The Race to Save Jakarta, Indonesia: the World's 2nd Largest MEGACITY

TDC
25 Aug 202220:57
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRJakarta, the second-largest city in the world, is grappling with environmental crises including floods, toxic air, and land subsidence. The Indonesian government is relocating the capital to Borneo, but for the 34 million residents of Jakarta, sustainable coastal living and community-driven solutions are key to adapting to the challenges. The city's history of poor planning has led to severe flooding and infrastructure issues, yet innovative approaches like Bus Rapid Transit systems and metro lines are alleviating traffic. To combat subsidence, Jakarta is looking to other cities' experiences and implementing strategies such as piped water systems and river cleanup. The future of Jakarta may lie in embracing its aquatic environment and becoming a model for water-friendly urban design.

Takeaways
  • 🌊 Jakarta is facing severe environmental challenges including floods, toxic air, and land subsidence at an alarming rate of 25 cm per year.
  • 🏙️ The Indonesian government is moving the capital to a new location on a different island due to the unsustainable conditions in Jakarta, leaving 34 million residents with limited options.
  • 🌱 To adapt to the waterlogged ecosystem, Jakarta needs to maintain undeveloped greenspaces that can absorb floodwater during storms and keep the city dry.
  • 🚧 Rapid urbanization and lack of competent city planning have led to environmental degradation and a failure to provide basic public services, exacerbating the city's problems.
  • 💧 Over-extraction of groundwater has caused the city to sink, with 40% of Jakarta now below sea level, making it highly susceptible to severe flooding.
  • 🌊 The city's rivers, once a source of life, have been channelized and concrete-lined, preventing aquifer recharge and leading to overflow during storms.
  • 🏘️ Unregulated housing development has led to the proliferation of informal settlements, complicating efforts to manage and 'naturalize' flood-prone areas.
  • 🛠️ Residents are raising their homes to avoid the effects of flooding, but this is a temporary solution that does not address the underlying issues.
  • 🛡️ The government is proposing massive projects like sea walls and artificial islands to combat the rising sea levels, but these are seen as temporary fixes.
  • 🌳 Efforts to 'naturalize' rivers and create greenspaces are underway, along with plans to map the city's topography to enforce regulations on building in low-lying areas.
  • 🏡 Innovative solutions like flood-resistant tiny houses and community-driven approaches to avoid eviction are being explored to adapt to the changing environment.
Q & A
  • What is the current environmental situation in Jakarta?

    -Jakarta is facing numerous environmental challenges including floods reaching up to three meters, toxic air, and land subsidence by about 25 cm a year. The city is also referred to as having the world's dirtiest river.

  • Why is the Indonesian government moving the capital to a new location?

    -The Indonesian government is moving the capital to a different island due to the environmental catastrophes unfolding in Jakarta and to adopt sustainable coastal living practices, which are difficult to implement in the current situation.

  • What is the historical context of Jakarta's urban planning?

    -Jakarta was originally called Sunda Kelapa and was a trading post established by the Dutch who renamed it Batavia. They engineered canals that segregated native people from European neighborhoods. After independence, planning was taken over by Indonesians, but it was heavily influenced by the corrupt regime of Suharto, which encouraged speculative real estate development.

  • How has rapid urbanization impacted Jakarta's infrastructure and environment?

    -Rapid urbanization has led to a lack of green spaces, over-reliance on wells causing the water table to deplete and the city to sink, and inadequate waste treatment leading to water pollution with toxins and disease-causing microbes.

  • What are some of the consequences of the subsidence in Jakarta?

    -Subsidence, or the sinking of the land, has resulted in 40% of Jakarta being below sea level, making it extremely vulnerable to severe flooding, especially during the rainy season.

  • What was the situation during the heavy rainfall on January 1st, 2020 in Jakarta?

    -On January 1st, 2020, Jakarta experienced the heaviest rainfall in a single day in 24 years, causing severe flooding that inundated large parts of the city and turned it into a city underwater.

  • What measures is the government taking to address Jakarta's flooding issues?

    -The government is working on two major projects: completing miles of sea walls to hold back water and constructing 32 km of artificial islands shaped like a Garuda, Indonesia's national symbol, to create a freshwater lagoon and block the encroaching sea.

  • What are the concerns regarding the government's plan to create artificial islands?

    -Concerns include the project taking too long and thus being ineffective as most of coastal Jakarta will be underwater by the time it's completed, potential environmental and public health dangers due to stagnant water without proper sewage and water treatment, and the displacement of residents.

  • Why is the Indonesian government moving the capital to Borneo?

    -The move aims to centralize management and representation of the country's distant islands, spread development to many islands, decongest Jakarta's heavy traffic, and protect the new capital from volcanic eruptions, which have historically affected Java.

  • What are some of the challenges and questions surrounding the new capital in Borneo?

    -Challenges include sorting out logistics, funding the $35 billion project, potential gains for political backers from land interests, impact on the Borneo rainforest, and maintaining control over Jakarta from a distance of 1,000 km on a different island.

  • How are Jakartans adapting to the city's environmental challenges?

    -Jakartans are adapting through smart policies like the Bus Rapid Transit system and metro lines to alleviate traffic, efforts to clean up rivers, de-channelization, creating green spaces, and constructing buildings designed to withstand flooding and subsidence.

Outlines
00:00
🌊 Jakarta's Environmental Challenges and Capital Relocation

Jakarta, the second-largest city in the world, is grappling with severe environmental issues including floods, pollution, and land subsidence. The city's location on a low-lying delta exacerbates these problems, with floods reaching up to three meters and the land sinking at an alarming rate. The government of Indonesia, the fourth-most populous country, is responding by moving the capital to a new location on a different island. However, the majority of Jakarta's 34 million residents are left to adapt to these conditions. The city's diverse population and economic significance are highlighted, as is the history of poor urban planning and the legacy of Dutch colonial control. Efforts to combat these issues through sustainable coastal living and learning from neighboring communities are discussed.

05:05
🏚️ The Impact of Unregulated Development and Flooding in Jakarta

The consequences of uncontrolled construction and the resulting compression of soft sediment have left 40% of Jakarta below sea level, leading to frequent and severe flooding. The city's vulnerability is further increased by the lack of effective waste treatment, leading to toxic waterways. Personal stories illustrate the struggle, with residents like Webuo raising their homes to avoid flooding. The issue is particularly severe in areas where rivers have been channelized and lined with concrete, preventing aquifer recharge and leading to overflow during storms. The government's response has been to allow unregulated housing villages to spread, which now must be reclaimed to 'naturalize' the spaces. This has resulted in resistance and displacement, with residents facing eviction and relocation challenges, including rent debt and loss of informal employment opportunities.

10:05
🛠️ Government Initiatives and the Move to a New Capital

In response to Jakarta's environmental crisis, the government is pursuing two major projects: the completion of sea walls to prevent flooding and the creation of artificial islands shaped like Indonesia's national symbol, the Garuda. These efforts aim to combat the rising sea levels and subsidence but are criticized as potentially too slow and ineffective. The government has also decided to move the capital to Borneo, a $35 billion project called Nusantara, which promises to be a carbon-neutral eco paradise. This decision is justified by several benefits, including better management and representation of the country's islands, spreading development, reducing traffic congestion, and protecting from volcanic eruptions. However, questions remain about the logistics, funding, and environmental impact of this move, as well as the implications for Jakarta and the new capital's ability to govern from a distance.

15:17
🚍 Jakarta's Adaptation and Efforts to Overcome Challenges

Despite the government's move to a new capital, many Jakartans remain and are actively working to address the city's challenges. Traffic congestion, once the worst in the world, has been alleviated through smart policies such as the implementation of a Bus Rapid Transit system and the opening of a new metro line. Efforts are also being made to slow Jakarta's sinking by learning from other cities that have faced similar issues, such as Tokyo and Shanghai. The city aims to pipe water to all residents by 2030 and shut down unregulated wells to combat subsidence. Additionally, there are plans to clean up the Citarum river, the most polluted in the world, and to create green spaces and regulations to manage flooding. Innovative solutions like low-cost floating bridges and flood-resistant housing designs are being explored to adapt to the city's waterlogged conditions.

20:20
🏘️ Community Involvement and Sustainable Solutions for Jakarta

The narrative concludes with a focus on community involvement and sustainable solutions. Residents have been adapting by constructing buildings that can withstand flooding and subsidence, and there are proposals for regulations that would make Jakarta more water-friendly. Architect Yu Sing has designed affordable flood-resistant housing, and citizens have come together to avoid mass eviction by voluntarily modifying their homes. The story highlights the importance of dialogue and negotiation between informal villages, slums, and the government to find solutions that work for everyone. The hope is that the collaborative approach seen in Jakarta can serve as a model for other communities facing similar challenges.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Environmental Catastrophes
Environmental catastrophes refer to severe and often irreversible environmental disasters that have a significant negative impact on the ecosystem and human life. In the video, Jakarta is facing a multitude of environmental catastrophes such as floods, toxic air, and land subsidence, which are unfolding due to a lack of proper intervention and sustainable practices. These catastrophes are central to the video's theme, illustrating the urgent need for change in the city's approach to urban planning and environmental management.
💡Land Subsidence
Land subsidence is the gradual settling or sudden sinking of the ground surface due to natural or human-induced factors. In the context of Jakarta, the script mentions that the land is sinking at an alarming rate of about 25 cm a year, which is a direct consequence of excessive groundwater extraction and the weight of urban development. This keyword is crucial as it highlights one of the primary challenges faced by the city and ties into the overarching theme of environmental degradation and its impact on urban living.
💡Rapid Urbanization
Rapid urbanization describes the fast process of rural populations moving to urban areas, leading to the expansion of city sizes and populations. The script points out that Jakarta's rapid urbanization has gone 'horribly, horribly wrong,' resulting in a lack of green spaces and the exacerbation of environmental issues. This term is key to understanding the video's message about the negative consequences of unplanned and unsustainable urban growth.
💡Sustainable Coastal Living
Sustainable coastal living involves practices and strategies that allow communities to coexist with the coastal environment in a way that preserves natural resources and minimizes negative impacts. The video suggests that to thrive under the current conditions, Jakarta's inhabitants need to adopt the best practices in sustainable coastal living, following the example of their most forward-thinking neighbors. This concept is integral to the video's narrative, as it presents a potential solution to the city's environmental challenges.
💡Green Spaces
Green spaces refer to areas covered with grass, trees, plants, or other vegetation, providing ecological, social, and economic benefits in urban environments. The script laments the lack of green spaces in Jakarta, which are essential for flood mitigation and environmental health. The concept of green spaces is significant in the video as it underscores the importance of preserving and creating such areas to combat the city's environmental issues.
💡Subsistence
Subsistence in the context of the video refers to the phenomenon where parts of Jakarta are now below sea level due to land subsidence. The script states that 'These cumulative effects mean that 40% of Jakarta is now below sea level.' This keyword is pivotal as it illustrates the severity of the land subsidence issue and its direct relation to the city's vulnerability to flooding.
💡Channelization
Channelization is the process of confining a river within a constructed channel or straightening its course to control flooding and improve navigation. The script discusses the negative impacts of channelizing Jakarta's rivers, which has led to issues with aquifer recharge, siltation, and overflow during storms. This term is central to the video's argument against certain historical approaches to urban water management that have contributed to current environmental problems.
💡Kampungs
Kampungs are traditional Indonesian villages, often characterized by dense settlements and community ties. In the script, kampungs are mentioned in the context of unregulated housing villages that have proliferated throughout Jakarta, contributing to environmental challenges and social issues. The term is significant as it highlights the human aspect of the city's environmental crisis and the complexities involved in addressing these issues.
💡Sea Walls
Sea walls are barriers constructed along coastlines to protect against flooding from the sea, especially during high tides and storm surges. The video mentions the government's plan to finish miles of sea walls to hold back the encroaching sea. This keyword is important as it represents one of the proposed solutions to Jakarta's flooding problems and illustrates the scale of the challenge the city faces.
💡Artificial Islands
Artificial islands are human-made landforms created through land reclamation, often for urban development or infrastructure projects. The script refers to a $30+ billion megaproject involving 32 km of artificial islands in the shape of Indonesia's national symbol, the Garuda. This concept is integral to the video's exploration of the government's ambitious plans to combat Jakarta's environmental issues through large-scale engineering projects.
💡Nusantara
Nusantara is the name given to the proposed new capital city of Indonesia, located on Borneo, over 1000 km away from Jakarta. The script discusses the government's drastic step of moving the capital to address the environmental and logistical challenges faced by Jakarta. This keyword is significant as it represents a potential long-term solution to the city's problems and raises questions about the future of Jakarta and its inhabitants.
Highlights

Jakarta, the second-largest city in the world, faces environmental catastrophes and an uncertain future.

Environmental issues have been unfolding for decades with minimal intervention by authorities.

Jakarta experiences floods up to three meters and has the world’s dirtiest river.

The city's land is sinking by about 25 cm a year, exacerbating flooding issues.

Indonesia's government is moving the capital to a new location due to these challenges.

Jakarta's 34 million residents have limited options to escape the city's environmental issues.

The city is a melting pot of Indonesia's diverse ethnic groups and cultures.

Jakarta serves as the economic hub of Southeast Asia with a rapidly growing service sector.

Indonesia's natural paradise faces threats from poor city planning and urbanization.

Jakarta's history includes Dutch colonial control and a legacy of ineffective urban planning.

The city's infrastructure struggles with providing basic services like water and waste management.

Subsidence, caused by over-extraction of groundwater, is causing parts of Jakarta to sink.

Floods in Jakarta are severe, with the heaviest rainfall in 24 years occurring on January 1st, 2020.

Efforts to combat Jakarta's environmental issues include building sea walls and artificial islands.

The印尼政府计划将首都迁移到婆罗洲,一个完全不同的岛屿上,以避免沿海风险。

Jakarta's traffic congestion has been alleviated by the introduction of a Bus Rapid Transit system and a new metro line.

The city is working on a plan to provide piped water to all households and shut down unregulated wells.

Jakarta is undertaking river cleanup and de-channelization efforts to improve its waterways.

Community collaboration and innovative architecture are being used to create flood-resistant housing.

Residents of Jakarta are adapting by constructing buildings that can withstand flooding and subsidence.

The city is exploring the use of low-cost floating bridges to connect areas affected by flooding.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: