Neither Male or Female - Secret Intersex (Gender & Sex Documentary) | Only Human

Only Human
12 Jan 201848:38
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis documentary explores the lives of intersex children and their families in Britain, challenging traditional perceptions of gender. It delves into the complexities of medical decisions, personal identity, and societal understanding, as these individuals navigate life with anatomical features of both sexes. The film highlights the passionate debate around the treatment of intersexuality, the dilemmas of gender assignment, and the emerging voices advocating for intersex rights and self-determination.

Takeaways
  • 🌟 Intersex individuals are born with anatomical features of both sexes and are defined by doctors as such, challenging the traditional binary understanding of gender.
  • πŸ” The script follows the lives of three families with intersex children, exploring the complexities they face in terms of identity and societal perceptions.
  • πŸ₯ Medical interventions for intersex conditions have historically been shrouded in secrecy, with doctors often advising parents to keep the diagnosis confidential.
  • 🧬 Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS) is a rare intersex condition where the body does not respond to the male hormone testosterone, leading to the development of external female characteristics despite having male XY chromosomes.
  • πŸ‘Ά The decision-making process for parents and doctors regarding surgery and the assignment of gender for intersex children is fraught with dilemmas and potential long-term consequences.
  • 🌱 Some intersex individuals, like those with AIS, may outwardly appear to align with one gender but have internal reproductive organs that do not correspond to their external appearance.
  • πŸ’‰ Medical procedures such as hormone replacement therapy and surgeries are not without risks and can significantly impact the quality of life for intersex individuals.
  • πŸ€” The script raises questions about the ethics of performing surgeries on intersex infants and children, with some arguing for a more cautious approach that respects the individual's right to self-determination.
  • 🌈 Intersex advocates argue for greater visibility and understanding, challenging societal norms and advocating for a broader recognition of gender diversity.
  • πŸ‘¨β€πŸ‘§β€πŸ‘¦ The experiences of the families in the script highlight the importance of open communication and support in helping intersex children navigate their unique challenges.
  • πŸ”‘ The script emphasizes the need for ongoing medical care and potential further surgeries for many intersex individuals, illustrating the lifelong nature of managing these conditions.
Q & A
  • What is the approximate rate at which intersex children are born in Britain each year?

    -Intersex children are born at a rate of around one in 4,000 babies each year in Britain.

  • What is the medical term for individuals with anatomical features of both sexes?

    -Individuals with anatomical features of both sexes are medically defined as 'intersex'.

  • What is the condition that Illa was diagnosed with at nine months old?

    -Illa was diagnosed with Complete Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (CAIS), a rare intersex condition where the body is unable to respond to the male hormone, testosterone.

  • What are the physical characteristics of individuals with Complete Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (CAIS)?

    -Individuals with CAIS look female and most have a vagina, but internally where reproductive organs should be, they have testes instead of ovaries, and there is no uterus.

  • Why did doctors traditionally advise parents to keep a diagnosis of intersexuality a secret?

    -Doctors traditionally advised parents to keep a diagnosis of intersexuality a secret due to the stigma and lack of understanding surrounding the condition.

  • What is the dilemma faced by individuals with AIS regarding their testes?

    -The dilemma faced by individuals with AIS regarding their testes is whether to have them removed due to a risk of cancer in later life and to reinforce their female identity, or to keep them as they produce estrogen and testosterone, which would otherwise require hormone replacement therapy.

  • What is the inheritance pattern of Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS)?

    -AIS is an inherited condition passed along the maternal line.

  • What is the intersex condition that Louise was born with, and how was it initially treated?

    -Louise was born with true hermaphroditism, an extremely rare intersex condition with parts of testes and ovaries inside. Initially, her genitalia were underdeveloped, and she was raised as a female after doctors advised surgery to create a vagina and remove her ovary and testes.

  • What is Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia (CAH), and how is it different from AIS?

    -Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia (CAH) is an inherited intersex condition where the body produces too much testosterone, causing female babies to have some male characteristics. Unlike AIS, girls with CAH have female chromosomes and ovaries but may have an enlarged clitoris and an incompletely formed vagina.

  • What is the current debate regarding surgical intervention for intersex children with CAH?

    -The current debate is about the necessity and timing of surgical intervention for intersex children with CAH. Some argue that surgery should be delayed until puberty or avoided altogether, while others believe early surgery is necessary to ensure a 'normal' life.

  • What is the impact of being raised without knowledge of one's intersex condition, as was the case with Louise?

    -Being raised without knowledge of one's intersex condition can lead to feelings of confusion, isolation, and identity struggles. Louise experienced behavioral issues and a sense of loneliness, which were exacerbated by the secrecy surrounding her condition.

  • What is the current medical approach to treating intersex conditions, and what are the challenges?

    -The current medical approach to treating intersex conditions is more cautious and considers the individual's psychological well-being. Challenges include a lack of evidence-based guidelines, the need for individualized treatment plans, and the potential for surgery to impact sexual function and identity.

Outlines
00:00
🌟 Intersex Identities and Challenges

This paragraph introduces the concept of intersex individuals, who possess anatomical features of both sexes and are born at a rate of about one in 4,000 in Britain. It discusses the personal experiences and self-perception of an intersex person who doesn't identify strictly as male or female. The paragraph also touches on the historical secrecy and taboo surrounding intersexuality and the recent emergence of passionate debates about the treatment and societal perception of intersex individuals. The narrative follows three families with intersex children, exploring the complexities of growing up neither distinctly male nor female.

05:00
πŸ” Medical Insights on Intersexuality

The second paragraph delves into the medical aspects of intersexuality, focusing on conditions such as Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS) and the physical characteristics of individuals with this condition. It discusses the internal anatomy of intersex individuals, highlighting the presence of testes instead of ovaries and the lack of typical male or female genitalia. The paragraph also addresses the traditional medical advice to keep intersexuality a secret and the personal journey of a family that chose to be open about their child's condition, including the potential medical interventions such as the removal of testes to reinforce a female identity.

10:05
πŸ‘Ά Raising Intersex Children: Louise's Story

This paragraph tells the story of Louise, who was born with true hermaphroditism, an extremely rare intersex condition. It describes the medical decisions made during her infancy, including the choice to raise her as a female despite her having both testes and ovaries. The narrative explores the impact of this decision on Louise's upbringing and her struggle with gender identity and societal norms. It also touches on the emotional turmoil Louise experienced, her feelings of loneliness, and the challenges she faced in her behavior and social interactions.

15:05
πŸ₯ Surgical Interventions and Ethical Dilemmas

The fourth paragraph discusses the ethical dilemmas and medical interventions associated with intersexuality, particularly in the case of congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH). It describes the physical characteristics of individuals with CAH and the historical medical practice of performing surgeries to feminize or masculinize the genitalia of intersex infants. The paragraph presents the case of Bianca, who has CAH, and the decision-making process her parents and doctors faced regarding surgery, highlighting the evolving medical opinion on the timing and necessity of such procedures.

20:08
πŸ“‰ Shifting Medical Practices and Patient Autonomy

This paragraph examines the historical shift in medical practices regarding intersex conditions, moving away from early surgical interventions towards a more patient-centered approach. It reflects on the lack of evidence to support the new approach and the uncertainty of its long-term outcomes. The narrative also includes the perspectives of medical professionals and intersex activists, who advocate for less aggressive treatments and for allowing intersex individuals to make their own decisions about medical interventions when they are older.

25:10
🌈 Exploring Gender Identity and Expression

The sixth paragraph explores the impact of intersexuality on gender identity and expression, particularly in children. It discusses the case of Ellis and Xenia, who have AIS, and how their outward appearance and interests may not align with societal gender norms. The paragraph highlights the importance of understanding and accepting intersex individuals' self-identified gender, whether it aligns with traditional male or female categories or exists as a neutral or intersex identity.

30:16
πŸ€” Navigating Social Perceptions and Personal Realities

This paragraph delves into the social perceptions and personal experiences of intersex individuals. It discusses the societal binary view of gender and how intersex people challenge this norm. The narrative includes personal reflections from intersex individuals on how they disclose their intersexuality to others and the reactions they receive, emphasizing the importance of openness and understanding in overcoming societal misconceptions.

35:22
🏠 Family Dynamics and Decision-Making

The seventh paragraph examines the family dynamics and decision-making processes surrounding the upbringing of intersex children. It presents the case of Louise, who was raised without knowledge of her true condition, and the contrasting approach of her mother, Luiz, who allowed her daughter to access her medical records. The narrative explores the complexities of these decisions and the impact on the individuals involved, including the emotional and psychological effects on both the parents and the intersex children.

40:24
πŸ›  Surgical Outcomes and Lifelong Management

This paragraph discusses the outcomes and challenges of surgical interventions for intersex conditions, focusing on the case of Bianca, who underwent surgery to construct a vagina. It highlights the success of the surgery and the need for lifelong management due to her condition's effects on hormone production. The narrative also touches on the potential need for further surgeries in the future and the importance of providing intersex individuals with the autonomy to make their own decisions about their medical care.

45:36
πŸ’” The Struggle for Wholeness and Identity

The eighth paragraph presents the emotional journey of Louise, who underwent unsuccessful surgery to construct a vagina and is now considering a second operation. It explores her feelings of incompleteness and her desire to feel whole as a person. The narrative discusses the complexities of the surgery, the medical challenges due to Louise's unique physiology, and the uncertain outcomes in terms of sexual function and sensation.

πŸ‘©β€β€οΈβ€πŸ‘¨ Intersex Life and Relationships

The final paragraph addresses the personal life and relationships of intersex individuals, focusing on their experiences with romantic relationships and societal perceptions. It discusses the case of an intersex person who is open about their condition and how it affects their interactions with potential partners. The narrative also touches on the individual's thoughts on future relationships, family planning, and their personal aspirations, emphasizing resilience and a positive outlook despite the challenges faced.

🎭 Aspirations and Acceptance

This paragraph concludes the script by highlighting the aspirations and acceptance of intersex individuals. It discusses the individual's interest in pursuing a career in performing arts or genetics, reflecting their passion for self-expression and their love for biology. The narrative emphasizes the importance of embracing one's true self and the individual's determination to live life authentically, regardless of societal expectations or limitations.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘Intersex
Intersex refers to individuals who are born with reproductive or sexual anatomy that doesn't fit typical binary notions of male or female bodies. In the video, intersex individuals are portrayed with a range of experiences and conditions, such as Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS) and Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia (CAH), highlighting the diversity within this group and the challenges they face in a society that often struggles to recognize and accept their identities.
πŸ’‘Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS)
Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome is a rare intersex condition where an individual's body is unable to respond to the male hormone testosterone, leading to the development of typically female external genitalia despite having male XY chromosomes. The script mentions individuals with AIS who are raised as girls, yet they have testes instead of ovaries, illustrating the complexity of their physical and social identities.
πŸ’‘Hermaphroditism
Hermaphroditism is an outdated term that was historically used to describe individuals with both male and female reproductive organs. The video script uses this term to reference the past medical understanding and treatment of intersex conditions, reflecting the evolution of language and attitudes towards intersex individuals.
πŸ’‘Gender Identity
Gender identity is a person's internal sense of being male, female, or something else. The video explores how intersex individuals may have a gender identity that is different from or does not fit within the binary male/female construct, as seen in the experiences of individuals with AIS who may identify as more female than male, or as intersex.
πŸ’‘Sex Development
Sex development refers to the process by which an individual's sex characteristics, including genitalia, develop during embryonic and fetal growth. The video discusses atypical sex development in intersex individuals, such as those with AIS or CAH, where the typical male or female development pathways are altered, leading to a range of physical characteristics.
πŸ’‘Medical Intervention
Medical intervention in the context of the video refers to the surgical and hormonal treatments that intersex individuals may undergo. The script discusses the history of early surgical interventions to 'normalize' the appearance of intersex individuals' genitalia, as well as the evolving medical perspectives on the necessity and timing of such interventions.
πŸ’‘Secrecy and Taboo
Secrecy and taboo are themes in the video that reflect the historical stigma and lack of understanding surrounding intersex conditions. The script describes how intersex individuals were often kept secret from society and even from themselves, highlighting the social and personal impact of these attitudes.
πŸ’‘Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia (CAH)
Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia is an inherited intersex condition that affects the development of the reproductive system, often resulting in ambiguous genitalia in females. The video script discusses the treatment dilemmas for individuals with CAH, such as the decision to perform surgery to feminize the genitalia, and the potential impact on their sexual function.
πŸ’‘Feminizing Surgery
Feminizing surgery is a type of medical intervention aimed at making an individual's genitalia appear more female. The video script mentions the use of feminizing surgery in intersex individuals with CAH, discussing the ethical and medical considerations of performing such surgery, especially in early childhood.
πŸ’‘Vaginoplasty
Vaginoplasty is a surgical procedure to construct or modify a vagina. The video script describes the complex vaginoplasty performed on Louise, an intersex individual, to create a vagina despite her unique physiology and previous unsuccessful attempts, illustrating the medical challenges and personal significance of such surgeries.
πŸ’‘Self-Identification
Self-identification is the process by which individuals define their own gender identity. The video script emphasizes the importance of allowing intersex individuals to self-identify, suggesting that decisions about gender assignment should be made by the individual when they are old enough to understand their condition and make an informed choice.
Highlights

Intersex individuals are born with anatomical features of both sexes, challenging the conventional binary understanding of gender.

Intersex conditions like Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome (AIS) and Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia (CAH) are explained, highlighting their impact on gender identity.

The film follows three families with intersex children, exploring the complexities of growing up with an intersex condition.

Intersex people have historically been subjected to secrecy and taboo, but are now beginning to speak out and challenge societal norms.

Medical interventions for intersex conditions, such as surgery and hormone therapy, are debated in terms of necessity and timing.

The importance of open communication and support for intersex children is emphasized, as they navigate their unique identities.

The role of parents in making medical decisions for intersex children, including the ethical considerations of early surgeries.

The debate over whether early surgical intervention is beneficial or harmful to intersex individuals' long-term well-being.

Personal stories of intersex individuals who have undergone surgeries, discussing the outcomes and their impact on identity and sexuality.

The psychological impact of growing up intersex, including feelings of isolation, confusion, and the struggle for acceptance.

The medical community's evolving approach to treating intersex conditions, with a shift towards less invasive procedures.

The ethical dilemma of assigning gender to intersex newborns and the potential consequences of these decisions.

The experiences of intersex individuals in relationships and society, and the challenges they face in terms of acceptance and understanding.

The film showcases the resilience and self-acceptance of intersex individuals, as they define their own identities and advocate for visibility.

The ongoing medical and societal debate about the best practices for treating and supporting intersex individuals.

Personal reflections on the potential impact of different upbringings on intersex individuals' sense of self and well-being.

The film concludes with a call for greater understanding and respect for the diverse experiences of intersex individuals.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: