Why is pi here? And why is it squared? A geometric answer to the Basel problem
TLDRThe video script delves into the Basel problem, an infinite series challenge that Euler famously solved, revealing the sum to be ฯยฒ/6. The script offers a novel proof using geometric intuition, starting with a lighthouses analogy to represent the series. It then employs the inverse square law and the lesser-known inverse Pythagorean theorem to transform single lighthouses into pairs without altering total brightness. The proof culminates in an infinite array of lighthouses, illustrating the connection between the series and geometry, ultimately leading to the pi-related result.
Takeaways
- ๐ The Basel Problem, posed 90 years before Euler solved it, involves the sum of the reciprocals of the squares of natural numbers, which surprisingly equals ฯยฒ/6.
- ๐ Pi's appearance in the Basel Problem might seem unusual, but it's indicative of a deeper connection to circles and geometry, as often ฯ signifies a relationship with circular properties.
- ๐ฐ The problem is visualized by imagining lighthouses on the positive number line, each emitting light with brightness inversely proportional to the square of their distance from the observer.
- ๐ The concept of 'apparent brightness' is tied to the idea of solid angles in spherical geometry, which helps explain the inverse square law for light and other spreading quantities.
- ๐ The video introduces a method to rearrange the lighthouses without changing the total brightness perceived, using the Inverse Pythagorean theorem to split one lighthouse into two.
- ๐ The Inverse Pythagorean theorem is used to show that the brightness from a single lighthouse is equal to the combined brightness from two strategically placed lighthouses, a key to solving the Basel Problem.
- ๐ The solution involves creating an infinite array of lighthouses around a circular lake, doubling the size of the circle and number of lighthouses at each step while maintaining equal brightness.
- ๐ By iteratively applying the inverse Pythagorean theorem, an infinite series of lighthouses is formed, evenly spaced and contributing to the sum of the Basel Problem.
- ๐ The sum of the reciprocals of the squares of odd numbers alone gives ฯยฒ/8, and adjusting for the missing even numbers leads to the solution of the Basel Problem.
- ๐จ The video script was created by Ben Hambricht, a new member of the '3Blue1Brown' team, highlighting the collaborative effort in educational content creation.
Q & A
What is the Basel problem and how is it related to the sum of inverse squares?
-The Basel problem is an unsolved challenge for 90 years that involves the sum of the reciprocals of the squares of natural numbers. It was eventually solved by Euler, who found that the sum approaches ฯยฒ/6. The problem is related to the sum of inverse squares because it specifically deals with the infinite series of the inverses of the squares of natural numbers.
Why is the Basel problem solution surprising?
-The solution to the Basel problem is surprising because it involves the constant ฯ squared, which is not typically associated with the sum of inverse squares. The appearance of ฯ in this context is unexpected and intriguing.
What is the significance of the inverse square law in the context of the Basel problem?
-The inverse square law is significant in the Basel problem because it describes how the intensity of light, sound, or other forms of energy decreases with the square of the distance from the source. This law is applied in the physical representation of the Basel problem, where the brightness received from an infinite line of lighthouses follows the same pattern as the sum in the Basel problem.
How does the concept of solid angle relate to the Basel problem?
-The concept of solid angle is used to describe the proportion of a sphere that a shape covers as viewed from a given point. In the context of the Basel problem, it helps in understanding how the apparent brightness of lighthouses changes with distance, which is crucial for the geometric interpretation of the problem.
What is the Inverse Pythagorean theorem and how does it relate to the Basel problem?
-The Inverse Pythagorean theorem is a mathematical relationship that states 1/aยฒ + 1/bยฒ = 1/hยฒ for certain geometric configurations. It is used in the Basel problem to transform a single lighthouse into two others without changing the total brightness perceived by an observer, which is a key step in the geometric proof of the problem.
How does the video script use geometric intuition to explain the Basel problem?
-The script uses geometric intuition by creating a physical representation of the problem with lighthouses and circles. It explains how the brightness perceived by an observer from an infinite line of lighthouses can be manipulated using geometric principles, leading to the solution of the Basel problem.
What is the role of the number line in the script's explanation of the Basel problem?
-The number line is used as a conceptual tool to represent the infinite series of the Basel problem. It is likened to a limit of ever-growing circles, and the sum across the number line is analogous to adding up along the boundary of an infinitely large circle.
How does the script connect the sum of the inverse squares to the geometry of circles?
-The script connects the sum of the inverse squares to the geometry of circles by using the concept of apparent brightness and the inverse square law. It shows that the sum of the reciprocals of the squares of odd integers can be represented as the brightness along an infinitely large circle, leading to the solution involving ฯ squared.
What is the final step in the script's explanation that leads to the solution of the Basel problem?
-The final step involves recognizing that the sum of the reciprocals of the squares of odd integers gives ฯยฒ/4, and then adjusting for the sum of the reciprocals of the squares of even integers. By scaling the series and multiplying by the appropriate factors, the script arrives at the solution for the Basel problem, ฯยฒ/6.
Who is credited with the solution to the Basel problem and what was Euler's contribution?
-Leonhard Euler is credited with the solution to the Basel problem. His contribution was finding that the sum of the reciprocals of the squares of natural numbers approaches ฯยฒ/6, a result that was surprising and significant in the field of mathematics.
How does the script use the concept of 'apparent brightness' to explain the Basel problem?
-The script uses the concept of 'apparent brightness' to describe the intensity of light received from an infinite line of lighthouses. This concept is key to understanding how the sum of the inverse squares can be represented geometrically and how it leads to the solution of the Basel problem.
Outlines
๐ The Basel Problem and Euler's Solution
The script introduces the Basel Problem, an infinite series of reciprocals of square numbers that Euler famously solved, showing it converges to ฯยฒ/6. The problem remained unsolved for 90 years until Euler's discovery. The script hints at a connection to circles and geometry, suggesting that ฯ's appearance is not coincidental. It sets the stage for a unique proof involving lighthouses and the concept of brightness as perceived by an observer, which will be used to represent the mathematical series.
๐ก The Concept of Apparent Brightness and Inverse Square Law
This paragraph delves into the concept of apparent brightness, using the analogy of lighthouses on a number line to represent the Basel Problem's series. It explains how the brightness perceived by an observer decreases with the square of the distance, following the inverse square law. The script introduces the idea of manipulating the arrangement of these 'lighthouses' without changing the total brightness, setting the stage for a geometric interpretation of the problem.
๐ The Inverse Pythagorean Theorem and Geometric Transformations
The script presents the Inverse Pythagorean Theorem, which allows transforming a single lighthouse into two without altering the total brightness perceived. It describes a geometric construction involving circles and tangents to demonstrate this theorem's application. The process involves creating larger circles and placing new lighthouses at specific points to maintain the same brightness, leading to an evenly spaced infinite array of lighthouses.
๐ Summing the Infinite Series and Relating It to ฯ
The final paragraph explains how the geometric arrangement of lighthouses leads to an infinite series that sums to ฯยฒ/4, focusing on odd integers. It then adjusts this result to account for even integers, showing how the original Basel Problem series can be derived. The script concludes by connecting the series to the geometry of circles, highlighting the surprising appearance of ฯ in the solution to a seemingly unrelated mathematical problem.
Mindmap
Keywords
๐กBasel Problem
๐กEuler
๐กInverse Square Law
๐กSolid Angle
๐กLighthouse
๐กGeometric Intuition
๐กInfinite Series
๐กInverse Pythagorean Theorem
๐กSpherical Geometry
๐กCircles and Geometry
๐กEven and Odd Numbers
Highlights
The Basel problem, which remained unsolved for 90 years, was finally solved by Euler, revealing an unexpected connection to pi squared divided by 6.
The proof involves a novel approach different from Euler's original, emphasizing the geometric intuition behind the problem.
The video suggests that pi's appearance in equations often implies a connection to circles, challenging the view that pi is only about circles.
The Basel problem is visualized using a line of lighthouses on a number line, each with decreasing brightness following the inverse square law.
The concept of 'apparent brightness' is introduced, relating to the solid angle covered by light in spherical geometry.
The inverse square law is explained as a key to understanding how light intensity decreases with the square of the distance.
A method to rearrange lighthouses without changing total brightness is proposed, using the Inverse Pythagorean theorem.
The video presents a creative geometric proof involving lighthouses on the circumference of circles, illustrating the distribution of brightness.
The transformation of a single lighthouse into two others using the Inverse Pythagorean theorem is demonstrated.
The process of doubling the size of circles and transforming lighthouses is shown to maintain constant brightness and even spacing.
An infinite series representing the sum of the inverse squares of odd integers is derived, leading to a connection with pi squared.
The video explains how to adjust the sum to include even integers, resulting in the solution to the Basel problem.
The final solution to the Basel problem is presented, showing how the sum of the reciprocals of all integers relates to pi squared divided by 6.
The video concludes by emphasizing the surprising and deep connection between the Basel problem and the geometry of circles.
The creative and visual approach to solving the Basel problem is credited to Ben Hambricht, a new member of the '3Blue1Brown' team.
Transcripts
Browse More Related Video
The Wallis product for pi, proved geometrically
Power series of ln(1+x_) | Series | AP Calculus BC | Khan Academy
Another derivation of the sum of an infinite geometric series | Precalculus | Khan Academy
Proof Of The Basel Problem
Euler's real identity NOT e to the i pi = -1
Series sum example | Sequences, series and induction | Precalculus | Khan Academy
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Thanks for rating: