What if POLAND Won WW2? Animated Alternate History

Videntis
15 Jul 202329:01
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis historical narrative explores an alternate post-WWI scenario where Poland, under Józef Piłsudski, forms the Intermarium, a federation of Eastern European nations, to counterbalance Russian and German influence. Despite initial challenges, the Intermarium prospers, leading to a pivotal role in World War II. The federation's unity and military strength prevent Soviet and Nazi domination, ultimately shaping a new Europe based on cooperation and stability. The video delves into the political, economic, and military intricacies of this alternate history, highlighting the Intermarium's impact on global affairs.

Takeaways
  • 🇵🇱 After World War I, Poland regained independence and Józef Piłsudski emerged as a key figure, envisioning the Intermarium federation to ensure Eastern European nations' independence from Russia and Germany.
  • 🛡️ Poland faced multiple wars to secure its borders and survival, including the Polish-Soviet War, which saw a miraculous defeat of Soviet forces led by Piłsudski, saving Europe from communism.
  • 🔄 Despite Piłsudski's efforts, political enemies led to the abandonment of the Intermarium concept, and Eastern European nations including Ukraine and Belarus fell under communist rule.
  • 🗽 Piłsudski's military coup in 1926 aimed to rebuild Poland, but his reign ended with his death in 1935, leaving the Second Polish Republic to face economic challenges and threats from growing powers, Germany and the Soviet Union.
  • 📜 The Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact of 1939 resulted in the joint invasion and annexation of Poland by Germany and the Soviet Union, ending the 2nd Polish Republic.
  • 🌍 An alternate timeline is presented where the Intermarium succeeds, leading to a strong, united Eastern Europe that serves as a bulwark against aggression, with Poland, the Baltics, Belarus, and Ukraine forming a federation with unique governance.
  • 🏰 The Intermarium's success in this alternate history hinges on a stronger victory against the Soviet Union, leading to territorial expansion and influence over liberated nations, fostering economic cooperation and a formidable military.
  • ⚔️ World War II in this alternate timeline sees the Intermarium and Allies facing off against the Axis powers led by Germany and the Soviet Union, with significant battles and shifting alliances shaping the conflict.
  • 🏗️ Post-war, the Intermarium focuses on reconstruction and industrial revitalization, with the division and reallocation of territories and power in Europe, aiming to prevent the resurgence of aggressive ideologies.
  • 🌐 The Budapest Agreement determines the borders of Eastern Europe, with Russia divided into separate entities, and the Intermarium transforming into a multinational federation promoting stability and cooperation.
  • 🕊️ The Intermarium's vision reshapes Europe, leading to a new reality focused on peace, unity, and prosperity, with the member nations looking towards a promising future.
Q & A
  • What was Józef Piłsudski's vision for Poland and Eastern Europe after World War I?

    -Józef Piłsudski envisioned the creation of Międzymorze, also known as the Intermarium, a federation of Eastern European nations aimed at ensuring their collective independence from Russia and Germany.

  • What were some of the challenges Poland faced in securing its borders and survival after regaining independence?

    -Poland faced numerous challenges including the Polish-Ukrainian War, the Greater Poland Uprising, the Polish-Czechoslovak War, and the Silesian Uprisings. These conflicts were crucial in shaping Poland's borders and ensuring its survival.

  • How did the Polish-Soviet War contribute to the geopolitical landscape of Europe in the early 20th century?

    -The Polish-Soviet War, which took place from October 1920 to March 1921, was significant as it prevented the spread of communism into the rest of Europe. Piłsudski's leadership enabled the Polish army to defeat the Soviets, thus saving Poland and potentially the rest of Europe from communist influence.

  • What was the impact of the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact on Poland?

    -The Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, signed in 1939 between Germany and the Soviet Union, led to the joint invasion of Poland. This resulted in the annexation and division of Poland between the invaders, marking the end of the 2nd Polish Republic.

  • How did the Intermarium federation modernize and strengthen its position in the 1930s?

    -The Intermarium federation modernized by integrating various allied nations, benefiting from the knowledge of expelled Jewish scientists and engineers, and developing a formidable military force. It also experienced rapid economic growth, becoming the largest in Europe by 1936, fueled by industrialization and the development of rail networks.

  • What was the significance of the Battle of Stalingrad in the context of the Intermarium's conflict with the Soviet Union?

    -The Battle of Stalingrad was a turning point in the conflict, involving combined forces from the entire Międzymorze. Lasting from May to November, it resulted in a devastating defeat for the Soviets, severely crippling their forces and leading to anti-Soviet uprisings in Georgia, Armenia, and Azerbaijan.

  • How did the division of Germany after World War II contribute to the stability of Europe according to the script?

    -The division of Germany into separate nations, such as the Commonwealth of Hanover-Westphalia, the Catholic Republic of Austria-Bavaria, and the Federal Republic of Prussia, was aimed at preventing any resurgence of a unified German state that could threaten European stability.

  • What role did the United States play in the Pacific during World War II in this alternate timeline?

    -In this alternate timeline, the United States focused its efforts on the Pacific front, redirecting a significant air force to bomb Japanese cities and concentrating more troops in the region. The lend-lease system also favored Nationalist China, which contributed to the defeat of Japan and prevented the rise of the Communist Party in China.

  • How did the Intermarium's approach towards Prussia differ from their approach towards Germany after World War II?

    -The Intermarium treated the newly formed Prussian state, led by Chancellor Tresckow, as a puppet state of Poland-Lithuania, acknowledging Prussia's rejection of the former fascist German government. They granted Prussia part of the Polish Corridor and allowed them to retain some historic Prussian lands, promoting reconciliation and a new narrative beyond the destructive aspects of German identity.

  • What were the key outcomes of the Budapest Agreement for the Intermarium and Eastern Europe?

    -The Budapest Agreement resulted in the division of Russia into three distinct nations and the expansion of the Intermarium into a multinational entity. It included the division of Russia into the Confederation of Russian States, the Republic of Novgorod, and the Volgograd Commonwealth, as well as the annexation of territories by China and the independence of several Central Asian states.

Outlines
00:00
🏰 Post-WWI Poland and the Intermarium Concept

After regaining independence post-World War I, Poland faced numerous challenges including securing its borders through various wars such as the Polish-Ukrainian War and the Greater Poland Uprising. Józef Piłsudski, a key figure, envisioned Międzymorze, or the Intermarium, a federation of Eastern European nations aimed at ensuring collective independence from Russia and Germany. Despite military successes, political turmoil led to Piłsudski's 1926 coup and his efforts to streamline the country. The Second Polish Republic introduced a new currency in 1924, leading to economic stability despite trade issues. However, threats from Germany and the Soviet Union grew, culminating in the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact and the invasion and annexation of Poland in 1939. The video also discusses an alternate historical scenario where Poland's victory against the Soviet Union leads to a stronger Intermarium federation, influencing Eastern Europe to unite against shared security threats.

05:01
🛤️ The Rise of the Intermarium Federation

The Intermarium federation, including Poland, the Baltics, Belarus, and Ukraine, emerged in 1923 with a unique governance system combining a strong central government with local autonomy. The federation's parliament, the Sejm, elected a leader and set federal objectives, receiving support from France and England, particularly in military technology. The Ukrainians convinced the French to extend the Maginot Line to the Atlantic. The federation modernized quickly, taking advantage of political instability in Romania and orchestrating revolts that led to territorial gains. The Treaty of Visegrád in 1927 brought Czechoslovakia and Hungary into the Intermarium, and Romania joined after a revolt in 1931. Lithuania integrated into Poland in 1932, and by 1933, free movement was allowed throughout the federation. The Intermarium's economy grew rapidly by 1936, becoming the largest in Europe, fueled by industrialization, rail network development, and contributions from Jewish refugees.

10:04
🗡️ World War II: Intermarium's Struggle and Victories

World War II began with the Intermarium, the United Kingdom, and France as the Allies facing off against the Axis powers led by Germany and the Soviet Union. Germany's initial advances into Poland were met with strong resistance, and the Blitzkrieg strategy faltered. The Intermarium forces held their ground, causing heavy losses for the Germans. The Soviet Union's invasion of Ukraine was initially successful, but the Soviets later suffered defeats at Kiev and other locations. The Winter War between Finland and the Soviet Union did not occur, and Finland joined the Allies. The Baltic region became a battleground, with Estonia successfully resisting the Soviet invasion. By 1940, the Soviet advance across Belarus was halted, and the Soviets suffered significant losses. The Intermarium also experienced victories in Ukraine and Belarus, and the Battle of Stalingrad resulted in a devastating defeat for the Soviets, leading to anti-Soviet uprisings in Georgia, Armenia, and Azerbaijan.

15:06
⚔️ The Decisive Battles and the Fall of Germany

The Polish-Lithuanian army achieved a major victory at the Battle of Danzig, leading to significant German losses and near-total city destruction. Polish forces continued their offensive, reclaiming key cities and causing dissent among German troops. The Wehrmacht turned against the SS, and Intermarium forces advanced, capturing several cities. The fall of Frankfurt in November marked Hitler's self-inflicted demise, and Henning von Tresckow was appointed provisional head of state by the Wehrmacht Provisional Government. The Czech offensive continued, and an agreement was reached between the Intermarium and Tresckow, leading to Germany's partition and the signing of the Treaty of Kalisz. The Allies advanced, capturing key German cities and forcing the SS to abandon their cause. The British continued their strategic bombing campaign, and by the year's end, Germany had suffered heavy losses, and their grip on the war began to crumble.

20:07
🏛️ The Post-War Reconfiguration of Europe

After World War II, the borders of Eastern Europe were determined through the Budapest Agreement. The Intermarium nations advocated for the division of Russia into separate entities to prevent future aggression. Prussia joined the Intermarium and experienced significant prosperity, becoming a major military industrial leader within the alliance. Russia was divided into three distinct nations, with the Confederation of Russian States, the Republic of Novgorod, and the Volgograd Commonwealth each having different levels of autonomy and alliances. China took advantage of the situation and annexed lands in eastern Russia and Mongolia, expanding its influence. Several states gained independence from Russia, and the Międzymorze transformed into a multinational entity, including various nations. The Intermarium aimed to foster stability, cooperation, and reconciliation among its member states and the wider European region.

25:08
🌏 The New World Order and the Intermarium's Legacy

The video concludes by discussing the new reality shaped by the Intermarium's vision, focusing on reconstruction, industrial revitalization, and policies for stability and prosperity. The collective efforts of the Intermarium toppled oppressive regimes and demonstrated that peace, unity, and cooperation among nations were crucial for a better future. The future of the Intermarium remained uncertain, but the shared spirit, determination, and values of its member nations pointed towards a promising path ahead, instilling hope for a better and more prosperous tomorrow. The video invites viewers to share their thoughts and suggests a Part 2 if the video receives enough engagement.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Międzymorze
Międzymorze, also known as the Intermarium, refers to a historical concept for a federation of Eastern European nations proposed by Józef Piłsudski. It was intended to act as a buffer zone between Germany and Russia, ensuring the collective independence of the countries involved. In the video's narrative, Międzymorze represents the core idea around which the alternate history of Eastern Europe is built, with Poland at its center, aiming to create a united front against external threats.
💡Józef Piłsudski
Józef Piłsudski was a Polish statesman and revolutionary who played a central role in the reestablishment of an independent Poland in 1918. He is a key figure in the video's script as the leader who envisioned the Międzymorze federation and led Poland during the Polish-Soviet War, which was a critical conflict in shaping Poland's borders and influence in the region.
💡Polish-Soviet War
The Polish-Soviet War, which took place from 1919 to 1921, was a significant conflict between Poland and Soviet Russia. In the script, this war is highlighted as a pivotal moment where Piłsudski's leadership led to a surprising defeat of the Soviet forces advancing towards Warsaw, which is portrayed as a crucial event that could have shaped the fate of Europe.
💡Second Polish Republic
The Second Polish Republic refers to the country of Poland from 1918 to 1939. In the video, it is depicted as a period of economic and political challenges for Poland, but also as a time when Poland began to stabilize with the introduction of a new currency and despite trade issues with its neighbors, Germany and the Soviet Union.
💡Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact
The Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, also known as the Nazi-Soviet Non-Aggression Pact, was a real-life agreement signed in 1939 between Germany and the Soviet Union. In the video's alternate history, the pact is mentioned as the precursor to the joint invasion and partition of Poland, leading to the end of the Second Polish Republic.
💡Intermarium Federation
The Intermarium Federation in the script represents an alternate historical development where the Międzymorze concept materializes into a real political entity. It includes Poland, the Baltic States, Belarus, and Ukraine, and is characterized by a unique governance system with a strong central government and local autonomy. This federation is portrayed as a symbol of freedom and a bulwark against aggression in Eastern Europe.
💡Treaty of Visegrád
The Treaty of Visegrád mentioned in the script refers to an agreement that brought Czechoslovakia and Hungary into the Intermarium federation. This is an example of the diplomatic and alliance-building efforts that the video suggests could have strengthened the Międzymorze concept and its member states.
💡Eastern Front
The Eastern Front in the context of the video refers to the theater of war between the Intermarium and the Soviet Union during the alternate World War II scenario. It is depicted as a critical battleground where intense fighting led to significant victories for the Intermarium, ultimately contributing to the weakening and collapse of the Soviet Union.
💡Budapest Agreement
The Budapest Agreement in the script represents a set of post-war negotiations that determined the borders of Eastern Europe. It signifies the establishment of a new political order in the region, with the Międzymorze playing a central role in shaping the outcome and ensuring stability and cooperation among its member states.
💡Nationalist China
Nationalist China, led by Chiang Kai-shek, is portrayed in the video as a significant beneficiary of American aid through the lend-lease system in this alternate timeline. This support enabled Nationalist China to resist and defeat the Japanese armies and to prevent the rise of the Communist Party, thus altering the political landscape of Asia and averting conflicts such as the Korean and Vietnam Wars.
💡Prussia
In the video's narrative, Prussia is depicted as a key player in the Intermarium alliance, having joined and experienced significant prosperity. It is portrayed as a technologically advanced German state and a military industrial leader, which rejected a nationalistic German identity in favor of its distinct Prussian heritage. The revival of Prussian identity is presented as a strategic move to limit German nationalism and promote regional stability.
Highlights

Poland regained independence after World War I and Józef Piłsudski emerged as a key figure, envisioning the Intermarium federation for collective independence from Russia and Germany.

Poland faced numerous post-independence challenges, including the Polish-Ukrainian War and the Greater Poland uprising, securing borders and territories.

The Polish-Soviet War from 1920 to 1921 was a pivotal conflict where Piłsudski's leadership defeated the Soviets, saving Europe from communism.

Internal political turmoil in Poland led to Piłsudski's military coup in 1926, aiming to rebuild and streamline the country.

The Second Polish Republic introduced a new currency in 1924 to stabilize the economy despite trade issues with Germany and the Soviet Union.

Germany and the Soviet Union's threats to Poland culminated in the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact and the joint invasion of Poland in 1939.

An alternate timeline envisions a stronger Intermarium alliance with Poland at its helm, fostering unity and deterring German and Soviet aggression.

In this alternate history, the Intermarium modernizes and expands, including the Treaty of Visegrád and the integration of Czechoslovakia and Hungary.

The Intermarium's economy and military grow formidable through industrialization, rail development, and contributions from Jewish refugees.

Germany and the Soviet Union form the Berlin-Moscow Axis, initiating World War II against the Intermarium and its allies.

The Intermarium successfully defends against German and Soviet invasions, leading to the defeat of both powers and the end of the war.

Post-war, the Intermarium reshapes Europe, advocating for the division of Germany and Russia to prevent resurgence of aggressive ideologies.

The Federal Republic of Prussia emerges as a significant nation within the Intermarium, rejecting nationalistic German identity.

The Soviet Union surrenders in 1949, leading to the worldwide eradication of communism, with China playing a crucial role in this outcome.

The Budapest Agreement determines the borders of Eastern Europe, creating a multinational Intermarium federation.

The Intermarium's vision focuses on reconstruction, industrial revitalization, and policies for stability and prosperity, shaping a new reality for Europe.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: