Types of claims in argument | Reading and writing
TLDRIn this educational video, Renee from Teaching Learning English guides learners on understanding the types of claims in reading and writing. She introduces the concept of explicit and implicit information in critical reading, emphasizing the importance of distinguishing between them to evaluate an author's claims. Renee explains the characteristics of good claims and the three main types: claims of fact, value, and policy. She provides examples and strategies for defending each type, encouraging active engagement with the text to discern the writer's point or position.
Takeaways
- 📘 The lesson is focused on teaching how to differentiate the types of claims in reading and writing.
- 🔍 Recalling the last lesson, there are four properties of a written text: organization, coherence and cohesion, language use, and the mechanics of writing.
- 🎓 The lesson objectives include the ability to classify statements according to their type and formulate statements for each type of claim.
- 💑 The script uses romantic sentences to introduce the difference between implicit and explicit information in critical reading.
- 🔎 Critical reading involves distinguishing clearly stated explicit information from implied, or implicit, information to infer or guess about what is read.
- 📚 Understanding implicit and explicit information helps in evaluating a claim made by an author, recognizing arguments, and evidence.
- 📝 A claim is the writer's point or position on a topic, often found in the introduction or early paragraphs, which they aim to prove with evidence.
- 🤔 Characteristics of good claims include being argumentative, specific, focused, interesting, engaging, and logical with reasonable support.
- 📈 There are three main types of claims: claims of fact, value, and policy, with additional types mentioned in some references.
- 🧐 Claims of fact are based on data, documents, and scientific observation, often found in research papers and historical or predictive statements.
- 🏆 Claims of value are moral judgments based on standards and norms, requiring the use of moral standards and examples to clarify meanings.
- 🏛 Claims of policy suggest specific actions to address issues, advocating for policies or courses of action to solve problems.
- 📋 Tips are provided for defending claims, including stating the claim clearly, defining terms, providing sufficient and accurate evidence, and having a clear conclusion.
Q & A
What is the main topic of the video script?
-The main topic of the video script is the types of claims in reading and writing, focusing on how to differentiate, classify, and formulate statements for each type of claim.
What are the four properties of a written text mentioned in the script?
-The four properties of a written text mentioned are organization, coherence and cohesion, language use, and the mechanics of writing.
What is the difference between explicit and implicit information in critical reading?
-Explicit information is clearly stated in the text, while implicit information is suggested and needs to be inferred by the reader.
Why is it important to distinguish between explicit and implicit information when evaluating a claim made by an author?
-Distinguishing between explicit and implicit information helps in understanding the author's arguments and evidence, allowing the reader to better evaluate the claim and judge the writer's work.
What is a claim in the context of a written text?
-A claim is the writer's point or position regarding the chosen topic, also known as the central argument or thesis statement, which the writer tries to prove by providing details, explanations, and evidence.
What are the characteristics of good claims according to the script?
-Good claims should be argumentative and debatable, specific and focused, interesting and engaging, and logical, with reasonable support.
How many types of claims are mentioned in the script, and what are they?
-The script mentions three main types of claims: claims of fact, claims of value, and claims of policy. However, it also references additional types from a reference material by Nancy Wood, which includes claims of definition and claims of cause.
What are claims of fact, and how are they typically used in writing?
-Claims of fact refer to conditions that have existed, exist, or will exist, based on data, documents, and scientific observation and research. They are commonly used in research papers and historical accounts.
What are claims of value, and what standards are they based on?
-Claims of value are value judgments made based on morals, standards, and norms. They require the use of standards of evaluation, presentation of moral standards, and often rely on credible experts or authorities.
What are claims of policy, and what do they advocate for?
-Claims of policy argue for specific and measurable actions that need to be taken to address issues or concerns. They advocate for the adoption of policies or courses of action to solve problems.
How can one defend their claims of fact in writing?
-To defend claims of fact, one should state the claim clearly, define any controversial or ambiguous terms, ensure the evidence is sufficient, accurate, recent, and from a reliable authority, and have a clear conclusion.
What tips are given for defending claims of value in writing?
-To defend claims of value, one should make clear the values or principles being defended, consider the potential differences in the relative importance of these values among readers, use examples and illustrations to clarify meanings, and use testimony from others to show shared values.
How can one support their claims of policy in an argument?
-Supporting claims of policy involves convincing the audience that a problem exists, making the proposal clear and precisely defined, considering opposing arguments, and providing solid data and moral considerations to support the proposal.
What is the purpose of the quiz at the end of the script?
-The purpose of the quiz is to test the viewer's understanding of the different types of claims by identifying whether given statements are claims of fact, value, or policy.
Outlines
📚 Introduction to Claims in Reading and Writing
The script introduces the topic of differentiating types of claims in the context of reading and writing skills. Renee, the instructor, welcomes the learners to the class and prompts a recall of the previous lesson about the properties of written text. The lesson objectives are outlined, which include the ability to identify and classify claims and formulate statements for each type. The instructor uses the upcoming Valentine's Day to illustrate the difference between implicit and explicit information in critical reading. The importance of recognizing a writer's claim or central argument is emphasized, which is typically found in the introduction or early paragraphs of a text.
🔍 Characteristics of Good Claims and Types of Claims
This paragraph delves into the characteristics that define a good claim: it should be argumentative, specific, interesting, and logical with reasonable support. The instructor then introduces the three main types of claims as per the learning competencies: claims of fact, value, and policy. However, the focus is extended to five types, including claims of definition and cause, as cited by Nancy Wood. The paragraph explains that claims of fact are based on data and observations, while claims of value involve moral judgments and standards. Claims of policy propose specific actions to address issues.
📝 Tips for Defending Claims and Quiz
The script provides guidance on how to defend claims of fact, value, and policy with clear strategies. For claims of fact, it suggests stating the claim, defining terms, using sufficient and accurate data, and having a clear conclusion. Claims of value should emphasize the importance of the values being defended and use examples to clarify meanings. Claims of policy require convincing the audience of a problem, proposing a clear solution, and considering opposing arguments. The paragraph concludes with a quiz to identify whether statements are claims of fact, value, or policy, testing the learners' understanding of the concepts discussed.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Claims
💡Critical Reading
💡Explicit Information
💡Implicit Information
💡Types of Claims
💡Claims of Fact
💡Claims of Value
💡Claims of Policy
💡Coherence and Cohesion
💡Thesis Statement
💡Evaluation of Claims
Highlights
Introduction to the topic of types of claims in reading and writing.
Recall of the properties of a written text from the previous lesson.
Discussion on the importance of differentiating between implicit and explicit information in critical reading.
Explanation of how to evaluate a claim made by an author and recognize arguments and evidence.
Introduction of the concept of a claim as the writer's point or position in a text.
Characteristics of good claims: argumentative, specific, interesting, and logical.
Introduction of the three main types of claims: fact, value, and policy.
Description of claims of fact as statements based on data, documents, and scientific observation.
Guiding questions for analyzing claims of fact, such as verifying truthfulness and checking for factual basis.
Examples of claims of fact, including historical facts and predictions based on scientific evidence.
Explanation of claims of value as value judgments based on morals, standards, and norms.
Guiding questions for analyzing claims of value, focusing on evaluating what is considered good or right.
Examples of claims of value, discussing moral standards and personal preferences.
Introduction of claims of policy as specific actions needed to address issues or concerns.
Examples of claims of policy, such as dress codes and presidential orders.
Guiding questions for analyzing claims of policy, including identifying problems and proposing clear solutions.
Quiz to identify if statements are claims of fact, value, or policy, with examples provided.
Discussion on how to defend claims of policy with solid data and moral considerations.
Encouragement for learners to ask questions and seek clarifications in the comments section.
Transcripts
Browse More Related Video
Arguments and Claims Mini Lesson
SHS Reading and Writing Q1 Ep 8 Introduction to Claims
Author's Purpose (Entertain, Inform, or Persuade) - Video and Worksheet
Citing evidence in literary analysis | Reading | Khan Academy
CER 3 Steps to Evidence - based writing in Middle school
Author's Purpose: Persuade, Inform, Entertain
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)
Thanks for rating: