As retailers close stores due to shoplifting, are the concerns real or overblown?

PBS NewsHour

29 Sept 202307:31

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRMajor retailer Target announces the closure of nine stores in four states next month due to rising concerns over theft and organized retail crime. The move comes amid a significant problem of theft affecting the retail industry, with inventory loss costing retailers about $12 billion annually. While some suggest internal issues may be blamed for high inventory loss rates, the industry is pushing for stricter penalties to combat the problem. Retailers are also implementing measures to secure merchandise and track down those selling stolen goods.

Takeaways

🏬 Target plans to close nine stores across New York, San Francisco, Portland, and Seattle due to rising retail theft and organized crime concerns.
🚪 The decision to close these stores is driven by concerns for the safety of workers and customers.
🛒 Other retailers have also reported significant impacts from theft, leading to more merchandise being locked up in stores.
📉 The National Retail Federation estimates inventory loss costs retailers about $112 billion annually, though these figures are debated.
📊 Some industry observers suggest that claims of rising theft may be exaggerated or used to cover up internal management issues.
🔒 There is a notable increase in organized retail theft and smash-and-grab robberies, including recent incidents in Philadelphia.
🔍 Measuring retail theft is challenging, with no definitive data to confirm the extent of the problem.
💼 Retailers face pressure from various fronts, including inventory management issues and supply chain disruptions.
📉 Despite the increase in reports of theft, the overall inventory shrinkage rate remains relatively low at 1.57% of total retail sales.
📜 Companies are advocating for stricter penalties and laws to combat organized retail crime and address repeat offenders.

Q & A

Why is Target planning to close several stores?
-Target is planning to close several stores due to rising concerns over theft and organized retail crime, which have become significant problems affecting their bottom lines.
Which cities are affected by Target's store closures?
-Target will be closing stores in New York, San Francisco, Portland, and Atlanta next month.
What is the main concern behind these closures?
-The main concern behind these closures is the safety of both workers and customers, as theft and crime have become alarming issues.
How are other retailers responding to the rise in theft?
-Other retailers are locking up merchandise and expressing a notable increase in organized theft, as well as a disturbing number of smash-and-grab robberies and looting incidents.
What did the National Retail Federation report about inventory loss costs?
-The National Retail Federation reported that inventory loss costs retailers about 1.2 billion dollars.
Is there a debate about the accuracy of the reported theft figures?
-Yes, industry observers suggest that the figures may not be clear, and a former Walgreens executive acknowledged that perhaps they cried too much the previous year when it came to characterizing theft and store incidents.
What is the impact of retail theft on business owners and residents?
-The impact of retail theft is alarming for business owners and residents, with some residents expressing concern about having to move out of the area due to the rise in crime.
How prevalent is the issue of retail theft according to the data?
-The problem is that there is no good data available to measure the prevalence of retail theft accurately. Retailers are not going to break down by retail crime, and the National Retail Federation's survey on shrink, which is lost inventory, is not conclusive.
Are retailers using theft as a reason to cover up mismanagement?
-Some retailers that are taking about shrink and lost inventory like to blame retail crime, but reporting has found that it can often be internal issues that lead to these high numbers, such as poor inventory management.
How are companies responding to the increase in brazen smash-and-grab thefts?
-Companies are responding by planning for loss inventory as a percentage of sales, which is considered the cost of doing business. They are also using economic scales and lenses to pass legislation for stricter penalties.
What legislative actions are being taken to combat organized retail crime?
-Legislative actions being taken include the decriminalization of low-level offenses in some states, which is seen as creating opportunities for criminals to exploit the system. There are efforts to change this to have repeat offenders face stricter penalties and to combat organized retail crime on an aggregate basis.

Outlines

00:00

🛒 Store Closures Due to Retail Crime

Major retailer A, STATE UNIVERSITY, has announced plans to close several stores in response to increasing theft and organized retail crime. The closures will affect nine stores across four states, including New York and San Francisco, with concerns for worker and customer safety cited as the primary reason. The decision comes amidst a broader discussion among retailers about the impact of theft on their bottom lines. The National Retail Federation reports that inventory loss costs retailers approximately $12 billion annually. However, some industry observers suggest that these figures may not be entirely accurate, with a former Walgreens executive acknowledging potential overreporting in previous years. Residents are alarmed by the trend, with some fearing the need to move out of their communities due to the rise in robberies and looting, which have been linked to police-related incidents in some cases. Retailers are under pressure to address the issue, with some pointing to internal management issues as a contributing factor to high inventory loss rates.

05:02

📉 Addressing Retail Crime and Loss Inventory

Retailers are grappling with the issue of retail crime and its impact on inventory loss. While some are advocating for stricter penalties for repeat offenders, others are focusing on improving inventory management to reduce losses. The National Retail Federation has conducted an annual survey on 'shrink,' which refers to lost inventory, and has reported an overall increase in the shrink rate. Retailers typically plan for a loss inventory rate of up to 2.5%, and a rate of 1.57% is considered healthy. However, if the rate reaches 3%, it would trigger another round of cooperation discussions. Retailers are using economic scale and density to influence lawmakers to pass legislation for stricter penalties. The decriminalization of low-level offenses has created opportunities for criminals to exploit the system, and there are efforts to address this by making it easier for law enforcement to track down those selling stolen goods. The focus is also on combating organized retail crime, including changing the threshold for felony offenses to be based on an aggregate basis, which would allow for stricter penalties for repeat offenders who steal small amounts of goods over time.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Retail Theft

Retail theft refers to the act of stealing goods from retail stores. It is a significant concern in the video, as it is cited as a reason for the planned closure of several stores. The script mentions that theft has become a rising concern for retailers, affecting their bottom lines and prompting some to take measures such as locking up merchandise.

💡Organized Retail Crime

Organized retail crime is a type of theft where criminal groups systematically target retail stores to steal goods for resale. The script discusses this as a notable trend, with retailers experiencing an increase in these types of crimes, which are more coordinated and can involve larger-scale operations such as smash-and-grab robberies.

💡Shrink

In retail, 'shrink' refers to the reduction in inventory due to various factors, including theft, damage, and loss. The script mentions a survey on shrink, indicating that inventory loss costs retailers about $47 billion, and it is a measure used to understand the scale of loss in the retail sector.

💡Safety Concerns

Safety concerns are a central theme in the video, with the decision to close stores being driven by the need to protect both workers and customers from the risks associated with retail theft and organized crime. The script highlights the impact of theft on the safety of retail environments.

💡Smash-and-Grab

A smash-and-grab robbery is a type of crime where criminals break into a store, often by smashing windows or doors, and quickly steal as much merchandise as possible before fleeing. The script refers to an incident in Philadelphia where looting occurred, illustrating the severity of such crimes.

💡Inventory Management

Inventory management involves the processes of ordering, storing, and controlling stock. The script suggests that poor inventory management could be a contributing factor to high shrink rates, indicating that internal issues within retail operations might be exacerbating the problem of lost inventory.

💡Misdemeanor

A misdemeanor is a criminal offense that is less serious than a felony and typically punishable by a fine, probation, community service, or a short jail term. The script discusses the issue of repeat offenders committing small thefts that are treated as misdemeanors, which may not carry strict penalties.

💡Felony

A felony is a serious crime that is punishable by imprisonment for more than one year or by significant fines. The script mentions the desire to change legislation so that repeat offenders who steal small amounts of goods over time could be charged with a felony, indicating a push for stricter penalties for retail theft.

💡National Retail Federation

The National Retail Federation is a trade association that represents retailers in the United States. The script notes that this organization conducts an annual survey on shrink, providing data on inventory loss, which helps to quantify the impact of retail theft on the industry.

💡Legislation

Legislation refers to the process of making or enacting laws. The script discusses the efforts of retailers and industry groups to influence lawmakers to pass stricter penalties for retail theft, aiming to combat the issue through legal means.

💡Decriminalization

Decriminalization is the process of reducing the penalties for certain offenses, often making them less severe. The script mentions the deccriminalization of lower-level offenses, suggesting that this may create opportunities for criminals to exploit the system, which is a factor contributing to the retail theft problem.

Highlights

Major retailer announces closure of several stores due to theft and organized retail crime concerns.

Nine stores in four states, including New York and San Francisco, will be closed next month.

Decision is driven by safety concerns for workers and customers.

Other retailers are experiencing significant problems with theft impacting their bottom lines.

Some retailers are locking up merchandise in response to the increase in theft.

A notable rise in smash-and-grab robberies and looting, including an incident in Philadelphia.

The National Retail Federation reports inventory loss costing retailers about 1.2 billion.

Industry observers suggest that theft and store incidents are alarming business owners and residents.

Residents express fear and consider moving out due to the rise in robberies.

Lack of good data on retail theft makes it difficult to measure the problem accurately.

National Retail Federation's annual survey on shrinkage is not conclusive.

Retailers are under pressure from various places, including the issue of inventory loss.

Some suggest that internal issues, such as poor inventory management, could be contributing to high shrinkage numbers.

Brash smash-and-grab thefts are on the rise, but are considered isolated incidents.

Retailers plan for a certain percentage of inventory loss as part of doing business.

There is a push for economic crime scales and demands to pass legislation for stricter penalties.

Decriminalization of low-level offenses may create opportunities for criminals to exploit the system.

Legislative efforts are underway to combat organized retail crime and change misdemeanor defenses.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

$2,000,000 for an Airbnb. How investors destroyed Florida’s housing market.

How The U.S. Is Exporting Obesity | AJ+

China's Evergrande liquidation is 'trillion dollar problem'

The Rise, Fall and Possible Rise Again of San Francisco’s Downtown | WSJ

The future of shopping: what's in store?

The Credit Card Game (full documentary) | FRONTLINE

As retailers close stores due to shoplifting, are the concerns real or overblown?

Takeaways

Q & A

Why is Target planning to close several stores?

Which cities are affected by Target's store closures?

What is the main concern behind these closures?

How are other retailers responding to the rise in theft?

What did the National Retail Federation report about inventory loss costs?

Is there a debate about the accuracy of the reported theft figures?

What is the impact of retail theft on business owners and residents?

How prevalent is the issue of retail theft according to the data?

Are retailers using theft as a reason to cover up mismanagement?

How are companies responding to the increase in brazen smash-and-grab thefts?

What legislative actions are being taken to combat organized retail crime?