The German prison program that inspired Connecticut

60 Minutes
31 Mar 201913:48
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis script explores the contrasting approaches to criminal justice reform in the US and Germany. Highlighting Germany's focus on rehabilitation over punishment, it showcases how their prisons prioritize reintegration into society, leading to lower recidivism rates and reduced costs. American officials are now seeking solutions from Germany to improve their own prison systems.

Takeaways
  • 🇺🇸 Criminal justice reform is a rare issue that can unite Democrats and Republicans in the U.S., where the incarceration rate is significantly higher than in other nations.
  • 🌍 The U.S. has 5% of the world's population but accounts for 25% of the global prison population, highlighting a unique and pressing issue.
  • 💲 The cost of housing inmates in the U.S. is staggering, amounting to $80 billion per year.
  • 🇩🇪 German prisons focus on rehabilitation rather than retribution, which is a stark contrast to the U.S. approach.
  • 📉 Germany's recidivism rate is about half that of the U.S., suggesting a more effective approach to prison management.
  • 🚀 The concept of 'normalization' in German prisons aims to mirror life outside as much as possible to facilitate reintegration into society.
  • 🏡 Smaller prison populations in Germany and the use of fines or probation for low-level offenders reserve prison space for the most serious criminals.
  • 🔑 Inmates in German prisons have keys to their cells and enjoy a level of privacy and personal freedom that would be surprising to many in the U.S.
  • 🎨 German prisons offer a range of activities for inmates, including vocational training, work opportunities, and recreational activities, to promote personal development.
  • 🤝 Prison guards in Germany are well-paid and highly trained, focusing on conflict management and communication skills rather than the use of force.
  • 🧘 German prisons emphasize humane treatment and respect for human dignity, with a focus on therapy and personalized prison plans for inmates.
  • 🔄 The U.S. is exploring German prison systems for potential solutions to its own criminal justice challenges, with some states implementing reforms inspired by German practices.
Q & A

  • What is a common issue that unites Democrats and Republicans in the U.S.?

    -Criminal justice reform is a common issue that unites Democrats and Republicans in the U.S.

  • What percentage of the world's population does the U.S. have, and what percentage of its prisoners?

    -The U.S. has 5% of the world's population but accounts for 25% of its prisoners.

  • What is the annual cost of housing inmates in U.S. prisons?

    -The annual cost of housing inmates in U.S. prisons is eighty billion dollars.

  • What is the main objective of German prisons?

    -The main objective of German prisons is rehabilitation, not retribution.

  • How does the recidivism rate in Germany compare to that in the U.S.?

    -Germany's recidivism rate is about half that of the U.S.

  • What is the concept of 'normalization' in German prisons?

    -Normalization in German prisons means making life inside the prison as similar to life outside as possible, with an emphasis on reintegration into society.

  • What is the typical prison population size in Germany?

    -German prisons typically have small populations, reserving incarceration for the most serious offenders.

  • How do German prisons handle privacy for inmates?

    -German prisons respect privacy by providing cells with doors instead of bars and allowing inmates to decorate their cells as they please.

  • What is the role of prison guards in German prisons?

    -Prison guards in German prisons are well-paid, highly trained, and focus on humane treatment and rehabilitation, acting as 'calm down experts'.

  • What is the approach to solitary confinement in German prisons?

    -Solitary confinement is used sparingly in German prisons, with a focus on non-aggressive and therapeutic interactions with inmates.

  • How do German prisons address the issue of violence?

    -German prisons address violence by treating inmates with respect and avoiding aggressive behavior, which can provoke a violent response.

  • What is the term for prisoners deemed too dangerous to release in Germany?

    -In Germany, prisoners deemed too dangerous to release are placed in 'preventive detention'.

  • What is the typical duration for lifers to be considered for parole in Germany?

    -In Germany, 75 percent of lifers are paroled after 20 years or less.

  • What are some of the activities available to inmates in German prisons to aid in their rehabilitation?

    -Inmates in German prisons have access to various activities such as painting, pottery, soccer, crocheting, and vocational training to aid in their rehabilitation.

  • What is the attitude towards punishment in German prisons compared to incarceration in the U.S.?

    -In German prisons, the focus is on rehabilitation and reintegration into society, whereas in the U.S., there has traditionally been a greater emphasis on punishment and incarceration.

  • What are some of the challenges faced by the German prison system?

    -Despite its focus on rehabilitation, the German prison system faces challenges such as dealing with gangs, drugs, and signs of Islamic radicalization.

  • How does the script describe the American public's historical view on crime?

    -The script describes the American public's historical view as demanding tougher sentencing and being against a more lenient approach to crime.

  • What is the current consensus among Democrats and Republicans regarding the U.S. correction system?

    -The current consensus is that the correction system has been mishandled for 30 years and that it's time to adopt a different approach.

Outlines
00:00
🏛️ Criminal Justice Reform: US vs. Germany

This paragraph discusses the bipartisan support for criminal justice reform in the US, highlighting the high incarceration rates and costs associated with the American system. It contrasts this with Germany's approach, which focuses on rehabilitation over retribution. The recidivism rate in Germany is noted to be significantly lower than in the US, prompting an exploration of German prisons. The narrative introduces Bernd Younga, a convicted murderer serving a life sentence, who is allowed weekend leave for good behavior, indicative of Germany's emphasis on reintegration into society. The paragraph also introduces Bernd's story and his potential for early release after 20 years, showcasing the German perspective on punishment and rehabilitation.

05:04
🌳 German Prisons: Rehabilitation and Normalization

The second paragraph delves into the German prison system, emphasizing the concept of 'normalization' where prison life mirrors life outside as much as possible. It describes small prison populations, with only serious offenders serving time, and the availability of fines or probation for low-level offenders. The narrative continues with a visit to a German prison, noting the quiet and peaceful atmosphere, and the surprising level of freedom inmates enjoy, such as having keys to their cells and the ability to decorate them. The paragraph also touches on the activities available to inmates, such as painting, pottery, and sports, highlighting the focus on preparing prisoners for life outside of prison. The contrast between German and American prisons is further emphasized, with the former appearing more like a campus and the latter being more restrictive and violent.

10:06
🔒 US Prisons: Challenges and Potential Solutions

The third paragraph shifts focus to the challenges faced by US prisons, particularly the high rates of violence and the rigidity of the system. It introduces Connecticut Governor Dannel Malloy and Pennsylvania's Secretary of Corrections, John Wetzel, who have visited German prisons to seek solutions. Wetzel's experience in Germany led him to implement changes in his own prisons, such as increased staff training and programs to help inmates reintegrate into society. The paragraph also discusses the cultural resistance in the US to a more lenient approach, despite the potential benefits. It concludes with a reflection on the need for a significant shift in mindset to value human beings even when incarcerated, suggesting that a more compassionate approach to corrections might be necessary.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Criminal Justice Reform
Criminal justice reform refers to the changes in the policies and practices of the criminal justice system, aimed at improving fairness, reducing incarceration rates, and addressing issues like racial disparities. In the video, it is highlighted as a rare issue that unites Democrats and Republicans, emphasizing the need for reform in the U.S. after decades of 'tough on crime' policies.
💡Incarceration
Incarceration is the act of confining someone in a prison or jail as a punishment for a crime. The script discusses the high rate of incarceration in the U.S., noting that the country has 5% of the world's population but 25% of its prisoners, which underscores the scale of the issue being addressed.
💡Rehabilitation
Rehabilitation in the context of the criminal justice system means the process of helping offenders to reintegrate into society as law-abiding citizens. The video contrasts the U.S. approach with Germany's focus on rehabilitation, where the main objective of prisons is to help inmates reform rather than merely punish them.
💡Recidivism Rate
Recidivism rate is the percentage of released prisoners who return to criminal behavior and are re-incarcerated. The script mentions that Germany has about half the recidivism rate of the U.S., suggesting that their approach to prison reform might be more effective in preventing repeat offenses.
💡Normalization
Normalization in the context of German prisons refers to making life inside prison as similar to life outside as possible. This concept is used to facilitate reintegration into society. The script describes how German prisons have small populations, private cells, and allow inmates to engage in activities that mirror those in the outside world.
💡Early Release
Early release is a policy that allows prisoners to be released from incarceration before their sentence is fully served, often as a reward for good behavior. The video mentions that in Germany, 75 percent of lifers are paroled after 20 years or less, indicating a more lenient approach to punishment and rehabilitation.
💡Humane Treatment
Humane treatment in prisons involves respecting the dignity and basic rights of inmates. The script highlights that German prisons emphasize humane treatment, with guards being well-paid, highly trained, and focusing on conflict management and psychology, rather than using aggressive tactics.
💡Preventive Detention
Preventive detention is a legal measure where a person is held in custody to prevent future criminal activity, rather than as a punishment for past crimes. The video discusses this concept in the context of German prisons, where some inmates deemed too dangerous are held in this manner.
💡Reintegration
Reintegration in the context of the video refers to the process of helping released prisoners to become productive members of society again. It is a key goal of the German prison system, as described in the script, where efforts are made to train inmates in skills and behaviors that will help them avoid re-offending.
💡Smart on Crime
Being 'smart on crime' is a policy approach that emphasizes using evidence-based strategies to reduce crime, rather than simply increasing punishment. The script suggests that the U.S. is moving towards this approach, recognizing the need for more effective and less punitive methods in the criminal justice system.
💡Race and Ethnicity
Race and ethnicity are social categories that have been historically associated with disparities in the criminal justice system. The video script mentions these factors in the context of the U.S., suggesting that they play a role in the high incarceration rates and the need for reform.
Highlights

Criminal justice reform is a rare issue that unites Democrats and Republicans.

The U.S. incarcerates more of its citizens than any other nation, with 5% of the world's population but 25% of its prisoners.

The annual cost of housing U.S. inmates is $80 billion.

Germany focuses on rehabilitation rather than retribution in its prisons, achieving better results with lower spending.

German prisons have a recidivism rate about half that of the U.S.

In Germany, 75% of lifers are paroled after 20 years or less for good behavior.

German prisons aim for 'normalization', making life inside mirror life outside as closely as possible.

Small prison populations and a focus on the worst offenders characterize the German system.

Inmates in German prisons have private cells with doors, not bars, for privacy.

German inmates enjoy activities such as painting, pottery, and beach volleyball as part of their rehabilitation.

Prison guards in Germany are well-paid and highly trained, focusing on conflict management and psychology.

German prisons use solitary confinement sparingly and emphasize a non-aggressive approach.

Psychologists in German prisons create personalized plans for inmates, including counseling and vocational training.

Inmates in Germany who follow their rehabilitation plan can earn greater freedom and early release.

American officials are visiting German prisons to seek solutions for the U.S. prison system.

Connecticut Governor Dannel Malloy was impressed by the lower crime and recidivism rates in Germany, despite spending less on jails.

Pennsylvania's Secretary of Corrections, John Wetzel, implemented ideas from Germany to improve his prisons.

The German approach to prison reform is protected by the country's highest court, despite some considering it too lenient.

In Germany, inmates deemed too dangerous for release are placed in preventive detention.

Convicted murderer Bernd Younger in Germany expects to be released soon, having adhered to his rehabilitation plan.

At Pennsylvania's Graterford prison, murderers are kept locked up 23 hours a day, reflecting a stark contrast to German practices.

There is a growing consensus in the U.S. that the correction system needs a significant change.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Swedish Prison vs United States Prison - How Do They Actually Compare?

Germany: Low Crime, Clean Prisons, Lessons for America | Jeff Rosen | TEDxMountainViewHighSchool

Why Does the U.S. Have Such an Insanely Large Prison Population?

TEDxStLouis - Andre Norman - How to Fix the American Prison System

Prisoners In Finland Live In Open Prisons Where They Learn Tech Skills | On The Ground

Modern Marvels: The Frightening Evolution of Prisons (S6, E8) | Full Episode

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Criminal JusticeRehabilitationRecidivismUS PrisonsGerman PrisonsReintegrationPunishmentHuman RightsLegal ReformSocial ImpactPrison Life