StarTalk Podcast: Cosmic Queries – Black Holes and Dark Energy, with Neil deGrasse Tyson

StarTalk Podcast Full Episodes

2 Apr 202054:16

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn this engaging episode of Star Talk, Neil deGrasse Tyson and co-host Chuck Nice delve into cosmic queries surrounding black holes and dark energy. They discuss the nature of black holes, including their gravitational effects on surrounding matter and the phenomenon of spaghettification. The conversation also touches on dark energy's role in the universe's expansion and the challenges of understanding and manipulating such mysterious forces. With a mix of humor and scientific insight, the show explores the fascinating aspects of these cosmic entities and their impact on our understanding of the universe.

Takeaways

🌌 The center of galaxies, including ours, is believed to contain supermassive black holes due to the observed high-speed orbits of stars around a dense, dark mass.
🌑 Black holes are regions of space where gravity is so strong that not even light can escape. Their existence is inferred from the effects on nearby matter and the bending of light.
🌟 Stars and galaxies exhibit different behaviors; stars rotate on their axes while galaxies revolve around their centers, and sometimes entire clusters of galaxies revolve around a common center.
🔍 The Hubble Space Telescope has been instrumental in observing distant galaxies and providing evidence for the presence of black holes at their centers.
⚫️ Dark energy is a mysterious force that is accelerating the expansion of the universe. It does not have a direct impact on everyday life on Earth due to its relative weakness in regions with high matter density.
⚗️ The concept of 'spaghettification' describes the theoretical stretching of objects into long, thin shapes due to the extreme tidal forces near a black hole.
🚀 If a black hole were to replace the Sun, planets like Earth would continue to orbit it, albeit in a drastically altered solar system.
🌀 The rotation and revolution of celestial bodies are governed by the laws of physics, such as gravity and the conservation of angular momentum.
⛰️ The 'eye' of a hurricane is used as an analogy to explain the misconception about the center of a galaxy being an empty space, similar to the calm center of a storm.
🌠 Dark matter, while invisible and intangible by current means, has measurable gravitational effects on visible matter and the universe's expansion.
💡 The exploration of black holes, dark energy, and dark matter remains a frontier in astrophysics, with the potential to revolutionize our understanding of the cosmos.

Q & A

Why are we so sure that there are black holes at the center of our galaxy and possibly every galaxy?
-We are sure because the observed orbits of stars around a central dark area in galaxies can be explained by a massive object. According to Kepler's laws, the speed of an orbit is determined by the mass inside the orbit. The mass must be huge, dark (not emitting light), and small, which are characteristics that align with a supermassive black hole.
Can a small black hole orbit a bigger black hole, and if so, can it be a stable orbit?
-Yes, a small black hole can orbit a larger black hole, and it can be a stable orbit. The stability depends on the specific dynamics and masses involved, but in general, a smaller black hole could orbit a larger one without immediately falling into it.
What happens to a black hole as it loses mass through Hawking radiation?
-As a black hole loses mass through Hawking radiation, it shrinks in size, maintaining its black hole properties. It does not reignite into a star, but continues to shrink until all its mass is radiated away.
How does dark energy impact our everyday life?
-Dark energy does not have a direct impact on our everyday life. It is a mysterious force that affects the large-scale structure of the universe, causing it to expand at an accelerating rate. Its effects are not felt at the human scale or in the interactions that we experience daily.
Is it possible to manipulate dark matter or dark energy to use it as a fuel?
-Currently, it is not possible to manipulate dark matter or dark energy. Dark matter interacts with us only through gravity, and dark energy is even more elusive, not interacting with normal matter or light in any known way. Therefore, harnessing it as a fuel is beyond our current scientific capabilities.
What would happen if the Earth came close or directly in contact with a black hole?
-If the Earth came close to a black hole, the tidal forces would cause the Earth to stretch or 'spaghettify' due to the difference in gravitational forces on the near and far sides. This would result in massive earthquakes, tsunamis, and eventually the breaking apart of the Earth as the materials can't hold the elongated shape.
Why don't black holes consume space-time itself and destroy the entire universe?
-Black holes do not consume space-time more voraciously than they did as stars before they became black holes. The gravitational strength of a black hole is related to its mass, not its size. Once a black hole has formed, its gravitational influence on the rest of the universe does not increase; it is the same as when it was a star, just more concentrated.
Do galaxies revolve or rotate around something else, like a supermassive black hole at the center of a supercluster?
-Galaxies rotate on their axes and revolve around the center of their own galaxies and galaxy clusters. In some cases, such as galaxy superclusters, galaxies may revolve around a central point, which could be a concentration of mass, possibly a supermassive black hole or a group of galaxies.
How can we determine if a supercluster is revolving around a black hole or another massive object?
-We can measure the speed of galaxies within the supercluster using the Doppler shift and estimate how long it would take for the galaxies to cross the cluster at that speed. If the time is longer than the age of the universe, it suggests the cluster has not had time to organize into orbits, and such measurements would not indicate the presence of a central revolving mass.
What is the concept of 'spaghettification' in the context of black holes?
-Spaghettification refers to the theoretical process by which an object is stretched out into a long, thin shape under the influence of a very strong, uneven gravitational field, like that near a black hole. It's a term used to describe the extreme elongation due to tidal forces when an object gets too close to a black hole.
What is the significance of the Doppler shift in understanding the motion of galaxies and superclusters?
-The Doppler shift is a change in frequency or wavelength of a wave in relation to an observer who is moving relative to the source. In the context of galaxies and superclusters, it allows astronomers to measure the speed at which these celestial bodies are moving away from or towards us, providing insights into the dynamics and structure of the universe.

Outlines

00:00

🎥 Introduction to Cosmic Queries on Black Holes and Dark Energy

The video script begins with a lively introduction by Neil deGrasse Tyson and Chuck Nice, setting the stage for a discussion on black holes and dark energy. They touch upon Chuck's tweeting during the Super Bowl halftime and the importance of the Latino influence in Tyson's household. The conversation humorously transitions into the topic of the day, with a commitment to exploring the mysteries of black holes and dark energy, hinting at the expertise of Janna Levin should it be required.

05:02

🌌 The Evidence for Supermassive Black Holes at Galactic Centers

The summary delves into the question of why scientists are confident that supermassive black holes exist at the center of our galaxy and potentially every galaxy. Tyson explains the role of Kepler's laws in determining the mass within an orbit, leading to the conclusion that a massive, compact object, such as a black hole, must reside at the center of the observed stellar orbits. The concept of a Copernican principle is mentioned to argue that our galaxy is not unique in having a central black hole.

10:05

🪐 Matter Compression and the Formation of Black Holes

This section explores the states of matter and how extreme pressure can lead to the collapse of atoms and the formation of black holes. Tyson and Nice discuss the progression from electron degeneracy pressure, which prevents a star from collapsing, to the formation of white dwarfs, neutron stars, and ultimately black holes. The discussion highlights the immense densities and gravitational forces at play, with a humorous analogy comparing the density of a black hole to cramming 300 billion elephants into a thimble.

15:05

🌟 The Impact of Black Holes on Space-Time and Orbital Dynamics

The paragraph discusses the possibility of a smaller black hole orbiting a larger one, and the conditions for a stable orbit. It explores the concept of black holes as massive objects without a specific 'black hole' awareness, and the idea that if Earth were to become a black hole, it would still maintain its orbit around the Sun. The conversation also touches on the nature of gravitational wells and how they change as a star falls into a black hole's gravitational well.

20:06

🚀 Theoretical Manipulation of Black Holes and Dark Energy

This section ponders the hypothetical scenario of using black holes as a source of energy or weaponization, inspired by science fiction narratives. It also addresses the question of whether dark energy or dark matter could be harnessed as a fuel. The summary explains the challenges in interacting with these mysterious phenomena due to their apparent lack of interaction with normal matter and radiation.

25:08

🌍 Effects of Black Holes on Earth and Galactic Dynamics

The focus shifts to the potential consequences for Earth if it were to encounter a black hole, describing the process of 'spaghettification' where tidal forces would cause Earth to disintegrate. Additionally, the paragraph explores the dynamics of galaxies within superclusters and the possibility of detecting a central black hole or massive object around which these galaxy clusters might revolve.

30:09

🌀 Rotation and Revolution in the Cosmos

The final paragraph investigates the rotation and revolution of celestial bodies, from planets and stars to galaxies and superclusters. It questions whether galaxies rotate around an external center and how observable phenomena like the Doppler shift can provide insights into the movement and organization of galaxies within the universe.

35:09

🕰 The Human Perspective on Cosmic Timescales

In a reflective conclusion, Tyson uses the analogy of the Super Bowl timeline to illustrate the brief span of human history within the vast timescales of the universe. The conversation contemplates the limitations of human perception and understanding in the face of cosmic phenomena that operate beyond the scope of our senses and lifespan.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Black Holes

Black holes are regions in space where the gravitational pull is so strong that nothing, not even light, can escape from them. They are formed from the remnants of massive stars after they have exhausted their nuclear fuel and undergone a supernova explosion. In the video, the concept of black holes is central, with discussions ranging from their formation to their role at the centers of galaxies. An example from the script is the explanation of why black holes are believed to exist at the center of our galaxy and others, based on the observed motion of stars near the galactic center.

💡Dark Energy

Dark energy is a hypothetical form of energy that permeates all of space and is believed to be responsible for the observed acceleration in the expansion of the universe. It is an enigmatic concept that is not well understood. In the video, dark energy is mentioned as a topic of interest, with the host discussing its effects on the universe's expansion without directly impacting everyday life on Earth.

💡Event Horizon

The event horizon is a boundary around a black hole beyond which nothing can escape the black hole's gravitational pull. It is often considered the 'point of no return' for any matter or radiation approaching a black hole. The concept is illustrated in the video by explaining that the event horizon defines the region from which not even light can escape, emphasizing the black hole's immense gravity.

💡Spaghettification

Spaghettification, also known as the noodle effect, is a term used to describe the theoretical stretching and thinning of objects due to extreme tidal forces when they approach a massive object like a black hole. The term is used in the video to describe what would happen to Earth if it were to come close to a black hole, emphasizing the intense gravitational forces at play.

💡Supermassive Black Hole

A supermassive black hole is a black hole with a mass that is many millions or even billions of times greater than the mass of our Sun. These black holes are believed to reside at the centers of most galaxies, including our own Milky Way. In the video, the concept is discussed in the context of the central dark region of galaxies and how the presence of a supermassive black hole influences the orbits of stars in the vicinity.

💡Hawking Radiation

Hawking radiation is a theoretical prediction by physicist Stephen Hawking that black holes are not completely black but emit small amounts of thermal radiation due to quantum effects near the event horizon. This phenomenon is mentioned in the video when discussing whether a black hole could lose enough mass to potentially transform back into a star-like object.

💡Tidal Force

Tidal force refers to the difference in gravitational pull experienced by two sides of an object due to the presence of a massive body. In the context of the video, tidal forces are discussed as the cause of spaghettification, highlighting the extreme gravitational effects a black hole can have on nearby objects like planets.

💡Dark Matter

Dark matter is a form of matter that does not interact with electromagnetic radiation, making it invisible to our current detection methods. However, its presence is inferred through its gravitational effects on visible matter. The video discusses dark matter in the context of its gravitational influence on galaxies and the universe's structure, without directly interacting with normal baryonic matter or light.

💡Pulsar

A pulsar is a highly magnetized, rotating neutron star that emits a beam of electromagnetic radiation out of its magnetic poles. This radiation can only be observed when the beam of emission is pointing towards Earth, appearing as pulses. The video touches on pulsars as an example of extremely dense objects that result from the collapse of massive stars, and how their discovery contributed to our understanding of the universe.

💡Neutron Star

A neutron star is the collapsed core of a massive star that has undergone gravitational collapse after a supernova explosion. It is composed almost entirely of neutrons and is incredibly dense. Neutron stars are mentioned in the video as an example of the densest form of matter that is not a black hole, and as the possible end state of stars before they collapse further to form black holes.

💡Supercluster

A supercluster is a large group of galaxy clusters or groups that are gravitationally bound together. The video discusses the concept of superclusters in the context of the large-scale structure of the universe, and how galaxies within these structures may orbit a common center of mass, potentially influenced by the presence of a central black hole or other massive objects.

Highlights

Neil deGrasse Tyson and Chuck Nice discuss the concept of black holes and dark energy.

Tyson explains how the orbit of stars around the center of galaxies indicates the presence of supermassive black holes.

Chuck Nice shares his experience tweeting during the Super Bowl and the Latino cultural aspects of the halftime show.

The conversation covers the idea that black holes can orbit each other and the possibility of stable orbits.

Tyson describes the process of how matter collapses into different states, from white dwarfs to neutron stars, and finally to black holes.

The hosts touch on the concept of dark energy and its influence on the expansion of the universe.

They discuss the impact of dark energy on everyday life and why it has no visible or measurable effects on human scales.

Tyson and Nice explore the idea of black holes emitting light and radiation, despite not allowing it to escape their gravity.

The possibility of manipulating dark matter or dark energy as a fuel source is debated, highlighting our current lack of interaction with these phenomena.

Tyson explains why black holes do not consume space-time itself and why they don't destroy the entire universe.

The discussion includes the concept of galaxies spinning and rotating, and the potential for superclusters to orbit around a central point.

Nice and Tyson talk about the limitations of human perception and our ability to understand the universe through our senses.

The use of the Doppler shift to measure the speed of galaxies and the challenges of understanding cosmic timescales is explained.

Tyson illustrates the concept of cosmic timescales using the analogy of the Super Bowl's field length representing the age of the universe.

The conversation concludes with a reflection on human ego and our place in the universe, relative to other animals and the vastness of time.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Why Does The Universe Exist? Fan Grab Bag With Neil deGrasse Tyson

Cosmic Queries – Cosmological Curiosities with Neil deGrasse Tyson

Cream of The Universe Soup with Neil deGrasse Tyson | Cosmic Queries

StarTalk Podcast: Cosmic Queries – Edge of the Universe with Neil deGrasse Tyson and Janna Levin

Expanding Past Our Cosmic Horizon with Neil deGrasse Tyson – Cosmic Queries

StarTalk Podcast: Cosmic Queries – Fan Grab Bag

Related Tags

Cosmic Queries Black Holes Dark Energy Astronomy Physics StarTalk Neil deGrasse Tyson Space-Time Supermassive Black Holes 宇宙探索