How to Lay Siege to a Fortress in the High Middle Ages (1000-1300)

SandRhoman History

20 Mar 202240:36

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe video script offers an in-depth look at the strategies and tactics employed during medieval sieges in Western Europe. It outlines a 9-step guide to laying siege to a fortress, highlighting the importance of surprise, speed, and psychological warfare. The script details the various stages of a siege, from initial assaults and negotiations to extended blockades and the use of siege engines like trebuchets. It also discusses the significance of supply lines, the impact of disease, and the potential outcomes of a siege, including surrender, storming, or a negotiated peace. The narrative is enriched with historical examples, such as the sieges of Valencia, Béziers, and Acre, providing a comprehensive understanding of the complexities and brutalities of medieval warfare.

Takeaways

🏰 **Fortified Defenses**: Medieval warfare in Western Europe focused on capturing fortified places like castles and walled towns, which were difficult to take due to their design.
🏇 **Cavalry Operations**: Garrisons, especially cavalry, had a large operational range to protect and attack, including the ability to ravage and forage.
🌟 **Surprise Attacks**: A mounted advance force would approach at night to surprise defenders, limiting their time to prepare defenses or summon reinforcements.
🛡️ **Small War Tactics**: Attackers used tactics like raiding farms and ambushing merchants to weaken the town's morale and resources before the actual siege began.
⏳ **Negotiations and Truces**: Negotiations could potentially end a siege quickly, but defenders had to balance showing resistance with the risk of harsh treatment if they held out too long.
🚧 **Siege Preparations**: If negotiations failed, attackers readied for a siege by setting up a fortified camp and preparing for a prolonged stay, which was labor-intensive.
🏞️ **Natural Defenses**: Natural features like cliffs, water, or ditches added to the difficulty of sieges, as did man-made outworks like earthworks and wooden palisades.
🎢 **Hasty Assaults**: Risky and usually involving high losses, hasty assaults with ladders were attempts to quickly scale the walls before the defenders could fully prepare.
🛠️ **Siege Engines**: Stone throwers like mangonels and trebuchets were used to damage walls and gates, though they were more effective against less resistant materials.
⛏️ **Mining and Tunneling**: Miners would dig tunnels under walls to create cavities, which were then set on fire to collapse the wall, a slow process that could take weeks or months.
🛡️ **Breaching and Storming**: Once a wall was breached, attackers would attempt to storm through, facing high casualties due to bottlenecks and elite defenders.

Q & A

What was the primary focus of warfare in Western Europe during the Middle Ages?
-The primary focus of warfare in Western Europe during the Middle Ages was on fortified places such as castles and walled towns, which controlled large parts of their surroundings.
How did a mounted advance force during a siege typically approach a town?
-A mounted advance force would approach the town at night in a forced march to prevent the defenders from preparing themselves, potentially taking the town by surprise.
What is the term used to describe the actions of raiding farms, villages, and ambushing merchants during a siege?
-These actions are often summarized under the technical terms 'small war' or 'chevoshi'.
What was the general outcome of most medieval sieges?
-Most medieval sieges ended before they had really begun, sometimes due to a successful assault or stratagem, but more often due to an early surrender or the besieging army being needed elsewhere.
What was the typical method of attack during a medieval siege before the advent of gunpowder artillery?
-The typical method of attack during a medieval siege before the advent of gunpowder artillery involved a combination of assault, mining, and negotiations to damage the walls and gates of the fortified town or castle.
How did the besiegers attempt to limit the exit points of a garrison during a siege?
-Besiegers would sometimes build forts or blockhouses in front of the gates and sally ports to limit the exit points of a garrison and protect against sudden counter-attacks.
What was considered the biggest concern during a siege after security?
-Supply was the biggest concern during a siege after security, as maintaining a steady stream of supplies was crucial for the besieging army's sustenance and success.
What was the purpose of bombardment, mining, and negotiations during a siege?
-The purpose of bombardment, mining, and negotiations during a siege was to equalize the advantage of the besieger's superior position and to damage the walls and gates to weaken the defenses.
How did miners contribute to the breaching of walls during a siege?
-Miners contributed to the breaching of walls by digging tunnels under the walls, creating a cavity, and then collapsing the supporting pillars, causing a section of the wall to collapse.
What was the most effective means to bring down a solid wall during a medieval siege?
-The most effective means to bring down a solid wall during a medieval siege was deep mining, where miners would dig tunnels and undermine the wall's foundation.
What were the three typical outcomes of a medieval siege?
-The three typical outcomes of a medieval siege were the besieged army abandoning the fortress, the fortress being taken by storm, or the defenders surrendering.

Outlines

00:00

🏰 Medieval Siege Warfare: An Introduction

This paragraph introduces the concept of medieval siege warfare, focusing on the importance of fortified structures like castles and walled towns in Western Europe. It outlines the strategic and tactical considerations in laying siege to these strongholds, emphasizing the need to deal with them first in any invasion. The paragraph also provides a 9-step guide to besieging a medieval fortress and sets the stage for the detailed discussion of siege tactics that follows.

05:01

⚔️ The First Move: Rapid Advance and Small War

The paragraph discusses the initial phase of a siege, which involves a swift and surprising advance force, often at night, to catch the defenders off guard. This approach aims to prevent the town from preparing defenses, stockpiling supplies, or summoning reinforcements. The attackers may engage in small-scale harassment tactics, such as raiding nearby farms and villages, ambushing merchants, and capturing workers, which are collectively referred to as 'small war' or 'chevoshi.' These actions significantly impact the morale of the defenders and the availability of goods, setting the stage for the main siege.

10:02

🕰️ The Nature of Medieval Sieges

This section provides an overview of the general nature of medieval sieges, contrasting the popular image of long, drawn-out conflicts with the reality that many sieges ended quickly due to early surrenders or other strategic factors. It highlights that while each siege was unique, certain basic methods and principles of attack and defense remained consistent throughout the Middle Ages, particularly before the advent of gunpowder artillery in the 1420s and 1430s. The paragraph also touches on the ripening of the town as a metaphor for the preparation phase before the actual siege begins.

15:02

🏺 Assaults, Outworks, and the Challenge of the Main Walls

The paragraph details the various stages of an assault on a fortified town, starting with a hasty assault that aims to capitalize on the element of surprise and the potential disarray of the defenders. It describes the challenges posed by outworks, such as earthworks and wooden palisades, and the significant obstacle presented by the main walls. The text highlights the high risks and potential rewards of such assaults, including the use of ladders to scale the walls and the defenders' tactics to repel attackers, such as dropping rocks and other dangerous objects.

20:04

⛺️ Setting Up Camp and Dealing with Sorties

If a quick assault is not feasible or fails, the attackers must prepare for a longer siege. This involves setting up a fortified camp, establishing a system of guards and watch posts, and ensuring a steady supply of provisions. The paragraph explains the importance of being prepared for sorties, or sudden counter-attacks by the defenders, which can disrupt the attackers' siege engines and supplies. It also discusses the logistics of finding a suitable location for the camp, the need for sanitation, and the challenges of maintaining a secure and well-supplied camp.

25:05

🚂 Supply Strategies for Prolonged Sieges

This section delves into the logistics of supplying an army during a prolonged siege. It outlines the various methods of supply, including bringing food from home via land or water, foraging in the local area, and relying on the local population for supplies. The paragraph also discusses the challenges of maintaining a supply line, the risks of foraging, and the importance of integrating local merchants and settlers into the supply system to ensure a steady flow of goods, particularly food, to the camp.

30:06

🏺 Combined Offensive Measures: Bombardment, Mining, and Negotiations

The paragraph describes the offensive measures used during a siege, including bombardment with various types of artillery, mining to undermine the walls, and negotiations to persuade the defenders to surrender. It explains the role of different types of trebuchets and their effectiveness against different materials and structures. The text also highlights the psychological impact of these offensive measures on the defenders and the potential for them to cause internal strife and surrender.

35:07

🛠️ Siege Engines and the Preparations for Assault

This section focuses on the construction and use of siege engines like battering rams, siege towers, and miners' tunnels. It discusses the various purposes of these engines, from protecting and elevating archers to physically breaching the walls. The paragraph also touches on the vulnerabilities of siege towers, the slow process of deep mining, and the challenges of bringing siege engines close to the walls. It emphasizes the multifaceted nature of a siege, with various activities occurring simultaneously.

40:08

🏺 The Threat of Assault and the Role of Negotiations

The paragraph discusses the psychological warfare aspect of a siege, where the visible preparations for an assault are used to intimidate the defenders into surrendering. It highlights the role of negotiations and the promise of good treatment for quick surrender as a means to end the siege without a costly and prolonged conflict. The text also describes the tactics used by both attackers and defenders to demoralize each other and the importance of these tactics in influencing the outcome of the siege.

🏺 The Siege's Climactic Assault and the Defenders' Response

This section describes the final stages of a siege, including the climactic assault on the walls and the defenders' response. It details the multi-dimensional nature of the assault, with infantry, archers, miners, and siege engines all playing a role. The paragraph also discusses the challenges of breaching the walls, the high casualties associated with storming breaches, and the potential for the defenders to counterattack. It highlights the importance of the defenders' morale and the potential for internal conflict within the city under siege.

⛓️ Blockade, Starvation, and the Aftermath of a Siege

The final paragraph discusses the last resort of a besieger: a full blockade, turning the siege into a game of attrition. It explains the process of encircling and starving the town, the improvement of the besiegers' camp, and the tactics used to weaken the defenders until they surrender. The text also covers the consequences of a prolonged siege, including disease, hunger, and the potential for the defenders to expel non-combatants to reduce the strain on resources. It concludes with the various ways a siege can end, from surrender and negotiated terms to the brutal aftermath of a town taken by storm.

📝 A Call to Responsible Use of Siege Knowledge

In a lighter note, the final paragraph humorously reminds the viewer to use the information about siege warfare responsibly, only resorting to plundering peasants, bombarding towns, or undermining buildings if absolutely necessary. It also includes a call to action for viewers to support the content creators via Patreon, suggesting a share of the 'profit' gained from the practical information provided.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Siege

A siege is a military operation in which enemy forces surround a town or building, cutting off essential supplies, with the aim of compelling the surrender of those inside. In the video, sieges are the central theme, illustrating the various strategies and tactics employed during the Middle Ages to conquer fortified places like castles and walled towns.

💡Fortified Centers

Fortified centers refer to structures that have been adapted or built to withstand attacks, such as castles and walled towns. These were the primary targets during medieval warfare, as they controlled large parts of the surrounding area and were difficult to take by force, as described in the video.

💡Garrison

A garrison is a group of soldiers stationed in a fortified place to defend it. In the context of the video, garrisons were responsible for the defense of castles and walled towns, and they played a critical role in the operational range and defensive capabilities of these strongholds.

💡Cavalry

Cavalry refers to soldiers mounted on horses, providing them with greater mobility and often used for rapid assaults or flanking maneuvers. In the video, the cavalry is mentioned as having a large operational range, which allowed them to protect their territory, attack the enemy, and perform various operational tasks such as ravaging and foraging.

💡Counterweight Trebuchet

A counterweight trebuchet is a type of medieval siege engine that uses a massive counterweight to fling projectiles, typically stones, at high speeds towards enemy fortifications. The video discusses its introduction in the 12th century and its role in damaging walls during a siege, although it was not always effective against solid stone walls.

💡Sorties

Sorties, also known as sallies, are sudden, aggressive forays made by the defenders of a besieged place against the besiegers. In the video, sorties are described as a powerful tool for defenders to launch counter-attacks, potentially disrupting the attackers' siege engines or supplies.

💡Battering Ram

A battering ram is a siege engine used to break down doors, gates, or walls. It typically consists of a large, heavy beam suspended by ropes or chains and protected by a wooden framework. In the video, it is mentioned as one of the tools used to attempt to breach the walls of a fortress, although it was more effective against wooden gates than thick stone walls.

💡Blockade

A blockade is a method of siege warfare where the besieging force surrounds a town or city to prevent supplies, reinforcements, and information from entering or leaving. The video describes a full blockade as a game of attrition, where the aim is to weaken the defenders by exhaustion of their supplies until they surrender.

💡Sappers

Sappers are combat engineers who specialize in constructing or destroying fortifications, bridges, and tunnels. In the context of the video, sappers are involved in the dangerous work of mining, where they dig tunnels to undermine the walls of a fortress, creating cavities that can be collapsed to bring down the wall.

💡Surrender

Surrender in the context of a siege refers to the act of the defenders giving up the stronghold to the besiegers, often in exchange for certain terms or guarantees of safety. The video discusses surrender as a possible outcome of a siege, where negotiations and the pressure of the siege can lead to an agreement and the end of hostilities.

💡Storming

Storming is the act of attacking and attempting to take a fortified place by force, typically involving direct assaults on walls, breaches, or gates. The video describes storming as a high-risk, high-reward endeavor that could lead to the quick end of a siege if successful, but often resulted in heavy casualties.

Highlights

Throughout the Middle Ages, warfare in Western Europe was centered around fortified places like castles and walled towns, which had significant control over their surroundings.

Garrisons, particularly cavalry, had a large operational range to protect and attack, making them a formidable force against invaders.

A 9-step guide is presented for laying siege to a medieval fortress, emphasizing the complexity and multi-faceted nature of such endeavors.

Surprise attacks using mounted advance forces at night could catch defenders off guard, sometimes leading to quick victories without a siege.

Small war or chevoshi tactics involved raiding and ambushing to weaken the morale and supplies of the town before the actual siege began.

Most medieval sieges ended before they began, often due to early surrender or the besieging army being needed elsewhere.

Negotiations between besiegers and defenders could lead to a truce or surrender, saving lives and resources.

Hasty assaults were risky but offered the chance to end the siege quickly, especially if the town was ill-prepared.

Outworks, such as earthworks and wooden palisades, were the first obstacles for attackers to overcome before reaching the main walls.

Deep mining was a slow but potentially effective method to bring down a solid wall, involving the creation of cavities under the wall.

Siege towers were used to elevate and protect archers, but were not as common or effective as often portrayed in media.

Battering rams were used to attack weak spots in gates or walls, but were less effective against thick stone walls.

Negotiations and the visible threat of siege preparations were often used to persuade defenders to surrender without a fight.

Blockades were a game of attrition, where the goal was to exhaust the defenders' supplies until they surrendered.

The end of a siege could result in the town changing possession, being plundered, or the defenders negotiating terms for their departure.

The harsh treatment of inhabitants after a town was taken by storm was sometimes mitigated after an initial period of violence.

The documentary also recommends additional resources on the topic, such as the documentary on the siege of Orleans and the series 'Beleaguered Fortress'.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

The Earliest Sieges in History (and How they Worked)

Ancient-Warfare Historian Rates 10 More Battle Scenes In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? | Insider

Was Genghis Khan Really As Barbaric As We Think? | Line Of Fire | Chronicle

The Reason Why Cancer is so Hard to Beat

Siege of Jerusalem 70 AD - Great Jewish Revolt DOCUMENTARY

The Russian Revolution After The Crimean War | Crimean War | Timeline