College, Inc. (full documentary) | FRONTLINE

FRONTLINE PBS | Official
14 Jun 202254:31
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe video script for 'Frontline's College, Inc.' investigates the for-profit education industry, highlighting the business boom in higher education and the potential pitfalls for students. It features Michael Clifford, an 'educational entrepreneur' who invests in struggling universities, turning them around into profitable entities. The script raises questions about the quality of education provided, the high costs of tuition, and the aggressive recruitment tactics used by these institutions. It also discusses the role of federal financial aid in funding these businesses and the growing concern over student debt. The piece explores the debate over whether for-profit schools are a viable solution to the demand for higher education, and examines the regulatory challenges faced by these institutions.

Takeaways
  • πŸŽ“ **Profitable Education**: The for-profit education sector is booming, with businesses like Grand Canyon University valued at $1.2 billion, indicating a shift towards seeing education as a business opportunity.
  • πŸ’Ό **Investment in Struggling Universities**: Entrepreneurs like Michael Clifford invest in failing universities, infuse them with capital, and aim to turn them around for a profit when they go public.
  • ⛽️ **Capital Injection**: Clifford's approach involves a significant injection of capital into the universities he invests in, which is intended to revitalize them and increase their market value.
  • πŸ“ˆ **Rapid Growth and Public Offerings**: For-profit schools like Grand Canyon University have seen major growth, with some, like the University of Phoenix, reaching nearly half a million students.
  • πŸ“š **Non-Traditional Students**: For-profit universities often cater to non-traditional students, such as working adults and those seeking career changes, filling a gap left by traditional higher education.
  • πŸ“Š **High Costs and Student Debt**: For-profit colleges typically charge higher tuition fees than community colleges, leading to greater student debt loads and concerns about default rates.
  • 🚨 **Regulatory Concerns**: There is growing scrutiny from regulators and lawmakers regarding the practices of for-profit schools, including their recruitment tactics and the quality of education provided.
  • πŸ“‰ **Impact on Investors**: The for-profit education sector's growth and practices have attracted the attention of investors and lobbyists, leading to a tug-of-war between business interests and regulatory oversight.
  • πŸ›οΈ **Traditional vs. For-Profit**: For-profit colleges are positioned as an alternative to traditional higher education, particularly for those who feel underserved or overlooked by conventional institutions.
  • πŸ’Έ **Dependence on Federal Aid**: A significant portion of for-profit schools' revenue comes from federal grants and loans, raising questions about the sustainability and ethics of their business models.
  • 🌐 **Online Education Expansion**: The growth of online education platforms within for-profit universities has been a key factor in their expansion, offering convenience but also raising questions about the quality of interaction and learning experience.
Q & A
  • What is the main focus of the 'Frontline' episode 'College, Inc.'?

    -The main focus of the episode is the for-profit education industry, its business practices, and the controversy surrounding the high cost of tuition, aggressive recruitment tactics, and the burden of student debt.

  • What does Michael Clifford describe as the three key elements to turning around a failing college?

    -Michael Clifford states that the three key elements to turning around a failing college are money, management, and marketing.

  • How does the for-profit education model differ from traditional colleges in terms of accessibility?

    -For-profit education models often focus on providing access to a wider demographic, including working adults and those of modest means who may not fit into the traditional higher education system.

  • What is the significance of regional accreditation for a college?

    -Regional accreditation is significant because it is often considered a mark of higher quality for educational institutions. It also qualifies the school for federal student loan programs.

  • What was the role of John Sperling in the for-profit education industry?

    -John Sperling was the founder of the University of Phoenix and is considered the architect of the for-profit education model. He believed in mass-producing education and running his school more like a corporation.

  • How does the University of Phoenix cater to the needs of its students?

    -The University of Phoenix caters to its students by offering year-round classes starting every five weeks, providing campuses in convenient locations near freeways, and designing coursework around the needs of the students.

  • What is the 'gainful employment' rule proposed by the Department of Education?

    -The 'gainful employment' rule is a proposed regulation that would require for-profit schools to ensure that their graduates can find jobs that enable them to repay their student loans.

  • Why are some critics concerned about the fast-foodization of higher education?

    -Critics are concerned that focusing on low-cost convenience and ease of finishing could detract from the value of a quality education that is developed over time, potentially leading to a decline in educational standards.

  • How does the for-profit college sector contribute to the total federal student loan defaults?

    -Despite representing only ten percent of all college students, for-profit college students account for nearly half of all federal student loan defaults.

  • What is the role of marketing in the for-profit education industry?

    -Marketing plays a significant role in the for-profit education industry, with schools spending heavily on advertising and employing sales tactics to attract students, sometimes rivaling the ad budgets of multinational brands.

  • What is the potential impact of increased government scrutiny and regulation on for-profit colleges?

    -Increased scrutiny and regulation could lead to more stringent requirements for accreditation, tighter controls on enrollment practices, and potentially a decrease in federal financial aid, which could impact the business model of for-profit colleges.

Outlines
00:00
πŸŽ“ The Profitable World of Education

This segment introduces the concept of for-profit education, highlighting the booming business of finding students loans and providing them with diplomas. It discusses the appeal of online universities and the concerns about the fast-foodization of higher education. The role of educational entrepreneur Michael Clifford is explored, including his acquisition of failing universities and his partnership with significant investors like Jack Welch. The story of Clifford's personal transformation and entry into the world of academia is also detailed.

05:01
🏫 The Changing Landscape of Higher Education

The second paragraph delves into the transformation of higher education in America, driven by entrepreneurs like Clifford. It discusses the demand for education from adult students and the failure of community colleges to keep up with this demand. The paragraph also explores the for-profit model of education, exemplified by the University of Phoenix, which has seen significant growth and has attracted substantial investment. The University's approach to education, including its teaching methods, facilities, and the business strategies that have made it successful, are also covered.

10:04
πŸ’Ό The Business of Online Education

This section focuses on the profitability of online education and the capacity for rapid expansion it provides. It discusses the high cost of online courses and the simplicity of the online learning format, which primarily consists of instructor-led discussion groups. Concerns are raised about the potential loss of quality in education due to the convenience and ease of online learning. The importance of maintaining a traditional campus to anchor the university and build its brand is also highlighted.

15:06
πŸ“ˆ Marketing and the For-Profit College Industry

The fourth paragraph examines the marketing and advertising strategies of for-profit schools, which rival those of multinational brands. It discusses the high costs associated with sales and marketing in comparison to the spending on teaching. The paragraph also touches on the recruitment tactics used by these institutions and the pressure they face to continually add students to maintain growth. Concerns about unethical practices and the industry's history of legal issues and negative press are also mentioned.

20:06
πŸ“š Accreditation: The Key to Federal Funds

This segment discusses the importance of regional accreditation for colleges, which allows them to access federal financial aid funds. It follows Michael Clifford's efforts to save Patten University, a struggling institution, by leveraging its accreditation. The potential deal between Patten and the Dream Center, a non-profit Christian mission, is explored, along with the challenges and risks associated with turning around a failing college.

25:07
🀝 The Deal and the Future of Education

The sixth paragraph continues the discussion on the deal between Patten University and the Dream Center. It outlines the intentions to keep the operations non-profit while still seeking investors if necessary. The paragraph also addresses the political and regulatory challenges facing for-profit education, with a focus on the potential impact on students and the broader education sector.

30:10
πŸ›οΈ The Role of Government in For-Profit Education

The seventh paragraph examines the role of the government in regulating for-profit educational institutions. It discusses the potential for the government to intervene in cases where students have been misled, and the broader issue of student debt. The paragraph also highlights the debate over the value and purpose of for-profit education and the need for greater oversight to protect students and taxpayers.

35:11
πŸ’Ό The Battle Over For-Profit Education Regulation

The eighth segment focuses on the contentious debate over proposed regulations for for-profit colleges, particularly the gainful employment rule. It discusses the potential impact of these regulations on the industry and the efforts by for-profit colleges and their lobbyists to resist them. The paragraph also touches on the challenges faced by for-profit institutions in maintaining accreditation and the ongoing tension between investors and regulators.

40:13
🌎 The Global Perspective on Educational Investment

The final paragraph steps back to consider the broader implications of the for-profit education model, both domestically and internationally. It suggests that the Obama administration may need to rely on the growth of for-profit colleges to meet its educational goals and raises questions about the sustainability and ethics of treating education as a business. The segment ends with a teaser for the next episode of 'Frontline/World,' which will explore the challenges of international aid and development.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘For-profit education
For-profit education refers to educational institutions that operate with the primary goal of generating revenue or profit. In the video, it is a central theme as it discusses the rise and impact of for-profit colleges, such as the University of Phoenix and Grand Canyon University, which have grown significantly by offering degrees with substantial federal financial aid.
πŸ’‘Student loans
Student loans are financial aids provided to students to support their education, which must be repaid with interest after graduation. The video highlights the issue of student loan debt, particularly in the context of for-profit schools, where students often accumulate substantial debt without successful job outcomes to justify the cost.
πŸ’‘Regional accreditation
Regional accreditation is a status granted to educational institutions that meet certain standards set by regional accrediting bodies. It is a key factor in the video as it allows colleges to qualify for federal student loan programs. Michael Clifford's interest in Patten University is partly due to its regional accreditation, which is valuable for accessing federal funds.
πŸ’‘Default rates
Default rates refer to the percentage of borrowers who fail to make required payments on their loans and become delinquent. In the context of the video, default rates are a significant concern for for-profit schools, as they have higher default rates compared to non-profit institutions, indicating a potential problem with the sustainability of their business model.
πŸ’‘Gainful employment
Gainful employment is a proposed rule that would require educational programs to prove that their graduates are likely to find jobs that enable them to repay their student loans. The video discusses this as a potential regulation that for-profit colleges fear could threaten their business, as many of their graduates struggle to find well-paying jobs post-graduation.
πŸ’‘Regulatory environment
The regulatory environment refers to the rules, laws, and oversight that govern an industry. In the video, the regulatory environment is changing, with increased scrutiny and potential new rules that could impact the operations of for-profit colleges, reflecting a broader debate on the role of government in ensuring educational quality.
πŸ’‘Marketing and recruitment
Marketing and recruitment strategies are methods used by for-profit schools to attract students. The video script highlights that these schools often spend heavily on advertising and employ aggressive sales tactics to enroll students, which has led to controversy and allegations of misleading practices.
πŸ’‘Community colleges
Community colleges are two-year educational institutions that provide affordable higher education and job training. The video contrasts for-profit colleges with community colleges, noting that the latter are often over-enrolled and underfunded, leading to opportunities for for-profit colleges to attract students who cannot access community college classes.
πŸ’‘Online education
Online education refers to academic courses that are delivered via the internet rather than in a traditional classroom setting. The video discusses the profitability of online education for for-profit universities, as it allows them to reach a wider student body with lower overhead costs, although the quality and effectiveness of such programs are called into question.
πŸ’‘Educational entrepreneur
An educational entrepreneur is an individual who starts or invests in educational ventures, often with an emphasis on innovation and profitability. Michael Clifford, highlighted in the video, is an example of an educational entrepreneur who has built an empire by investing in failing universities and turning them into for-profit successes.
πŸ’‘Political influence
Political influence refers to the ability to affect policy decisions through lobbying, campaign contributions, and other means. The video touches on how for-profit education companies use political influence to navigate regulatory changes, protect their interests, and maintain access to federal financial aid programs.
Highlights

The for-profit education industry is booming, with businesses finding innovative ways to finance and market their services.

For-profit universities like Grand Canyon University have grown significantly in value, reaching $1.2 billion.

Michael Clifford, an educational entrepreneur, invests in failing universities and turns them around for profit.

Clifford's approach to education includes a significant focus on online learning, which is convenient but may lack certain educational values.

For-profit schools are criticized for their high tuition fees, which are significantly higher than community colleges and state universities.

The University of Phoenix, a major for-profit institution, has a unique model that includes year-round classes and campuses near freeways.

For-profit colleges have been successful in attracting investment and going public, generating substantial returns for stakeholders.

The for-profit education sector faces allegations of false advertising and illegal recruitment efforts.

Former employees of for-profit schools have reported being pressured to meet enrollment quotas, which can compromise integrity.

For-profit schools rely heavily on federal financial aid, with a significant portion of their revenue coming from federal grants and loans.

The Department of Education is considering increased oversight of for-profit schools due to concerns about student debt and default rates.

Some for-profit schools are facing legal challenges from former students who claim they were misled about program accreditation and job prospects.

The government is proposing a 'gainful employment' rule, which would require for-profit schools to demonstrate that their graduates can find jobs to repay their loans.

Despite regulatory pressures, for-profit education providers argue that they fill an important role in educating a diverse population and meeting workforce needs.

The for-profit education industry has significant lobbying power in Washington and has successfully pushed back against certain regulatory changes.

The debate over for-profit education reflects broader questions about the role of business in education and the balance between accessibility, quality, and financial sustainability.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: