The Scaling Fences: Voices of Irregular African Migrants to Europe report launch

United Nations Development Programme (UNDP)
22 Oct 201995:16
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) has launched a report titled 'Scaling Fences: Voices of Irregular African Migrants to Europe', which delves into the experiences and motivations of African migrants. The report, based on interviews with over 3,000 migrants, aims to humanize migration, challenge the perception of migrants as a homogenous group, and highlight the complex interplay between migration and development. It emphasizes that migration is not merely driven by unemployment but by a lack of opportunities and the pursuit of ambitions, often fueled by education and awareness of global possibilities. The discussion underscores the need for policy reform, better communication of opportunities within Africa, and a shift in narrative to encourage a more constructive approach to migration as a development issue.

Takeaways
  • 🌐 The report emphasizes that migration is a complex issue deeply intertwined with development, and it is neither new nor will it end, highlighting the need for a nuanced understanding of migration beyond simplistic narratives.
  • πŸ“ˆ Migration is often a result of ambition outpacing opportunity, with many migrants being more educated and from urban environments, seeking better prospects than those available to them at home.
  • πŸ™οΈ Urbanization and the growth of cities in Africa are significant factors influencing migration, as people move from areas with more development to seek further opportunities.
  • πŸ’Ό Many irregular migrants come from larger households and contribute to their families back home through remittances, which represent a significant portion of their income.
  • 🧳 The journey of migration is perilous and uncertain, yet a majority of those interviewed would still choose to make the journey again, indicating the depth of their desire for a better life.
  • 🚫 There is a lack of trust in institutions and governance in the countries of origin, which influences the decision to migrate.
  • 🀝 The report calls for a global partnership to address migration, involving countries of origin, transit, and destination, to manage migration in a way that benefits all parties.
  • πŸ“‰ The presence of irregular migrants in Europe can lead to a perception crisis and policy vacuum, resulting in visible displacement and contributing to anti-migration sentiments.
  • 🌱 Investment in development in African countries is key to addressing the root causes of migration, with a focus on expanding opportunities and choices for youth.
  • πŸ“Š The report provides a detailed analysis of the demographics, motivations, and experiences of African migrants in Europe, offering a data-driven perspective on migration.
  • πŸ”„ There is a need for a shift in the discourse around migration, focusing on the positive aspects of migration when managed well and the role it can play in global development.
Q & A
  • What is the main focus of the 'Scaling Fences' report?

    -The 'Scaling Fences' report focuses on understanding the phenomenon of migration from a development perspective, particularly irregular migration, and how it is linked to development. It aims to address the issue by presenting the voices and experiences of those who have made the journey, challenging the development community to see and hear a group of people who are often spoken of but not listened to.

  • Why is it important to consider migration as part of human history and future?

    -Migration is considered part of human history and future because it is neither new nor will it end. It is a complex issue that has been managed well or failed abysmally at different times. Understanding migration in this context helps to address it from a development perspective, which is crucial for the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP).

  • What does the report suggest about the typical profile of irregular migrants?

    -The report suggests that the typical profile of irregular migrants is not necessarily the most desperate, least educated, or most starving individuals. Often, it is those who have some education, a sense of another horizon, some savings, and the energy and courage to take risks that make up the majority of irregular migrants.

  • How does the report address the issue of youth and migration in Africa?

    -The report addresses the issue of youth and migration in Africa by highlighting the voices of young irregular migrants. It points out that these young people are part of a generation with unfulfilled ambitions and dreams, and it emphasizes the need for accelerated development and improved Human Development Index in Africa to provide opportunities for these youth.

  • What are the key statistics mentioned in the report regarding migration?

    -The report mentions that between 2014 and 2018, about 30,000 people lost their lives in transit, with the largest percentage of these losses occurring over the Mediterranean Sea. It also states that 272 million people are international migrants worldwide, which is 3.5 percent of the global population.

  • Why is it crucial to understand the individual stories of migrants?

    -Understanding the individual stories of migrants is crucial because each decision to migrate comes with a whole story that influences the choices made. By understanding these stories, policymakers and development agencies can better address the reasons behind migration and work towards solutions that respect the human aspect of this global phenomenon.

  • What role does the UNDP play in addressing migration?

    -The UNDP plays a significant role in addressing migration by adding depth and diversity of experience to the discussion, particularly focusing on irregular migrants. It aims to humanize migration discussions, provide a platform for genuine voices of those shaping development, and offer insights into why people choose to migrate.

  • How does the report challenge the perception of migration as a problem?

    -The report challenges the perception of migration as a problem by presenting it as a part of human history and future that can be managed well or poorly. It emphasizes the importance of understanding migration from a development perspective and focusing on the aspirations and experiences of migrants rather than viewing them as a threat.

  • What are the recommendations of the report for addressing migration?

    -The report recommends expanding opportunities and choices in Africa, particularly for the youth, as a critical factor in addressing migration. It also suggests the need for legal pathways for migration and addressing the policy vacuum that leads to visible dislocation of migrants in host countries.

  • How does the report link migration to development?

    -The report links migration to development by showing that migration is often a result of incomplete development and the lack of opportunities in migrants' home countries. It argues that accelerated development leading to an improved Human Development Index can provide opportunities and make home countries more attractive to their citizens.

  • What is the significance of the report's focus on irregular migrants?

    -The significance of the report's focus on irregular migrants is to bring attention to a group that is often marginalized and not part of the development decision-making process. By focusing on their voices and experiences, the report aims to influence policy and bring a more human and comprehensive perspective to the migration debate.

Outlines
00:00
🌟 Introduction to the Development Program and Migration's Role

The speaker expresses gratitude and emphasizes the importance of understanding migration from a development perspective. They introduce the topic as a critical aspect of the United Nations' development program, highlighting the need to comprehend the relationship between migration and development. The speaker acknowledges the complexity of migration, noting its historical and ongoing significance and the importance of addressing it from a human and developmental angle rather than merely as a problem.

05:03
🌐 The Complexity of Migration and Its Global Impact

The paragraph delves into the multifaceted nature of migration, dispelling myths that migrants are solely motivated by poverty or repression. It underscores the hyperconnected world we live in and the UN Development Program's focus on youth, particularly in Africa. The speaker challenges the audience to consider the broader implications of migration beyond simplistic explanations, emphasizing the need for a nuanced understanding that encompasses both the experiences of migrants and the socio-economic conditions in their home countries.

10:05
πŸ“ˆ Statistics and Stories of African Migration

Presenting sobering statistics, the speaker highlights the tragic loss of life among migrants, particularly young Africans, who have perished during their journeys. The paragraph calls attention to the urgency of understanding the drivers of migration and the importance of hope. It also introduces the 'Scaling Fences' report, which aims to provide a deeper understanding of the experiences and perspectives of irregular migrants, as well as the need for a more constructive discourse on migration and development.

15:15
🌍 The Journey and Experiences of African Migrants in Europe

The speaker discusses the methodology and findings of the 'Scaling Fences' report, which focuses on self-declared development migrants from African countries now living in Europe. The report covers various aspects, including the social structures, motivations, and journeys of these individuals. It also examines their life in Europe, their aspirations, and how these have evolved since their arrival. The speaker emphasizes the importance of understanding the broader context of migration and the need for policies that address the root causes.

20:17
πŸ™οΈ Urbanization and the Educational Background of Migrants

This paragraph focuses on the urban origins of the migrants and their educational background. It reveals that the majority of migrants come from urban environments and have a higher level of education than their peers in Africa. The speaker discusses the implications of these findings, suggesting that migration is not solely driven by a lack of jobs or extreme poverty, but also by the pursuit of greater opportunities and the ambition to succeed.

25:18
🀝 Family Ties and Financial Support for Migrants

The paragraph explores the significant role of family investment in migration, with many migrants receiving financial assistance from family and friends. It also discusses the migrants' employment status in Europe, highlighting the discrepancy between their skilled jobs in Africa and the lower-skilled jobs they often take in Europe. The speaker emphasizes the migrants' commitment to supporting their families back home through remittances, which represent a significant portion of their income.

30:20
🌱 The Role of Development and Opportunities in Africa

The speaker addresses the relationship between migration and development, emphasizing that addressing the development deficit in Africa is crucial for stemming migration. They discuss the importance of creating opportunities for youth in Africa and the role of good governance in fostering an environment that allows individuals to meet their ambitions. The paragraph also touches on the visible displacement caused by policy vacuums and its impact on migration debates.

35:25
πŸ“š Communication, Perception, and Policy in Migration Management

The paragraph discusses the importance of communication in shaping the narrative around migration. It emphasizes the need for African governments to effectively communicate opportunities available to their youth to encourage them to stay. The speaker also highlights the role of the private sector and media in promoting positive stories of success and opportunity in Africa. Additionally, the paragraph touches on the challenges of managing migration policy, particularly in terms of regularizing existing irregular migrants without encouraging further irregular migration.

40:27
πŸ€” Addressing the Root Causes of Migration

The speaker stresses the importance of addressing the root causes of migration, rather than just the symptoms. They argue for a comprehensive approach that considers the development needs of African countries and the aspirations of their youth. The paragraph also calls for a global effort to manage migration as a historic and ongoing phenomenon, advocating for coordinated action among all stakeholders to find sustainable solutions.

45:28
🌟 Concluding Remarks and the Launch of the Report

In the concluding remarks, the speaker reiterates the importance of changing the discourse around migration and emphasizes the potential for migration to be a positive force for development. The speaker calls for investment in creating hope and opportunity, both in the countries of origin and destination, and for policies that respect the ambitions of migrants. The report 'Scaling Fences: Voices of Irregular African Migrants to Europe' is officially launched, aiming to provide a deeper understanding and spur a more constructive conversation on migration.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘Migration
Migration refers to the movement of people from one place to another with the intent of establishing a new, usually permanent, residence. In the context of the video, it is a central theme as it discusses the reasons behind migration from Africa to Europe, the experiences of migrants, and the impact of migration on both the migrants and the regions they leave and go to.
πŸ’‘Irregular Migration
Irregular migration is the act of migrating without complying with the necessary laws and procedures, often involving unauthorized border crossings. The video focuses on this type of migration, highlighting the challenges and complexities faced by those who undertake such journeys, as well as the policy and social implications.
πŸ’‘Development
Development in this context refers to the process of improving the economic, social, and environmental well-being of a region or country. The video emphasizes the link between underdevelopment and migration, suggesting that a lack of opportunities and fulfillment of ambitions in African countries drives migration.
πŸ’‘Human Development Report
The Human Development Report is an annual report published by the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) that focuses on various aspects of human development. The video mentions a 2009 report that began to address the issue of migration, indicating the report's role in shaping the discourse on migration and development.
πŸ’‘Ellis Island
Ellis Island, mentioned in the video, is a historical site in the United States known for being the entry point for many immigrants. It serves as a metaphor for understanding the long history of migration and the diverse experiences of migrants, illustrating the complex nature of migration as a phenomenon.
πŸ’‘African Diaspora
The African diaspora refers to the communities of people of African origin living outside Africa. The video discusses the experiences and challenges of this group, particularly those who have migrated irregularly, and how their stories and voices are often unheard in the broader migration discourse.
πŸ’‘Youth
Youth is a recurring theme in the video, with a focus on the aspirations, ambitions, and challenges faced by young African migrants. The discussion highlights how the lack of opportunities for youth in Africa contributes to migration, and the potential impact of harnessing the energy and drive of this demographic.
πŸ’‘UNDP
The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) is an agency that aims to eradicate poverty and reduce inequality. The video discusses the UNDP's role in conducting research and presenting reports on migration, which aim to influence policy and improve understanding of the issue from a development perspective.
πŸ’‘Scaling the Fence
Scaling the Fence is a report mentioned in the video that explores the experiences of African migrants in Europe. The report is used to illustrate the challenges faced by migrants and to highlight the need for a more nuanced understanding of migration that goes beyond viewing it as a problem.
πŸ’‘Remittances
Remittances are money transfers sent by migrants to their home countries. The video discusses the significant role remittances play in supporting families back home, emphasizing the economic contribution of migrants to their countries of origin despite the challenges they face in their host countries.
πŸ’‘Policy真空 (Policy Vacuum)
Policy vacuum refers to a lack of effective policy or regulation in a particular area. In the context of the video, it is used to describe the absence of comprehensive policies that could address the root causes of irregular migration or provide legal pathways for migrants, contributing to the visibility and challenges faced by migrants in Europe.
Highlights

Migration is a complex phenomenon that is neither new nor will it end, and it is essential to understand its relationship with development.

The report 'Scaling the Fences' aims to address migration from a development perspective rather than viewing it solely as a problem.

Irregular migration is often a choice made by individuals when they perceive better opportunities abroad than in their home country.

The journey of migrants is marked by significant challenges and risks, yet many would choose to make the journey again due to the prospects abroad.

The report emphasizes the importance of including the voices of migrants in the development discourse to understand their motivations and experiences.

Migration is often driven by a lack of opportunities and ambition rather than just economic necessity.

The report challenges the stereotype of irregular migrants, showing that many are educated and from urban environments.

There is a need for safer and more legal pathways for migration to reduce the risks and improve the integration of migrants.

The experiences of African migrants in Europe highlight the need for better policies that address the aspirations and contributions of migrants.

The report calls for a shift in the perception of migration from a threat to an opportunity that can benefit both host and origin countries.

The role of youth in migration is significant, with many young Africans migrating due to limited opportunities to fulfill their ambitions at home.

The report suggests that development efforts should focus on expanding opportunities and choices for youth in Africa to reduce irregular migration.

There is a strong correlation between migration and the Human Development Index, indicating that improved development can influence migration patterns.

The report emphasizes the importance of including migrants in the development process, recognizing their potential as agents of change.

Policymakers are encouraged to use the insights from the report to create more effective and humane migration policies.

The discussion around migration needs to evolve to consider the broader implications on development and the potential benefits of managed migration.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: