Great Schism (1054)

Ryan Reeves

4 Apr 201531:01

EducationalLearning

32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe script discusses the often-neglected Orthodox Church, explaining its origins from the Great Schism of 1054, which separated the Catholic and Eastern Churches. It highlights the Orthodox Church as the second largest Christian denomination, with around 250 million adherents. The lecture delves into the political, theological, and ecclesiastical factors leading to the schism, emphasizing the role of the Pope and the Eastern Emperor. It also touches on controversies like iconoclasm and the Filioque clause, illustrating the deep-rooted differences in authority and practice between the East and West.

Takeaways

😕 The Orthodox Church is often overlooked, especially in Protestant North America, and is mistakenly referred to as just Greek Orthodox, despite its diverse geographical and linguistic presence.
🌍 The Orthodox Church is the second largest Christian denomination globally, with approximately 250 million adherents, following the Catholic Church and ahead of Protestant denominations.
🔍 The Great Schism of 1054 marked the separation of the Catholic Church from the Eastern Church, which later became known as the Orthodox Church, due to a culmination of political, theological, and ecclesiastical differences.
🏛 Historically, the Eastern and Western Churches had a unified political identity under the Roman Empire, but over time, the Western Church sought greater autonomy, leading to the establishment of the Holy Roman Empire.
👑 The Eastern Orthodox Church does not recognize a single supreme leader like the Pope; instead, it operates under a system of principal patriarchs who collaborate and share authority.
📜 Theological disputes, such as the Filioque controversy (the addition of 'and the Son' in the Nicene Creed by the Western Church), contributed to the growing divide between East and West.
🗣️ Communication barriers, including language differences (Greek in the East and Latin in the West), and cultural differences, exacerbated the separation of the two Churches.
🛑 The final break, known as the Great Schism, was triggered by a conflict between the papal legate Humbert of Silva Candida and the Patriarch of Constantinople, Michael I, culminating in mutual excommunication in 1054.
🕊️ Despite the Schism, there have been efforts towards reconciliation, such as the joint omission of the Filioque clause by Pope John Paul II and the Patriarch of Constantinople in 2004.
📚 Understanding the historical context, political motivations, and theological disputes is crucial for appreciating the complexity and significance of the Great Schism and the ongoing relationship between the Catholic and Orthodox Churches.

Q & A

What is the common misnomer for the Orthodox Church and why is it incorrect?
-The common misnomer for the Orthodox Church is 'Greek Orthodox,' which is incorrect because the Orthodox Church is not limited to Greece. It is a diverse and widespread church with different geographical, linguistic, and patriarchal aspects, not just Greek.
Why is the term 'Byzantine Church' also a misnomer?
-The term 'Byzantine Church' is a misnomer because it incorrectly localizes the epicenter of the Orthodox Church solely in the Byzantine lands, particularly in Constantinople (modern-day Istanbul), whereas the Orthodox Church has a broader geographical presence.
What is the significance of the Orthodox Church being the second largest single unit Church in the world?
-The significance lies in its size and influence. With approximately 250 million adherents, the Orthodox Church represents a vitally important Christian body that has maintained its identity and traditions despite being in regions that can be hostile to Christianity.
What historical event is known as the Great Schism and what did it result in?
-The Great Schism of 1054 is the historical event that resulted in the separation of the Catholic Church (Western Church) from the Eastern Church, which later became known as the Orthodox Church. This division had lasting theological and political implications.
What are some of the factors that led to the separation between the East and the West in the Christian Church?
-Factors leading to the separation include political issues, such as the desire for autonomy and the rise of the Holy Roman Empire; theological differences, such as the Filioque controversy and the use of icons; and cultural and communication barriers, including language differences between Greek and Latin.
Why did the papacy begin to assert its independence from the Eastern Emperor?
-The papacy began to assert its independence due to a desire to not always answer to the Eastern Emperor, especially after the coronation of Charlemagne by Pope Leo III, which marked a move towards having an autonomous authority in the West.
What is the theological controversy surrounding the Filioque clause?
-The Filioque clause controversy revolves around the addition of 'and the Son' in the Nicene Creed by the Western Church, which states that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father 'and the Son.' The Eastern Church does not include this phrase, viewing the original Creed as sufficient and the Western addition as an overreach of papal authority.
How did the issue of iconoclasm exemplify the growing divide between the Eastern and Western Churches?
-The issue of iconoclasm exemplified the divide as the Eastern Emperor and patriarchs condemned the use of religious images, while the Western Church, led by the papacy, refused to comply, thus highlighting the theological and political differences between the two branches of Christianity.
What was the role of Humbert of Silva Candida in the events leading up to the Great Schism of 1054?
-Humbert of Silva Candida was a papal advisor who, after translating and reacting to a critical letter from the East, helped escalate tensions. He was part of the delegation sent to Constantinople in 1054, where he engaged in a heated dispute with the Patriarch Michael I, culminating in mutual excommunications.
How did the mutual excommunication in 1054 between the representatives of the Western and Eastern Churches contribute to the Great Schism?
-The mutual excommunication in 1054, where Humbert excommunicated the Patriarch Michael I and vice versa, symbolized a breakdown in communication and a hardening of positions. Over time, this event became a fixed point in the separation of the Eastern and Western Churches.

Outlines

00:00

🌍 The Neglected Orthodox Church

The speaker addresses the common oversight of the Orthodox Church's existence and diversity in the modern Protestant world, particularly in North America. They highlight the misnomer of referring to the Orthodox Church as solely 'Greek Orthodox' or 'Byzantine Church,' emphasizing its geographical and linguistic variety. The Orthodox Church is identified as the second largest Christian denomination globally, with approximately 250 million adherents. The script also points out the challenges faced by Orthodox communities in hostile regions and sets the stage for a discussion on the Great Schism of 1054, which led to the separation of the Orthodox Church from the Catholic Church.

05:02

🏛 The Political and Ecclesiastical Origins of the Schism

This paragraph delves into the political backdrop leading to the Great Schism, discussing the historical unity of the Christian Empire established by Constantine and the evolving tensions between the Eastern and Western Churches. It outlines the shift in power dynamics, with the papacy asserting its independence from the Byzantine Emperor and the establishment of the Holy Roman Empire in the West. The paragraph also touches on the ecclesiastical differences, such as the Eastern Church's collective governance by principal patriarchs versus the Western Church's centralized papal authority, setting the stage for the impending schism.

10:05

🤝 The Misunderstood Role of the Bishop of Rome

The speaker clarifies misconceptions about the Orthodox Church's view of the Bishop of Rome, explaining that the Eastern Church does not recognize a single Pope with authority over all but rather a collaborative governance among several patriarchs. The historical development of this ecclesiastical structure is traced back to the Constantinople Council, which established the preeminence of certain bishoprics, including Rome and Constantinople. The paragraph highlights the ongoing disputes and theological disagreements rooted in differing views on the Pope's role and authority.

15:06

🗝 Theological Disputes: Filioque and Iconoclasm

This section focuses on two significant theological disputes that contributed to the schism: iconoclasm and the Filioque controversy. Iconoclasm refers to the Eastern Emperor's ban on religious images, which the Western Church resisted. The Filioque issue concerns the addition of 'and the Son' to the Nicene Creed by the Western Church, which the Eastern Church vehemently opposed as an unauthorized alteration. These disputes underscore the broader issues of authority and theological interpretation between the Eastern and Western Churches.

20:07

📜 The Filioque Controversy: A Theological Deep Dive

The paragraph provides a detailed examination of the Filioque controversy, explaining the theological reasoning behind the Western Church's addition of 'and the Son' to the Nicene Creed and the Eastern Church's objections. It discusses the Western Church's concern with Arianism and the desire to emphasize the co-equality of the Father and the Son in the procession of the Holy Spirit. The speaker also recounts a significant moment in 2004 when the Pope and the Patriarch of Constantinople agreed to omit the Filioque during a joint service, indicating a potential easing of tensions over this issue.

25:08

💥 The Great Schism of 1054: Ego Clash and Excommunication

The narrative culminates in the events of 1054, detailing the interactions between Humbert of Silva Candida, a papal advisor, and Michael the First, the Patriarch of Constantinople. Their diplomatic conflict, characterized by stubbornness and a lack of willingness to compromise, led to a dramatic excommunication exchange during the Easter service. This act is identified as the catalyst for the formalization of the Great Schism, which, although not initially perceived as permanent, eventually became a lasting division between the Eastern and Western Churches.

30:10

🕊️ The Lasting Impact of the Great Schism

In conclusion, the speaker reflects on the unintended long-term consequences of the 1054 excommunications, which solidified the separation of the Eastern and Western Churches. Initially viewed as a temporary dispute between two powerful figures, the schism evolved into a permanent state of division, especially as subsequent historical events like the Crusades further strained relations. The paragraph leaves the audience with a contemplation of how such a significant split originated from a single, heated moment in history.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Orthodox Church

The Orthodox Church, also known as the Eastern Orthodox Church, is one of the oldest Christian traditions and is known for its rich liturgical practices and theology. It is the second-largest Christian body in the world, with approximately 250 million adherents. In the video, the speaker discusses the tendency to overlook the Orthodox Church in the West, highlighting its significant presence and the need for greater awareness of its history and practices.

💡Great Schism

The Great Schism of 1054 refers to the event that led to the division between the Eastern Orthodox Church and the Roman Catholic Church. It symbolizes a significant split in Christianity that was both political and theological. The video script delves into the causes and implications of this schism, emphasizing its long-lasting effects on the Christian world.

💡Patriarch

A Patriarch in the Orthodox Church is a high-ranking bishop who heads one of the major dioceses, often associated with a historical city. The script mentions the Patriarch of Constantinople as a significant figure in the governance of the Eastern Church, contrasting with the centralized authority of the Pope in the Western Church.

💡Filioque

The Filioque controversy is a theological dispute over the wording of the Nicene Creed, specifically whether the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father 'and the Son' (Filioque in Latin) or only from the Father, as stated in the original Greek version. The script discusses how this issue contributed to the rift between the Eastern and Western Churches.

💡Papal Primacy

Papal Primacy refers to the authority of the Pope as the head of the Roman Catholic Church. The concept is central to the debate on the governance of the Church, with the Eastern Orthodox Church viewing the Pope as a first among equals, rather than the supreme authority over the entire Christian world, as the Western Church does.

💡Iconoclasm

Iconoclasm was a period of religious and political conflict within the Byzantine Empire where the use of religious images or icons was banned by imperial decree. The script uses this historical event to illustrate the theological and cultural differences between the Eastern and Western Churches.

💡Hagia Sophia

Hagia Sophia is a significant historical building located in Istanbul (formerly Constantinople), which was once a cathedral and later a mosque, and is now a museum. In the script, it is mentioned as the site where the mutual excommunication between the Eastern and Western Churches took place during the Great Schism.

💡Byzantine Empire

The Byzantine Empire, also referred to as the Eastern Roman Empire, was the continuation of the Roman Empire in its eastern provinces during Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages. The script locates the epicenter of the Orthodox Church in the Byzantine lands, particularly in Constantinople.

💡Crusades

The Crusades were a series of religious wars sanctioned by the Latin Church during the Middle Ages, the script mentions them as a time when the existing schism between the East and West was further complicated and exacerbated.

💡Eucharist

The Eucharist is a Christian sacrament that involves the consumption of bread and wine, symbolizing the body and blood of Jesus Christ. The script discusses a disagreement over the type of bread used in the Eucharist, with the Western Church using unleavened bread, which was criticized by the Eastern Church.

💡Holy Roman Empire

The Holy Roman Empire was a multi-ethnic complex of territories in Western and Central Europe during the Middle Ages. The script refers to the establishment of the Holy Roman Empire and its significance in the West's desire for autonomy and its separation from the Eastern Byzantine Empire.

Highlights

The Orthodox Church is often mistakenly referred to as Greek Orthodox, despite its diverse geographical and linguistic spread.

The term 'Byzantine Church' is a misnomer, as it incorrectly localizes the Orthodox Church's epicenter in Byzantine lands.

The Orthodox Church is the second largest single unit Church globally, with approximately 250 million adherents.

The Great Schism of 1054 marked the separation of the Catholic Church from the Eastern Church, later known as the Orthodox Church.

Political factors, theological differences, and ecclesiastical authority disputes contributed to the East-West separation.

The papacy began asserting independence from the Eastern Emperor, especially after the coronation of Charlemagne by Pope Leo III.

The establishment of the Holy Roman Empire with Otto I signified a deepening identity of the Western Church as a separate entity.

The Eastern Orthodox Church operates on a model of principal patriarchies rather than a single Pope ruling over the entire Church.

The role of the Bishop of Rome within the Eastern Church has been a central point of contention between East and West.

The issue of iconoclasm, where the Eastern Emperor and patriarchs condemned the use of religious images, highlighted theological differences.

The Filioque controversy, concerning the procession of the Holy Spirit, is a major theological dispute between the Eastern and Western Churches.

The West's addition of the Filioque to the Nicene Creed without Eastern consent was seen as an overextension of papal authority.

In 2004, the Pope and the Patriarch of Constantinople agreed not to pronounce the Filioque when saying the Nicene Creed together.

The Great Schism was triggered by a conflict between papal legate Humbert of Silva Candida and Patriarch Michael I of Constantinople.

The mutual excommunication in 1054 by Humbert and Michael marked the official beginning of the Great Schism.

Initially, the Great Schism was not seen as a permanent division, but it solidified over time due to ongoing conflicts.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

The Great Schism of 1054 Why the Catholic West and Orthodox East Divided DOCUMENTARY

Great Schism 1054 A.D.

The Great Schism of 1054: How the Church Became Divided | Church History

Great Schism or East-West Schism part 1 | World History | Khan Academy

Great Schism: The Bitter Rivalry Between Greek and Latin Christianity

The Great Schism

Related Tags

Great Schism Christianity Orthodox Church Catholic Church 1054 Divorce Church History Religious Division Eastern Orthodoxy Western Christianity Historical Theology