Siegfried Kracauer's Theory of Film

Film & Media Studies

18 Oct 202232:00

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis video analyzes Siegfried Kracauer's 1960 book Theory of Film, considered a seminal work of realist film theory. It provides context on Kracauer's intellectual trajectory, outlines his argument that film uniquely captures transient aspects of physical reality unlike other arts, and shows how he contends cinema can reveal and redeem the material world. Key ideas examined include the unstaged, the fortuitous, indeterminacy, and film as shield from horrific reality. The script traces debates around Kracauer’s work and situates Theory of Film among 20th century approaches to realism, formalism, revelation, and ambiguity in film language.

Takeaways

😀 Krakauer's Theory of Film is considered his work of realist film theory, differing from his earlier writings
😮 Krakauer argues that film's essence lies in capturing transient material life like gestures and street scenes
🤔 Krakauer sees film revealing aspects of physical reality that normally escape human perception
😯 Krakauer categorizes different phenomena film captures like the transient, fortuitous and indeterminate
🧐 Krakauer defends his realism against charges of being unartistic by citing documentaries and neo-realism
😲 Krakauer says physical reality needs redeeming due to modern world losing touch through science and history
😀 Krakauer thinks film reawakens contact with physical reality in its concreteness
😮 Krakauer uses myth of Perseus to argue film shields us from horrors while letting us process them
🤨 Critics have redeemed Theory of Film by linking it to Krakauer's political and cultural concerns
🤓 Krakauer sees film documenting traces of material reality like refuse and vestiges of the past

Q & A

What are the three major works of Siegfried Kracauer?
-The three major works of Siegfried Kracauer are: 1) The Mass Ornament, a collection of essays published in 1927 2) From Caligari to Hitler, published in 1947 3) Theory of Film, published in 1960
How did critics view Kracauer's American writings compared to his earlier German writings?
-Critics like Theodor Adorno viewed Kracauer's American writings, especially Theory of Film, as lacking the radical critical force of his earlier German writings like The Mass Ornament.
What is Kracauer's theory of film focused on?
-Kracauer's theory of film is focused on realist film theory, specifically cinema's ability to represent and reveal physical reality.
What does Kracauer mean when he talks about cinema revealing physical reality?
-Kracauer means that the motion picture camera can capture transient phenomena in physical reality that humans would hardly perceive on their own. So cinema reveals or uncovers aspects of material reality invisible to normal human vision.
Why does Kracauer argue that depictions of trash and accidents have an affinity for cinematic realism?
-Kracauer argues depictions of trash and accidents tap into the haphazard contingencies of material reality, showing nature's indifference to human intention, which offers insight into the friction between desire and the world.
How does Kracauer defend his realist position against criticisms by formalist theorists?
-Kracauer defends his realist position by arguing that there is creativity and intention involved in capturing physical phenomena for their own sake, as seen in documentaries and some fiction films. So realism need not preclude artistry.
Why does physical reality need 'redeeming' according to Kracauer's view?
-Physical reality needs redeeming because the modern world has lost touch with it due to science's focus on abstract laws and history's focus on grand evolutionary schemes rather than concrete material existence.
What kind of protection does cinema offer in depicting horrific reality?
-Cinema allows a reflection of horrific reality that audiences can take in from a safe distance, like Perseus looking at Medusa's reflection. So cinema protects by making the darkest aspects of reality visible but mediated.
How might Theory of Film relate to concerns in Kracauer's earlier books?
-Theory of Film relates to concerns in earlier books about capitalist mass culture (Mass Ornament) and fascism rising in Germany (From Caligari to Hitler) through rare passages showing cinema's ability to redeem and process historical horrors.
What film techniques does Kracauer associate with cinematic realism?
-Kracauer associates techniques like long takes, deep focus cinematography, and capturing unstaged moments that assert the autonomy of physical reality with cinematic realism.

Outlines

00:00

😃 Introducing Siegfried Kracauer and his theory of film

This paragraph introduces Siegfried Kracauer, a film theorist who wrote the book 'Theory of Film' in 1960. It provides background on his earlier works and notes that this book marked a shift to focusing on realist film theory. The paragraph explains that Kracauer's American writings like this have been criticized as less radical than his early German works, but there have been efforts to redeem the value of this realist film theory.

05:02

🔍 Explaining Kracauer's idea of film revealing physical reality

This paragraph analyzes Kracauer's central idea that film "reveals" physical reality. It relates this to the tradition of cinematic revelationism and notes that while theorists use this idea differently, Kracauer focuses specifically on film capturing ephemeral phenomena like moments in time, gestures, and impressions.

10:04

🗑️ Trash and chance events symbolize physical reality

Here Kracauer argues trash and randomness, though overlooked in life, are apt emblems of physical reality and past traces that film can capture uniquely. Even choreographed chance in comedies indirectly shows the friction between human will and indifferent external circumstances.

15:05

🎥 The 'unstaged' and film's affinity for actuality

This paragraph examines Kracauer's category of the 'unstaged,' which encompasses much of his thinking. He argues film is drawn to capturing unfabricated slices of reality. Even in fictions, the camera picks up on and preserves unplanned moments of bodily struggle and authentic reactions.

20:12

😆 The fortuitous in slapstick comedies

Kracauer finds affinity between cinematic realism and choreographed chance events in slapstick comedies. Though fantastical, the accidental mishaps symbolically reveal friction between intentionality and material realities.

25:14

🤔 Why physical reality needs redeeming in the modern world

Here Kracauer argues that science and history's focus on abstract laws and narratives has alienated modern humans from the concrete material world. Film's photographic basis lets it reawaken our contact with physical reality in its specificity.

30:15

😨 Film as shield from horrors of physical reality

Finally, Kracauer believes film uniquely captures horrifying aspects of reality yet also shields spectators from their visceral impacts. As with Perseus and Medusa, film allows us to overcome fear, process historical trauma, and address the causes.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Siegfried Krakauer

Siegfried Krakauer was a significant figure in film theory, known for his works that analyze the relationship between film, culture, and society. His transition from Germany to the United States and shift from cultural and political criticism to realist film theory mark significant phases in his intellectual journey. Krakauer's 'Theory of Film' is highlighted in the video as a departure from his earlier works, focusing on the realistic depiction of physical reality in cinema, contrasting with his prior engagements with the Frankfurt School's Marxist critiques and political historiography.

💡Realist Film Theory

Realist Film Theory, as discussed in the video, emphasizes cinema's capacity to capture and represent physical reality. Krakauer's contribution to this theory is noted for its focus on film's ability to reveal aspects of the visible world that might otherwise go unnoticed, thus asserting cinema's unique relationship with material reality. This perspective contrasts with formalist theories that prioritize cinematic techniques and the manipulation of visual elements to achieve artistic effects.

💡The Mass Ornament

The Mass Ornament' is referenced as Krakauer's early work that embodies Frankfurt School cultural criticism. This collection of essays critiques mass culture and the aestheticization of political life in Germany, reflecting Krakauer's radical Marxist inclinations during his time in Germany. It represents his initial engagement with the socio-political implications of mass culture and the arts.

💡Theodore Adorno

Theodore Adorno, a pivotal figure of the Frankfurt School, is mentioned as a critic of Krakauer's later works, particularly his transition to realist film theory in the United States. Adorno's critique highlights a perceived shift from Krakauer's earlier critical force towards a more conservative approach in 'Theory of Film,' sparking a debate within film studies about the continuity and shifts in Krakauer's intellectual pursuits.

💡Redemption of Physical Reality

The concept of 'The Redemption of Physical Reality' is central to Krakauer's 'Theory of Film.' It suggests film's potential to capture transient, material aspects of life, such as fleeting impressions and involuntary gestures, thereby redeeming these moments from being overlooked. Krakauer argues that cinema, through its photographic basis, is uniquely positioned to document and reveal the physical world, providing a counterpoint to tendencies that prioritize abstract or staged realities.

💡Inherent Affinities

Inherent Affinities' refers to Krakauer's identification of specific phenomena that cinema is uniquely suited to capture, such as the unstaged, the transient, and the refuse of everyday life. This concept underscores Krakauer's argument for cinema's natural inclination towards documenting physical reality, highlighting his belief in the medium's ability to authentically represent the ephemeral and overlooked aspects of the material world.

💡Formalist Film Theory

Formalist Film Theory, positioned as the antithesis to Realist Film Theory in the video, emphasizes cinema's ability to transcend its ties to physical reality through artistic manipulation and stylistic techniques. Prominent formalists like Rudolph Arnheim and Sergey Eisenstein are mentioned as advocates for cinema's capacity to express artistic visions that reshape or reinterpret material reality, contrasting with Krakauer's realist emphasis on cinema's documentary potential.

💡Unstaged Reality

Unstaged Reality is discussed as a key interest of Krakauer's realist film theory, suggesting a preference for film content that captures life as it occurs, without artificial manipulation or staging. This approach values authenticity and the incidental over constructed narratives or scenes, aligning with Krakauer's broader argument for cinema's unique ability to document the genuine elements of physical reality.

💡Eisenstein

Eisenstein is referenced as a major formalist film theorist, known for his theory of montage and emphasis on cinema's ability to create meaning through the juxtaposition of images. The video contrasts Eisenstein's formalist approach with Krakauer's realist theory, particularly in the discussion of 'Battleship Potemkin,' a film Krakauer appreciates for its documentary aspects despite its formalist underpinnings.

💡Physical Reality vs. Mental Life

The dichotomy between Physical Reality and Mental Life is a thematic concern in Krakauer's work, particularly in his argument for the significance of cinema's ability to document the external, material world. Krakauer contrasts the tangible, visible aspects of reality with the abstract, interior experiences of mental life, advocating for film's capacity to engage with and redeem the former from being marginalized by the latter's predominance in modern culture.

Highlights

Kracauer's theory of film is considered his work of realist film theory, different from his first two books of cultural criticism and political criticism.

There is a major project in film studies to redeem Kracauer's theory of film and his realist film theory as philosophically informed rather than a naive realism.

Kracauer argues film comes into its own when recording and revealing physical reality, including phenomena barely perceived without film.

Kracauer is interested in the unstaged, nature, involuntary gestures, ephemeral life that film captures "on the wing".

Kracauer sees the camera as a "rag picker" that satisfies its curiosity by capturing mundane objects like garbage cans and gutters.

Kracauer argues accidents and chance events in comedies show indifference of physical reality despite fantastical choreography.

Kracauer connects ideas of the unstaged, fortuitous and street scenes as showing where the accidental prevails over the predictable.

Kracauer wants images to retain indeterminacy and not be limited by Soviet montage theory determining meaning.

Kracauer defends his realism by arguing there is creativity in capturing physical phenomena on their own terms.

Kracauer argues physical reality needs redeeming as modern world lost touch through science controlling nature and abstract history.

Film can reawaken contact with physical reality and give experience of "things in their concreteness".

Only in film does raw life material remain itself unlike traditional arts where it disappears for artist's expression.

Film provides distance to reflect on real horrors, "incorporating them into memory" without directly facing trauma.

Seeing horrors in film helps "redeem horror from its invisibility behind veils of panic and imagination."

Examining film's relation to physical reality and history shows continuity in Kracauer's concerns throughout his work.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Stanley Cavell's The World Viewed

Rudolf Arnheim's Formalist Film Theory

Christian Metz's Semiotic Film Theory

Walter Benjamin and Film's Lack of Aura: "The Work of Art" Part 2

Ordinary Media and Cinematic Innovation: Unfriended Part 1

Icon, Symbol, Index: C.S. Peirce's Three Signs