Lecture 22: Contextualizing Cities (1980-2021)

IIT Roorkee July 2018
23 Aug 202142:56
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe lecture covers the shift from modernism to neoliberalism, the decline of industrial cities, and new approaches to urban planning and city growth like knowledge and financial hubs, creative cities, green cities, and transit-oriented development. It discusses the rise of technology like AI and robotics, the concept of new urbanism, and moves towards sustainability. Finally, it examines how the COVID-19 pandemic requires rethinking cities for better health infrastructure, work-life balance, public spaces, transportation, and environmental impact.

Takeaways
  • πŸ˜€ From 1980-1999 we saw a shift from modernism to neoliberalism with more private sector control of economies
  • πŸ“ˆ Financial cities started rising across the globe while industries grew in the global south
  • 🌍 Global cities like New York and London started commanding other cities globally
  • πŸ’‘ Declining cities regenerated creatively by transforming industrial spaces and attracting investments
  • 🚊 Transit oriented development emerged as cities focused on sustainability and public transportation
  • 🌳 Concepts like green cities and eco cities became popular for environmentally responsible planning
  • βš™οΈ Technology like AI, robotics and internet started transforming cities towards being 'smart'
  • 😷 COVID-19 is making us rethink city planning for public health, work from home and other impacts
  • πŸ‘©β€πŸ« India decentralized local governance and opened up markets under liberalization post 1991
  • πŸš† Major infrastructure projects used public-private partnerships model for implementation
Q & A
  • What is neoliberalism and how did it impact cities?

    -Neoliberalism is an economic policy model that transfers control of economic factors from the public sector to the private sector. It led to industrial cities declining in the West, the rise of financial cities, and cities opening up more for private investment.

  • How did smaller cities try to compete for investment and tourists?

    -Smaller cities organized themselves into urban agglomerations to increase their size and capacity. They also formed economic clusters combined with agglomeration to create specialized niches in the global economy.

  • What is transit-oriented development and how was it adopted in India?

    -Transit-oriented development integrates land use and transport planning to develop sustainable urban growth centers with public transit access. Many Indian cities have adopted it to address urban sprawl and congestion.

  • What are industrial corridors in India and what is their purpose?

    -Industrial corridors in India connect major industrial hubs through world-class transportation networks. They aim to boost industrialization and planned urbanization with complementary infrastructure.

  • What is new urbanism and how has India invested in public infrastructure?

    -New urbanism emphasizes a return to more traditional, connected, and dense living and working environments. India has invested heavily in metro rails and other rapid transit systems as public infrastructure.

  • How did cities use concepts like green cities and creative cities?

    -Cities adopted concepts like building eco-cities and creative cities centered on arts and culture in order to attract investment and talent as sustainable approaches to growth.

  • How are smart cities using technology to become more efficient?

    -Smart cities implement solutions like smart energy, transportation, buildings and communication networks to become more efficient through the use of data and technology.

  • How has Covid-19 impacted assumptions about urban planning?

    -The pandemic has led cities to rethink density, public transit and spaces in light of public health needs, remote work, and vulnerable populations.

  • What major decentralization reforms happened in India in the 90s?

    -India introduced constitutional amendments empowering local municipal bodies for governance through the 73rd and 74th Amendment Acts in 1992.

  • How were public-private partnerships used for infrastructure projects?

    -Indian cities increasingly relied on public-private partnerships to fund major urban infrastructure projects as city authorities had decreasing budgets.

Outlines
00:00
πŸŽ“ Introduction to the lectures on urban planning context

This first paragraph is an introduction, welcoming to the course on urban planning. It outlines the learning objectives, which include understanding the planning narratives and interventions in cities globally and in India from the late 20th century onwards. Key topics mentioned that will be covered include the shift from modernism to neoliberalism, knowledge economies, transit developments, technology use, sustainability, and the Covid-19 health shifts.

05:01
πŸ“ˆ Shift from physical to economic planning in cities

This paragraph discusses the shift in urban planning from a physical, architect-driven approach to a more economic, private sector-driven model. It mentions industrial cities declining in the West, financial cities rising, and a power imbalance as industries grew in developing countries. It also notes growing awareness of climate change and green/eco city approaches.

10:01
πŸ—³οΈ Decentralization and economic liberalization policies in India

This paragraph summarizes major Indian policy changes relevant to cities, including decentralization acts in the 1990s, and economic liberalization policies allowing foreign direct investment and public-private partnerships for urban infrastructure. It mentions how policies like URDPFI provided guidance on urban planning to integrate these changes.

15:04
🚊 Public-private transport infrastructure case studies

This paragraph analyses Indian case studies of public-private transportation projects. It examines the Delhi Metro as a successful model, implemented through equal public-private partnership. It also mentions India's first privately owned metro in Gurgaon, noting private infrastructure sometimes lagged on public facilities.

20:06
πŸ™οΈ Strategies for growth in declining Western cities

This paragraph discusses strategies adopted in declining Western cities to spur growth, like transforming old industrial spaces or leveraging local universities. It examines the Research Triangle Park as a case where incentives promoted private companies to locate near universities, though notes poverty remains.

25:08
πŸ“Š Comparing knowledge economy indices between India and OECD

This paragraph compares India's performance on knowledge economy indices to OECD countries. It finds India's scores lag significantly, though mentions some Indian cities with growing tech and biotech hubs. It implies India's knowledge economy remains limited in reach.

30:10
πŸ’° Rise of global financial command cities

This paragraph discusses the rise in importance of global financial cities that command influence over other cities in networks. It mentions cities like New York, London and Tokyo as top examples, with Mumbai and Delhi having growing clout. It implies financial cities concentrate power.

35:12
✨ Smaller city strategies like clustering for competitiveness

This paragraph analyses how smaller cities try to boost competitiveness, including forming urban agglomerations to increase scale or developing specialized economic clusters. Indian efforts to promote manufacturing clusters are noted. Implication is collaborative strategies can help smaller cities compete.

40:13
🎭 City branding and creative city concepts gain prominence

This paragraph discusses city branding through mega-events and the creative city concept as an urban strategy. It mentions Richard Florida's creative class theory. In India, initiatives like UNESCO's creative cities network are starting to formally recognize cultural resources.

πŸŒ‡ Transit-oriented development adopted to check sprawl

This paragraph introduces transit-oriented development or TOD as an urban planning concept to promote sustainability and curb car-dependent sprawl. It notes many Indian cities have started adopting TOD principles of dense, mixed-use development clustered around transit hubs.

πŸš† Large infrastructure investments in corridors and metros

This paragraph discusses India's focus on large, integrated infrastructure investments like industrial corridors and metro rail networks for urban transformation. It implies a recommitment to public transit and clusters after earlier auto-centric policies.

🏘️ New urbanism and public infrastructure investment

This paragraph introduces new urbanism as an urban planning movement emphasizing walkability, density, mixed use, and investment in public transit and infrastructure. Indian metro system expansion and private sector involvement is highlighted.

🌳 Sustainability concerns spur eco-city experiments

This paragraph analyzes the eco-city concept which emerged from growing sustainability concerns. It found many experiments like China's Dongtan project faced feasibility issues in practice. India examples like green efforts in Bangalore are mentioned as more incremental.

πŸ€– Smart urbanism rises with new technologies

This final paragraph discusses the rise of data-driven smart urbanism leveraging AI, sensors, big data and other emerging technologies to manage city operations. Indian smart cities program experiments are mentioned. Transition to thinking about post-pandemic health infrastructure is noted.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘Neoliberalism
Neoliberalism refers to an economic policy model that favors free market capitalism, privatization, and reduced government spending. As described in the video, it involves transferring control of economic factors from the public sector to the private sector. An example is the increased use of public-private partnerships (PPPs) for infrastructure projects in Indian cities during this period.
πŸ’‘Public-private partnership (PPP)
A public-private partnership (PPP) involves collaboration between a government agency and a private sector company to finance, build and operate projects. The video discusses how PPPs were encouraged in India under neoliberalism to address poor urban infrastructure. For example, the Delhi Metro project successfully used a 50-50 PPP model between the government and private company.
πŸ’‘Knowledge economy
A knowledge economy refers to an economy where economic growth is driven by knowledge-intensive activities rather than traditional industries. The video talks about the rise of tech hubs, science & tech parks, and knowledge-based jobs in cities to tap into the knowledge economy. However, these new economies still show disparities in opportunities.
πŸ’‘Financial cities
As traditional manufacturing industries declined in the West, financial hubs and services became concentrated in global cities like New York, Tokyo and London. These "financial cities" commanded influence across global economic networks. The video cites Mumbai and Delhi in India also playing stronger financial roles.
πŸ’‘Creative cities
Creative cities refer to cities that harness human creativity as a strategic asset for economic growth, through promoting arts, culture, innovation and tolerance. Pioneer Richard Florida coined the "creative class" concept. Examples in India include Hyderabad as a UNESCO creative city and Delhi's initiatives like Dilli Haat for cultural revival.
πŸ’‘Green cities
Green cities aim to be environmentally sustainable and energy efficient through green construction, renewable energy, green spaces etc. Bangalore emerged as a top green city in India with demand for solar and garden products. However, reviews on actual sustainability are mixed.
πŸ’‘New Urbanism
New Urbanism is an urban planning movement promoting walkable, transit-oriented developments with mixed land use and connectivity. It contrasts urban sprawl. In India, public metro rail infrastructure and transit-oriented development around stations support New Urbanism.
πŸ’‘Smart cities
Smart cities leverage data and technology like IoT, AI, big data to provide better infrastructure and services. They focus on innovations across energy, mobility, water etc. India's Smart Cities Mission funds smart city projects like intelligent traffic management and smart meters.
πŸ’‘Sustainability
Sustainability became a focus area in cities due to climate change awareness. Compact transit-oriented development, renewable energy, public transport etc. are now seen as sustainable approaches vs urban sprawl, car dependency etc. But pandemic recovery also needs to balance health.
πŸ’‘Post-COVID cities
The COVID pandemic has led cities to rethink assumptions on density, mobility and access to healthcare. Recovery needs balancing sustainability aims and health infrastructure, while addressing economic disparities amplified during lockdowns.
Highlights

We will see how we moved from modernism to neoliberalism

We will look at new ways we started to address the cities to grow and sustain

We also look at how we moved to sustainability agenda

Neoliberalism means transfer of control of economic factors from the public sector to the private sector

Urban planning started with architects and planners, now see multinational companies planning cities

When cities have less money, they start giving tax breaks and incentives to private investors

73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendment Act in 1989 brought decentralization and empowered municipal bodies

Public-private partnerships increased for urban infrastructure projects in India

Post-industrial spaces transforming to night time economy, cities regaining creative ways

Smaller cities organize in urban agglomerations to compete globally

Cities compete through economic clusters combined with agglomeration

Cities compete through mega events and branding for investment and tourism

Transit oriented development aims for sustainable urban growth centers with transit access

Sustainability agenda looks at compact, mixed-use development focused on public transit

Pandemic questions density, public spaces - need to rethink cities for health

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: