$150 Honda Clone vs $600 Honda? Let’s settle this! Fuel Efficiency, Horsepower, Durability, Starting

Project Farm
5 Feb 202314:07
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRIn this video, the host compares four different gasoline engines - the Honda GX200, a knockoff Honda, the Harbor Freight Predator, and the Briggs and Stratton - across various performance metrics. After 48 hours of running, the engines are evaluated on fuel efficiency, oil consumption, torque, and speed. The Honda demonstrates superior performance but the Predator offers the best value for money, balancing cost with competitive performance.

Takeaways
  • πŸ’° Cost Comparison - The Honda GX200 is priced at $400-$600, while the knockoff is around $150, and the Predator and Briggs & Stratton are priced at $312 and $208 respectively.
  • πŸš€ Power Ratings - The knockoff claims 6.5 horsepower but has a sticker indicating 7.5 horsepower, the genuine Honda is rated at 5.5 horsepower, Predator and Briggs & Stratton are both around 6.5 horsepower.
  • 🏭 Manufacturing Origins - The knockoff Honda is made in China, while the genuine Honda is made in Thailand, Predator is made in China, and Briggs & Stratton is also made in China.
  • πŸ“ˆ Performance Testing - Engines were tested for 48 hours for fuel efficiency, oil consumption, torque, and speed in dragging a tractor trailer and Cousin Eddie.
  • πŸ’‘ Fuel Efficiency - The Honda used 29 pounds of fuel in 24 hours, the knockoff used 30 pounds, showing a slight advantage for the Honda.
  • πŸ”₯ Oil Consumption - The knockoff Honda burned more oil than the genuine Honda, indicating potential issues with engine longevity.
  • πŸ“Š Noise and Vibration - The knockoff Honda was louder and vibrated more than the genuine Honda, while the Predator and Briggs & Stratton had similar noise and vibration levels.
  • πŸ› οΈ Maintenance - The genuine Honda has a better air filter system and is heavier, suggesting potentially better build quality and durability.
  • 🏎️ Tractor Trailer Test - The genuine Honda outperformed the knockoff in pulling power, while the Predator showed the best average time in the speed test.
  • πŸ“‰ Engine Wear - Oil analysis showed the knockoff Honda had more aluminum, indicating more wear, but all engines had low levels of chromium, suggesting minimal piston ring wear.
  • 🌑️ Cold Weather Performance - All engines started easily in cold weather conditions, showing good cold start performance.
Q & A

  • What is the main purpose of the comparison in the script?

    -The main purpose of the comparison is to evaluate the performance, fuel efficiency, oil consumption, and overall value of different engine brands, specifically a Honda motor, its knockoff, Briggs and Stratton, and Harbor Freight Predator, to determine which offers the best value for money.

  • How much horsepower does the knockoff Honda engine claim to make?

    -The knockoff Honda engine claims to make 6.5 horsepower, but there's a sticker on the side of the motor indicating it makes 7.5 horsepower.

  • What are some of the features of the genuine Honda engine mentioned in the script?

    -The genuine Honda engine is designed for commercial applications, has a cast iron cylinder sleeve for longer service life, claims to start easily and run quietly, and includes a paper filter and foam cover for air intake. It is made in Thailand and comes with an NGK spark plug.

  • How did the knockoff Honda engine perform in the 48-hour test compared to the genuine Honda engine?

    -The knockoff Honda engine consumed more oil than the genuine Honda, as it had to have oil added twice to prevent it from running out. In terms of fuel consumption, both engines were close, but the genuine Honda was slightly more fuel-efficient. The knockoff also vibrated significantly more than the genuine Honda, indicating potential imbalance and durability issues.

  • What was the outcome of the oil analysis for the engines tested?

    -The oil analysis showed that the knockoff Honda had more aluminum in the oil, indicating more wear, while the Predator had the most chromium, suggesting piston ring wear. However, the levels of wear metals were low across all engines. The knockoff Honda also had the lowest amount of iron and the highest percentage of insolubles in the oil.

  • How did the engines perform in the go-kart test?

    -In the go-kart test, the genuine Honda outperformed the knockoff Honda and was faster than the Harbor Freight Predator and Briggs and Stratton in the 100-foot run. The Predator had the fastest average time, followed closely by the Honda, while the Briggs and Stratton came in last.

  • What was observed about the engines' performance in cold weather?

    -All engines were able to start on the first pull despite being left outside overnight in just below freezing temperatures, indicating good cold start performance.

  • What is the price range of the genuine Honda engine mentioned in the script?

    -The genuine Honda engine is priced between four to six hundred dollars.

  • What is the main conclusion drawn from the tests conducted on the engines?

    -While the genuine Honda engine seems to be the best in terms of performance and durability, the Harbor Freight Predator offers the best value considering its lower price and competitive performance.

  • What is the significance of the vibration levels observed in the engines?

    -High vibration levels, as observed in the knockoff Honda, can indicate potential durability issues and may lead to the engine shaking itself apart over time, affecting its lifespan and reliability.

  • What additional test was conducted to evaluate the engines' performance?

    -An additional test conducted was the 100-foot run without a trailer to evaluate the engines' performance across the entire RPM range, which gave insights into their acceleration and top speed capabilities.

Outlines
00:00
🚜 Engine Comparison and Testing

This paragraph introduces a comparative analysis of different engines, including a Honda motor, a knockoff Honda, a Briggs and Stratton, and a Harbor Freight Predator. The focus is on evaluating their fuel efficiency, oil consumption, torque, and overall performance. The engines are put through a 48-hour test, and their specifications are detailed, such as horsepower, materials, and country of manufacture. The Honda clone is compared directly to the genuine Honda engine, highlighting the differences in air filter systems, spark plugs, and weight. The paragraph sets the stage for a comprehensive engine performance test.

05:00
🏎️ Performance and Efficiency Results

The second paragraph delves into the results of the engine performance tests. It discusses the fuel and oil consumption of the Honda and the Honda clone over a 48-hour period. The Honda clone is found to be louder and less clean-burning than the Honda. Additionally, the paragraph covers the oil analysis, revealing that the Honda clone burns more oil than the Honda. The engines' weights and the amount of fuel used are compared, showing that the Honda is more fuel-efficient than the Honda clone. The paragraph also includes a detailed account of the testing process, including the use of fuel cells and the alternator setup.

10:01
🏁 Drag and RPM Range Testing

The final paragraph focuses on the drag and RPM range tests conducted on the engines. It describes the performance of the Honda clone, Honda, Harbor Freight Predator, and Briggs and Stratton in pulling a go-kart and a lawn tractor, as well as Cousin Eddie. The Harbor Freight Predator outperforms the others in the drag test, while the Honda has the fastest average time in the 100-foot run without a trailer. The cold weather performance of the engines is also tested, with all engines starting successfully despite being left outside overnight. The oil analysis reports are mentioned again, with the Predator showing the highest levels of wear metals. The paragraph concludes with a summary of the overall performance and value of each engine, highlighting the Predator as the best value considering its price and performance.

Mindmap
Keywords
πŸ’‘Honda motor
The Honda motor is a commercial-grade engine designed for most demanding and commercial applications. In the video, it is compared with knockoff and other brand engines in terms of performance, fuel efficiency, oil consumption, and durability. The Honda motor is noted for its precision-engineered components that result in low vibration and is advertised to start easily and run quietly.
πŸ’‘Knockoff
A knockoff refers to a replica or imitation product, often sold at a lower price than the original. In the context of the video, a knockoff Honda motor is tested alongside the genuine Honda motor and other brands to evaluate its performance and value for money. The knockoff is noted to have a similar horsepower rating but differences in build quality and performance become evident under testing.
πŸ’‘Fuel efficiency
Fuel efficiency refers to the energy efficiency or mileage extracted from a particular type of fuel by an engine or motor. In the video, fuel efficiency is one of the critical parameters compared among different engines, with measurements taken after running the engines for 48 hours to determine which engine uses less fuel for the same amount of work.
πŸ’‘Oil consumption
Oil consumption refers to the amount of motor oil used or burned by an engine over a certain period of operation. In the context of the video, oil consumption is another performance metric evaluated by measuring the amount of oil used by each engine after 48 hours of running time, indicating the engine's efficiency and potential for wear over time.
πŸ’‘Torque
Torque is a measure of the rotational force an engine can produce. It is a critical factor in determining an engine's ability to perform tasks that require moving or turning something, such as dragging a load. In the video, the engines are tested for the amount of torque they can generate, with the Honda engine outperforming the knockoff Honda in this aspect.
πŸ’‘Drag test
A drag test, as mentioned in the video, is a performance test where an engine's ability to pull a load, in this case, a tractor trailer and Cousin Eddie, is measured. This test evaluates the engine's power and torque under practical, real-world conditions.
πŸ’‘Vibration
Vibration in an engine refers to the oscillatory motion or trembling that occurs during operation, which can affect the engine's performance and longevity. The video discusses the low vibration of the Honda engine due to its precision-engineered components, and compares this with the knockoff and other engines to evaluate the build quality and smoothness of operation.
πŸ’‘Air filter system
The air filter system in an engine is designed to remove dust, dirt, and other contaminants from the air before it enters the engine. A good air filter system helps to protect the engine from damage and improves its performance and efficiency. In the video, the genuine Honda engine is noted to have a much better air filter system compared to the knockoff, which has a paper filter and foam cover.
πŸ’‘Spark plug
A spark plug is a device that ignites the air-fuel mixture in an internal combustion engine by generating an electric spark. It is a critical component that affects the engine's performance and fuel efficiency. The video compares the spark plugs used in different engines, with the genuine Honda coming with an NGK spark plug and the knockoff using a spark plug made by SAP.
πŸ’‘Wear metal content
Wear metal content refers to the levels of metal particles found in engine oil, which can be an indicator of the engine's internal wear. Analyzing wear metals can help determine the health of an engine and predict its future performance. In the video, oil samples from the engines are sent to a lab to measure the wear metal content, providing insights into the engines' conditions after 48 hours of operation.
πŸ’‘Value for money
Value for money refers to the worth or benefit you get from a product relative to its cost. In the context of the video, it is used to evaluate whether the cheaper knockoff engine and the Harbor Freight Predator offer a better cost-performance ratio compared to the more expensive genuine Honda engine.
Highlights

Comparing engines from Honda, Briggs and Stratton, Harbor Freight Predator, and a knockoff Honda, with a focus on performance and cost.

Running engines for 48 hours to compare fuel efficiency and oil consumption.

Evaluating torque production among the different engines.

Assessing the speed of each engine in dragging a tractor trailer and Cousin Eddie.

The knockoff Honda claims to have 6.5 horsepower and uses high-quality materials, but lacks a paper filter.

The genuine Honda GX200 is advertised as a commercial-grade engine with low vibration and a cast iron cylinder sleeve for longevity.

The Predator, sold at Harbor Freight, has a 212 CC overhead valve engine and is compared for performance and fuel efficiency.

Briggs and Stratton's 208cc engine is耐用 with a durable cast iron sleeve and is rated for similar horsepower as the others.

Measuring engine vibration and balance, with the Honda clone showing excessive vibration.

Fuel and oil consumption results show the Honda clone has a slight advantage in fuel efficiency but burns more oil.

Oil analysis reveals the knockoff Honda has more aluminum in the oil, indicating potential wear.

The Predator outperforms the other engines in the go-kart test, showing the best value for its price.

Cold weather performance test shows all engines starting successfully despite being left outside overnight.

The genuine Honda engine demonstrates better performance overall but is more expensive than the alternatives.

The Briggs and Stratton struggles in performance tests but has consistent results.

The Harbor Freight Predator has the lowest amount of wear metal chromium, indicating good durability.

The knockoff Honda has the lowest amount of iron in the oil, suggesting less engine wear.

The Honda clone's excessive insolubles in the oil may be due to its higher oil content from additional refills during the test.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Best Beginner Motorcycles! Ninja 400 vs Meteor 350 vs CRF300L vs Sondors Metacycle vs G310GS | CTXP

Four Stroke Engine | Petrol vs Diesel Engine | Turbocharger | Cylinder And Piston | CC of Engine

Advanced Rider Motorcycle Tier List

Carnot Heat Engines, Efficiency, Refrigerators, Pumps, Entropy, Thermodynamics - Second Law, Physics

The 9 Best Beginner Adventure Motorcycles: Best Entry-Level ADV Bikes for New Riders (2023 Edition)

HORSEPOWER VS TORQUE SIMPLEST EXPLANATION

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Engine ComparisonHonda vs KnockoffPerformance TestingFuel EfficiencyDurability TestPower OutputLawn EquipmentMechanical ReviewConsumer GuideMaintenance Tips