What is a "Developed" Country? Crash Course Geography #40

CrashCourse
31 Jan 202212:28
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis script from Crash Course Geography explores the complexities of development, particularly focusing on the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. It challenges traditional economic metrics, highlighting the historical impact of colonialism on perceptions of development. The video discusses the uneven distribution of wealth and power, the evolution of terms like 'developed' and 'developing', and the need for a more nuanced understanding that goes beyond GDP. It emphasizes the importance of considering various forms of development, including human-centered and environmental metrics, and the role of international relations and investment in shaping economic growth.

Takeaways
  • πŸ“ˆ The Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region sits on significant oil reserves, with at least 113.2 billion metric tons, influencing its economic and political power.
  • 🌍 Historically, the MENA region was home to powerful empires and influential schools of thought, indicating its significance long before the oil era.
  • 🧐 The concept of 'development' is not fixed and is subject to change based on perceptions and opinions at a particular time.
  • πŸ“š The term 'development' has roots in European colonialism, often used to justify the exploitation of resources from 'backward' colonies.
  • 🏭 Initially, 'developed' countries were those with living standards and wealth resembling those in Europe and North America, usually with a history of industrialization and colonialism.
  • 🌎 The 1st, 2nd, and 3rd worldεˆ†η±» was tied to political leanings during the Cold War and economic models, but these terms have become outdated in the post-Cold War era.
  • 🀝 There is a pushback against tying development to Western economic and political models, with an emphasis on more nuanced understandings of development.
  • πŸ’° Economic metrics, such as GDP, are still used to measure a country's economic development, but they don't capture the full picture of wealth distribution and quality of life.
  • 🌱 The Human Development Index (HDI) and the Gender Inequality Index are examples of alternative metrics that focus more on human-centered measures of development.
  • 🌿 There's a growing interest in redefining development to include environmental and socioeconomic sustainability, as well as happiness, as measures of a country's success.
  • 🌍 The global community is recognizing the need to rethink development in the context of climate change and historical injustices, with a focus on putting people first.
Q & A

  • What is the significance of the term 'black gold mine' in the context of the Middle East and North Africa region?

    -The term 'black gold mine' refers to the vast reserves of oil beneath the Middle East and North Africa region, which is estimated to be at least 113.2 billion metric tons. This resource has played a significant role in the region's wealth and global power dynamics.

  • How has the distribution of wealth and power in the Middle East and North Africa region changed over time?

    -The Middle East and North Africa region, or MENA, was once home to powerful empires and influential schools of thought. However, not every country in the region is considered powerful today. The discovery and exploitation of oil resources have significantly impacted the economic development and political power of the region.

  • What is the historical context behind the term 'development' as it is used to describe countries?

    -The term 'development' started being used in the mid-20th century and has ties to European colonialism. It was initially used in economic terms to describe countries with standards of living and material wealth similar to those in Europe and North America. The term has evolved over time, but it still carries implications of economic and political similarity to the West.

  • How did European colonizers use language to justify their actions?

    -European colonizers often described their colonies as 'backward' compared to their 'modern' or 'advanced' home countries. This language was used to justify taking resources from their colonies and maintained a narrative of superiority over the colonized peoples.

  • What are some limitations of using GDP as a measure of a country's economic development?

    -GDP measures the monetary value of an economy's final goods and services, but it does not capture the quality of life, social and physical health, or distribution of wealth within a country. It can also be influenced by factors such as natural resources, which may not reflect the overall economic health or stability of a nation.

  • How does the Human Development Index (HDI) differ from GDP as a measure of development?

    -The HDI, calculated by the United Nations, is a compound index that considers variables like access to safe water, birth rate, death rate, education, and healthcare. It aims to provide a more holistic view of a country's level of development by focusing on human-centered measures rather than just economic output.

  • What is the Gender Inequality Index, and what does it measure?

    -The Gender Inequality Index is a measure that looks at income disparity between men and women. It provides insight into the equality and fairness in access to resources and opportunities within a country, highlighting issues related to gender equity.

  • How is the concept of development being rethought in the context of the Middle East and North Africa region?

    -Development organizations are exploring new ways to encourage economic growth in the Middle East and North Africa, focusing on managing the region as an economic whole rather than individual states. There's also a shift towards considering alternative investment strategies, like direct infrastructure investment in return for land for factories, to reduce reliance on loans.

  • What is the importance of redefining development in a way that goes beyond economic metrics?

    -Redefining development beyond economic metrics allows for a more inclusive and diverse understanding of what constitutes progress and well-being. It can help address issues of inequality, environmental sustainability, and social justice, ensuring that development policies and practices are more equitable and people-centered.

  • How does the story we tell about development impact global economic practices and relationships?

    -The stories we tell about development shape global perceptions, economic interactions, and policies. They determine which countries are seen as successful or in need of assistance, and they influence how wealth and resources are distributed and managed on a global scale.

  • What are some alternative metrics for measuring a country's success beyond GDP and HDI?

    -Alternative metrics include the Gender Inequality Index, which measures income disparity, and the Gross National Happiness index, which surveys people on their overall quality of life. These metrics aim to capture a broader range of factors that contribute to a country's well-being and development.

Outlines
00:00
🌍 Geopolitical Power and Development in the MENA Region

This paragraph discusses the significant oil reserves in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region and its historical influence on power and wealth distribution. It highlights the region's past as a home to powerful empires and influential schools of thought. The script also addresses the concept of development, noting its ties to European colonialism and the evolving perception of what it means for a country to be 'developed.' The narrative critiques the traditional economic metrics used to measure development, emphasizing the need for a more nuanced understanding that considers historical, cultural, and political factors.

05:01
πŸ“ˆ Economic Challenges and Resource Distribution

The second paragraph delves into the economic challenges faced by countries like Lebanon, despite its natural resources. It explores the complexities of economic production and the limitations of using GDP as a sole measure of a country's wealth. The script discusses the historical context of economic development, including the impact of colonialism and the extraction of resources. It also touches on the global economic policies and the debt traps that low-income countries often fall into. The paragraph suggests the need for a more inclusive and sustainable approach to development that goes beyond economic growth and considers social, political, and environmental factors.

10:02
🌐 Rethinking Development and Investment in the 21st Century

The final paragraph focuses on the need to rethink the concept of development, especially in the context of the Middle East and North Africa region with its large young population. It discusses international efforts to manage the region as a whole and new investment strategies that bypass traditional loans. The script emphasizes the importance of putting people first in development narratives and the need to redefine what it means for a country to be developed. It calls for a more holistic approach that considers the well-being of people, the sustainability of resources, and the impact of colonial legacies. The paragraph concludes by highlighting the role of development in shaping global interactions and the stories we tell about ourselves and others.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘MENA Region
The MENA Region refers to the Middle East and North Africa, highlighted for sitting on vast oil reserves, hence the reference to a 'black gold mine.' This region's geography is significant because it directly impacts the distribution of wealth, due to the uneven spread of oil beneath the Earth's surface. The historical context provided emphasizes the region's importance beyond its oil wealth, mentioning its past as a hub for powerful empires and influential schools of thought.
πŸ’‘Development
Development within the context of the video is a multifaceted concept, traditionally associated with economic growth, standards of living, and material wealth primarily based on Western models. The narrative critically examines how 'development' has been used historically, pointing to its colonial roots and how it has evolved to include or exclude nations from the category of being 'developed.' The term is debated for its implications on global inequality and the push for a redefinition that goes beyond economic metrics.
πŸ’‘Economic Development
Economic development is discussed as one way to measure a country's progress, typically through indicators like GDP. The video contrasts the UAE's wealth, significantly boosted by oil revenues and foreign investments, with Lebanon's challenges despite its resources. This comparison underlines that merely having natural resources does not guarantee wealth or 'development,' highlighting the complex factors that contribute to economic outcomes.
πŸ’‘Colonialism
Colonialism is a critical concept in the video, explored through its lasting impact on language, culture, and economic conditions in colonized countries. The script discusses how European powers justified their exploitation and resource extraction by labeling colonized societies as 'backward.' This historical context is crucial for understanding contemporary discussions around 'development' and the global distribution of wealth and power.
πŸ’‘Underdeveloped/Developing
The terms 'underdeveloped' and 'developing' are scrutinized for their implications and origins in the script. Initially used to describe countries that did not match the Western standards of 'development,' these terms reflect a historical bias and contribute to a narrative of superiority and inferiority. The transition from 'underdeveloped' to 'developing' is noted, alongside the critique of these labels for perpetuating stereotypes and inequalities.
πŸ’‘GDP
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is mentioned as a traditional economic metric used to gauge the economic development of a country, representing the total value of goods and services produced. The UAE's ranking among the top countries by GDP is used as an example of its economic strength, facilitated by oil wealth. However, the script also questions GDP's adequacy in measuring the well-being and quality of life of a country's population.
πŸ’‘Post-colonialism
Post-colonialism is discussed as a critical response to colonial narratives and practices, emphasizing the rights and voices of formerly colonized peoples. The framework seeks to challenge and redefine concepts of 'development' by advocating for a broader understanding that includes economic, social, and environmental dimensions. This approach encourages a departure from Eurocentric models of development and acknowledges diverse paths to prosperity.
πŸ’‘Human Development Index (HDI)
The Human Development Index (HDI) is introduced as an alternative to GDP for assessing a country's level of development. It incorporates measures of education, life expectancy, and income to offer a broader view of human well-being. The UAE's high HDI score, due to factors like access to education and electricity, exemplifies how this index provides a more comprehensive assessment of development beyond economic output.
πŸ’‘Gender Inequality Index
The Gender Inequality Index is mentioned as a tool to evaluate disparities between men and women within countries, particularly in terms of income, education, and health care. The video uses the UAE as an example, noting that despite equal access to some resources, significant income gaps exist between genders. This highlights the importance of considering gender as a critical factor in discussions of development and equality.
πŸ’‘Environmental and Socioeconomic Sustainability
Environmental and socioeconomic sustainability are discussed in relation to development, emphasizing the need for practices that are both ecologically viable and equitable. The script advocates for rethinking development in terms of sustainability to address the climate crisis and reduce inequalities. It suggests a shift from traditional, consumption-driven models of development to ones that prioritize long-term health of the planet and its inhabitants.
Highlights

The Middle East and North Africa region, known as MENA, sits on a vast oil reserve of at least 113.2 billion metric tons.

The distribution of oil wealth in the MENA region is uneven, reflecting broader patterns of wealth and power distribution globally.

Historically, the MENA region was home to powerful empires and influential schools of thought, indicating its significance beyond its oil wealth.

The concept of 'development' is not fixed and is subject to change based on perceptions and opinions over time.

The term 'development' has ties to European colonialism, with colonizers often describing their colonies as 'backward' compared to their 'modern' or 'advanced' home countries.

Until the 1970s, 'development' was largely understood in economic terms, with 'developed' countries mirroring the living standards and wealth of Europe and North America.

The shift from 'underdeveloped' to 'developing' and the association with the Third World reflects the evolving political and economic narratives.

The terms '1st', '2nd', and '3rd world' were political descriptors during the Cold War but have become outdated in the post-Cold War era.

Colonized peoples and scholars have challenged the narrative of development tied to Western economic and political models.

Economic metrics are still used to measure a country's development, with countries like the United Arab Emirates (UAE) boasting strong economies due to oil resources.

Lebanon, despite its resources, has struggled with political and economic setbacks, illustrating that natural resources do not guarantee wealth or development.

The Human Development Index (HDI) introduced by the United Nations considers variables like education, healthcare, and access to safe water, providing a more holistic view of development.

The Gender Inequality Index highlights disparities in income and opportunities between men and women, showing that development metrics often overlook gender aspects.

Alternative metrics like the Gross National Happiness measure intangible aspects of development, focusing on overall quality of life.

Development discourse is evolving, with a growing emphasis on sustainable and equitable economic growth, especially in regions like the Middle East and North Africa with large young populations.

The concept of development needs to be rethought in the context of climate change and the legacy of colonialism, with a focus on people-centric practices.

The way we define and talk about development shapes global economic practices, wealth distribution, and the narratives of global interaction.

Crash Course Geography emphasizes the importance of recognizing and respecting the history and contributions of Indigenous and Aboriginal peoples in understanding the geography of a place.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Groundwater & the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: Crash Course Geography #25

MIT Study Reveals Why Africa Is Still Poor

Capitalism, Communism, & Political Economies: Crash Course Geography #38

Development | What is Development | Development Studies

Capitalism and Socialism Crash Course World History #33

Where and Why Do People Move? Crash Course Geography #32

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
MENA RegionOil WealthColonial LegacyEconomic DevelopmentResource DistributionGlobal North-SouthPost-ColonialismGender InequalitySustainabilityHuman Development Index