11. Formal Charge and Resonance

MIT OpenCourseWare

3 Aug 201728:45

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis script from an MIT OpenCourseWare lecture delves into the intricacies of the octet rule in chemistry, highlighting its limitations and exceptions. It explores scenarios with odd numbers of valence electrons, leading to radical species like the methyl group and nitric oxide, which play crucial roles in biology. The lecture also addresses octet-deficient molecules, valence shell expansion, and the importance of experimental data in confirming molecular structures, setting the stage for molecular orbital theory discussions.

Takeaways

📚 The script discusses the limitations of the octet rule and introduces the concept of radical species, which have unpaired electrons and are highly reactive.
🧪 Radical species play a dual role in human health, being both harmful by causing DNA damage and beneficial as signaling agents and in immune responses.
🌀 The importance of nitric oxide (NO) as a radical species is highlighted, with its role as a signaling molecule in the body and its connection to the development of a best-selling pharmaceutical.
🔍 The script challenges the traditional Lewis structure approach by presenting cases where it fails to accurately represent the actual molecular structure, such as with molecular oxygen and boron trifluoride.
🔬 The need for molecular orbital theory to explain the structure of molecules like oxygen, which is a biradical, is mentioned as a topic for future discussion.
🚫 The octet rule is not universally applicable; certain elements like boron and aluminum can have fewer than eight electrons in their valence shell, known as octet deficiency.
🌟 The concept of valence shell expansion is introduced, where certain elements with a principal quantum number greater than or equal to three can accommodate more than eight electrons in their valence shell.
⚛️ The script explains that elements like phosphorus and transition metals with d-orbitals can engage in valence shell expansion, allowing for more than the usual four bonds.
🔗 The importance of considering formal charges when evaluating the accuracy of Lewis structures is discussed, as it helps in determining the most stable configuration of a molecule.
🔬 The role of experimental data in determining the actual molecular structure is emphasized, as it can deviate from what is predicted by Lewis structures and rules.
📝 The script concludes with a reminder of the importance of understanding Lewis structures, formal charges, and the exceptions to the octet rule for accurately depicting molecular structures.

Q & A

What is the octet rule and why does it have limitations?
-The octet rule states that atoms tend to combine in such a way that each atom has eight electrons in its valence shell, giving it the same electronic configuration as a noble gas. However, the rule has limitations because there are instances where atoms do not adhere to this rule, such as when there is an odd number of valence electrons or when certain elements, like boron and aluminum, are involved.
Why can't every atom in a molecule with an odd number of valence electrons have a complete octet?
-A complete octet requires an even number of electrons for pairing. In molecules with an odd number of valence electrons, it is impossible to distribute these electrons in a way that every atom has a complete octet because there will always be one unpaired electron, resulting in a radical species.
What is a radical species and why are they reactive?
-A radical species is a molecule with an unpaired electron. These species are highly reactive because the unpaired electron is not in a stable bonding situation and is often seeking to either donate its electron to another atom or accept an electron to achieve a stable configuration.
How do radicals play a role in human health?
-Radicals can be both beneficial and harmful in human health. On the negative side, they can damage DNA, leading to mutations, cancer, and death. On the positive side, they act as signaling agents in the body, are essential for enzyme reactions, and are used by white blood cells to kill invading microbes.
What is nitric oxide and why is it significant in the body?
-Nitric oxide (NO) is a radical species that serves as an important signaling molecule in the body. It activates guanylyl cyclase, an enzyme that starts a second signaling system involving GTP and cyclic GMP, leading to vasodilation. This has implications for treating heart disease and other conditions.
How does the structure of molecular oxygen differ from what Lewis structures predict?
-According to Lewis structures, molecular oxygen would be represented with a double bond between the two oxygen atoms. However, in reality, oxygen is a biradical with one bond and two unpaired electrons, a structure that cannot be explained by Lewis structures alone and requires molecular orbital theory.
What are octet deficient molecules and which elements are commonly associated with this exception?
-Octet deficient molecules are those where one or more atoms do not have a complete octet of electrons. The elements commonly associated with this exception are boron and aluminum, which can be satisfied with fewer than eight electrons in their valence shell.
Why do some elements, like phosphorus, allow for valence shell expansion beyond an octet?
-Valence shell expansion occurs in elements with a principal quantum number (n) equal to or greater than three, which allows access to d-orbitals. This is common in larger atoms like phosphorus when surrounded by several small, electronegative atoms, as it can accommodate more than eight electrons in its valence shell.
How can the structure of a molecule be determined to be incorrect based on formal charge calculations?
-If the formal charge calculations result in large charge separations or charges that are not typically favored (like +2 or -2), it can indicate that the proposed Lewis structure may not be correct. A more stable structure would have formal charges closer to zero.
What is the significance of resonance structures in determining the correct Lewis structure of a molecule?
-Resonance structures are different ways of arranging the same number of electrons in a molecule to satisfy the octet rule. They are used to represent the actual structure of a molecule more accurately when the Lewis structure alone cannot account for the observed bonding, such as in the case of chromium with four oxygens.
Why are Lewis structures not always accurate representations of a molecule's actual structure?
-Lewis structures are a useful tool for predicting the bonding and electron distribution in molecules, but they are not always accurate because they do not account for all the complexities of electron behavior, such as the presence of unpaired electrons in radicals or the existence of d-orbitals in transition metals. Experimental data is often needed to confirm the actual structure.

Outlines

00:00

📚 Introduction to the Octet Rule and Its Exceptions

The narrator introduces the video content under a Creative Commons license and encourages donations to MIT OpenCourseWare. Dr. Catherine Drennan starts by discussing the octet rule, its importance, and its limitations. She explains that for molecules with an odd number of valence electrons, like the methyl group (CH3), it's impossible for every atom to have a complete octet. This leads to the formation of radical species, which are highly reactive and have significant roles in human health, both positively as signaling agents and negatively by causing DNA damage.

05:02

🧪 The Role of Radicals in Biology and Nitric Oxide

Dr. Drennan explores the concept of radical species further, using nitric oxide (NO) as an example. She explains how NO is a radical species with an odd number of bonding electrons and its importance as a signaling molecule in the body, leading to vasodilation. The discussion includes the development of a pharmaceutical molecule designed to inhibit an enzyme and increase vasodilation, which unexpectedly became the best-selling pharmaceutical of all time. The lecture also touches on the significance of radical species in biological processes and their dual role in health and disease.

10:02

🔍 Understanding Molecular Structures Beyond the Octet Rule

The lecture continues with an exploration of molecules that do not adhere to the octet rule, such as molecular oxygen, which is a biradical. Dr. Drennan explains that Lewis structures fail to accurately represent the true structure of some molecules, like oxygen, which is better explained by molecular orbital theory. She also introduces the concept of octet-deficient molecules, specifically boron and aluminum, and how they form compounds with incomplete octets, as demonstrated by the example of boron trifluoride.

15:04

🌐 Valence Shell Expansion and Its Implications

Dr. Drennan discusses valence shell expansion, a phenomenon where certain elements can have more than eight electrons in their valence shell, particularly when the central atom is large and surrounded by small, electronegative atoms. She uses the example of phosphorus pentachloride to illustrate how this expansion can occur, leading to a molecule with more than the typical eight electrons around the central atom. The lecture emphasizes the importance of considering the properties of the atoms involved when predicting molecular structures.

20:09

🔬 Resonance Structures and Formal Charge Analysis

The final part of the lecture focuses on resonance structures and formal charge calculations. Dr. Drennan uses the example of a chromium-oxygen compound with a -2 charge to demonstrate how formal charge analysis can guide the understanding of molecular structure. She shows that the initial Lewis structure with single bonds does not reflect the experimental findings, which indicate a bond order between single and double bonds. The lecture concludes with the importance of considering resonance structures to accurately represent the true nature of molecules.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Octet Rule

The Octet Rule is a chemical rule of thumb that states atoms tend to form bonds in a way that each atom has eight electrons in its valence shell, giving it the same electronic configuration as a noble gas. In the video, the Octet Rule is discussed to understand molecular structures, but it is also highlighted that there are exceptions to this rule, which is a central theme of the educational content.

💡Valence Electrons

Valence Electrons are the electrons in the outermost shell of an atom that are involved in chemical bonding. The script explains how the number of valence electrons determines the potential for an atom to form bonds and how an odd number of these electrons can lead to the formation of radicals, which are key in understanding certain chemical behaviors and biological processes.

💡Methyl Group

The Methyl Group, represented as CH3 in the script, is a functional group in organic chemistry consisting of one carbon atom bonded to three hydrogen atoms. It serves as an example in the video to illustrate the concept of an odd number of valence electrons and the resulting inability for all atoms to achieve a complete octet, leading to the formation of a radical species.

💡Radical Species

A Radical Species is a molecule with an unpaired electron. The video explains that such species are highly reactive because they tend to seek to pair their unpaired electrons, either by losing or gaining another electron. Radicals play a dual role in human health, being both harmful, as in the case of DNA damage leading to mutations, and beneficial, such as acting as signaling agents in the body.

💡Nitric Oxide

Nitric Oxide (NO) is a radical species that acts as an important signaling molecule in the body. The script describes its role in activating guanylyl cyclase, an enzyme that initiates a signaling pathway leading to vasodilation. The discussion of nitric oxide in the video also touches on how scientific research can lead to unexpected but profitable outcomes, as seen with the development of a pharmaceutical molecule.

💡Lewis Structure

Lewis Structures are graphical representations of molecules that show the arrangement of atoms and the pairs of electrons (both bonding and lone pairs) around each atom. The video uses Lewis structures to illustrate the bonding in molecules like the methyl group and nitric oxide, and to point out the limitations of this model when dealing with molecules that do not adhere to the Octet Rule.

💡Formal Charges

Formal Charges are the charges assigned to atoms in a Lewis structure based on the number of valence electrons and the number of electrons assigned to an atom in the structure. In the script, formal charges are used to assess the validity of Lewis structures and to understand why certain molecules have the structures they do, as seen with the example of boron trifluoride.

💡Biradical

A Biradical is a molecule with two unpaired electrons. The video explains that molecular oxygen (O2) is actually a biradical, contrary to the simplistic Lewis structure with a double bond. This concept is crucial for understanding the unique chemical properties of oxygen and its role in biological processes.

💡Octet Deficient Molecules

Octet Deficient Molecules are those in which one or more atoms do not have eight electrons in their valence shell. The video mentions boron and aluminum as examples of elements that commonly form octet deficient molecules, which is an exception to the Octet Rule and is important for understanding their chemical behavior.

💡Valence Shell Expansion

Valence Shell Expansion is a phenomenon where atoms with a principal quantum number (n) equal to or greater than three can accommodate more than eight electrons in their valence shell, often involving d-orbitals. The video uses the example of phosphorus pentachloride to illustrate this concept, showing that certain atoms can form more than four bonds, contrary to the typical expectations of the Octet Rule.

💡Resonance Structures

Resonance Structures are different valid Lewis structures for a molecule that cannot be accurately represented by a single Lewis structure due to the presence of multiple equivalent bonding arrangements. In the script, resonance is discussed in the context of chromium with four oxygens, where multiple structures are needed to fully describe the molecule's bonding and electron distribution.

Highlights

Introduction to the Octet Rule and its limitations with odd numbers of valence electrons.

Explanation of how molecules with an odd number of valence electrons cannot achieve a complete octet for every atom.

The concept of radical species and their reactivity due to unpaired electrons.

Importance of radical species in human health, with both harmful and beneficial roles.

The role of free radicals in DNA damage and their connection to cancer.

Benefits of radical species as signaling agents and their necessity for life processes.

Nitric oxide (NO) as a vital signaling molecule with health implications.

The discovery of nitric oxide's role in vasodilation and its pharmaceutical applications.

The limitations of Lewis structures in accurately representing certain molecules, such as molecular oxygen.

Introduction to molecular orbital theory as a tool to explain the structure of molecules like oxygen.

Identification of octet-deficient molecules, specifically boron and aluminum.

The exception to the octet rule demonstrated by boron's incomplete octet in BF3.

Valence shell expansion as an exception to the octet rule for certain elements with d-orbitals.

Examples of valence shell expansion in molecules like PCl5 and CrO4^2-.

The use of formal charges to assess the stability and accuracy of Lewis structures.

The importance of resonance structures in accurately depicting the bonding in complex molecules.

The practical application of Lewis structures, formal charges, and resonance in understanding molecular geometry and reactivity.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

8.2 How to Draw Lewis Dot Structures | Complete Guide | General Chemistry

Chemical Bonding Concepts (Part 1)

How to Draw Lewis Structures, The Octet Rule and Exceptions | Study Chemistry With Us

1.1 Lewis Structures | Organic Chemistry Complete Course

8.2 Lewis Dot Structures | High School Chemistry

Lewis Structures and Formal Charges Practice Problems | Study Chemistry With Us

Related Tags

Octet Rule Chemistry Education Molecular Structure Lewis Structures Electron Valence Radical Species Nitric Oxide Biological Chemistry Molecular Orbital Valence Shell Expansion