Divine Men in Antiquity

Centre Place

19 Jul 2023120:45

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe lecture delves into the concept of 'Divine men' in antiquity, exploring how ancient civilizations perceived divine interactions with humans and the potential for human deification. It contrasts this with the modern Western perspective, shaped by monotheism and scientific understanding, which views the divine as more distant and supernatural phenomena as distinct from natural causation. The talk also examines ancient religious practices, the role of gods in everyday life, and the evolution of religious thought, including the deification of figures like Julius Caesar. It highlights the fluid boundary between the divine and human realms in the ancient world and the influence of philosophical ideas on religious beliefs.

Takeaways

📜 The script discusses the concept of 'divine men' in antiquity, exploring how ancient civilizations perceived divine interactions with humans and the potential for humans to become gods.
🛐 There is a comparison between the ancient worldview, where the boundary between the divine and human realms was less distinct, and the modern Western perspective, shaped by centuries of monotheism and a more stark divide between the divine and humanity.
🌌 The speaker highlights how our modern understanding of the cosmos has significantly expanded compared to the ancients', contributing to a greater perceived divide between the vastness of the universe and the concept of a creator.
🔬 The development of scientific theories and explanations for natural phenomena has led to a distinction between natural and supernatural causes, with the latter often attributed to divine or magical intervention in the ancient world.
🏛 In ancient religions, such as those of the Greco-Roman period, there was a hierarchy of gods with varying degrees of power and influence, from all-powerful deities to those associated with specific aspects of life.
🌳 The script mentions stories of gods interacting with humans, such as Jupiter and Mercury in disguise, testing human hospitality, and the parallel story in the Hebrew Bible about Sodom and Gomorrah.
🧝 The theme of divine-human interbreeding, resulting in demigods or heroes like Hercules, is prevalent in Greco-Roman mythology and is also found in Jewish mythology, as discussed in the Book of Enoch.
👑 The deification of mortals, such as Julius Caesar and Augustus, became an institutional practice in the Roman Empire, where emperors were declared gods after their death.
📚 The script contrasts the skeptical views of philosophers like Seneca, who mocked the deification of emperors like Claudius, with the beliefs of those who considered certain philosophers, like Pythagoras, to be divine or semi-divine figures.
🌟 The concept of 'theios anēr', or divine men, is exemplified by figures like Apollonius of Tyana, who was said to perform miracles and was later venerated, drawing comparisons to Jesus Christ in terms of their shared attributes and narratives.

Q & A

How did ancient people perceive the boundary between the divine and human realms?
-Ancient people perceived the boundary between the divine and human realms as less stark than it is today, with a belief in divine men and women who could interact with gods and even ascend to godhood.
What impact did the development of scientific theories have on the conceptual divide between the divine and natural causation?
-The development of scientific theories led to a more pronounced divide between the divine and natural causation, as people began to understand and predict natural phenomena through science, reserving the concept of the supernatural for events that seemed to defy natural explanation.
How did the ancient Greco-Roman world view the gods in comparison to the modern understanding?
-In the ancient Greco-Roman world, there was a hierarchy of gods with varying degrees of power, from all-powerful to very limited, in contrast to the modern understanding of a singular, omnipotent God far beyond human comprehension.
What role did the gods play in the ancient world regarding natural phenomena and human life events?
-In the ancient world, gods were believed to directly influence natural phenomena and human life events, such as luck, death, and growth, due to the limited understanding of physical causation.
How did the concept of divine causation directly influence ancient religious practices and rituals?
-Ancient religious practices and rituals were centered around the idea of divine causation, where people would seek to propitiate the gods to prevent misfortune or to gain favor, often through the guidance of specialized practitioners.
What is the significance of the story of Jupiter and Mercury disguising themselves as humans in Greco-Roman mythology?
-The story of Jupiter and Mercury disguising themselves as humans highlights the belief in gods interacting with humans and testing their hospitality, which mirrors similar stories in other mythologies, such as the story of Sodom and Gomorrah in the Hebrew Bible.
How did the concept of divine heritage influence historical figures like Julius Caesar and Alexander the Great?
-The concept of divine heritage was used to legitimize the power and authority of historical figures like Julius Caesar and Alexander the Great, who were believed or claimed to have divine ancestry, enhancing their image as semi-divine conquerors.
What was the process of deification of mortals in the Roman Empire, and how was it institutionalized?
-The deification of mortals in the Roman Empire involved the Roman Senate formally declaring a deceased emperor a god, often based on signs or the belief that they had ascended to heaven. This practice became institutionalized as a perk of being a Roman Emperor.
How did the idea of divine men or wonder workers like Pythagoras and Apollonius of Tyana compare to the concept of Jesus Christ in early Christianity?
-The idea of divine men or wonder workers like Pythagoras and Apollonius of Tyana shares similarities with the concept of Jesus Christ in early Christianity, as they were seen as individuals with supernatural powers and divine inspiration, performing miracles and healings, which led to debates and comparisons about their divinity and the nature of their teachings.
What role did the Septuagint, the Greek translation of the Hebrew Bible, play in shaping the narratives of Jesus' life in the Gospels?
-The Septuagint played a significant role in shaping the narratives of Jesus' life in the Gospels, as authors like Mark, Matthew, and Luke used it to fill in details about Jesus' life when traditions or memories were lacking, often interpreting the scriptures typologically to create a narrative that showed Jesus as the fulfillment of prophecies.

Outlines

00:00

Divine Perceptions in Antiquity

This section explores how ancient people perceived the divine, including the interactions between gods and humans and the fluid boundaries between the divine and human realms. It contrasts this with the stark divide seen today due to monotheism and modern scientific understanding.

05:02

Natural and Supernatural Causation

Here, the text discusses the difference between natural and supernatural causes, highlighting modern scientific explanations for natural phenomena. It compares these to ancient views where events like lightning and disease were seen as directly caused by the gods.

10:03

The Hierarchy of Gods

This paragraph describes the vast hierarchy of gods in Greco-Roman religion, from supreme gods like Jupiter to minor household deities. It also touches on philosophical views that reformed religious narratives, portraying gods as ethical models.

15:03

Mythical Interactions with Mortals

Focusing on myths of gods interacting with humans, this section recounts tales of divine-human interbreeding, resulting in demi-gods like Hercules. It also compares Greco-Roman myths with similar stories in Jewish texts, like those in Genesis.

20:04

Divine Men and Deification

The text discusses how mortals like Julius Caesar were deified, highlighting both the sincere belief in their divinity and the more cynical views, such as those expressed by philosopher Seneca. It contrasts the elevation of emperors with the skepticism of some philosophers.

25:05

Philosophers as Divine Men

This paragraph explores how ancient philosophers like Pythagoras and Empedocles were considered divine men, capable of performing miracles and possessing supernatural powers. It includes legends about their abilities and their revered status.

30:06

Comparing Apollonius and Jesus

Here, the text examines the life of Apollonius of Tyana, a neo-Pythagorean philosopher, and compares it to the life of Jesus, highlighting their similarities in performing miracles, gathering disciples, and facing opposition.

35:06

Divine Men in Context

The section argues that the concept of divine men like Jesus and Apollonius was not unusual in the ancient world. It emphasizes that early Christians' stories about Jesus fit well within the broader context of ancient beliefs about divine figures.

40:09

Understanding the Gospels

This paragraph discusses the nature of the Gospels, explaining that they are not historical biographies but theological texts. It highlights the differences between the various accounts of Jesus's life and how these were shaped by early Christian beliefs.

45:12

Mark's Apocalyptic Vision

The text explores the Gospel of Mark, written during the first Roman-Jewish War, emphasizing its apocalyptic themes. It discusses how Mark's narrative was influenced by the belief in an imminent end of the world and how it reinterpreted earlier Christian testimonies.

50:14

Constructing Jesus's Narrative

This section explains how the author of Mark used community traditions and scriptural references to construct a narrative about Jesus's life. It also touches on the Gospel's abrupt ending and its impact on later Gospel writers.

55:15

Matthew and Luke's Gospel Revisions

Here, the text discusses how the authors of Matthew and Luke expanded and revised the Gospel of Mark, adding new stories and interpretations. It highlights their use of the Hebrew Bible to create details for Jesus's life and their dissatisfaction with Mark's ending.

00:17

Symbolic Narratives in Matthew

The text examines how the author of Matthew used Hebrew scriptures to craft a narrative about Jesus's birth and early life. It discusses the symbolic and theological purposes of these stories, rather than their historical accuracy.

05:19

Luke's Use of Scripture

This paragraph focuses on the Gospel of Luke, highlighting how its author used Old Testament stories to create new narratives about Jesus. It includes the story of the Widow of Nain and its similarities to the story of Elijah in Kings.

10:22

Interpreting the Gospels

The text argues that modern readers often misunderstand the Gospels, viewing them as historical accounts rather than theological narratives. It emphasizes that the Gospels were shaped by early Christian experiences and scriptural interpretations.

15:23

The Historical Jesus

This section discusses the academic study of the historical Jesus, separating it from the theological understanding of Christ. It argues that the historical details are less important for faith than the theological and symbolic meanings.

20:23

Contextualizing Ancient Beliefs

The text concludes by placing the Gospels within the broader context of ancient beliefs about divine men and supernatural events. It emphasizes the importance of understanding these narratives within their historical and cultural framework.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Divine men

The term 'Divine men' refers to individuals in the ancient world who were believed to possess a special connection with the divine or gods. In the context of the video, it discusses how these figures were seen as intermediaries between the human and divine realms, with examples from Greek and Roman mythology. The concept is integral to understanding the ancient perspective on the fluid boundary between gods and humans, as opposed to the more rigid divide found in modern monotheistic religions.

💡Monotheism

Monotheism is the belief in a single, all-powerful God. The video contrasts the ancient world's perception of divine interaction with the more recent dominance of monotheistic religions, which have shaped the modern Western understanding of a stark divide between the divine and human. Monotheism is significant in the discussion as it represents a shift from the polytheistic and animistic beliefs where gods were more intimately connected with human life and natural phenomena.

💡Post-theism

Post-theism refers to a philosophical or cultural context where traditional religious beliefs, particularly theism, have lost their dominance or relevance. The script mentions post-theism to describe the current Western intellectual climate, which has largely moved away from theistic explanations for the universe and life. This concept is important for understanding the modern disconnect between scientific understanding and traditional religious narratives.

💡Natural causation

Natural causation is the concept that natural phenomena occur through natural processes and laws, as opposed to supernatural or divine intervention. The video discusses the ancient world's limited understanding of natural causation, leading them to attribute events like lightning, disease, and death to the actions of gods. In contrast, the modern world has developed robust scientific theories that explain these phenomena, reducing the role of the divine in everyday life.

💡Supernatural

Supernatural refers to phenomena or powers that are believed to exceed the natural laws of the universe and are often attributed to divine or magical forces. In the video, the concept of supernatural is used to describe abilities or events that cannot be explained by natural causation, such as telekinesis or levitation. The script contrasts the modern skepticism of supernatural phenomena with the ancient world's acceptance of such events as part of their religious beliefs.

💡Pagan

Pagan, in the context of the video, refers to the religious practices of polytheistic, pre-Christian cultures, particularly those of the Greco-Roman world. The script discusses paganism as a belief system where a multitude of gods and goddesses governed various aspects of life, and where divine-human interactions were more common and less distinct than in later religious traditions.

💡Deification

Deification is the process of raising a person to divine status or attributing divine qualities to a mortal. The video mentions deification in the context of ancient leaders like Julius Caesar and philosophers like Pythagoras, who were revered as having divine qualities or were posthumously declared gods. This concept is key to understanding the fluid boundary between human and divine in ancient cultures.

💡Philosophers

In the script, philosophers refer to the thinkers and scholars of the ancient world who engaged in the study of natural causation and the nature of the divine. They are contrasted with the religious practices of their time, with some philosophers offering more rational or speculative explanations for phenomena. The term is important for understanding the diversity of thought and the development of early scientific inquiry in the ancient world.

💡Hagiographies

Hagiographies are biographies that idealize or present the subject, often a religious figure, in an admiring and sometimes supernatural light. The video mentions hagiographies in the context of later followers of Pythagoras, who wrote about his life in a way that attributed divine and miraculous qualities to him. This term is important for understanding how historical figures could be mythologized and revered as divine in ancient cultures.

💡Interbreeding

Interbreeding, as discussed in the video, refers to the ancient mythological narratives where gods and humans were said to have mated, producing offspring that were part divine and part human, such as demigods. The script uses interbreeding as an example of the close relationship between the divine and human realms in ancient mythology, which contrasts with the more distinct separation in modern religious views.

💡Risen Christ

The term 'Risen Christ' refers to the Christian belief in the Resurrection of Jesus Christ, the central event of the Christian faith. The script discusses the Risen Christ in the context of early Christian experiences and testimonies, which were based on visions and spiritual encounters rather than historical events. This concept is crucial for understanding the development of Christian theology and the distinction between historical and spiritual perspectives on Jesus.

Highlights

Discussion on the concept of divine men and women in antiquity and their interaction with the divine.

Exploration of how ancient people perceived the divine and the blurred lines between the divine and human realms.

Analysis of the evolution of the conceptual divide between the divine and humanity due to monotheism and post-theism in Western ideas.

Insight into the ancient perspective on natural causation and the attribution of phenomena like weather and luck to divine intervention.

Comparison of ancient and modern understandings of natural causation and the concept of supernatural causes in contemporary thought.

Examination of the role of gods in ancient religions, including the hierarchy from all-powerful to very limited gods, and their influence on daily life.

Discussion on the ancient belief in gods interacting with humans, with stories of Jupiter and Mercury disguising as humans to test hospitality.

Parallels drawn between Greco-Roman and Hebrew myths regarding divine beings testing human hospitality and morality.

Exploration of the theme of gods interbreeding with humans, resulting in demi-god figures like Hercules in Greco-Roman mythology.

Analysis of the Greco-Roman and Jewish mythology's shared narratives of divine-human interbreeding and the resulting heroic figures.

Investigation of the idea of deification of mortals, such as Julius Caesar and Augustus, and its institutionalization in Roman Emperors.

Critique of the deification of Emperors by philosophers like Seneca, who satirized the concept as 'pumpkinification'.

Overview of the concept of 'Theos on air' or divine men, like Pythagoras, who were considered to possess supernatural powers and wisdom.

Comparison of Apollonius of Tiana with Jesus, highlighting their similar narratives and the ancient context of divine men performing miracles.

Critique of the historical Jesus narrative, suggesting that gospel accounts are more theological than historical, drawing from the Septuagint.

Discussion on the development of the gospel narratives, showing how they were constructed using existing traditions and scriptures.

Analysis of the author of Mark's unique apocalyptic perspective and its influence on the formation of the gospel narrative.

Explanation of how later gospels like Matthew and Luke corrected and expanded upon Mark's narrative to fit their communities' theological views.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Religion in Ancient Mesopotamia

David Butler & Mike Day | The Ancient Temple and Lehi's Tree of Life Vision

Confucianism vs Buddhism vs Taoism - Realpolitik of the Three Teachings of Ancient China

Carlo Rovelli presents Anaximander and the Nature of Science

Chapter 3: A Little History of the World by E.H. Gombrich classroom reading

The Philosophy of Spinoza & Leibniz - Bryan Magee & Anthony Quinton (1987)

Related Tags

Divine Men Antiquity Culture Religious Beliefs Mythology Greco-Roman Monotheism Post-Theism Natural Causation Supernatural Phenomena Ancient Philosophy