The Math of Bubbles // Minimal Surfaces & the Calculus of Variations #SoME3

Dr. Trefor Bazett
17 Aug 202317:27
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThis video script delves into the fascinating world of minimal surfaces, exemplified by the catanoidโ€”a surface formed when two rings are dipped into a bubble solution. The speaker explores the mathematical concept of minimal surfaces using calculus of variations, focusing on how to derive these surfaces given a boundary. The example of a helix creating a helicoid is highlighted, and the process involves finding the function that, when revolved around the x-axis, yields the smallest surface area. The Euler-Lagrange equation is introduced as a powerful tool for solving such problems, with the specific application of finding a hyperbolic cosine function that connects two circles with the least surface area. The video concludes with a discussion on the limitations of minimal surfaces and an invitation to explore further the rich field of minimal surfaces.

Takeaways
  • ๐Ÿงผ The video discusses the concept of minimal surfaces, such as a catenoid formed by dipping two rings into a bubble solution.
  • ๐Ÿ“ The mathematical study of minimal surfaces involves finding the surface with the least area given a specific boundary, using the calculus of variations.
  • ๐Ÿ” The example of two parallel rings is used to illustrate the problem, where the goal is to determine the shape with the smallest surface area that connects the rings.
  • ๐Ÿ“‰ The video refutes the common assumption that a cylinder is the minimal surface solution, by explaining that a narrower middle portion could reduce the surface area.
  • ๐ŸŒ€ The problem is simplified by assuming circular symmetry in the bubble's shape, which allows the use of a curve revolving around the x-axis to model the surface.
  • ๐Ÿ“ˆ The surface area of a curve revolved around the x-axis is calculated using the integral of \(2\pi f(x) \sqrt{1 + (f'(x))^2}\), where \(f(x)\) is the function describing the curve.
  • ๐Ÿ”ง The calculus of variations is introduced as a technique to find the function \(f(x)\) that minimizes the surface area, treating functions as the input rather than specific points.
  • ๐Ÿคน The Euler-Lagrange equation, derived from the calculus of variations, is used to find the function that minimizes the integral expression representing the surface area.
  • ๐Ÿ”„ The process involves considering small perturbations of the function \(f(x)\) and setting the derivative of the resulting expression with respect to the perturbation parameter to zero.
  • โš™๏ธ The specific example of the bubble surface problem leads to a hyperbolic cosine function for \(f(x)\), which minimizes the surface area for given boundary circles.
  • ๐Ÿ”— The video concludes by noting that different boundaries can create a variety of minimal surfaces, and the catenoid is just one example of such surfaces.
Q & A
  • What is a catanoid and how is it formed?

    -A catanoid is a minimal surface that forms when two rings are dipped into a bubble solution. It is created due to the surface tension trying to minimize the surface area, and it can be mathematically described using the principles of calculus of variations.

  • What is the mathematical study of finding the shape of a bubble given a boundary?

    -The study of finding the shape of a bubble given a boundary is known as the study of minimal surfaces. It involves determining which surface, among all possible surfaces with a given boundary, has the least surface area.

  • Why might a cylinder not be the optimal shape for a bubble between two rings?

    -A cylinder might not be the optimal shape for a bubble between two rings because it has an inefficiency in the middle portion. Making the middle portion narrower could reduce the circumference and thus decrease the overall surface area.

  • What is the calculus of variations and how is it used to derive minimal surfaces?

    -The calculus of variations is a mathematical technique used to find the function that minimizes or maximizes a certain quantity. In the context of minimal surfaces, it is used to derive the shape of a surface that minimizes the surface area given a boundary.

  • What is the significance of assuming circular symmetry in the problem of finding minimal surfaces?

    -Assuming circular symmetry simplifies the problem by reducing it to finding a curve in the X-Y plane that, when rotated around the x-axis, forms a surface of revolution with the smallest possible surface area.

  • What is the formula used to compute the surface area formed when a function is revolved around the x-axis?

    -The formula used to compute the surface area when a function is revolved around the x-axis is the integral of 2ฯ€ times the function (f(x)) times the square root of 1 plus the derivative of the function squared (1 + (f'(x))^2).

  • What is a functional in the context of calculus?

    -A functional in calculus is an expression that takes a function as its input and produces a number as its output. It is used in the calculus of variations to represent the quantity that needs to be minimized or maximized.

  • How does the Euler-Lagrange equation relate to finding minimal surfaces?

    -The Euler-Lagrange equation is used in the calculus of variations to find the function that minimizes or maximizes a given functional. In the context of minimal surfaces, it helps to determine the shape of the surface that minimizes the surface area.

  • What is the physical interpretation of the Euler-Lagrange equation in the context of minimal surfaces?

    -The Euler-Lagrange equation states that for a surface to be minimal, the partial derivative of the Lagrangian with respect to the function (f) minus the derivative with respect to x of the partial derivative of the Lagrangian with respect to the derivative of the function (f') must be zero.

  • How does the video script demonstrate the application of the calculus of variations to a specific example?

    -The script demonstrates the application of the calculus of variations by considering a specific example of finding the minimal surface area between two parallel rings. It guides through the process of setting up the problem, applying the Euler-Lagrange equation, and solving it to find the function that describes the minimal surface.

Outlines
00:00
๐Ÿ” Introduction to Minimal Surfaces and Calculus of Variations

The video begins by exploring the concept of minimal surfaces, such as the catanoid formed when dipping two rings into a bubble solution. The mathematical challenge is to determine the shape of a bubble given a specific boundary, which is the essence of the study of minimal surfaces. The presenter demonstrates the use of a helix to create a helicoid shape and introduces the calculus of variations as a technique to derive these surfaces. The focus is on finding the surface with the least area between two parallel rings, which is simplified by assuming circular symmetry. The problem is reformulated to find the curve or function that, when rotated around the x-axis, yields the smallest surface area. A formula for computing the surface area of a function revolved around the x-axis is provided, and the concept of functionals is introduced as a function that takes other functions as input.

05:01
๐Ÿ“ Applying the Calculus of Variations to Find Minimal Surfaces

The video continues by delving into the calculus of variations, a mathematical framework for finding functions that minimize a certain integral. The presenter illustrates this with the example of a function f(x) that minimizes a given integral expression. To find such a function, the video describes a method of perturbing f(x) and considering the resulting changes. A new function G(x) is defined as a sum of the original function f(x) and a perturbation function P(x), scaled by a small factor epsilon. The integral expression is then evaluated for G(x), resulting in a function Phi of epsilon. The minimization property is applied, setting the derivative of Phi with respect to epsilon to zero. This leads to the use of the multivariable chain rule to find the derivative of the Lagrangian, a function that depends on the independent variable x, the function f(x), and its derivative. The video concludes this section by emphasizing the generality of the approach, noting that many interesting Lagrangians come from physics.

10:01
๐Ÿงฎ Solving the Euler-Lagrange Equation for a Specific Lagrangian

The presenter then focuses on solving the Euler-Lagrange equation, which is derived from the calculus of variations and is key to finding the function that minimizes the integral. The specific Lagrangian from the surface area formula is used, and the partial derivatives with respect to the function and its derivative are computed. The process simplifies the equation and leads to an integral that must equal a constant. The video demonstrates how to isolate the derivative of the function, integrate both sides, and recognize the resulting expression as the inverse of hyperbolic cosines. The constants from the integration are discussed, and the function f(x) is expressed in terms of these constants.

15:02
๐Ÿ”— Matching the Solution to the Given Boundary and Discussing the Physical Limitations

The video concludes with the application of the derived function to match a specific pair of circles, which represent the boundary of the bubble. The constants in the hyperbolic cosine expression are adjusted to fit the boundary conditions. The presenter uses numerical approximation to demonstrate how the function can be made to fit the given circles. However, it is noted that if the circles are too small or too far apart, it may not be possible to find a matching bubble shape, leading to a physical limitation where the bubble would 'pop' and result in two flat discs. The video wraps up by stating that the catanoid, formed by revolving the hyperbolic cosine function around the x-axis, represents the minimal surface area for the given boundary. The presenter acknowledges the vastness of the topic of minimal surfaces and encourages viewers to explore further.

Mindmap
Keywords
๐Ÿ’กCatanoid
A catanoid is a type of minimal surface that forms when a soap film spans between two rings. In the context of the video, the catanoid is the fascinating bubble surface created by dipping two rings into a bubble solution. It represents a physical manifestation of the mathematical concept of minimal surfaces, which the video aims to explore and explain.
๐Ÿ’กMinimal Surface
A minimal surface is a surface that has the least possible surface area for a given boundary. The video discusses this concept in relation to soap bubbles and how they form surfaces with the least area between given boundaries, like rings. The catanoid mentioned is an example of a minimal surface, and the video delves into the mathematical process of determining such surfaces.
๐Ÿ’กCalculus of Variations
The calculus of variations is a mathematical technique used to find the function that minimizes or maximizes a certain quantity. In the video, this technique is used to derive the shape of minimal surfaces. It is a powerful tool that helps in solving optimization problems, such as finding the surface with the least area, which is central to the video's theme.
๐Ÿ’กSurface of Revolution
A surface of revolution is created by rotating a curve around an axis. In the video, the concept is used to simplify the problem of finding minimal surfaces by assuming that the soap bubble's surface has circular symmetry and can be generated by revolving a curve around the x-axis. This allows the problem to be tackled using integral calculus.
๐Ÿ’กFunctional
In the context of the video, a functional is an expression that takes a function as its input and produces a number as its output. The video explains how functionals are used in the calculus of variations to represent the surface area of a soap bubble for a given function describing the shape of the bubble's boundary.
๐Ÿ’กLagrangian
A Lagrangian in the video is a function that depends on an independent variable, a function, and the derivative of that function. It is used in the calculus of variations to formulate the problem of finding minimal surfaces. The specific Lagrangian for the soap bubble problem involves the function describing the bubble's shape and its derivative.
๐Ÿ’กEuler-Lagrange Equation
The Euler-Lagrange equation is a key result from the calculus of variations that provides a necessary condition for a function to be a minimum or maximum. In the video, this equation is derived and used to find the function that describes the shape of the minimal surface, specifically the catanoid formed by revolving a curve around the x-axis.
๐Ÿ’กHyperbolic Cosine
The hyperbolic cosine is a mathematical function that appears in the solution to the Euler-Lagrange equation for the soap bubble problem. In the video, the shape of the minimal surface that connects two rings is found to be related to the inverse hyperbolic cosine function, which describes the curve that, when revolved, forms the minimal surface.
๐Ÿ’กPerturbation
In the calculus of variations, a perturbation is a small change or variation made to a function to test whether it is a minimum or maximum. The video describes using perturbations to establish that if a function is a minimum, then the derivative of the functional with respect to the perturbation must be zero at the minimum.
๐Ÿ’กIntegration by Parts
Integration by parts is a technique in calculus used to evaluate integrals by breaking them down into simpler parts. In the video, this method is used in the process of deriving the Euler-Lagrange equation for the soap bubble problem, helping to simplify the expression and eventually find the function that minimizes the surface area.
Highlights

Exploring the creation of a catanoid, a minimal surface formed by dipping two rings into a bubble solution.

Introduction to the mathematical study of minimal surfaces and their relation to given boundaries.

Using the calculus of variations to derive the shape of minimal surfaces.

Assumption of circular symmetry in bubbles to simplify the problem.

Transforming the problem into finding a curve that, when revolved, gives the smallest surface area.

Explanation of the integral formula for computing surface area from a function revolved around the x-axis.

Introduction of functionals as inputs for functions and outputs for numbers in calculus.

The minimization problem for functionals as opposed to traditional functions.

Generalization of the problem for arbitrary Lagrangians in calculus of variations.

Concept of perturbations in functions to test for minima in calculus of variations.

Derivation of the Euler-Lagrange equation from the calculus of variations.

Application of the Euler-Lagrange equation to the specific example of minimal surfaces.

Technical computation leading to the hyperbolic cosine form of the function that minimizes surface area.

Matching the computed function to given boundary circles to find specific minimal surfaces.

Discussion on the limitations of the model when circles are too far apart or too small.

Visual representation of different minimal surfaces created by various boundaries.

Submission to the Summer of Math Exposition 3, highlighting the contribution to mathematical exposition.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: