Early Christian Schisms - The Council of Nicaea - Extra History - Part 3

Extra History
14 May 201608:05
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn 325 CE, Emperor Constantine convened the Council of Nicaea to address the Arian Heresy and unite the Christian Church. The council, attended by 318 bishops, debated theological issues, including the nature of Christ. Athanasius, an anti-Arian, introduced the term 'homoousian', leading to polarization and the eventual rejection of Arianism. Despite the Nicene Creed's establishment of the Trinitarian view, Arianism persisted, influencing figures like Eusebius and Constantine's son. The heresy spread to the Gothic tribes, contributing to the Empire's fragmentation.

Takeaways
  • 🛑 Emperor Constantine convened the First Council of Nicaea in 325 CE to address various challenges within the Christian Church, including the Arian Heresy.
  • 🏛 318 bishops from around the world gathered in the town of Nicea to resolve theological disputes and unify the Church under a common doctrine.
  • 🗓 The council aimed to settle issues such as the date for celebrating Easter, healing the Meletian schism, and establishing rules for church structure and priestly conduct.
  • 🔊 The main focus of the council was to resolve the Arian Heresy, which was causing significant division within the Christian world.
  • 🤝 Constantine set a conciliatory tone for the council, emphasizing unity and the need to find common ground among the bishops.
  • 💬 The debate was intense, with rhetoric and discussion among both laity and clerics, but most bishops sought a moderate path to consensus.
  • 🔍 The council's discussions centered around the viewpoints of Arius, the originator of Arianism, and Athanasius, a staunch opponent of the heresy.
  • 📜 Athanasius introduced the term 'homoousian' (of the same substance) into the debate, which became a pivotal point of contention.
  • 🚫 The majority of bishops eventually sided with the homoousian view, leading to the declaration of Arianism as heresy and the anathematization of its teachings.
  • 👑 Constantine, seeking harmony, initially exiled Arius and his supporters but later became more receptive to a softer stance, influenced by court intrigues and personal relationships.
  • 🔙 Despite the council's efforts, the Arian controversy persisted, with figures like Eusebius and Arius being exiled and then recalled, reflecting the ongoing struggle for theological and political control within the Empire.
Q & A

  • Who was Constantine and what was his purpose in calling the council of bishops?

    -Constantine was a Roman Emperor who sought to unite the empire under Christianity. He called the council of bishops to resolve various challenges facing the Church, including the Arian Heresy, to strengthen the unity of the empire.

  • What were the main issues discussed at the Council of Nicaea in 325 CE?

    -The Council of Nicaea addressed several issues, including the date to celebrate Easter, healing the Meletian schism, formalizing the liturgy, providing rules for the Church structure, setting guidelines for priests, and primarily, dealing with the Arian Heresy.

  • What was the Arian Heresy and why was it a central issue at the Council of Nicaea?

    -The Arian Heresy was a theological dispute about the nature of Jesus Christ, suggesting that He was not of the same substance as God the Father. It was central because it was causing significant division within the Christian world, and the council aimed to resolve this issue to restore unity.

  • Who were Arius and Athanasius, and what were their roles in the Council of Nicaea?

    -Arius was a presbyter and the figurehead of Arianism, whose views had led to the calling of the council. Athanasius was a deacon of Alexandria and a staunch opponent of Arianism. Their opposing views dominated the discussions at the council.

  • What was the significance of the term 'homoousian' in the discussions at the Council of Nicaea?

    -The term 'homoousian', meaning 'of the same substance', was significant because it was used by Athanasius to counter Arianism. It was a term that Arius would not accept, thus making it a point of polarization and a key factor in the formulation of the Nicene Creed.

  • What was the outcome of the Council of Nicaea regarding the Arian Heresy?

    -The Council of Nicaea resulted in the rejection of Arianism and the adoption of the Nicene Creed, which affirmed that Christ was 'of the same substance' as God the Father, thus declaring Arianism as heresy.

  • Why did Emperor Constantine exile Eusebius, and what were the consequences?

    -Constantine exiled Eusebius because he continued to refuse to condemn Arius despite signing the Nicene Creed. The exile, however, cemented Eusebius as a firm Arian and upon his return, he worked to soften Constantine's views on Arianism and schemed against Athanasius.

  • What happened to Athanasius after the Council of Nicaea?

    -Athanasius was eventually exiled after being accused of various crimes by groups instigated by Eusebius. This led to a rigged trial and his conviction, which in turn allowed Arianism to gain strength again in the Empire.

  • How did the Arian Heresy continue to influence the Roman Empire even after it was declared heresy?

    -Despite being declared heresy, Arianism continued to spread and gain influence, partly due to the efforts of Eusebius and the exile and recall of Athanasius and Arius. It also spread beyond the Empire through the missionary work of Ulfilas among the Gothic tribes.

  • What was the long-term impact of the Arian Heresy on the Roman Empire and its neighboring tribes?

    -The Arian Heresy contributed to the lack of integration of the Gothic tribes into the Roman Empire, as they adopted Arian Christianity. This separation and the strength of Arianism played a role in the eventual tearing apart of the Empire.

  • What was the Nicene Creed and how did it shape the future of Christianity?

    -The Nicene Creed was a statement of faith established at the Council of Nicaea, affirming the Trinitarian view of Christ. Although Arianism experienced a reprieve, the Nicene Creed eventually won out, shaping the doctrine of Christianity for centuries to come.

Outlines
00:00
🏛️ The Council of Nicaea and the Arian Heresy

The first paragraph describes the historical context and events leading to the Council of Nicaea in 325 CE, which was convened by Emperor Constantine to address various challenges facing the Christian Church, including the Arian Heresy. The council aimed to establish a unified doctrine and resolve disputes such as the date for celebrating Easter and the Meletian schism. The gathering of 318 bishops in Nicea was a significant event, with the Emperor himself attending and setting a tone of unity rather than conflict. The discussions were intense and sometimes contentious, with the debate centering around the theological views of Arius and Athanasius. The term 'homoousian' was introduced by Athanasius, leading to a polarized stance among the bishops. The paragraph concludes with the majority of bishops signing the Nicene Creed, which established the Trinitarian view of Christ and declared Arianism as heresy.

05:01
👑 Aftermath of the Council: Exile and Coexistence

The second paragraph details the aftermath of the Council of Nicaea. Despite the apparent unity achieved through the signing of the Nicene Creed, challenges persisted. Constantine faced further complications when he had to exile Eusebius, a supporter of Arius and a member of his court, for refusing to condemn Arius. Eusebius' subsequent recall from exile and his influence at court led to a softening of Constantine's stance towards Arianism. Eusebius' scheming against Athanasius resulted in Athanasius' exile and Arius' recall, allowing Arian doctrine to regain strength. The paragraph also highlights the long-term effects of these events, including the spread of Arianism among the Gothic tribes, which contributed to their separation from the Roman Empire and, ultimately, the Empire's fragmentation.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Council of Christian Bishops
The Council of Christian Bishops refers to a gathering of high-ranking clergy convened by Emperor Constantine to address various theological and administrative issues facing the early Christian Church. In the video's context, this council is pivotal as it aimed to resolve the Arian Heresy and unify the empire under Christianity. The council's decisions would have far-reaching implications for the Church's structure and doctrine, as seen in their discussions on Easter, the Meletian schism, and the liturgy.
💡Arian Heresy
The Arian Heresy is a theological dispute that emerged in the early 4th century and centered around the teachings of Arius, who denied the co-equality and co-eternal nature of God the Father and Jesus Christ. In the video, this heresy is the main issue that the Council of Nicaea was convened to address, as it was causing significant division within the Christian community. The heresy's resolution was critical to Constantine's goal of unifying the empire under a single religious doctrine.
💡Constantine
Constantine, also known as Constantine the Great, was a Roman Emperor who played a crucial role in the Christianization of the Roman Empire. In the script, he is depicted as a unifying figure who sought to resolve the religious divisions within the empire, particularly by addressing the Arian Heresy. His influence is seen in the organization of the Council of Nicaea and his personal involvement in the discussions, which underscores his commitment to establishing Christian unity.
💡Council of Nicaea
The Council of Nicaea was the first ecumenical council of the Christian Church, held in 325 CE in the town of Nicaea. It was convened by Constantine to resolve the Arian Heresy and to establish a unified Christian doctrine. The council is highlighted in the video as a significant event where the Nicene Creed was formulated, which affirmed the Trinitarian view of Christ and declared Arianism as heresy.
💡Nicene Creed
The Nicene Creed is a statement of faith that emerged from the Council of Nicaea and is foundational to the Christian doctrine of the Holy Trinity. It affirms that Jesus Christ is 'of the same substance' (homoousian) as God the Father, directly opposing the Arian view. In the video, the Creed is the culmination of the council's efforts to establish a unified Christian belief and marks the formal condemnation of Arianism.
💡Athanasius
Athanasius was a staunch defender of Trinitarianism and a key figure in the opposition against Arianism. As a deacon of Alexandria, he is portrayed in the video as a determined anti-Arian who played a strategic role in the Council of Nicaea. His introduction of the term 'homoousian' into the debate was a pivotal moment that helped to sway the council towards the Trinitarian view and against Arianism.
💡Arius
Arius was a Christian presbyter and the central figure associated with the Arian Heresy. His teachings, which posited that Jesus Christ was not co-eternal with God the Father, sparked the controversy that led to the Council of Nicaea. In the video, Arius is depicted as an unbending figure who refused to compromise on his views, ultimately leading to the formal condemnation of his teachings.
💡Eusebius
Eusebius of Nicomedia was a bishop who initially signed the Nicene Creed but later continued to support Arianism, leading to his exile by Constantine. In the video, Eusebius is shown as a significant figure who, through his influence at court, managed to have Arius recalled and Athanasius exiled, thereby contributing to the resurgence of Arianism within the empire.
💡Excommunication
Excommunication is a religious censure used by the Christian Church to exclude a baptized member from participation in church activities. In the context of the video, the threat of excommunication was used as a means to pressure bishops into conforming to the Nicene Creed and rejecting Arianism, highlighting the severity of the theological dispute.
💡Trinitarian View
The Trinitarian View is the doctrine of the Christian faith that God is one being in three persons: God the Father, God the Son (Jesus Christ), and God the Holy Spirit. This view is central to the video's narrative as it is the belief system that the Council of Nicaea sought to affirm against the Arian Heresy, ultimately leading to the formulation of the Nicene Creed.
💡Ulfilas
Ulfilas, also known as Wulfila or Wolfila, was a Gothic bishop who played a significant role in spreading Arianism among the Gothic tribes. In the video, Eusebius is shown to have ordained Ulfilas, who then went on a mission to convert the Gothic tribes to Arianism. This spread of Arianism contributed to the cultural and religious divide between the tribes and the Roman Empire, with lasting effects on the empire's unity.
Highlights

Constantine called a council of Christian bishops to resolve Church challenges and unite the empire under Christianity.

The council aimed to tackle issues including Easter celebration, Meletian schism, and the structure of the Church.

The main topic of the council was the Arian Heresy, which was dividing the Christian world.

318 bishops assembled in 325 CE in Nicea to settle the Arian Heresy once and for all.

The Emperor provided for the bishops and attended the council, emphasizing unity and cooperation.

Debate was vigorous, with both laity and clerics arguing the merits of each side.

Most bishops were moderate, seeking a compromise that both sides could agree to.

The council's discussions were dominated by Arius and Athanasius, two opposing figures.

Athanasius introduced the term 'homoousian', causing polarization and difficulty in finding middle ground.

An attempt to compromise with the term 'homoiousian' was rejected by both sides.

Athanasius secretly persuaded bishops to his side, assembling a majority coalition against Arianism.

Almost all delegates signed onto the homoousian idea of Christ, declaring Arianism heresy.

Constantine exiled those who disagreed with the Nicene Creed, aiming to restore unity.

Eusebius, a relative of Constantine, was exiled for refusing to condemn Arius but was later recalled.

Eusebius worked to soften Constantine's views on Arianism and schemed against Athanasius.

Athanasius was convicted and exiled, and Arius was recalled, allowing Arianism to gain strength again.

Constantine was baptized by Eusebius at the end of his life, and his son ruled as a diehard Arian.

Arian Christianity spread to the Gothic tribes, impacting their integration into the Roman Empire.

The Gothic tribes remained separate and contributed to the tearing apart of the Roman Empire.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

How Did Catholicism Start?

Roman Empire and Christianity | World History | Khan Academy

Constantine the Great

Early Christian Schisms - Ephesus, the Robber Council, and Chalcedon - Extra History - Part 4

Is the "fall" of the Roman Empire a myth? The Rise and Fall of the Ostrogoths

How Constantine Changed History

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Council of NicaeaChristianityTheological DebateConstantineArian HeresyEaster CelebrationMeletian SchismAthanasiusArianismTrinitarian View