupings, calling plays, and using motion to understand where he wants to go with the football.

  • What is the significance of a quarterback's pre-snap skills in transitioning to the NFL, as mentioned in the transcript?

    -Pre-snap skills are significant because they indicate a quarterback's ability to call a huddle, make adjustments, and understand defensive responses, which are crucial for success in the NFL where the game is more complex and requires quick decision-making.

  • How does the transcript suggest a team should approach playing close games with a quarterback like Russell Wilson?

    -The transcript suggests that a team should be prepared to play close games with Wilson due to his tendency to put himself in harm's way, taking sacks that are his responsibility, and the need for a strong defense and offensive weaponry to overcome those negative plays.

Outlines
00:00
🏈 NFL Quarterback Dynamics and Schematic Fit

The first paragraph discusses the contrasting styles of NFL quarterbacks, particularly focusing on the incompatibility between Russell Wilson's playing style and Sean Payton's coaching preferences. It highlights the moment when Payton advised Wilson to stop 'kissing babies', signifying a cultural clash between the two. The discussion moves on to the technical aspects of football, with an emphasis on the importance of timing and anticipation in throws, and how Wilson's tendency to scramble can be frustrating for coaches seeking precision. The paragraph concludes with an analysis of Wilson's skills, such as his deep ball throwing and athleticism, and how these could be utilized effectively in a team with a strong defense and running game.

05:01
📈 Evaluating Transferable Skills in NFL Quarterbacks

The second paragraph delves into the evaluation of quarterbacks, especially in the context of the NFL draft. It emphasizes the importance of pre-snap recognition and the ability to run a pro-style offense, using JJ McCarthy from Michigan as an example of a quarterback with these transferable skills. The discussion points out the difference between college and NFL offenses, and how McCarthy's experience in calling plays and adjusting formations pre-snap could give him an advantage in the NFL. The paragraph also touches on the potential for Russell Wilson to play for a lower salary and the necessity for a team to have a strong defense and offensive weaponry to compensate for a quarterback who might take risks and suffer sacks. It concludes with a comparison of different quarterbacks and the strategic considerations a team might have when choosing between them.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Super Bowl
The Super Bowl is the championship game of the National Football League (NFL), often considered the most important single event in American sports. In the context of the video, 'three time Super Bowl champ' refers to a player who has won this prestigious championship three times, indicating a high level of success and skill.
💡Pro Bowler
A Pro Bowler is a player selected to play in the Pro Bowl, the NFL's all-star game, which is a recognition of the best players in the league. The term signifies that the player is among the top performers in their position, as mentioned in the script when referring to Mark Sareth.
💡Schematic Fit
Schematic fit refers to how well a player's skills and style align with a team's offensive or defensive system. In the video, the lack of schematic fit between Russell Wilson and Sean Payton's desired style of play is discussed, indicating that Wilson's playing style may not be a perfect match for Payton's coaching philosophy.
💡Anticipatory Throws
Anticipatory throws are passes made by a quarterback before the receiver has come open, based on the quarterback's understanding of the timing and route of the play. The script mentions that Russell Wilson's tendency to pull the ball down and scramble instead of making anticipatory throws is a point of concern for coaches who prefer on-time, purposeful throws.
💡Scrambling
Scrambling is when a quarterback, instead of passing the ball, runs with it to evade defenders and potentially gain yardage. The script discusses how Russell Wilson's scrambling can lead to sacks and disrupt the flow of the offense, which is not ideal for a coach seeking precision and quick decision-making.
💡Drew Brees
Drew Brees is a former NFL quarterback known for his precision, quick decision-making, and ability to process information rapidly on the field. In the video, he is used as an example of the type of quarterback Sean Payton would prefer, in contrast to Russell Wilson's style.
💡Mobile Quarterback
A mobile quarterback is one who is capable of moving around in the pocket and running with the ball when necessary. The script mentions that more mobile quarterbacks like Donovan McNabb and Cam Newton have shown a tendency to age quickly, implying that their style of play may not be sustainable over a long career.
💡Deep Ball
The deep ball refers to a pass thrown downfield towards the end zone, often a long-distance throw. The script praises Kirk Cousins for his ability to throw the deep ball exceptionally well, which is a valuable skill in an NFL quarterback.
💡Play Action
Play action is a deceptive strategy where the quarterback pretends to hand off the ball to a running back but then passes it instead. The script suggests that a mobile quarterback like Russell Wilson can be effectively used in play action situations to exploit the defense's expectations.
💡Pre-Snap Recognition
Pre-snap recognition is a quarterback's ability to read the defense and make adjustments before the snap. The script highlights JJ McCarthy's pre-snap recognition as a key skill that makes him a desirable prospect for the NFL, as it demonstrates his ability to process information quickly and make decisions on the field.
💡Pro-Style Offense
A pro-style offense is a traditional, NFL-style offensive system used in college football that involves huddles, multiple formations, and a more complex set of plays. The script notes that JJ McCarthy's experience with a pro-style offense at Michigan gives him an advantage in transitioning to the NFL, as it requires understanding personnel groupings, calling plays, and making pre-snap adjustments.
Highlights

Mark Sareth, a three-time Super Bowl champion and multiple-time Pro Bowler, shares his insights on the situation with Russell Wilson and Sean Payton.

Seth Wickersham's article quotes Sean Payton telling Russell Wilson to stop kissing babies, highlighting the difference in their personalities.

Colin Cowherd discusses the lack of schematic fit between Russell Wilson's playing style and Sean Payton's coaching preferences.

Wilson's tendency to pull the ball down and scramble instead of making anticipatory throws is a concern for coaches seeking on-time precision.

Payton prefers a quarterback like Drew Brees, who can quickly process information and make the right decisions, which is not Wilson's strength.

Kurt Cousins is mentioned as a mobile quarterback who has aged well, in contrast to others like Donovan McNabb and Cam Newton.

Cousins' ability to throw deep balls exceptionally well and his athleticism are still considered valuable assets.

A successful team with Cousins would need stellar defense and a strong running game to complement his scrambling abilities.

The importance of a quarterback's pre-snap recognition and ability to call plays in the huddle is emphasized for NFL success.

JJ McCarthy from Michigan is praised for his pre-snap skills and running a pro-style offense, making him a top draft prospect.

McCarthy's ability to make pre-snap adjustments and understand defensive responses is seen as highly transferable to the NFL.

The discussion considers the hypothetical scenario of Russell Wilson taking a pay cut to join a team with a strong supporting cast.

The necessity for a team with Wilson to be prepared for close games and manage negative plays due to his playing style.

The modern NFL's edge rushers are faster and more athletic, making it harder for quarterbacks like Wilson to escape.

Colin Cowherd invites viewers to subscribe for more exclusive content and behind-the-scenes videos.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Ex-NFL WR Andrew Hawkins Confirms Mike McDaniel’s Football Genius…& Hygiene Habits | Rich Eisen Show

The NFL’s Latest Evolution

How to Create a Play-Call Sheet

Raiders FOOLED EVERYBODY with QB Gardner Minshew!

How the number 865 changed Mike McDaniel's life | NFL Countdown

Why Europeans Are Taking Over The NBA

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
NFLRussell WilsonSean PaytonQuarterbackSchematic FitFootball AnalysisMobile QBDraft ProspectsOffensive StrategyCoaching Insights