Master Sommelier David Glancy on Umami and Kokumi
TLDRThe transcript appears to be from a wine tasting session and discussion on the sensory aspects of wine. The speaker delves into the concept of 'umami' and its role in the taste of wine, contrasting it with other flavors such as sweet, sour, bitter, and salty. They touch upon the cultural and linguistic differences in naming and understanding these tastes, referencing a study from 2010 that identified six basic tastes. The importance of understanding these elements is emphasized for educators and wine enthusiasts to enhance their appreciation and communication about wine. The speaker also discusses the role of tannins in wine and how they affect the tactile sensation in the mouth, and briefly mentions the concept of minerality in wines, suggesting it can indicate the origin of the wine.
Takeaways
- π¨π½βπ« The script discusses the complexity and subjectivity of tasting notes in wine, highlighting how different individuals can perceive the same aroma differently.
- π· Wine tasting is not just about flavor, but involves a blend of sensory experiences and personal associations, such as one person associating a smell with a swimming pool and another with bleach.
- π₯ The conversation includes a critique of the term 'umami' in wine tasting, suggesting it's not commonly used by professionals in descriptions or food pairings.
- π MSG (monosodium glutamate) is defended for its culinary value despite common misconceptions and its presence in natural ingredients like tomatoes and mushrooms.
- π³ There's an exploration of the notion that MSG and umami are often misunderstood and unnecessarily stigmatized in culinary contexts.
- πΆ The speaker touches on genetic research, suggesting shared DNA markers among different plants, which might explain similar flavor components in unrelated food items.
- π Discusses a study on 'sixth tastes' which points out cultural and terminological differences between Japanese and American researchers in defining new taste profiles.
- π The speaker mentions a historical perspective on taste research, noting a specific study from 2010 about the discovery of a sixth taste.
- πΊ There is a focus on the role of wine educators and the importance of keeping up with scientific advances to accurately inform students and audiences.
- π Emphasizes the importance of clear communication in wine education, especially in helping beginners understand basic concepts like the difference between 'sweet' and 'dry'.
Q & A
What is the definition of 'umami' that was discussed in the transcript?
-Umami is often referred to as a savory taste. It is one of the basic tastes, and it is associated with foods that are rich and satisfying, such as those containing glutamate, which is found in foods like mushrooms, tomatoes, and soy sauce.
What is MSG and is it commonly found in wine?
-MSG, or monosodium glutamate, is a flavor enhancer that is often associated with the taste of umami. It is not typically found in wine as a deliberate additive, but the discussion suggests that some components of wine might have a similar savory profile due to shared genetic markers with other umami-rich foods.
What are the shared genetic markers between grapes and other plants?
-The transcript mentions that there are shared genetic markers between grapes and strawberries, tomatoes, and artichokes. These genetic similarities might contribute to some common flavors or chemical components found across these different plants.
Why is the concept of 'mineralilty' in wine important?
-Mineralilty in wine refers to the taste of minerals that can be detected in certain wines, often associated with the soil in which the grapes were grown. It can provide clues about the terroir and the characteristics of the wine, adding depth and complexity to the tasting experience.
What is the difference between 'taste' and 'flavor' as discussed in the transcript?
-Taste is described as a more tactile reaction, which includes the basic tastes detected by the taste buds. Flavor, on the other hand, is closely related to the sense of smell and involves the combination of taste and aroma to create the overall sensory experience of food or drink.
Why is it important to understand the concept of 'sweet' and 'dry' when tasting wine?
-Understanding the difference between sweet and dry is fundamental to wine tasting because all wines start as sweet grape juice. The degree of sweetness in a wine is determined by how much of the sugar is converted into alcohol by the yeast. This understanding helps beginners to categorize and distinguish between different types of wines.
What role does acidity play in the taste of wine?
-Acidity in wine comes from the grapes themselves, primarily in the form of tartaric, malic, and lactic acids. Acidity contributes to the wine's tartness, freshness, and can help balance out the sweetness. It also plays a role in the perception of flavor, as it can make the wine seem more refreshing and less sweet.
What is the significance of tannins in wine?
-Tannins are compounds found in the skins, seeds, and stems of grapes, and they can also come from wood used in wine aging. They provide a dry, astringent feeling in the mouth, particularly at the back of the tongue and gum line. Tannins contribute to the structure, complexity, and aging potential of the wine.
Why might some people be hesitant to use the term 'umami' when discussing wine?
-Some people might be hesitant to use the term 'umami' in a wine-tasting context because it is not a traditional term used in Western wine vocabulary. Additionally, there might be confusion or disagreement about what exactly constitutes umami in the context of wine, as it is more commonly associated with food.
What is the importance of being aware of the 'sixth taste' as an educator?
-Being aware of the 'sixth taste', which could refer to umami or other emerging concepts in taste science, is important for educators to stay current with new research and cultural perspectives. This knowledge can enhance their teaching and provide a more comprehensive understanding of the sensory experience of tasting wine.
What is the role of cultural differences in the perception of taste?
-Cultural differences can significantly influence how individuals perceive and describe tastes. For example, the acceptance and understanding of 'umami' as a taste can vary between different cultures. Educators should be aware of these differences to effectively communicate and teach about the sensory aspects of wine tasting.
Why is it suggested not to add 'umami' to the blind tasting methodology?
-The speaker suggests not to add 'umami' to the blind tasting methodology because it might complicate the process, especially for beginners. The traditional focus on sweet, sour, salty, and bitter tastes is more universally recognized and can provide a solid foundation for understanding wine flavors without overwhelming the taster with too many new concepts.
Outlines
π Wine Tasting and MSG Controversy
This paragraph discusses the debate around the presence of MSG in wine and whether it's harmful or beneficial. The speaker mentions the genetic similarities between grapes and other plants, and how the flavors in wine come from a combination of the grapes, yeast, and soil. They also touch on the topic of wine and food pairing, and the importance of understanding the different tastes and flavors in wine, such as sweetness, acidity, and tannins. The speaker emphasizes the need for wine educators to stay informed about the latest research and developments in the field.
π§ Understanding the 6 Basic Tastes
The speaker talks about the concept of the 6 basic tastes - sweet, sour, salty, bitter, umami, and a 6th taste that is still being debated. They mention a study from Central Florida that identified 6 primary tastes, and how there are cultural differences in how these tastes are perceived and named. The speaker emphasizes the importance of educating wine tasting audiences about these fundamental tastes, as it helps them better understand and describe the flavors they experience in wine. They also discuss the role of acidity in wine and how it can be masked by sweetness.
π Tannins and Minerality in Wine
This paragraph delves into the role of tannins in wine, which are derived from the skins, seeds, and stems of grapes. Tannins contribute to the astringent, drying sensation in the mouth and are associated with the texture of wine. The speaker also discusses the concept of minerality in wine, which refers to the taste of minerals or soil characteristics that can be present. They mention how certain words used to describe minerality, like 'chalky', can evoke images of specific wine regions or vineyard sites. The speaker emphasizes the importance of helping students understand these complex flavor components in wine.
Mindmap
Keywords
π‘Umami
π‘MSG (Monosodium Glutamate)
π‘Genetic Markers
π‘Wine Tasting
π‘Tannins
π‘Acidity
π‘Mineraliness
π‘Flavor vs. Taste
π‘Sweetness
π‘Bitterness
π‘Salty
π‘Cultural Differences
Highlights
The discussion explores the concept of 'umami' and its role in the context of wine tasting, challenging the traditional definitions and understanding of taste.
The transcript mentions a debate on the presence of MSG in wine and its impact on taste, suggesting a deeper genetic connection between different food items.
The speaker emphasizes the importance of understanding the genetic markers in grapes and their shared DNA with other plants, which can influence the taste of wine.
The concept of personal and subjective experiences in wine tasting is highlighted, where the same smell can remind different people of different things.
The speaker discusses the modern approach to wine tasting, moving away from the term 'umami' and focusing on food and wine pairing.
A study from Central Florida is mentioned, which identifies six basic tastes, indicating a new frontier in the understanding of taste perception.
The transcript addresses the cultural differences in naming and understanding the concept of 'umami' between Japanese and US researchers.
The speaker criticizes the use of 'umami' in marketing and advocates for a focus on the actual taste experience rather than terminology.
A detailed explanation of the different types of acids found in wine and their impact on taste is provided, emphasizing the role of malic and tartaric acids.
The tactile reaction of taste is differentiated from the smell of flavor, with a focus on how acids can affect this tactile experience.
The concept of tannin in wine is explored, detailing its source from grape skins, seeds, and stems, and its effect on the mouthfeel.
The speaker discusses the challenge of defining and agreeing on the presence of 'minerality' in wine, suggesting alternative descriptive terms.
The importance of understanding the basics of wine tasting, such as sweetness and dryness, is emphasized for educating beginners.
A practical exercise is suggested for an introductory wine tasting class to help students understand the balance between sweetness and acidity.
The transcript touches on the idea that taste is a personal and synaptic response, which can be unpredictable and varies from person to person.
The speaker shares insights on how to conduct a blind tasting, focusing on the experience rather than relying on specific terms like 'umami'.
The concept of 'minerality' in wine is linked to the soil and geographical origin, providing a more nuanced understanding of taste profiles.
Transcripts
Browse More Related Video
The Chemistry of Wine
How to make your food 30x more delicious
Georgian winemakers restoring countryβs ancient grape varieties | 60 Minutes
Modern Marvels: How Wine Is Made - Full Episode (S13, E54) | History
THE BEST ITALIAN STUFFED ARTICHOKES! SIMPLE INGREDIENTS! Whatβs for Lent Dinner? Barry and I taste
BEST ULTIMATE MEGA TRIVIA QUIZ GAME | #10 | 100 General knowledge Questions and answers
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Thanks for rating: