Manstein - Field Marshal of the Wehrmacht Documentary

The People Profiles
23 Sept 202262:15
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRErich von Manstein, born into a Prussian military aristocracy in 1887, rose to prominence as a key figure in the German military during World War II. Known for his strategic contributions, including the invasion of France and the Crimean campaign, Manstein's career was marked by military successes and moral complexities. Post-war, he played a central role in creating the myth of the 'clean Wehrmacht,' attempting to absolve the German military of Nazi atrocities. Despite initial success, evidence of his complicity emerged, leading to his arrest, trial, and imprisonment. His legacy remains a subject of intense debate, questioning the extent of his responsibility for the crimes committed under Nazi rule.

Takeaways
  • πŸŽ–οΈ Erich von Manstein was a high-ranking German military officer with a significant influence on the strategies used during World War II.
  • πŸ‘Ά Born into an aristocratic and military family, von Manstein was destined for a career in the military from a young age.
  • 🌟 His experiences in World War I provided a foundation for his later strategic planning, despite the war ending in defeat for Germany.
  • πŸ›‘ The Treaty of Versailles had severe consequences for Germany, including limitations on military size and the prohibition of an air-force, but von Manstein remained in the reduced Reichswehr.
  • πŸ“ˆ The rise of the Nazi Party and Adolf Hitler's ascension to power in 1933 led to a rapid expansion of the German military, with von Manstein being promoted to key positions.
  • πŸ” Evidence suggests von Manstein's political beliefs aligned with Nazi ideology, particularly regarding the perceived threat of Bolsheviks and Jews to Germany.
  • βš”οΈ Von Manstein played a crucial role in the invasion of Poland, utilizing strategies that he would later employ in other campaigns.
  • πŸ‡«πŸ‡· His strategic advice was instrumental in the successful invasion of France in 1940, which involved a surprise attack through the Ardennes.
  • 🀝 Despite his military effectiveness, von Manstein's complicity in Nazi atrocities, particularly on the Eastern Front, casts a shadow over his legacy.
  • πŸ† Post-war, von Manstein was involved in creating the 'clean Wehrmacht' myth, attempting to absolve the German military of responsibility for Nazi crimes.
  • πŸ”’ Von Manstein was eventually arrested and tried for war crimes, serving part of an 18-year sentence before being released and later becoming a military advisor.
Q & A
  • Who was Erich von Manstein and what was his significance in military history?

    -Erich von Manstein was a German military commander during World War II, known for his strategic and tactical expertise. He played a significant role in the planning and execution of key operations, including the invasion of France and the Crimean campaign, and was one of the few German officers retained in the reduced Reichswehr after World War I.

  • What was von Manstein's early life and family background?

    -Erich von Manstein was born into an aristocratic and military Prussian family. His biological parents were Eduard and Helene von Lewinski, but he was adopted by Georg and Hedwig von Manstein. His family had a strong military tradition, with nearly two dozen members involved in the Prussian military and officer class.

  • How did von Manstein's experiences in World War I shape his military career?

    -Von Manstein served on both the Western and Eastern Fronts during World War I, gaining valuable experience in warfare. He was involved in the invasion of France through Belgium and later in Poland against the Russians. His experiences provided a basis for devising strategies in both European theatres in later years.

  • What was the impact of the Treaty of Versailles on von Manstein's military career?

    -The Treaty of Versailles imposed severe restrictions on Germany's military, requiring the disbanding of the German imperial army and the creation of a much smaller Reichswehr. Despite these limitations, von Manstein was retained as part of the Reichswehr due to his reputation as an effective strategist and logistician.

  • How did the rise of the Nazi Party in Germany affect von Manstein's career?

    -The rise of the Nazi Party led to a rapid expansion of the German military, and von Manstein benefited from this, being promoted to several senior positions. His political beliefs appeared to align with Nazi ideology, and he was promoted to Head of the Operations Branch of the Army General Staff and later to General Major.

  • What role did von Manstein play in the planning and execution of the invasion of France during World War II?

    -Von Manstein was instrumental in the planning of the invasion of France, advocating for a surprise attack through the Ardennes Forest, which would outflank the Maginot Line and trap the French and British forces. His strategy was incorporated into the wider plan and proved highly effective, leading to a swift German victory.

  • What was von Manstein's involvement in Operation Barbarossa, the German invasion of the Soviet Union?

    -Von Manstein was appointed as the commander of the 56th Panzer Corps for Operation Barbarossa. He was assigned to the northern wing, Army Group North, with the objective of thrusting through the Baltic States and capturing Leningrad. His forces encountered stiff resistance but achieved some victories before the advance slowed in the autumn.

  • How did von Manstein's command of the 11th Army during the Crimean campaign influence the outcome of the campaign?

    -Von Manstein's leadership of the 11th Army in the Crimean campaign was marked by a high casualty ratio in favor of the Germans, defeating a numerically superior enemy. His forces secured the Crimean Peninsula, including the key port city of Sevastopol, after a lengthy siege and with the support of the 8th Air Corps.

  • What was the significance of von Manstein's role in the Battle of Stalingrad?

    -Von Manstein was appointed to command Army Group Don during the Battle of Stalingrad. He planned a counter-offensive, Operation Winter Storm, to relieve the encircled German 6th Army. However, his efforts were unsuccessful, and the 6th Army ultimately surrendered, marking a major turning point in the war.

  • How did von Manstein's career and reputation fare after World War II?

    -After the war, von Manstein was involved in the creation of the myth of the clean Wehrmacht, claiming that the German military was largely innocent of the crimes of the Nazi regime. However, he was eventually arrested, tried, and convicted for war crimes related to his conduct on the Eastern Front. Despite serving only a fraction of his sentence, his reputation remains a subject of intense debate.

Outlines
00:00
πŸ‘Ά Early Life and Aristocratic Background of Erich von Manstein

Erich von Manstein was born on November 24, 1887, in Berlin, into an aristocratic and military Prussian family. His father was Eduard von Lewinski, a Prussian general, and his mother was Helene von Sperling. Adopted by Georg and Hedwig von Manstein, he was raised among military icons and was destined for a career in the Prussian military. Despite the relative peace of the new German state during his upbringing, the family's involvement in past military campaigns and the unification of Germany under Otto von Bismarck shaped Erich's future.

05:05
πŸŽ“ Education and Early Military Career

Von Manstein began his military education at the Lyzeum in Strasbourg, a pre-military training school, at the age of seven. He later attended a cadet school and eventually the Prussian War Academy in Berlin. As Europe divided into military alliances, von Manstein's training progressed, and he gained early experience on both the Western and Eastern Fronts during World War I. His involvement in the war included the capture of Namur and operations around Verdun, as well as service in Poland and the Balkans. His experiences during World War I laid the foundation for his later strategic planning.

10:06
πŸŒ— Post-World War I and the Rise of the Nazis

Following World War I, von Manstein continued his military career in the reduced Reichswehr, rising through the ranks during the Weimar Republic's tumultuous period. He opposed the 'Aryan Paragraph' but also showed support for Nazi ideologies. The rise of the Nazi Party, led by Adolf Hitler, and its eventual control over Germany in 1933, set the stage for significant changes in the German military and von Manstein's career. The Treaty of Versailles' restrictions were overturned, and von Manstein was promoted to key positions within the expanding Wehrmacht.

15:07
πŸ“˜ The Path to World War II and Military Strategy

Von Manstein's political beliefs aligned with Nazi ideology, perceiving a threat from Bolshevik Communists and Jews to the German people. His military strategies were instrumental in the early successes of World War II, particularly in the invasion of Poland, where he advised on effective tactics that led to a swift victory. The German military's aggressive foreign policy in the late 1930s, including the annexation of Austria and Czechoslovakia, and the eventual invasion of Poland, marked the beginning of the war that von Manstein had earlier endorsed.

20:08
πŸ‡«πŸ‡· World War II: The Invasion of France and Dunkirk

Von Manstein played a significant role in the planning and execution of the invasion of France in 1940. His strategic advice led to the successful encirclement and defeat of French and British forces, resulting in the famous Dunkirk evacuation. Despite initial success, the plan did not capture the entire British Expeditionary Force due to a combination of German strategic decisions and a daring British rescue operation.

25:10
πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡Ί The Eastern Front and Operation Barbarossa

Von Manstein was appointed as the commander of the 56th Panzer Group and participated in the planning of Operation Barbarossa, the invasion of the Soviet Union. His forces were tasked with moving through the Baltic States towards Leningrad. The operation initially met with great success, but the advance slowed as Russian resistance increased and the harsh winter approached. Von Manstein's military acumen was recognized with promotions and awards, including the Knight’s Cross of the Iron Cross.

30:11
🏰 The Crimea Campaign and the Siege of Sevastopol

In 1941, von Manstein was transferred to command the 11th Army in Ukraine, where he oversaw the capture of the Crimean Peninsula and the siege of Sevastopol. Despite a lack of air support and harsh weather conditions, his forces made significant progress, although the siege of Sevastopol lasted until the summer of 1942. Von Manstein's strategies and tactics during this campaign demonstrated his ability to manage large-scale military operations.

35:15
❄️ The Eastern Front: Winter Challenges and Stalingrad

Von Manstein's command faced challenges during the Russian winter, with the German advance stalling outside Leningrad and Moscow. He was reassigned to command Army Group Don during the Battle of Stalingrad, where he was tasked with planning a counter-offensive to relieve the encircled German 6th Army. However, his efforts were unsuccessful, and Hitler's refusal to allow a breakout led to the eventual surrender of the 6th Army.

40:17
πŸ›‘ The Retreat and the Battle of Kursk

As the war progressed, von Manstein was placed in charge of Army Group South and oversaw various operations, including a successful counter-offensive at Kharkov. Despite this victory, the strategic situation worsened for Germany, culminating in the failed Operation Citadel at Kursk. Von Manstein's role in these operations highlighted the diminishing chances of a German victory and the increasing difficulties faced by the German military.

45:21
πŸ”™ The Final Years of War and Dismissal

In the final years of World War II, von Manstein commanded the German retreat from the Eastern Front. He objected to Hitler's order for all divisions to fight to the death and was dismissed from his command after a meeting with Hitler in March 1944. He spent the remainder of the war dealing with health issues, including a serious cataract problem, and was not reassigned to another command.

50:21
πŸ› Post-War Trials and the Myth of the Clean Wehrmacht

After the war, von Manstein was initially not put on trial and worked to defend the reputation of the German military, promoting the myth of the clean Wehrmacht. He testified at the Nuremberg trials to exonerate the Wehrmacht and attribute guilt to the Nazi Party and SS. However, evidence later emerged showing the Wehrmacht's complicity in war crimes, leading to von Manstein's arrest in 1948. He was found guilty of war crimes and sentenced to eighteen years in prison, although he only served just over three years.

55:22
πŸ“š Rehabilitation and Legacy

Von Manstein was released early from prison and became a military advisor to the West German government. He published a memoir in 1955, further attempting to clear his name and that of the Wehrmacht. His legacy is one of intense debate, with his military capabilities recognized but his role in promoting the myth of the clean Wehrmacht and his own complicity in Nazi atrocities being scrutinized.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘Erich von Manstein
Erich von Manstein was a German military commander during World War II. He is a central figure in this video script, known for his aristocratic background and significant role in the German military strategy. His name is indicative of the theme of military leadership and the influence of the aristocracy in shaping the course of the war.
πŸ’‘Prussian military
The Prussian military refers to the armed forces of the historical state of Prussia, which played a dominant role in the formation of the German Empire. In the script, von Manstein's family background in the Prussian military is highlighted, emphasizing the tradition and influence of this military force on his career and the German military strategy.
πŸ’‘Aristocratic background
Aristocratic background denotes a person's lineage from a noble or privileged class. The script clearly indicates that von Manstein was born into an aristocratic family, which was high up in the military and aristocracy of Prussia and the German Empire. This background is key to understanding his upbringing and the environment that shaped his military career.
πŸ’‘World War I
World War I, also known as the First World War, was a global war that lasted from 1914 to 1918. The script mentions von Manstein's experiences in this war, which provided him with a basis for devising strategies in both Western and Eastern Europe, and shaped his military career leading up to World War II.
πŸ’‘Reichswehr
The Reichswehr was the name of the German armed forces from 1919 to 1935, following the restrictions placed on Germany by the Treaty of Versailles after World War I. The script discusses von Manstein's role in the Reichswehr, illustrating his rise within the ranks and the military's limited size and significance during the interwar period.
πŸ’‘Nazi Party
The Nazi Party, or the National Socialist German Workers' Party, was a far-right political party in Germany that led by Adolf Hitler and was in power from 1933 to 1945. The script describes the rise of the Nazi Party and its impact on von Manstein's career, as well as the broader implications for Germany's militarization and the onset of World War II.
πŸ’‘Wehrmacht
The Wehrmacht was the unified armed forces of Nazi Germany, established in 1935. The script details the reorganization of the military under the Nazis, with von Manstein being promoted to senior positions within the Wehrmacht, reflecting the expansion and rearmament of Germany in violation of the Treaty of Versailles.
πŸ’‘Operation Barbarossa
Operation Barbarossa was the code name for the German invasion of the Soviet Union in 1941, which marked the beginning of the war on the Eastern Front in World War II. The script describes von Manstein's involvement in this operation, showcasing his strategic contributions and the scale of the military campaign.
πŸ’‘Holocaust
The Holocaust was the genocide of European Jews during World War II, in which millions were systematically murdered by the Nazi regime. The script touches on the Holocaust in the context of the Einsatzgruppen's actions and raises questions about von Manstein's awareness and complicity in these atrocities.
πŸ’‘Myth of the clean Wehrmacht
The myth of the clean Wehrmacht is a narrative that the German military leadership was largely unaware of or uninvolved in the war crimes committed by the Nazi regime. The script discusses von Manstein's role in promoting this myth, his efforts to defend the reputation of the Wehrmacht, and the subsequent challenges to this narrative with the uncovering of evidence of military complicity.
πŸ’‘Nuremberg Trials
The Nuremberg Trials were a series of military tribunals held after World War II to prosecute prominent leaders of Nazi Germany for war crimes. The script mentions von Manstein's involvement in the trials, his testimony, and the efforts to exonerate the Wehrmacht, which set the stage for the myth of the clean Wehrmacht and the eventual recognition of its flaws.
Highlights

Erich von Manstein was born into a Prussian military and aristocratic family, indicating a career in the military from a young age.

Von Manstein's early military education began at the Lyzeum in Strasbourg, followed by cadet school and the Prussian War Academy in Berlin.

Experience in World War I on both the Western and Eastern Fronts provided a foundation for von Manstein's later strategic planning.

Despite Germany's defeat in WWI, von Manstein's reputation as an effective strategist allowed him to remain in the reduced Reichswehr.

The rise of the Nazi Party and Adolf Hitler's ascension to power in 1933 had significant implications for von Manstein's career.

Von Manstein was promoted to key positions within the expanding German military under Hitler, indicating alignment with Nazi ideology.

Involvement in the invasion of Poland in 1939 showcased von Manstein's strategic advice, leading to a quick German victory.

Von Manstein played a significant role in the planning and execution of the successful invasion of France in 1940.

His promotion to command the 56th Panzer Group and involvement in Operation Barbarossa demonstrated von Manstein's continued military influence.

Von Manstein's leadership in the Crimea resulted in a decisive victory with a high ratio of enemy to German casualties.

Despite initial successes, von Manstein's efforts at Stalingrad and later in the war were overshadowed by German setbacks.

Von Manstein's dismissal by Hitler in 1944 and subsequent health issues marked the end of his active command role in the war.

Post-war, von Manstein was involved in the creation of the myth of the clean Wehrmacht, denying military complicity in Nazi crimes.

Von Manstein faced trial for war crimes, was convicted, but served only a fraction of his sentence due to political circumstances.

The myth of the clean Wehrmacht has been both defended and contested, with evidence suggesting von Manstein's direct involvement in atrocities.

Von Manstein's legacy is complex, marked by significant military achievements and controversial claims regarding the Wehrmacht's innocence.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: