Which is better: Soap or hand sanitizer? - Alex Rosenthal and Pall Thordarson

TED-Ed
5 May 202006:15
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis script explores the battle against viruses, particularly COVID-19, on our hands. It explains the lipid bilayer structure of the virus and how soap and water or hand sanitizer can effectively combat it. Soap molecules disrupt the virus's shell, while hand sanitizers destabilize it with alcohol. Doctors recommend soap and water for thorough cleansing, but sanitizer is a convenient alternative. The script also touches on the global water access issue and the importance of following medical advice for handling viral outbreaks.

Takeaways
  • 👐 The human hand's rough texture provides many hiding spots for viruses, emphasizing the importance of hand hygiene.
  • 🦠 The coronavirus causing COVID-19 has a lipid bilayer as its protective outer surface, which is vulnerable to certain substances.
  • 🧼 Soap contains amphiphilic molecules that can disrupt the lipid structure of the virus, leading to its disintegration.
  • 💦 Water helps to wash away the disrupted viral particles along with soap, effectively removing the virus from hands.
  • 🍶 Hand sanitizers, containing high concentrations of alcohol like ethanol or isopropanol, destabilize the virus's membrane and spike proteins.
  • 🔨 The hydrophobic effect, which gives the virus's membrane strength, is disrupted by alcohol in hand sanitizers, causing the virus to collapse.
  • 🕒 Both soap and water, and hand sanitizers are effective at killing the virus, but a minimum of 20 seconds of application is recommended for thorough cleaning.
  • 🧴 Soap and water are preferred for hand hygiene during a coronavirus outbreak due to their ability to remove dirt and ensure full hand coverage.
  • 🚿 However, hand sanitizer is more convenient for on-the-go use and should be used thoroughly when soap and water are not available.
  • 🌍 There are global challenges in accessing clean water, and innovative solutions are being developed to address this issue, particularly during outbreaks.
  • 💡 For different viral outbreaks, the effectiveness of soap and hand sanitizer may vary, and it's crucial to follow the advice of medical professionals for the best approach.
Q & A

  • Why is it important to wash your hands thoroughly?

    -Thorough hand-washing is important because the intricate landscape of your hands has many peaks, valleys, folds, and rifts where viruses can hide. Washing ensures that soap or sanitizer gets everywhere, including palms, fingertips, the outsides of your hands, and between your fingers.

  • How does soap destroy the coronavirus?

    -Soap contains amphiphiles, which are molecules similar to the lipids in the virus's membrane. These amphiphiles disrupt the regularity of the virus's membrane, causing it to break apart. The soap molecules then form bubbles around the viral particles, which can be washed away with water.

  • What is the role of the hydrophobic effect in maintaining the coronavirus's structure?

    -The hydrophobic effect causes the lipid molecules in the virus's membrane to stick together, which helps maintain its structure. This effect also holds the spike proteins in place, which are crucial for the virus to infect cells.

  • Why are hand sanitizers effective against the coronavirus?

    -Hand sanitizers contain alcohol, which disrupts the hydrophobic effect, causing the virus's membrane to collapse and its spike proteins to crumble. This results in the destruction of the virus.

  • What are the advantages of using soap and water over hand sanitizer?

    -Soap and water are more effective at washing away dirt that could hide virus particles and are easier to use thoroughly for the recommended 20 seconds. This ensures complete coverage of the hands.

  • Why is a 20-second hand-washing recommended?

    -A 20-second hand-washing is recommended to ensure that soap or sanitizer reaches all parts of your hands, given their intricate landscape with many places where viruses can hide.

  • How does hand sanitizer work differently from soap?

    -Hand sanitizer works by disrupting the hydrophobic effect with alcohol, which makes the virus's membrane and spike proteins collapse. Soap works by using amphiphiles to disrupt the virus's lipid membrane and then washing away the viral particles.

  • Why might hand sanitizer be more effective against some viruses than soap?

    -Hand sanitizer may be more effective against viruses like rhinoviruses, which have a capsid protein structure instead of a lipid membrane. The capsid has fewer weak points for soap amphiphiles to pry apart, but its surface proteins are still vulnerable to the destabilizing effect of hand sanitizer.

  • What are the challenges for people without access to clean water during a viral outbreak?

    -People without access to clean water face significant challenges in maintaining hand hygiene, which is crucial during a viral outbreak. Solutions such as devices that produce chlorinated water from salt, water, and a car battery are being developed to help these communities.

  • What should you do to determine the best hand hygiene method during an outbreak?

    -The best way to determine the appropriate hand hygiene method during an outbreak is to follow the advice of accredited medical professionals, who can provide guidance based on the specific virus and circumstances.

Outlines
00:00
🧼 The Efficacy of Soap and Hand Sanitizer Against COVID-19

This paragraph delves into the science behind the effectiveness of soap and water, as well as hand sanitizer, against the lipid bilayer of the coronavirus causing COVID-19. It explains how soap's amphiphiles disrupt the virus's membrane structure, leading to its disintegration, while hand sanitizers destabilize the virus by eliminating the hydrophobic effect, causing the membrane to collapse and spike proteins to crumble. The paragraph emphasizes the importance of a thorough 20-second hand-washing routine to ensure all areas of the hands are covered, and highlights the benefits of soap and water over hand sanitizer in terms of cleanliness and ease of application. It also touches on the convenience of hand sanitizer for situations without access to a sink.

05:00
🌐 Global Challenges and Solutions in Hand Hygiene

The second paragraph addresses the global issue of access to clean drinking water, particularly in the context of hand hygiene during a viral outbreak. It acknowledges the challenges faced by billions who lack this basic necessity and the efforts of researchers and aid groups to provide solutions, such as a device that uses salt, water, and a car battery to create chlorinated water for safe hand-washing. The paragraph also discusses the effectiveness of soap and hand sanitizer against different types of viruses, noting that while soap and water are generally recommended for coronavirus, hand sanitizer may be more effective against rhinoviruses due to their protein capsid structure. It concludes by advising to follow the guidance of medical professionals for the best approach during any outbreak.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Lipid bilayer
A lipid bilayer is a molecular structure composed of two layers of lipids, with their hydrophilic heads facing the aqueous environment and their hydrophobic tails facing each other. In the context of the video, the lipid bilayer is the protective outer surface of the coronavirus, which is crucial for its ability to infect cells. The script explains that soap molecules can disrupt this lipid bilayer, effectively neutralizing the virus.
💡Hydrophobic effect
The hydrophobic effect refers to the tendency of hydrophobic molecules to aggregate in an aqueous solution and avoid contact with water. This concept is central to the video's explanation of how soap and water break down the lipid bilayer of the virus. The script illustrates how the hydrophobic tails of lipids in the virus's membrane are repelled by water, which soap molecules exploit to dismantle the membrane.
💡Amphiphilic molecules
Amphiphilic molecules, like those found in soap, have both hydrophilic (water-attracting) and hydrophobic (water-repelling) parts. The video describes how these molecules compete with the lipids of the virus's shell for space, leading to the disruption and eventual collapse of the virus's protective layer. This is a key mechanism by which soap inactivates the virus.
💡Hand sanitizer
Hand sanitizer is a product that contains a high concentration of alcohol, such as ethanol or isopropanol, which is effective in killing viruses and bacteria on the skin. The script explains that hand sanitizer works by disrupting the hydrophobic effect, causing the virus's membrane to collapse and its spike proteins to crumble, thereby inactivating the virus.
💡Coronavirus
Coronavirus is a term used to describe a large family of viruses that cause illnesses ranging from the common cold to more severe diseases like COVID-19. The video script focuses on the structure of the coronavirus and how it can be inactivated by soap and hand sanitizer, emphasizing the importance of hand hygiene in preventing the spread of the virus.
💡Hydrophobic
Hydrophobic refers to the property of a molecule or substance that is repelled by water and tends to avoid contact with it. In the script, the hydrophobic tails of lipids in the virus's membrane are highlighted as a key feature that allows soap and hand sanitizer to be effective in breaking down the virus's protective layer.
💡Capsid
A capsid is a protein shell that encloses the genetic material of some viruses, such as rhinoviruses, which cause the common cold. The video script contrasts the lipid membrane of coronaviruses with the protein capsid of rhinoviruses, noting that the capsid has fewer weak points for soap to exploit, making hand sanitizer potentially more effective against such viruses.
💡RNA
RNA, or ribonucleic acid, is the genetic material of many viruses, including coronaviruses. The script mentions that when soap molecules break down the virus's lipid bilayer, they also encapsulate the virus's RNA, preventing it from infecting cells and effectively neutralizing the virus.
💡Spike proteins
Spike proteins are large protein structures on the surface of coronaviruses that enable them to attach to and infect host cells. The video script explains how hand sanitizer disrupts the stability of these spike proteins, preventing the virus from infecting cells and thereby inactivating it.
💡Handwashing
Handwashing is the act of cleaning one's hands with soap and water to remove dirt, grease, and microorganisms. The video emphasizes the importance of handwashing for at least 20 seconds to ensure that soap and water reach all parts of the hands, including the intricate areas where viruses can hide.
💡Chlorinated water
Chlorinated water is water that has been treated with chlorine to kill harmful pathogens. The script mentions a device that uses salt, water, and a car battery to produce chlorinated water as a solution for communities without access to clean drinking water, highlighting the importance of innovative solutions for maintaining hygiene during outbreaks.
Highlights

Hands have a complex surface that provides hiding places for viruses.

Touching the face after touching surfaces can lead to virus infection.

Soap and water, and hand sanitizer are two simple ways to prevent virus transmission.

COVID-19 virus has a lipid bilayer as its protective outer surface.

Lipids in the virus's shell are attracted to water and repulsed by it, forming a shell structure.

The hydrophobic effect causes lipids to stick loosely together, creating weak points in the virus's structure.

Soap molecules, called amphiphiles, compete with the virus's lipids and break its membrane.

Hand sanitizers with high alcohol concentration disrupt the hydrophobic effect, destabilizing the virus.

Both soap and sanitizer destroy the virus in seconds, but thorough hand-washing is recommended for 20 seconds.

Hand-washing is recommended over sanitizer during a coronavirus outbreak due to its ability to remove dirt and easier coverage.

Hand sanitizer is convenient for use when a sink is not available.

Billions lack access to clean drinking water, which is a significant issue during an outbreak.

Innovative solutions like devices using salt, water, and car batteries are being developed for water-scarce communities.

Soap may not be as effective against viruses with a protein capsid instead of a lipid membrane.

Hand sanitizer can be more effective against some viruses with fewer weak points in their structure.

Following the advice of medical professionals is the best approach to determine the most effective method during an outbreak.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Why Soap Is Our Secret Weapon Against Germs

How does Soap Work?

The Science of Soap

Applied Chemistry_ Water Hardness _ Lecture 09 _for all Polytechnic Boards 1st Semester

How Do Soap and Water Make Us Clean? | Chemistry for Kids

7 Common Bathing Mistakes You Must Avoid | Cleanse Your Body and Mind | Shower & Hygiene Routine

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Soap ScienceHand HygieneVirus ProtectionCoronavirusHydrophobic EffectSanitizer ImpactLipid BilayerHealth TipsHygiene PracticesMedical Advice