3 LITERATURE BASED HISTORIES! || Homeschool History Curriculum Comparison
TLDRIn this homeschooling video, Megan reviews three literature-based history curriculums: Biblio Plan, Story of the World, and My Father's World. She discusses the unique features of each, including their depth, scope, and the age range they cover. Megan highlights the customizable nature of Biblio Plan, which can be used from kindergarten through 12th grade, and compares it with the more resource-intensive My Father's World and the neutral, story-driven approach of Story of the World. Her insights aim to help viewers choose the best fit for their families, considering ease of use, cost, and educational depth.
Takeaways
- 📚 Megan introduces three literature-based history curriculums used in homeschooling: Biblio Plan, Story of the World, and My Father's World.
- 🔄 The curriculums follow a four-year history cycle, covering different historical periods each year, with the option to delve deeper into topics.
- 📖 Story of the World is presented in a story form, offering a broad overview of history with the possibility of additional depth through activity books and supplementary materials.
- 🌏 My Father's World provides a more in-depth study, including multiple texts and resources, and covers a wider range of subjects beyond history, suitable for 4th to 8th grade with extensions for younger students.
- 🏠 Biblio Plan is designed to be used by the whole family, from kindergarten through 12th grade, offering customization and adaptability to various family needs.
- 📝 Each curriculum has a teacher or family guide that outlines daily lessons, readings, and activities, with Biblio Plan and My Father's World providing more detailed instructions.
- 📚 Biblio Plan stands out for its affordability and the ability to add components as children grow and their needs change, unlike the more expensive My Father's World.
- 🎨 Both Biblio Plan and My Father's World offer additional resources like coloring books, student pages, and hands-on activities to enhance learning.
- 📘 My Father's World places significant emphasis on American history, including state facts and capitals, alongside the broader world history narrative.
- 📖 Biblio Plan's text is reader-friendly, resembling a textbook but with engaging content, pictures, and vocabulary explanations to aid understanding.
- 💬 Megan shares her personal preference for Biblio Plan due to its comprehensive nature, cost-effectiveness, and suitability for family discussions and learning.
Q & A
What are the three literature-based history curriculums discussed in the video?
-The three literature-based history curriculums discussed are Biblio Plan, Story of the World, and My Father's World.
What is the main difference between Story of the World and the other two curriculums?
-Story of the World is written in a story form and does not go into a lot of depth, unlike Biblio Plan and My Father's World, which offer greater depth and cover more subject areas.
How is the Story of the World curriculum structured?
-Story of the World is structured on a four-year history cycle, covering ancient, medieval, early modern, and modern history, with the option to go into more depth using the activity guide and additional resources.
What additional components does My Father's World include besides the main teacher guide?
-My Father's World includes additional components such as the American History Encyclopedia, Story of the World, read-alouds, and suggestions for science curriculum.
What is unique about the Biblio Plan curriculum compared to the others?
-Biblio Plan is unique because it is designed to be used from kindergarten through 12th grade, offering customization options and a family guide that can be adapted to various family needs.
Why did the speaker switch from My Father's World to Biblio Plan?
-The speaker switched to Biblio Plan because it offers a more affordable and customizable option that can be used across a wider age range, making it easier for a large family to study history together.
What are some of the additional resources that can be used with Biblio Plan?
-Additional resources that can be used with Biblio Plan include a coloring book, student pages, timelines, maps, projects, literature readings, movie suggestions, and online videos.
How does the speaker describe the reading experience of the Biblio Plan text?
-The speaker describes the Biblio Plan text as readable and not like a typical textbook, with great references, explanations of vocabulary, and pictures that accompany the reading material.
What is the recommended age range for My Father's World's family cycle curriculum?
-The recommended age range for My Father's World's family cycle curriculum is third through eighth grade, with extensions available for younger siblings.
How does the speaker suggest using Story of the World in conjunction with Biblio Plan?
-The speaker suggests using Story of the World as a supplementary resource, pulling out specific chapters that go into depth on topics that may be of interest or that the children may not be ready for yet.
What is the perspective of the history presented in the Story of the World compared to Biblio Plan and My Father's World?
-Story of the World is considered neutral, not specifically Christian-based, and has a more young Earth perspective. In contrast, Biblio Plan and My Father's World are more from a Christian standpoint, with a focus on church history.
Outlines
📚 Introduction to Literature-Based History Curriculums
In this introductory paragraph, Megan welcomes viewers to her channel and sets the stage for a discussion on literature-based history curriculums used in homeschooling. She mentions that she has experience with three different curriculums: Biblio Plan, Story of the World, and My Father's World. Megan explains that these curriculums are all literature-based and have been frequently compared by her audience. She provides a brief overview of her homeschooling journey, starting with My Father's World and incorporating Story of the World in between family cycles. The paragraph ends with a teaser for a detailed comparison of these curriculums.
🌏 Exploring Story of the World and My Father's World
Megan delves into the specifics of Story of the World and My Father's World. She describes Story of the World as a four-year history cycle that covers ancient, medieval, early modern, and modern history. The curriculum is presented in a story form, allowing for optional depth through the purchase of activity books. Megan also mentions the use of cross-reference materials and review questions for a deeper understanding. Moving on to My Father's World, she notes that it is designed for third through eighth grade but can be adapted for younger students. This curriculum is more in-depth and includes a teacher guide, multiple texts, and read-alouds. It also covers a wide range of subjects, with only independent reading, language arts, and math needing to be supplemented.
📘 Overview of Biblio Plan and Its Customization Options
In this paragraph, Megan introduces Biblio Plan, another four-year history cycle curriculum that can be used from kindergarten through 12th grade. She highlights the flexibility of Biblio Plan, which allows for customization based on family needs. The core of the program is the family guide, which can be used with a text for younger students or with additional resources like a coloring book, student pages, timelines, and project guides. Megan also discusses the inclusion of Bible reading plans and memory work for classical homeschooling families. She emphasizes the program's affordability and the ability to add components as children progress through the grades.
🏡 Personal Reasons for Choosing Biblio Plan
Megan shares her personal reasons for choosing Biblio Plan over My Father's World and Story of the World. She appreciates the ease of use and affordability of Biblio Plan, especially when compared to the cost of My Father's World. She also values the ability to do history together as a family, which is facilitated by Biblio Plan's K-12 scope. Megan mentions that her family doesn't start formal history until second grade, which is a personal decision. She also discusses the religious perspectives of the curriculums, noting that Biblio Plan and My Father's World are more Christian-focused, while Story of the World is more neutral.
📣 Conclusion and Invitation for Further Questions
In the concluding paragraph, Megan invites viewers to subscribe to her channel for more content on curriculum selections and homeschooling. She expresses hope that the video has been helpful in answering questions about the three curriculums discussed. Megan encourages viewers to leave comments with any further questions they might have, ensuring that she is responsive to her audience's needs.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Homeschool Curriculum
💡Literature-Based History
💡Biblio Plan
💡Story of the World
💡My Father's World
💡Family Cycle
💡Activity Book
💡Read-Alouds
💡Customizable Curriculum
💡Christian Perspective
Highlights
Introduction to Megan's channel and today's topic: comparing three literature-based history curriculums.
Megan's homeschooling journey started with My Father's World curriculum.
Story of the World is a four-year history cycle curriculum, covering ancient to modern times.
Story of the World is written in story form, allowing for optional deeper exploration with activity books.
My Father's World curriculum is used alongside Story of the World, covering kindergarten through eighth grade.
My Father's World includes a teacher guide, multiple texts, and read-alouds for a comprehensive approach.
Biblio Plan is also a four-year history cycle curriculum, suitable for K-12.
Biblio Plan offers a family guide and customizable components like coloring books and student pages.
Biblio Plan's literature readings are age-appropriate and include family read-aloud suggestions.
Megan's decision to switch to Biblio Plan was influenced by its affordability and ease of use for a large family.
My Father's World is more expensive and requires more resources, which can be overwhelming for some families.
Biblio Plan can be customized to fit the needs of different family members at various stages of education.
Story of the World is considered neutral in its approach, with some biblical references in ancient times.
My Father's World and Biblio Plan have a Christian standpoint, especially in their medieval history sections.
Megan uses Story of the World for specific chapters that provide depth on topics her children may not be ready for.
Final thoughts on the importance of choosing the right curriculum based on family needs and preferences.
Transcripts
Browse More Related Video
STORY OF THE WORLD VS HISTORY QUEST | Compare Secular History Curriculum | Homeschool History
Homeschool History Curriculum Comparison | Sonlight, Story of the World, Abeka, Mystery of History
STORY OF THE WORLD vs SIMPLY CHARLOTTE MASON Homeschool History Curriculum
Homeschool History Curriculum | My Favorite History Curriculum for Elementary Middle and High School
REVIEW OF STORY OF THE WORLD HISTORY WHAT CHRISTIANS NEED TO KNOW ABOUT IT
HOW I USE THE STORY OF THE WORLD IN OUR HOMESCHOOL || HOMESCHOOL HISTORY CURRICULUM
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Thanks for rating: