The Problem with Solar Energy in Africa

Real Engineering
23 Oct 202118:20
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe Saharan Desert, with its abundant solar potential, could theoretically power the world but faces significant challenges in transmission and infrastructure. Projects like Desertec aimed to harness this potential through concentrated solar power plants, but issues like high costs, land requirements, and water consumption hinder progress. The focus has shifted towards photovoltaic panels due to their lower costs and flexibility. Morocco, with its proximity to Europe and political stability, is well-positioned to lead in solar energy development, emphasizing local benefit and smart grid technology as key to the sustainable future of energy.

Takeaways
  • 🌞 The Saharan Desert and North Africa have vast untapped solar energy potential, capable of generating a significant amount of electricity.
  • 🔌 A single solar panel in Algeria can generate 3 times more electricity than the same panel in Germany due to the intense sunlight.
  • 📈 A 1 square kilometre solar farm in the desert could produce 5-7 Gigawatt hours of energy daily, enough to meet nearly 100% of Europe's energy needs.
  • 🚧 Transporting electricity from remote desert regions presents a major challenge, with only two interconnections currently existing between North Africa and Europe.
  • 💰 The cost of expanding interconnections is prohibitively high, with an estimated 8.9 billion dollars needed for the minimum required infrastructure.
  • 🔄 Desertec was a German-led initiative with a half trillion dollar investment fund aimed at developing solar generation and transmission infrastructure across North Africa and the Middle East.
  • 🔋 Concentrated solar power (CSP) and photovoltaic (PV) solar panels were considered for large-scale solar energy projects, with CSP being less competitive due to higher costs and land requirements.
  • 🏗️ The Noor complex in Morocco is a leading example of CSP technology, featuring different types of CSP systems, including the world's largest tower-based CSP plant with molten salt storage.
  • 📉 The rapid decrease in the cost of PV solar panels has made them a more economically viable option compared to CSP, leading to the decline of large-scale CSP projects like Desertec.
  • 🌍 Political instability and risks in North Africa, along with the need for water resources, present additional challenges to large-scale solar projects in the region.
  • 🌱 Grassroots movements and local investments in solar energy infrastructure are suggested as a more sustainable and equitable approach to harnessing Africa's solar potential.
Q & A

  • What is the potential of solar energy in the Saharan Desert and North Africa?

    -The solar energy in the Saharan Desert and North Africa is significant enough to power the entire world. A single solar panel in Algeria can generate three times more electricity than the same panel in Germany.

  • How much energy can a 1 square kilometre solar farm generate daily?

    -A solar farm of 1 square kilometre can generate between 5 to 7 Gigawatt hours of energy each day.

  • What is the challenge with transporting electricity from remote regions like the Saharan Desert?

    -The challenge lies in the infrastructure required to transport electricity. Currently, there are only two interconnections between North Africa and Europe, and expanding this would be costly and complex.

  • What is the estimated cost of the third interconnection between Morocco and Spain?

    -The third interconnection joining Morocco and Spain's grids is estimated to cost 150 million dollars.

  • How does the cost of concentrated solar power (CSP) compare to photovoltaic (PV) solar power?

    -While CSP was competitive with PV in the past, the cost of PV has significantly decreased, making it difficult for CSP to compete in the current market.

  • What is the Noor solar power plant in Morocco and how does it work?

    -The Noor solar power plant in Morocco is the largest CSP plant in the world, consisting of three sections (Noor 1, 2, and 3) that use different variations of CSP technology to generate a combined 510 MegaWatts of power.

  • What are the issues with the Crescent Dunes plant in Nevada?

    -The Crescent Dunes plant faced operational issues, including a leak in the molten salt tank that led to an 8-month shutdown. It also failed to meet performance requirements and was more expensive to operate compared to nearby photovoltaic plants.

  • Why is the Desertec initiative considered to have failed?

    -The Desertec initiative, which aimed to invest in CSP and transmission infrastructure across North Africa and the Middle East, failed due to the rise of cheap solar panels and the associated costs and risks of large-scale CSP projects.

  • What are the water requirements for CSP facilities?

    -CSP facilities require significant amounts of water for cooling the steam turbine and keeping the mirrors clean. For example, the facility in Morocco uses 2.5 to 3 billion litres of water every year.

  • How can North African countries benefit from their solar energy resources?

    -North African countries like Morocco can invest in their own energy needs and potentially export excess energy to Europe. This approach prioritizes local infrastructure and benefits local people first.

  • What is the current state of cross-border energy trading in Africa?

    -The technologies for cross-border energy trading exist, and investments are being made to increase capacity for trade, such as the third interconnector between Morocco and Spain.

  • Why is the shift towards smart grids and algorithm-based management important for electricity grids?

    -Smart grids and algorithm-based management are important because they allow for more efficient and automated control of the complex electricity grid infrastructure, which is impossible to manage effectively by hand.

Outlines
00:00
🌍 Untapped Solar Energy Potential of North Africa

The Saharan Desert and North Africa are highlighted as vast, underutilized energy resources with the solar power potential to supply the entire world. A single solar panel in Algeria can produce three times the electricity compared to one in Germany. Historically impoverished nations could experience an economic renaissance by harnessing this power. The text explains the theoretical energy generation capabilities based on the size of solar farms and the potential to meet Europe's energy needs. However, it also outlines the challenges faced in making this vision a reality, such as the lack of interconnections between North Africa and Europe, the high costs of infrastructure, and the historical failures in executing such plans.

05:04
🔌 The Challenges of Implementing a Solar Energy Grid

The paragraph delves into the complexities and costs associated with expanding the electrical interconnections between North Africa and Europe. It discusses the limitations of the current two interconnections and the plans for a third. The narrative explores the financial and technical challenges of establishing the necessary infrastructure for high-voltage transmission, both for short distances using alternating current (AC) and for long distances using direct current (DC). It also touches on the Desertec initiative, a German-led plan for a massive investment in solar energy generation and transmission across North Africa and the Middle East, and the considerations for using different transmission technologies based on distance.

10:04
🌞 Concentrated Solar Power vs. Photovoltaic Panels

This section contrasts concentrated solar power (CSP) with photovoltaic (PV) solar panels, emphasizing the operational differences and economic challenges of CSP. It describes an existing CSP facility in Morocco, the Noor complex, and its various technologies. The text addresses the high costs of CSP compared to the rapidly decreasing costs of PV panels, leading to a market where CSP struggles to compete. Additionally, it mentions the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) and the need for a metric that includes storage costs for a fair comparison. The paragraph also discusses the land and water requirements for CSP plants, the risks of investing in volatile regions, and the historical and environmental concerns related to foreign investment in African energy resources.

15:11
💡 Morocco as a Model for African Solar Energy Development

The final paragraph suggests that while large-scale projects like Desertec may not be feasible, there is potential for solar energy development in Africa, led by Morocco as an example. It outlines Morocco's geographical and political advantages, including its proximity to Spain, stable government, and abundant solar and wind resources. The text encourages a focus on local infrastructure to serve local needs first and then export excess energy. It also highlights the importance of smart grid technology and the growing demand for experts in algorithms and coding to manage complex grid systems. The paragraph concludes with a promotion for learning algorithms and coding through Brilliant.org and mentions other educational content available for further exploration.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Saharan Desert
The Saharan Desert is the largest hot desert in the world, located in North Africa. In the context of the video, it is highlighted as an untapped energy resource with immense potential for solar power generation due to the high amount of sunlight it receives. The video suggests that harnessing this potential could significantly contribute to global energy needs.
💡Solar Energy
Solar energy refers to the radiant light and heat from the sun that can be harnessed using various technologies such as solar panels or concentrated solar power facilities. The video emphasizes the vast potential of solar energy in the Saharan Desert, explaining that a single solar panel in Algeria could generate three times more electricity than the same panel in Germany due to the intense sunlight.
💡Energy Resources
Energy resources are natural sources that can be used to generate power. The video discusses the Saharan Desert and North Africa as regions with significant untapped energy resources, particularly in the form of solar energy. It explores the idea of transforming these regions into major energy providers for the world, highlighting the economic and environmental benefits of such a shift.
💡Economic Boom
An economic boom refers to a period of rapid economic growth. The video suggests that harnessing the solar energy potential of the Saharan Desert could lead to an economic boom for historically impoverished nations in North Africa by providing a new source of income through energy export and job creation in the renewable energy sector.
💡Solar Farms
Solar farms are large-scale solar power generation facilities, typically consisting of numerous solar panels or other solar energy technologies spread over a large area of land. The video discusses the potential for solar farms in the Saharan Desert, explaining that a 1 square kilometre solar farm could generate 5-7 Gigawatt hours of energy each day, enough to satisfy nearly 100% of Europe’s energy needs.
💡Interconnections
Interconnections refer to the physical links between different electrical grids that allow the transfer of electricity from one region to another. The video outlines the challenges of transporting electricity from North Africa to Europe, noting the current limited interconnections between Morocco and Spain. It highlights the need for significant infrastructure investment to increase these connections and enable large-scale energy transmission.
💡Desertec
Desertec was a German-led initiative that aimed to invest in renewable energy generation and transmission infrastructure across North Africa and the Middle East. The video discusses Desertec's ambitious plans for a half trillion dollar investment fund, which included increasing transmission capabilities across the Mediterranean. However, the video also points out the challenges and criticisms associated with the project, including cost, technology, and geopolitical issues.
💡Concentrated Solar Power (CSP)
Concentrated solar power is a technology that generates electricity by using mirrors or lenses to concentrate sunlight onto a small area, typically heating a fluid to produce steam that drives a turbine. The video describes CSP facilities, such as the Noor complex in Morocco, which uses different CSP technologies to generate a significant amount of power. It contrasts CSP with photovoltaic solar panels, highlighting the advantages and disadvantages of each technology in the context of large-scale energy generation in the desert.
💡Transmission Losses
Transmission losses refer to the decrease in electrical energy as it is transmitted from one point to another due to resistance and other inefficiencies in the electrical system. The video discusses the importance of minimizing transmission losses, especially when considering the long distances and challenges associated with transporting electricity from North Africa to Europe. It also explains the break-even point where high voltage direct current becomes more cost-effective than alternating current for long-distance transmission.
💡Levelized Cost of Electricity (LCOE)
The levelized cost of electricity is an economic measure that calculates the average cost of electricity over the lifetime of a power plant, taking into account factors like capital costs, operating costs, and fuel costs. The video mentions LCOE as a metric for comparing the costs of different energy generation methods, particularly between concentrated solar power and photovoltaic solar panels. It suggests that the industry should consider a combined cost of storage and cost of electricity metric to accurately compare these technologies.
💡Water Scarcity
Water scarcity refers to the lack of sufficient water resources to meet the demands of water usage within a region. The video points out that large-scale solar energy facilities, such as concentrated solar power plants, require significant amounts of water for cooling and maintenance, which can be problematic in regions like North Africa that are susceptible to droughts. It raises concerns about the sustainability of using water resources for energy production while also highlighting the need for technological improvements to reduce water consumption.
Highlights

The Saharan Desert and North Africa have vast untapped potential for solar energy, capable of powering the entire world.

A single solar panel in Algeria can generate 3 times more electricity than the same panel in Germany.

1 square metre solar panel in North Africa can produce 5 to 7 kWhs of energy daily.

1000 square kilometres of solar farms could generate 5-7 Terawatt hours daily, sufficient for nearly 100% of Europe's energy needs.

Plans to transform the Saharan Desert into a massive solar energy provider have faced numerous challenges and failures.

Transporting electricity from remote regions like the Sahara is a significant challenge, with only two interconnections between North Africa and Europe currently.

The cost of additional interconnections to transport enough electricity to power Europe is estimated at a minimum of 8.9 billion dollars.

Desertec was a German-led initiative with a half trillion dollar investment fund aimed at developing solar and transmission infrastructure in North Africa and the Middle East.

High voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission becomes more cost-effective than high voltage alternating current (HVAC) beyond 500-800 kilometres.

The Noor complex in Morocco is the world's largest concentrated solar power (CSP) plant, utilizing both trough and tower technologies.

Noor 1 and 2 use parabolic mirrors and synthetic oil to generate heat, while Noor 3 employs a tower system with molten salt for higher temperatures and efficiency.

Concentrated solar power plants require a lot of land and have high water consumption, making them less feasible compared to photovoltaic solar panels.

The levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) does not factor in the cost of storage for photovoltaics, which is often an inherent benefit of CSP.

The Desertec plan was deemed unfeasible due to the rise of cheap photovoltaic panels and the need for a grassroots movement rather than a large-scale investment.

Morocco's proximity to Spain and political stability makes it well-positioned to lead by example in solar energy investment and export.

Investments in smart grid technology and algorithms are essential for managing large-scale electricity distribution and trading.

The potential for Africa's solar energy future lies in local investment and infrastructure that benefits local people first.

The 3rd interconnector between Morocco and Spain, funded equally by both countries, represents a step towards cross-border energy trading.

Learning about algorithms and coding is crucial for the development and management of modern electricity grid infrastructure.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Will renewables stop the climate crisis? | DW Documentary

Why renewables can’t save the planet | Michael Shellenberger | TEDxDanubia

California's Renewable Energy Problem

Conversion of Energy

How We Make Energy | Essentials of Environmental Science

Sup3 - Polymer solar cells - UCSD NANO 134 - Darren Lipomi

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Solar EnergyNorth AfricaDesertecRenewable PowerEnergy ResourcesInfrastructureHigh VoltageTransmission LossesConcentrated Solar PowerNoor Solar PlantPhotovoltaic PanelsEnergy ExportClimate ChangeWater ScarcitySmart GridAlgorithmsCoding