Chemistry Demonstration Interview

Undergraduate Study at Oxford
19 May 202339:01
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe transcript outlines a mock interview scenario where the candidate, Charlie, is assessed on his understanding and application of chemistry concepts, specifically focusing on molecular orbitals and hydrogen bonding in water. The interview is conducted using Miro and Teams, allowing for interactive whiteboarding and discussion. Charlie demonstrates his ability to reason through unfamiliar concepts, such as the spatial arrangement of atomic orbitals in bonding and the implications of hydrogen bonding on the density of ice versus liquid water. The interviewers, Susan and Steve, emphasize the importance of clear communication and the candidate's capacity to handle new information and apply it to problem-solving.

Takeaways
  • πŸ“ The interview is conducted using both Teams and Miro, allowing for a combination of verbal discussion and visual collaboration.
  • πŸ’» Candidates are encouraged to practice using the Miro whiteboard to feel more comfortable during the actual interview.
  • 🌐 Technology issues should not be a cause for panic; interviewers are aware and prepared to handle such situations, possibly rescheduling if needed.
  • πŸŽ“ It is important to discuss with a supporting teacher beforehand to ensure a stable internet connection and a quiet place for the interview.
  • πŸ“š The interview focuses on candidates' ability to apply knowledge and problem-solving skills rather than prior knowledge.
  • 🧩 The interview may present information that contradicts the candidate's existing knowledge to assess their response to new evidence.
  • πŸ—£οΈ Candidates should practice explaining chemistry concepts and reasoning, as they will be expected to discuss their thought process during the interview.
  • πŸ•΅οΈβ€β™‚οΈ The interview is designed to identify how candidates connect facts, apply learning, and provide evidence of their abilities.
  • πŸ“Š During the interview, candidates should talk through their actions and thoughts, whether drawing or explaining concepts.
  • πŸ€” It is acceptable and encouraged to admit when something is not understood; this is a valuable skill for learning and problem-solving.
  • πŸ“ˆ The interview process aims to replicate aspects of small group teaching, focusing on candidates' ability to understand and engage with new material.
Q & A
  • What is the main purpose of using Miro during the interview as described in the transcript?

    -The main purpose of using Miro during the interview is to allow both the interviewer and the interviewee to write and illustrate things on the same whiteboard while they talk, which facilitates a more interactive and collaborative discussion.

  • What advice is given to interviewees if the technology doesn't work during the interview?

    -If the technology doesn't work during the interview, the advice given is not to panic. The interviewee should inform the interviewer if they don't hear them properly, and they will go back to where they were and start again, or in the worst case, reschedule the interview when everything is sorted out.

  • How does the interview aim to select candidates for the course?

    -The interview aims to select candidates who are best suited to the course by focusing on their ability to apply knowledge and facts provided during the interview. It assesses problem-solving skills and how candidates connect facts together and apply what they're learning to solve problems.

  • What is the significance of the water molecule discussion in the interview?

    -The water molecule discussion is significant as it serves as an example of how candidates are expected to apply their knowledge and understanding of chemistry concepts, such as molecular structure, bonding, and hydrogen bonding, to unfamiliar situations and to explain their reasoning process.

  • How does the interview assess a candidate's ability to handle new information?

    -The interview assesses a candidate's ability to handle new information by presenting them with concepts they may not have encountered before, such as atomic and molecular orbitals, and observing how they respond, learn, and apply this new information to solve problems or answer questions.

  • What is the importance of the phase diagram in the discussion about water and ice?

    -The phase diagram is important as it helps illustrate the relationship between pressure, temperature, and the states of water (liquid and solid). It is used to discuss the equilibrium between liquid water and ice and to explain why ice is less dense than liquid water.

  • How does the interview ensure that candidates do not have a disadvantage for not knowing something?

    -The interview ensures that not knowing something does not put candidates at a disadvantage by encouraging them to work through problems and new information out loud, allowing them to express their thought process, and by providing prompts and corrections that help them understand and correct any misunderstandings.

  • What is the role of hydrogen bonding in the structure of ice and liquid water?

    -Hydrogen bonding plays a crucial role in determining the structure of ice and liquid water. In ice, the hydrogen bonds are more ordered and form a rigid, lattice-like structure, causing the molecules to be fixed in place. In liquid water, the molecules are constantly moving and changing positions, which means that not all hydrogen bonds are in place at any given instant, allowing the molecules to pack more closely together and resulting in a higher density.

  • Why is it important for candidates to be able to talk about what they are thinking during the interview?

    -It is important for candidates to articulate their thought process during the interview because it helps the interviewers understand how the candidate is approaching the problem, what they understand, and where they might be going wrong. This also mirrors the process of small group teaching where being able to communicate and explain one's understanding is crucial.

  • What advice is given to candidates to prepare for the interview?

    -Candidates are advised to practice talking about chemistry and reasoning for things, familiarize themselves with handling different explanations or concepts, revise and understand their schoolwork, and ensure they have a stable internet connection and a quiet place for the interview. They are also encouraged to have pen and paper handy and to be open to learning and exploring new concepts during the interview.

Outlines
00:00
πŸ“ Introduction and Preparation for the Interview

This paragraph introduces the format of the demonstration interview, emphasizing the use of Teams and Miro for a more interactive experience. It highlights the importance of being familiar with Miro and its functionalities prior to the interview. The speaker advises candidates to ensure a stable internet connection and a quiet environment for the interview. The main goal of the interview is to select candidates who are best suited for the course, focusing on their ability to apply knowledge rather than their prior knowledge. The speaker encourages candidates to practice explaining chemistry concepts and to be prepared to engage with unfamiliar material during the interview.

05:03
🀝 Interviewer Introductions and the Structure of the Interview

The paragraph begins with the interviewers introducing themselves and explaining the structure of the interview. Susan Perkin, a physical chemist, and Professor Steve Faulkner, an inorganic chemist, will be conducting the interview. They explain that the interview will last about 20 minutes and will involve using the Miro board. The interviewers encourage the candidate to communicate any technical issues or lack of understanding during the interview. The interview starts with a question about water, aiming to assess the candidate's understanding of molecular structure and properties.

10:07
πŸ§ͺ Exploring Atomic and Molecular Orbitals in Water

This section delves into a detailed discussion about atomic and molecular orbitals, specifically focusing on how they might overlap to form bonds within a water molecule. The candidate is guided through thinking about the spatial arrangement of orbitals and how they contribute to bonding. The conversation involves exploring the concept of constructive and destructive interference of electron clouds, leading to the formation of bonding and antibonding orbitals. The candidate demonstrates understanding by correctly identifying the number of lone pairs and bonds in a water molecule and discussing the implications of these findings.

15:15
🌑️ The Properties of Water in Different Phases

The discussion shifts to the properties of water in its different phases, particularly focusing on the behavior of water in liquid and solid states. The candidate is asked to consider the equilibrium between liquid water and ice at atmospheric pressure and to identify the temperature at which this equilibrium occurs in Kelvin. The conversation explores the concept of density in relation to the phase of water, leading to the conclusion that liquid water is denser than ice. The candidate is encouraged to think about the role of hydrogen bonding in this density difference and to relate it to everyday experiences.

20:23
πŸ’‘ Rationalizing the Density of Liquid Water

This part of the interview focuses on rationalizing why liquid water is denser than ice, based on the candidate's understanding of hydrogen bonding and molecular arrangement. The candidate suggests that the constant movement of water molecules in the liquid state prevents all hydrogen bonds from being fully formed at any given instant, allowing for a more compact arrangement and thus higher density. The interviewers commend the candidate's ability to connect the molecular-level understanding to the macroscopic properties of water, such as its density and the fact that ice floats on water.

25:27
πŸ“š Reflecting on the Interview and Assessment

The interview concludes with the interviewers reflecting on the candidate's performance. They discuss the candidate's ability to engage with new concepts, such as atomic and molecular orbitals, and to apply this knowledge to solve problems. The interviewers appreciate the candidate's clear thinking and communication skills, emphasizing the importance of being able to articulate one's thought process and understanding during the interview. They also highlight that there is no disadvantage in not knowing something beforehand, as long as the candidate can work through the information provided and demonstrate their reasoning abilities.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘Interview
The interview is the central format of the demonstration, where candidates are assessed on their ability to apply knowledge and problem-solve. It's a conversational process that involves the use of technology like Miro for visual aid and is designed to mimic the interactive nature of small group teaching.
πŸ’‘Miro
Miro is a collaborative online whiteboard platform used in the interview process to facilitate visual communication and problem-solving. It allows both the interviewer and the interviewee to write and draw on the same virtual whiteboard, enhancing the interactive and collaborative aspects of the discussion.
πŸ’‘Atomic Orbitals
Atomic orbitals are regions around the nucleus of an atom where electrons are most likely to be found. They are defined by their shape and energy and play a crucial role in chemical bonding as they overlap to form molecular orbitals.
πŸ’‘Molecular Orbitals
Molecular orbitals are the result of the overlap of atomic orbitals from different atoms, forming a bond. They represent the regions where electrons are most likely to be found in a molecule and contribute to the molecule's structure and properties.
πŸ’‘Hydrogen Bonding
Hydrogen bonding is a type of intermolecular force that occurs when a hydrogen atom, which is covalently bonded to a highly electronegative atom like oxygen or nitrogen, is attracted to another electronegative atom in a neighboring molecule. This interaction significantly influences the physical properties of substances, such as boiling points and solubility.
πŸ’‘Density
Density is a measure of mass per unit volume of a substance. It is a fundamental property that can affect how substances behave under different conditions, such as the buoyancy of ice in water, which is related to its density being less than that of liquid water.
πŸ’‘Phase Diagram
A phase diagram is a graphical representation showing the conditions under which a substance transitions between phases, such as solid, liquid, and gas. It typically displays pressure on one axis and temperature on the other, with lines indicating the equilibrium between phases.
πŸ’‘Chemistry Concepts
Chemistry concepts refer to the fundamental principles and theories that describe the composition, structure, properties, and reactions of substances. These concepts are essential for understanding and predicting chemical behavior.
πŸ’‘Problem-Solving
Problem-solving in this context refers to the ability to analyze and work through complex issues to find solutions, often requiring the application of knowledge and the use of critical thinking skills.
πŸ’‘Communication
Communication in an academic or interview setting involves the clear and effective exchange of ideas, thoughts, and information. It is crucial for demonstrating understanding and for collaborative learning.
Highlights

The interview process integrates the use of technology, specifically Microsoft Teams and Miro, to facilitate a dynamic and interactive experience.

Candidates are encouraged to practice using the Miro whiteboard in advance to feel more relaxed during the actual interview.

The interview focuses on assessing the candidate's ability to apply knowledge and problem-solving skills rather than their prior knowledge.

The interview is designed to be a practice-like environment where candidates can demonstrate their reasoning and analytical skills.

The interviewers emphasize the importance of communication, encouraging candidates to talk through their thought process and not to panic if they get stuck.

Candidates are advised to revise their schoolwork to have a solid foundation of language and terminology, even though prior knowledge is not the focus.

The interview involves a discussion on chemistry, specifically focusing on the concept of atomic and molecular orbitals and their interactions.

The candidate demonstrates understanding of water's molecular structure, including its polar nature and the role of hydrogen bonding.

The interview explores the concept of hydrogen bonding and its impact on the density of water in different states, such as liquid and solid.

The candidate effectively uses the Miro whiteboard to illustrate concepts and engage with the interviewers' questions.

The interviewers provide guidance and prompts to help the candidate think through problems and articulate their reasoning.

The candidate shows adaptability by adjusting their understanding and diagrams based on new information provided during the interview.

The interview concludes with the interviewers providing feedback on the candidate's performance and discussing the interview process.

The interview process aims to replicate aspects of small group teaching, focusing on the candidate's ability to learn and adapt in real-time.

The candidate's ability to admit when they don't understand something is seen as an important skill for learning and is valued in the interview.

The interview is representative of a typical admissions interview, aiming to assess the candidate's grasp of chemistry and their ability to work through unfamiliar concepts.

The use of technology in the interview process is intended to assist and ensure clear communication between the candidate and the interviewers.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: