How humans are exploiting the oceans | DW Documentary

DW Documentary
8 Jun 202385:56
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe script explores the contentious issue of deep-sea mining, highlighting the potential environmental risks and the race for untapped mineral deposits. It discusses the technological advancements in mining equipment, the environmental concerns raised by organizations like Greenpeace, and the potential impact on marine ecosystems. The narrative also touches on the importance of preserving the oceans' ability to nurture humanity and the challenges of balancing resource extraction with environmental sustainability.

Takeaways
  • 🌊 The deep sea is being explored for vast mineral deposits, with technology like the 'Patanya' deep sea collector being tested for mining operations.
  • 🔋 Deep-sea minerals such as manganese, nickel, cobalt, and copper are vital for manufacturing batteries needed for the transition to clean energy.
  • 💡 Environmental organizations like Greenpeace are concerned about the potential environmental damage of deep-sea mining and advocate for its prevention.
  • 🌍 The oceans play a critical role in regulating the climate, providing oxygen, and absorbing CO2 emissions, making their health essential for the planet's survival.
  • 🐋 The decline in ocean health is evident through overfishing, pollution, and the creation of 'ocean dead zones,' impacting marine life and ecosystems.
  • 🚢 The 'Island Pride' vessel and its crew conducted an expedition to study the environmental impact of deep-sea mining using a 35-ton underwater harvesting machine.
  • 🌿 The United Nations has declared an 'Ocean Decade' to focus on the protection and sustainable development of the world's oceans, emphasizing the need for global cooperation.
  • 🤝 The balance between utilizing deep-sea resources and preserving marine environments is a complex issue that involves scientific research, industry interests, and policy-making.
  • 🚧 The demand for metals like cobalt, nickel, and copper is driving exploration in places like the Clarion Clipperton Zone, where massive quantities of polymetallic nodules are found.
  • 🐢 Conservation efforts, such as those by the Lantuna organization in Cape Verde, work to protect endangered species and restore habitats, highlighting the importance of local engagement in preservation.
  • 🔬 Scientific research during expeditions aims to understand and measure the potential disturbances to deep-sea ecosystems caused by mining activities, informing future regulations and policies.
Q & A
  • What is the primary goal of the expedition mentioned in the script?

    -The primary goal of the expedition is to explore the deep sea for enormous deposits of minerals and to test the first prototype of a deep-sea collector called Patanya, which is designed to harvest these minerals without causing environmental harm.

  • What are the main concerns of environmental protection organizations like Greenpeace regarding deep-sea mining?

    -Environmental protection organizations like Greenpeace are concerned that deep-sea mining could cause irreversible damage to the delicate underwater world and disrupt the natural balance of the ocean ecosystems.

  • What role do oceans play in mitigating the effects of climate change?

    -Oceans play a crucial role in mitigating the effects of climate change by serving as an important heat buffer and carbon sink, absorbing about a quarter of man-made CO2 emissions.

  • What is the significance of the United Nations' proclamation of an 'Ocean Decade'?

    -The United Nations proclaimed an 'Ocean Decade' to advance the protection and sustainable development of the world's oceans, emphasizing the need for global cooperation in marine science and policy to address the challenges facing our oceans.

  • What is the purpose of the mining IMPACT program?

    -The mining IMPACT program aims to examine the environmental impact of deep-sea mining operations, specifically testing a 35-ton underwater harvesting machine and developing environmental analysis parameters and standards.

  • What are the potential benefits of deep-sea mining compared to land mining?

    -Deep-sea mining could potentially offer an alternative to land mining that is less destructive to nature, does not require deforestation or relocation of communities, and could provide metals needed for the transition to clean energy technologies.

  • What is the main argument of the Canadian mining company GSR regarding deep-sea mining?

    -GSR argues that deep-sea mining could provide the necessary metals for clean energy technologies without the environmental and social costs associated with land mining, such as habitat destruction and poor working conditions.

  • What are the consequences of overfishing and illegal fishing practices on the high seas?

    -Overfishing and illegal fishing practices on the high seas lead to the depletion of fish stocks, disrupt marine ecosystems, and threaten the long-term sustainability of fisheries and the health of the oceans.

  • What is the mission of Alexandra Cousteau's Ocean's 2050 foundation?

    -The mission of Alexandra Cousteau's Ocean's 2050 foundation is to restore ocean habitats and promote sustainable practices that will rebuild ocean ecosystems and bring life back to the seas.

  • What are the potential environmental impacts of the manganese nodule collector Patanya?

    -The potential environmental impacts of the manganese nodule collector Patanya include the disturbance of the deep-sea floor, the release of sediment plumes that could cover marine life, and the potential for long-term damage to deep-sea ecosystems.

  • What is the significance of the Clarion Clipperton Zone in the context of deep-sea mining?

    -The Clarion Clipperton Zone is significant in the context of deep-sea mining because it is an area the size of Europe with an estimated 30 billion tons of polymetallic nodules containing valuable metals like cobalt, nickel, manganese, and copper, which are in high demand for clean energy technologies.

Outlines
00:00
🚢 Ambitious Deep Sea Expedition

An ambitious expedition sets out to explore the deep sea to uncover dormant mineral deposits. Despite having the technology to harvest these resources, scientists are concerned about the potential environmental impact. Greenpeace and other organizations are opposed to deep sea mining, fearing it could destroy delicate underwater ecosystems. The prototype for the deep sea collector, Patanya, is being tested at several thousand meters depth to monitor its feasibility and risks.

05:02
🔬 Environmental Impact Study

In March 2021, amidst the global coronavirus pandemic, a special ship called the Island Pride was prepared for a mission to examine the environmental impact of a manganese nodule collector on the seabed. Researchers equipped with high-tech marine research equipment were on board to analyze the first test of its kind. The expedition aimed to understand the environmental consequences of deep sea mining by deploying various measuring devices and collecting data.

10:03
🌍 The Destructive Impact of Land Mining

Mining on land, especially in politically unstable countries, is often destructive and harmful to both nature and human rights. Workers in countries like the Democratic Republic of Congo suffer from horrendous conditions, risking their lives for minimal wages. The industry argues that seabed mining could be less harmful as it doesn't require removing forests or relocating people, but emphasizes the need for thorough research to minimize environmental impact.

15:06
🏖️ Illegal Sand Mining Crisis

On the Cape Verde Islands, illegal sand mining has devastated the coastline. Trucks strip sand from beaches and seabeds to sell as raw material for construction, leaving behind barren stone landscapes. Conservationists like Maria struggle against this illegal activity, which severely impacts marine life and local ecosystems. The lack of enforcement allows this harmful practice to continue, contributing to the degradation of coastal habitats worldwide.

20:06
🔍 Patania's First Real Test

The Island Pride reaches the Clarion Clipperton Zone to join the Belgian ship testing Patania, the world’s first manganese nodule collector prototype. The machine's ability to function under extreme conditions and its potential environmental impact are closely monitored. Patania’s success could pave the way for commercial seabed mining, but the environmental risks and the extent of disturbance caused by such activities remain significant concerns.

25:09
🐢 Conservation Efforts in Cape Verde

In Cape Verde, conservationists like Anna Vega are committed to protecting the local marine life, especially the endangered loggerhead sea turtles. The removal of sand has destroyed vital nesting habitats, prompting conservation efforts to safeguard the eggs and ensure the survival of these turtles. Despite the challenges, Anna and her team work tirelessly to raise awareness and involve the community in conservation activities.

30:10
📊 Analyzing Deep Sea Biodiversity

Researchers aboard the Island Pride meticulously examine samples from the deep sea to understand the biodiversity of the Clarion Clipperton Zone. The team uses advanced equipment to measure oxygen levels and study microbial communities. These efforts aim to assess the environmental impact of seabed mining and highlight the rich, yet largely unknown, biodiversity in deep sea habitats.

35:11
🔬 Research and Conservation Synergy

The scientists aboard the Island Pride are excited to discover new species and study the unique deep sea fauna. Their research aims to provide crucial data to balance the need for resource extraction with environmental preservation. Meanwhile, conservationists in Cape Verde celebrate their small successes in protecting marine life, underscoring the importance of sustainable practices and local involvement in conservation efforts.

40:12
🛑 Greenpeace's Deep Sea Mining Protest

Greenpeace’s Rainbow Warrior tracks the industrial vessel Normand Energy, protesting against deep sea mining. They emphasize the potential long-term environmental damage and the need to preserve the ocean's biodiversity. Despite industry and scientific efforts to minimize harm, Greenpeace argues that the risks of disrupting deep sea ecosystems outweigh the benefits of resource extraction.

45:13
🌊 The Role of the International Seabed Authority

The International Seabed Authority (ISA), headquartered in Jamaica, regulates deep sea mining activities. It aims to balance industrial interests, scientific findings, and environmental concerns. With 167 member countries, the ISA is developing a mining code to ensure sustainable exploitation of deep sea resources. The organization's unique opportunity lies in establishing regulations before commercial mining begins, striving for a cautious and informed approach.

50:13
⚖️ Balancing Development and Conservation

The Island Pride’s expedition in the Clarion Clipperton Zone reveals the extensive environmental impact of seabed mining. The disturbance of sediment and potential damage to marine life raise significant concerns. The challenge lies in balancing the need for metals for green technology with the preservation of deep sea ecosystems. Researchers and policymakers must consider the long-term consequences of deep sea mining and strive for sustainable practices.

55:15
🧪 Exploring Unknown Deep Sea Species

Researchers aboard the Island Pride are excited to discover and study new species from the deep sea. Detailed analyses in the laboratory aim to understand the biodiversity of the Clarion Clipperton Zone. These efforts highlight the importance of preserving these largely unexplored habitats and provide valuable insights into the environmental impact of deep sea mining.

00:17
🐢 Protecting Sea Turtles in Cape Verde

In Cape Verde, conservationists work tirelessly to protect endangered sea turtles by safeguarding their nests from predators and human interference. Efforts include relocating eggs to protected areas and raising awareness among locals. These initiatives aim to ensure the survival of the turtles and promote sustainable practices in the community.

05:18
🐟 Sustainable Fishing Practices

The conservationists in Cape Verde and small-scale fishers in Germany advocate for sustainable fishing practices. By avoiding harmful industrial methods and focusing on local needs, they aim to preserve marine biodiversity and ensure the health of ocean ecosystems. Sustainable fishing not only benefits the environment but also supports the livelihoods of local communities.

10:20
🌍 Addressing Overfishing and Illegal Fishing

Overfishing and illegal fishing practices threaten marine life worldwide. Organizations like Greenpeace document these issues and advocate for stricter regulations to protect ocean ecosystems. The challenge is to balance the demand for fish with sustainable practices that allow fish populations to replenish and maintain biodiversity.

15:23
🔄 Sustainable Fishing in the Baltic Sea

The Myers, a father and son fishing team in the Baltic Sea, practice sustainable fishing methods to preserve fish populations. They use gill nets with larger mesh sizes to avoid catching small fish and sell their catch directly to local consumers. Their approach contrasts with industrial trawling, which depletes fish stocks and harms marine ecosystems.

20:23
🌊 Restoring Ocean Habitats

Ocean conservation advocates like Alexandra Cousteau emphasize the need to protect and restore marine habitats. Initiatives such as Ocean's 2050 aim to rebuild ocean ecosystems through sustainable practices and innovative solutions. The goal is to ensure the long-term health of the oceans, which are vital for the planet’s climate regulation and biodiversity.

25:34
⛏️ The Future of Deep Sea Mining

The Island Pride’s expedition concludes, highlighting the potential and risks of deep sea mining. While the need for metals for green technology is recognized, the environmental impact of seabed mining cannot be ignored. Researchers and policymakers must weigh the benefits against the long-term damage to deep sea ecosystems and strive for sustainable solutions.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Deep Sea Mining
Deep Sea Mining refers to the process of extracting minerals from the deep sea bed, often in the form of polymetallic nodules rich in metals like manganese, nickel, cobalt, and copper. In the video, this concept is central to the debate over exploiting the ocean's resources for technological advancement while considering the potential environmental impact. The script mentions the testing of a deep sea collector prototype called Patanya, indicating the real possibility of this activity becoming a commercial reality.
💡Environmental Impact
Environmental Impact denotes the effects—positive or negative—that human activities have on the environment. The video script discusses the potential destructive effects of deep sea mining on the delicate underwater world, such as disturbing sediments and marine life, and the release of CO2 from seabed sediments. The concern is highlighted by the presence of Greenpeace activists who are against such mining activities.
💡Sustainability
Sustainability, in the context of the video, refers to the ability to maintain or even improve environmental, social, and economic conditions without depleting resources or causing harm over the long term. The script mentions the head of sustainability for GSR, Samantha Smith, who discusses the need for moving towards clean energy and the role of sustainable practices in sourcing the necessary metals from the sea without causing irreversible damage to marine ecosystems.
💡Manganese Nodules
Manganese Nodules are a type of mineral deposit found on the deep sea floor, composed of various metals such as manganese, nickel, cobalt, and copper. These nodules are highlighted in the script as a valuable resource for the production of batteries, which are essential for renewable energy storage. The mining of these nodules is a focal point of the video, with discussions on the balance between harnessing their potential for clean energy and preserving the marine environment.
💡Overfishing
Overfishing is the act of catching fish at a rate that is faster than their capacity to reproduce, leading to a decrease in fish populations and affecting marine ecosystems. The video script touches on this issue, mentioning that one third of all fish stocks are overfished. It illustrates the problem with the example of Chinese industrial fishing vessels that operate around the clock, contributing to the depletion of fish stocks.
💡Climate Change
Climate Change is a significant and lasting change in the Earth's weather patterns, causing dangerous and harmful effects on the environment. The video script connects the health of the oceans to climate change, emphasizing the role of oceans as a carbon sink and their importance in regulating the climate. It suggests that the actions taken in exploiting marine resources could exacerbate the effects of climate change.
💡Oceans as a Carbon Sink
The term 'Oceans as a Carbon Sink' refers to the oceans' ability to absorb and store carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, thus helping to mitigate climate change. The script points out that oceans absorb about a quarter of man-made CO2 emissions, playing a crucial role in reducing the impacts of climate change. However, it also warns that disrupting the seabed through activities like deep sea mining could release stored carbon back into the atmosphere.
💡Biodiversity
Biodiversity refers to the variety of life in a particular ecosystem, including the number of species, genetic diversity within species, and the variety of ecosystems. The video script discusses the high biodiversity in the deep sea, suggesting that there could be more species diversity there than on land. It raises concerns that deep sea mining could disrupt and potentially destroy habitats, affecting unknown species and their contribution to the ecosystem.
💡Sustainable Fishing
Sustainable Fishing is a practice that ensures the long-term survival of fish populations and the overall health of marine ecosystems by avoiding overfishing and minimizing environmental impact. The script features a father and son fishing company in the Baltic Sea that has switched to sustainable fishing methods, using larger mesh sizes to avoid catching juvenile fish and focusing on species that are still relatively plentiful.
💡International Seabed Authority (ISA)
The International Seabed Authority is an organization established by the United Nations to regulate deep sea mining and ensure the sustainable use of marine resources. The script mentions ISA as the body that will decide whether deep sea mining is permissible, taking into account scientific advice, consensus among member states, and the development of regulations known as the mining code.
💡Marine Conservation
Marine Conservation involves the protection and management of marine ecosystems to preserve biodiversity and ensure the health of the oceans. The video script showcases the efforts of conservationists like Anna and her team from the organization Lantuna, who work to protect sea turtles and their habitats in Cape Verde. Their work is an example of marine conservation in action, emphasizing the importance of community involvement and sustainable practices.
Highlights

An ambitious expedition explores the deep sea for mineral deposits, raising questions about the potential benefits and environmental risks of deep-sea mining.

The first prototype of a deep-sea collector, Patanya, is tested at great depths, sparking debates on the potential destruction of delicate underwater ecosystems.

Environmental organizations like Greenpeace advocate against deep-sea mining, fearing irreversible damage to the ocean's ability to nurture humanity and mitigate climate change.

The ocean, covering 71% of Earth's surface, is crucial for climate regulation, food provision, and oxygen production, yet it faces severe threats from human activities.

The mining of manganese nodules, rich in metals like cobalt and nickel, is considered for meeting the growing demand for batteries in the transition to clean energy.

The United Nations proclaims an 'Ocean Decade' to advance ocean protection and sustainable development, emphasizing the need for global cooperation.

The mining impact program investigates the environmental effects of a 35-ton underwater harvesting machine, aiming to develop standards for sustainable mining practices.

Modern robots are presented as a potential solution for energy transition, but their impact on deep-sea life and ecosystems remains a concern.

The Island Pride vessel embarks on a mission to examine the environmental impact of deep-sea mining, carrying a team of European scientists and high-tech equipment.

The GSR company's manganese nodule collector faces scrutiny for its potential environmental footprint, as experts weigh the benefits of mining against ecological harm.

Cape Verde's beaches suffer from sand depletion, affecting local ecosystems and the habitat of endangered loggerhead sea turtles.

The Island Pride reaches the Clarion Clipperton Zone, where vast quantities of polymetallic nodules lie, and where the environmental impact of mining is tested.

Greenpeace's Rainbow Warrior protests against deep-sea mining, advocating for the preservation of the ocean's climate resilience and biodiversity.

The International Seabed Authority (ISA) is highlighted as the key decision-making body for deep-sea mining regulations, balancing industry interests with environmental concerns.

The research expedition aboard the Island Pride reveals the potential for significant environmental disturbance from deep-sea mining machinery.

Biologists and geologists on the Island Pride discover and analyze deep-sea fauna, emphasizing the high biodiversity and potential for unknown species in the Clarion Clipperton Zone.

The documentary raises questions about the trade-offs between the need for metal resources and the preservation of the deep sea, urging society to consider the long-term consequences of its actions.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: