Giuliani Addresses 'Black On Black Crime' | Meet The Press

NBC News
24 Nov 201403:26
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn a heated debate, Mayor Giuliani addresses the issue of police forces not reflecting the racial makeup of the communities they serve, citing New York City's efforts to diversify. Critics argue that the focus should include the disproportionate number of black individuals killed by other blacks, which Giuliani acknowledges but emphasizes is not the primary concern of the debate. The conversation highlights the trust issues between police and black communities and the need for systemic change to address racial disparities in law enforcement.

Takeaways
  • 📊 The script discusses the disproportionality of white police forces in communities, using data from a Washington Post analysis of census data in various cities.
  • 🌐 The cities of Miami Gardens, Florida, El Paso, Texas, Compton, Gary, Indiana, New York, and Detroit are highlighted as examples where the proportion of white police officers is higher than the white population.
  • 👮‍♂️ Mayor Giuliani emphasizes efforts in New York City to make the police force more representative of the community, acknowledging that it's not perfect but is better than the cities listed.
  • 🚨 The debate touches on the issue that 93% of black individuals in America are killed by other black individuals, suggesting that the focus should also be on this statistic.
  • 🔍 Mayor Giuliani argues that most black people who commit crimes against other black people are jailed, and that police officers are agents of the state with a duty to uphold the law, differentiating their role.
  • 🤔 The script raises the question of trust in the police force, particularly in communities of color, and the impact of this trust issue on community relations.
  • 🏛️ The issue of false equivalency is brought up, where the comparison between black-on-black crime and police violence against black individuals is seen as inappropriate.
  • 👨‍⚖️ The debate points out the disparity in the justice system, where white police officers who kill black individuals do not face the same consequences as black individuals who commit crimes.
  • 🏛️‍🔒 The script suggests that the heavy police presence in black communities is not justified by crime rates alone, and that the police cannot distinguish between criminals and law-abiding citizens.
  • 🛡️ The conversation highlights the defensive mechanisms of white supremacy, which may influence attitudes towards crime and policing in communities of color.
  • 🗣️ The heated exchange showcases the deep-seated tensions and differing perspectives on policing, race, and justice in America.
Q & A

  • What is the main issue discussed in the script regarding police forces?

    -The script discusses the disproportionality of white police forces in relation to the communities they serve, particularly in cities like Miami Gardens, El Paso, Compton, Gary, New York, and Detroit.

  • What does the term 'Fergusons' refer to in the context of the script?

    -The term 'Fergusons' refers to potential future incidents or situations similar to the unrest in Ferguson, Missouri, which was sparked by tensions between the predominantly white police force and the African American community.

  • How has New York City attempted to address the issue of police force representation?

    -New York City has tried to make its police force as proportionate as possible to the city's demographic makeup, under the administrations of Mayor Giuliani, Mayor Dinkin, Mayor Bloomberg, and Mayor DeBlasio.

  • What statistic is mentioned regarding the killing of African Americans in America?

    -The script highlights that 93% of African Americans in America are killed by other African Americans.

  • Why is the statistic of African Americans being killed by other African Americans considered significant in the debate?

    -The statistic is considered significant because it is used to argue that the focus on police violence against African Americans is misplaced, as most violence within the community is intraracial.

  • What is the counter-argument to the statistic mentioned above?

    -The counter-argument is that the issue of police violence against African Americans is distinct because police officers are agents of the state, and there is a disparity in the legal consequences faced by black individuals who kill within their community versus white police officers who kill black individuals.

  • What is the 'trust issue' mentioned in the script in relation to the police?

    -The trust issue refers to the lack of confidence in the police force, particularly among African American communities, due to perceived racial bias and disparities in how crimes are handled and punished.

  • What is the claim made by the speaker about the disproportionate representation of white police officers in black communities?

    -The claim is that a significant number of white police officers in black communities is not necessary and that their presence is part of a larger cultural issue related to race and policing in America.

  • What is the speaker's position on the issue of crime in predominantly black areas?

    -The speaker argues that crime within black communities is not the primary issue at hand in discussions about police representation and racial bias, and that focusing on this distracts from the systemic problems.

  • What is the term 'white supremacy' used to describe in the context of the debate?

    -The term 'white supremacy' is used to describe a defensive mechanism or mindset that the speaker believes is at work in the mind of Mayor Giuliani, suggesting that his views on crime and policing are influenced by racial bias.

  • What is the speaker's final point regarding the future of policing in the city if they become mayor?

    -The speaker suggests that if they become mayor, the issues of racial bias and disproportionate police presence in black communities will be addressed, implying that the situation would improve and such debates would no longer be necessary.

Outlines
00:00
👮‍♂️ Police Force Racial Disparity

The paragraph discusses the issue of racial disproportionality within police forces in the United States, using data from a Washington Post analysis of census data. It highlights that in several cities, the proportion of white police officers is significantly higher than the proportion of the white population. The conversation also touches on the efforts made by New York City mayors to make the police force more representative of the community. The paragraph emphasizes the importance of trust between the police and the community and the need to address the underlying issues of crime and racial bias in law enforcement.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Disproportionality
Disproportionality refers to an imbalance or inequality in representation or distribution. In the video's context, it highlights the disparity between the racial composition of police forces and the communities they serve. For example, the script mentions that in Miami Gardens, Florida, the proportion of white police officers is much higher than the proportion of the white population, illustrating the theme of racial disparity in law enforcement.
💡Census Data
Census data is collected by governments to enumerate the population and gather demographic information. The script references a Washington Post analysis of census data to demonstrate the disproportionality in police forces, showing how statistical evidence can be used to highlight social issues and the lack of representation in law enforcement.
💡Community Representation
Community representation is the concept of having a group or body that mirrors the diversity and characteristics of the community it serves. The video discusses the importance of police forces reflecting the racial makeup of the communities they protect, as seen in the efforts of New York City mayors to make the police force proportionate to the city's demographics.
💡Racial Disparities
Racial disparities refer to the differences in outcomes or treatment among different racial groups. The script addresses the issue of racial disparities in the context of crime and law enforcement, emphasizing that 93% of black Americans are killed by other blacks, which is used to argue for a focus on internal community issues rather than police-community relations.
💡Law Enforcement
Law enforcement is the activity of ensuring compliance with the law and maintaining public order. The video's theme revolves around the relationship between law enforcement and the communities they serve, particularly the issue of police forces not resembling the communities in terms of race and ethnicity.
💡Trust Issue
A trust issue refers to a lack of confidence or belief in someone or something. In the script, the trust issue is highlighted as a significant factor in the relationship between the police and the black community, with the implication that police presence and actions are not always perceived as protective or just.
💡Crime Statistics
Crime statistics are numerical data collected on criminal activities and their patterns. The script cites crime statistics to argue for the necessity of police presence in certain areas, with the claim that a high percentage of crime in a city justifies the heavy police presence, although this is challenged by others in the debate.
💡White Supremacy
White supremacy is the belief in the inherent superiority of the white race, which often results in discrimination and prejudice. In the video, the term is used to criticize a perspective that the speaker believes minimizes the impact of systemic racism and the need for police reform.
💡Indictment
An indictment is a formal charge or accusation made against someone, typically in a serious legal matter. The script mentions the ability of a jury to indict, using the phrase 'if a jury can indict a ham sandwich' to illustrate the perceived ease with which charges can be brought against individuals, contrasting with the difficulty of holding police officers accountable.
💡Accountability
Accountability is the obligation to report on or be responsible for one's actions. The video discusses the issue of police accountability, particularly in cases where white police officers are accused of killing black individuals, and the perceived lack of consequences for such actions.
💡Systemic Racism
Systemic racism refers to the presence of racism within the social system and its institutions. The script implies that systemic racism is a factor in the disproportionate representation of police forces and the treatment of black individuals by law enforcement, suggesting that the issue is deeply embedded in American culture.
Highlights

Disproportionality of white police forces compared to the communities they serve is highlighted.

Washington Post analysis of census data showing a higher proportion of white police officers than the white population in various cities.

Mayor Giuliani discusses efforts to make the police force in New York City more proportionate to the community.

The reality of New York City not being on the list of cities with disproportionate police forces.

Discussion on the statistic that 93% of black Americans are killed by other blacks.

Mayor Giuliani's argument that most black criminals who commit crimes against other blacks go to jail.

The distinction between police officers as agents of the state and individuals who commit crimes.

The issue of trust between the police and the black community.

The argument that heavy police presence in black communities is not justified by crime statistics.

The concern for black children killed by other black children and the lack of attention to this issue.

The debate on the role of white police officers in predominantly black areas.

The claim that 70 to 75% of crime in New York City is addressed by the police presence.

The accusation of a defensive mechanism of white supremacy in the discussion.

The heated exchange between Michael Eric Dyson and Mayor Giuliani on the issues of crime and race.

The tension and heated debate that characterizes the conversation on police and community relations.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Black Cops on the Murder of Tyre Nichols | Uncomfortable Conversations | Police Brutality FULL EP.

Is there a double standard for black-on-white crime?

Combating Racism: Preventing the Criminalization of Normal Adolescent Behavior Among Youth of Color

"Statistics on Cop on Black Crime" - #SOC119

What We Get Wrong When We Think About Food Insecurity | Leslie Campbell | TEDxYouth@PCI

Black murder is normal | Michael Smith | TEDxJacksonville

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Police RepresentationRacial DisparityCrime StatisticsCommunity TrustDeBlasioGiulianiCriminal JusticeUrban DebateLaw EnforcementSocial Issues