STORY OF THE WORLD vs SIMPLY CHARLOTTE MASON Homeschool History Curriculum

This Homeschool House
20 Jul 202109:07
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRChristine, a homeschooling mom and second-generation homeschooler from New Zealand, presents a comparison between two history programs: 'Story of the World' and 'Simply Charlotte Mason.' She shares her unique perspective as a former student and current teacher of these programs. 'Story of the World' is a secular, classical history curriculum with activity books and a teacher's guide, while 'Simply Charlotte Mason' is a Bible history and geography curriculum inspired by Charlotte Mason's methods, focusing on living books and narration. Christine highlights the differences in approach and content, offering insights for parents considering these curriculums for homeschooling.

Takeaways
  • 😀 Christine is a homeschooling mom of three children and a second-generation homeschooler.
  • 📚 She is comparing two history programs: Simply Charlotte Mason History Program and Story of the World.
  • 🌏 Christine lives in New Zealand and invites viewers to subscribe to her channel for more homeschool content.
  • 📚 Story of the World is a history curriculum that includes an activity book and a teacher's guide, starting from ancient times.
  • 🏛️ The Simply Charlotte Mason program focuses on Bible history and geography, with three components: Bible, geography, and history.
  • 📖 Simply Charlotte Mason is based on reading living books and narration, while Story of the World is more classical in approach.
  • 🏛️ Story of the World is secular and non-biased, whereas Simply Charlotte Mason is from a biblical worldview.
  • 🎓 Story of the World includes a read-aloud component, activity guide, and comprehension questions, with an optional audio version.
  • 🌍 Simply Charlotte Mason uses a teacher's manual that breaks down lessons into 180 parts, focusing on read-alouds and oral narration.
  • 🗺️ Geography in Simply Charlotte Mason involves mapping activities and references books like 'Our Material World' and 'Hungry Planet'.
  • 📚 Both curriculums are solid and Christine recommends them, having fond memories of using Story of the World as a child and currently using Simply Charlotte Mason with her kids.
Q & A

  • What is the main topic of the video?

    -The main topic of the video is a comparison between the Simply Charlotte Mason history program and the Story of the World history curriculum.

  • Who is the presenter of the video?

    -The presenter of the video is Christine, a homeschooling mom of three children and a second-generation homeschooler living in New Zealand.

  • What is Christine's unique perspective on the history programs discussed?

    -Christine's unique perspective is that she has used one of the history programs as a student when she was homeschooled and now uses it as a teacher with her own children.

  • What are the two components that come with the Story of the World curriculum?

    -The two components that come with the Story of the World curriculum are the activity book and the teacher's guide.

  • How does the Simply Charlotte Mason curriculum differ from the Story of the World in terms of content?

    -The Simply Charlotte Mason curriculum includes Bible history and geography, whereas the Story of the World is purely a history curriculum with a potential geography component but not intentional.

  • What is the educational approach of the Story of the World curriculum?

    -The Story of the World curriculum has a more classical approach and is secular, meaning it is non-biased and does not take a specific religious or philosophical stance.

  • How does the Simply Charlotte Mason curriculum incorporate a Charlotte Mason-inspired approach?

    -The Simply Charlotte Mason curriculum is based on reading living books to children, followed by narration and other activities that align with the Charlotte Mason educational philosophy.

  • What is the structure of the lessons in the Simply Charlotte Mason curriculum?

    -The lessons in the Simply Charlotte Mason curriculum are broken down into 180 lessons, with each lesson consisting of different activities such as Bible reading, geography mapping, and history read-alouds.

  • Which book does the Simply Charlotte Mason curriculum use for geography activities?

    -The Simply Charlotte Mason curriculum uses 'Visits to the Middle East' for geography activities, which includes mapping and learning about different families from the studied area.

  • What additional resources are recommended for those using the Story of the World curriculum?

    -For additional resources and examples of using the Story of the World curriculum, viewers are directed to follow Abby from Rooted in Rift on YouTube and to watch Christine's review video on her channel.

  • How does Christine describe the chapters in the Story of the Greeks book used in the Simply Charlotte Mason curriculum?

    -Christine describes the chapters in the Story of the Greeks book as very short and sweet, making them perfect for oral narration and easy for children to engage with.

Outlines
00:00
📚 Introduction to History Curriculum Comparison

Christine, a homeschooling mom from New Zealand, introduces her video comparing two popular history programs: 'Simply Charlotte Mason' and 'Story of the World'. She mentions her unique perspective as a second-generation homeschooler who has experienced both programs, one as a student and the other as a teacher. Christine invites viewers to subscribe for more homeschool content and promises a detailed comparison of the two curriculums, highlighting their differences in approach, content, and suitability for various educational styles.

05:00
🏛️ Exploring 'Story of the World' and 'Simply Charlotte Mason'

In this paragraph, Christine dives deeper into the specifics of each curriculum. 'Story of the World' is described as a classical history curriculum with a secular approach, offering a read-aloud component, activity book, and teacher's guide. It is noted for its non-biased nature and comprehensive coverage of historical events. On the other hand, 'Simply Charlotte Mason' is characterized as a Bible history and geography curriculum, inspired by Charlotte Mason's educational philosophy. It focuses on reading living books and oral narration, with a clear biblical worldview. Christine also discusses the structure of the lessons in 'Simply Charlotte Mason', which includes Bible, geography, and history components, and contrasts this with the activity-based approach of 'Story of the World'. She recommends resources for further exploration, such as Abby from Rooted in Wrist's YouTube channel and her own review video, and concludes by emphasizing the value of both curriculums in her personal homeschooling experience.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Homeschooling
Homeschooling refers to the educational practice where children are educated at home, typically by their parents or tutors, rather than attending a traditional school. In the video, the speaker, Christine, identifies herself as a homeschooling mom of three children, which is central to her channel's theme and the context of the video where she discusses educational programs.
💡Simply Charlotte Mason
Simply Charlotte Mason is a homeschooling curriculum inspired by the educational philosophy of Charlotte Mason. It emphasizes living books, narration, and a holistic approach to education. The video discusses a comparison between this curriculum and another history program, highlighting the unique perspective of the speaker who has used it both as a student and a teacher.
💡Story of the World
Story of the World is a history curriculum that presents historical events in a narrative style, suitable for young learners. The script mentions it as one of the two history programs Christine is comparing, noting its secular nature and the inclusion of an activity book and teacher's guide.
💡Biblical World View
A biblical world view is a perspective that interprets and understands the world through the teachings and principles of the Bible. The video explains that the Simply Charlotte Mason curriculum is influenced by this viewpoint, whereas Story of the World is secular and non-biased.
💡Read-Aloud
Read-aloud refers to the practice of reading text out loud to others, often used in educational settings to engage students and improve comprehension. In the context of the video, read-aloud is a key component of both the Simply Charlotte Mason and Story of the World curricula, with the former using it for Bible, geography, and history lessons.
💡Oral Narration
Oral narration is a method where students retell what they have read or heard in their own words, which helps reinforce learning and comprehension. The Simply Charlotte Mason curriculum, as described in the video, relies heavily on oral narration after read-aloud sessions.
💡Activity Book
An activity book is a type of educational material that includes interactive exercises, puzzles, and tasks to engage students in learning. The video mentions that Story of the World comes with an activity book, providing a more hands-on component to the curriculum.
💡Comprehension Questions
Comprehension questions are queries designed to test a student's understanding of the material they have read or studied. In the script, Christine mentions that the Story of the World includes comprehension questions in its activity guide to enhance learning.
💡Geography Component
A geography component in an educational curriculum involves the study of places and the relationships between people and their environments. The video notes that while Story of the World may have an implicit geography component, Simply Charlotte Mason intentionally integrates geography with mapping activities and references to specific books.
💡Living Books
Living books are works that are written in a narrative style, engaging the reader with vivid descriptions and storytelling, as opposed to more dry, textbook-like presentations. The Simply Charlotte Mason curriculum, as discussed in the video, is based on reading living books to children and encouraging them to narrate the stories back.
💡Curriculum Comparison
Curriculum comparison involves evaluating and contrasting different educational programs or materials to determine their suitability for a particular educational goal or context. The main theme of the video is a curriculum comparison between Simply Charlotte Mason and Story of the World, with Christine providing her insights based on personal experience.
Highlights

Christine introduces her channel and her role as a homeschooling mom of three in New Zealand.

She shares her surprise at the number of requests for a comparison video between two history programs.

Christine provides a personal connection to the 'Story of the World' program, having used it as a child.

She explains that 'Simply Charlotte Mason' is a Bible history and geography program, unlike 'Story of the World' which is purely history.

The 'Story of the World' curriculum includes a teacher's guide and activity book, with an optional audio version.

Christine mentions that 'Simply Charlotte Mason' is inspired by Charlotte Mason's educational philosophy, focusing on living books and narration.

She notes the secular nature of 'Story of the World' in contrast to the biblical worldview of 'Simply Charlotte Mason'.

Christine describes the structure of 'Story of the World', including its read-aloud portions and comprehension questions.

She recommends Abby from 'Rooted in Christ' for examples of using 'Story of the World' and provides a link to her channel.

The 'Simply Charlotte Mason' curriculum is broken down into 180 lessons with a variety of daily activities.

Christine explains the geography component of 'Simply Charlotte Mason', involving mapping activities and references to specific books.

She shares her experience with the 'Simply Charlotte Mason' curriculum, noting its effectiveness in her children's learning.

Christine contrasts the activity-based approach of 'Story of the World' with the reading and narration focus of 'Simply Charlotte Mason'.

She reflects on the lasting impact of 'Story of the World' from her own childhood and its effectiveness in sticking with students.

Christine concludes by recommending both curriculums and suggesting that they can be adapted to fit different homeschooling styles.

She invites viewers to leave questions in the comments and promises to respond.

Christine ends the video with a poetic reflection on love and kindness.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

HISTORY CURRICULUM REVIEW |AMERICA’S STORY 1 | MasterBooks | HOMESCHOOL CURRICULUM

A GENTLE FEAST Curriculum Review

Homeschool History Curriculum | My Favorite History Curriculum for Elementary Middle and High School

BEAUTIFUL FEET BOOKS FLIP THROUGH AND SAMPLE LESSON: Look inside AROUND THE WORLD IN PICTURE BOOKS

REVIEW OF STORY OF THE WORLD HISTORY WHAT CHRISTIANS NEED TO KNOW ABOUT IT

STORY OF THE WORLD VS HISTORY QUEST | Compare Secular History Curriculum | Homeschool History

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
HomeschoolingHistory ProgramsCurriculumCharlotte MasonStory of the WorldEducationParentingTeaching MethodsNew ZealandBiblical Worldview