The Difference Between Socialism, Communism, and Marxism Explained by a Marxist

azureScapegoat
18 Feb 201711:25
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe video script by azureScapegoat clarifies the common misconceptions surrounding the terms Socialism, Communism, and Marxism. It explains that while these terms are often used interchangeably, they represent distinct ideologies. Socialism is a broad term that can vary in meaning, but essentially refers to a society where the means of production are owned collectively, rather than by private individuals. Communism aims for a stateless, moneyless, and classless society, and is distinct from the so-called 'Communist states' which are actually socialist states ruled by a Communist Party. Marxism is a form of socialism that envisions a transitional phase of socialism before reaching communism, while Social Democracy is a revisionist form of Marxism that has adapted to a more capitalist-friendly approach. The video emphasizes the complexity of these ideologies and encourages further exploration and understanding of socialism.

Takeaways
  • 📜 The terms 'Socialism', 'Communism', and 'Marxism' are often confused and misused, leading to misunderstandings of their meanings and applications.
  • 🌐 Scandinavian countries like Sweden and Denmark are often incorrectly labeled as 'Socialist' due to their extensive social welfare systems, but are actually examples of Capitalism with social democratic policies.
  • 🏛️ Bernie Sanders, a prominent figure in American politics, identifies as a Socialist and often cites Scandinavian models as examples of successful social democracies.
  • 🇨🇳 The People's Republic of China describes itself as 'Socialist with Chinese characteristics', but operates under a predominantly Capitalistic market system with significant government control.
  • 🗺️ Cuba is an example of a country that practices 'Communism', with a state-planned economy and a single-party political system led by the Communist Party.
  • 📈 The definition of 'Socialism' is a society where the means of production, distribution, and exchange are owned by the community, with the state often acting as a representative of the community.
  • 🚀 Communism as an ideology aims for a stateless, moneyless, and classless society, where wealth acquisition is not the driving force of individuals' actions.
  • 🔄 Marxism is an umbrella term for ideologies that seek to transition from Capitalism to Communism, with various branches such as Anarchism, Social Democracy, and Democratic Socialism.
  • 🔄 Social Democracy is a form of Revisionist Marxism that has adapted to be a more 'friendly' version of Capitalism, often followed by countries in Western Europe.
  • 🔄 Democratic Socialism is distinct from Social Democracy in that it is anti-Capitalistic and seeks to establish a socialist mode of production alongside a democratic system.
  • 🌟 The video script encourages further exploration of Socialism and its potential effects on society, directing viewers to Socialism101.com for more information and to address common questions and misconceptions.
Q & A

  • What is the main confusion surrounding the terms 'Socialism', 'Communism', and 'Marxism'?

    -The main confusion arises from the misuse and misunderstanding of these terms, often used interchangeably. People often label political figures or ideologies with these terms without a clear understanding of their meanings and differences.

  • What does Bernie Sanders' self-identification as a 'Socialist' imply?

    -Bernie Sanders identifies as a 'Socialist' to advocate for a social welfare system similar to Scandinavian countries, emphasizing government-provided benefits like free education and healthcare, funded by higher taxes on the wealthy.

  • Why is Scandinavia often mistakenly called 'Socialist'?

    -Scandinavia is mistakenly called 'Socialist' because it has a strong social welfare system, but in reality, it operates under a capitalist system with a mix of private and public ownership, following a social democratic model rather than pure socialism.

  • How does the economic system in China differ from that of Cuba?

    -China has a mainly capitalist free-market system with significant government control and social security measures, while Cuba operates under a communist system with a public planned economy, where the state makes decisions about production, distribution, and wages.

  • What was the economic system of Nazi Germany, and how does it relate to the term 'Socialism'?

    -Nazi Germany had a largely capitalist economy with some protectionist measures and state interventions. Despite the term 'National Socialist' in the party name, the economy remained predominantly capitalist with a free market, not fitting the definition of socialism.

  • What is the definition of 'Socialism'?

    -Socialism is a society where the means of production, distribution, and exchange are owned by the community as a whole, rather than private individuals, aiming for collective ownership and control.

  • What are the key characteristics of a 'Communist Society'?

    -A Communist Society is stateless, moneyless, and classless, where wealth acquisition is not the driving force in people's lives, and the focus is on improving humanity as a whole.

  • How does 'Social Democracy' differ from 'Democratic Socialism'?

    -Social Democracy is a 'friendly' version of capitalism with a strong welfare system and state intervention, while Democratic Socialism is anti-capitalistic, aiming to establish a socialist mode of production alongside a democratic system, and may involve revolutionary means to achieve its goals.

  • What is the relationship between 'Marxism' and 'Anarchism'?

    -Both Marxism and Anarchism are socialist ideologies, but马克思主义 believes in a transitional period of socialism before reaching communism, while Anarchism seeks to establish communism directly after the overthrow of capitalism, bypassing the transitional phase.

  • What are some of the branches under 'Orthodox Marxism'?

    -Under Orthodox Marxism, there are branches such as Luxemburgism, Leninism, Trotskyism, Maoism, among others, each with their own interpretations and extensions of Marx's original theories.

  • What is the purpose of the website Socialism101.com mentioned in the script?

    -Socialism101.com is a website created to answer common questions about socialism, its workings, potential challenges, and misconceptions, aiming to educate people on the true nature of socialism.

Outlines
00:00
📚 Understanding the Terminology: Socialism, Communism, and Marxism

This paragraph clarifies the common confusion surrounding the terms Socialism, Communism, and Marxism. It highlights the misuse of these terms, especially in the context of political figures like Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump, and attempts to provide a clear definition of Socialism as a society where the means of production are owned by the community. The paragraph also touches on the differences between Scandinavian countries, China, Cuba, and the Nazis' self-identification as 'Socialist', emphasizing the vast disparities in practice and ideology among them.

05:05
🌐 The Spectrum of Socialist Ideologies

This section delves into the various ideologies that fall under the umbrella of Socialism, creating a visual infographic to illustrate the relationships between them. It contrasts Socialism with Capitalism and explains Communism as a stateless, moneyless, and classless society. The paragraph differentiates between the Western concept of a 'Communist State' and the ideal of a Communist Society, highlighting the roles of Anarchism and Classical Marxism. It further breaks down Classical Marxism into Orthodox and Revisionist Marxism, with Social Democracy and Democratic Socialism as key examples of the latter. The summary underscores the nuanced differences and common goals within these ideologies, despite their varying approaches to achieving a Socialist or Communist society.

10:05
🔄 Evolution and Diversification of Marxist Thought

This paragraph discusses the evolution of Marxist thought after Karl Marx's death, with various tendencies and ideologies emerging from Orthodox Marxism. It mentions Leninism, Trotskyism, Maoism, and others as extensions of the original Marxist principles. The paragraph also addresses the relationship between Anarchists and Marxists, noting their ability to collaborate toward the shared goal of Communism. Additionally, it distinguishes Democratic Socialism from Social Democracy, emphasizing the anti-Capitalistic nature of the former. The section concludes with a call to action for further education on Socialism and an invitation for viewers to engage in discussion and seek clarification on the presented topics.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Socialism
Socialism is a socio-economic system where the means of production, distribution, and exchange are owned or regulated by the community as a whole. In the context of the video, it's a term often misused or misunderstood, with various examples like Scandinavia being incorrectly labeled as socialist despite having capitalist elements with strong social democratic policies.
💡Communism
Communism is an ideological and social structure that aims to establish a stateless, moneyless, and classless society. The video explains that it is a stage beyond socialism, where wealth acquisition is not the driving force in life. Communism is contrasted with the Western concept of a 'Communist State', which is actually a socialist state ruled by a Communist Party, like the former USSR.
💡Marxism
Marxism is a social, political, and economic theory originated by Karl Marx, which argues that social change comes from the conflict of social classes and that capitalism will eventually be replaced by socialism and then communism. The video discusses different branches of Marxism, including Orthodox Marxism, which continues Marx's work, and Revisionist Marxism, which adapts or changes fundamental parts of Marx's theories.
💡Capitalism
Capitalism is an economic system where trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit. It is presented in the video as the opposite of socialism, with the two systems having fundamentally different approaches to the ownership and control of the means of production. The video also touches on how Scandinavian countries are often mistakenly considered socialist when they actually follow a form of capitalism with social democratic policies.
💡Social Democracy
Social Democracy is a political and economic ideology that aims to soften the inequalities and excesses of capitalism with a regulatory welfare state. In the video, it is described as a form of Revisionist Marxism that has adapted so much from the original Marxism that it is no longer socialistic but rather a 'friendly' version of capitalism, as seen in countries like Scandinavia and France.
💡Democratic Socialism
Democratic Socialism is an ideology that seeks to combine a socialist mode of production with a democratic political system. The video explains that it is distinct from Social Democracy in that it is anti-capitalistic in theory, aiming to establish socialism through democratic means, which may include elections or revolutionary means to establish 'real democracy' alongside socialism.
💡Anarchism
Anarchism is a political philosophy and movement that rejects all involuntary, coercive forms of hierarchy and authority. In the video, it is contrasted with Marxism, with the key difference being that anarchists seek to establish communism directly after the overthrow of capitalism without a transition period through socialism.
💡Nazis
The term 'Nazi' is a shorthand for 'Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei' or 'The National-Socialist German Workers' Party.' The video points out that despite the term 'Socialist' in their name, the Nazis' economic system was largely capitalist with totalitarian government control, illustrating the misuse and confusion around the term 'socialism.'
💡Cuba
Cuba is mentioned in the video as an example of a country that identifies as 'Socialist,' with a public planned economy where the state owns the means of production, distribution, and exchange. However, it is noted that even though Cuba is led by the Communist Party, it considers itself socialist, not communist, highlighting the complexity and varied interpretations of these terms.
💡China
The People's Republic of China is described in the video as a country that calls itself 'Socialist' with Chinese characteristics, implying a form of socialism adapted to its specific national context. The video suggests that despite its self-identification as socialist, China operates under a mainly capitalist free-market system with significant government intervention and social security.
💡Bernie Sanders
Bernie Sanders is mentioned as a political figure who identifies as a socialist and advocates for policies similar to those found in Scandinavian countries, such as free education and healthcare. The video uses Sanders to illustrate the common misconception in the United States about what socialism entails and to highlight the differences between his version of socialism and the definitions provided.
Highlights

Socialism, Communism, and Marxism are often confused terms, but they have distinct meanings and applications.

The term 'Socialist' has been applied to various political figures and ideologies, such as Bernie Sanders and Scandinavian countries, often inaccurately.

Scandinavian countries like Sweden and Denmark are often mistakenly labeled as 'Socialist', but they operate primarily under a social democratic model within a capitalist framework.

China identifies itself as 'Socialist' with Chinese characteristics, yet it maintains a predominantly capitalist market system with significant government control.

Cuba is an example of a country that identifies as 'Socialist', with a planned economy and state ownership of the means of production, distribution, and exchange.

The Nazis, or 'Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei', also referred to themselves as 'Socialist', but their economic model was largely capitalist with totalitarian control.

The definition of 'Socialism' is a society where the means of production, distribution, and exchange are owned by the community, rather than private individuals.

Socialism as an ideology aims to transition towards a society that fits its definition, encompassing various other ideologies such as Communism and Social Democracy.

Communism is a stateless, moneyless, and classless society, aiming to establish a Communist Society through the transition of Socialism from Capitalism.

Anarchism and Marxism are two branches of Communism, with the former seeking to establish Communism directly after the overthrow of Capitalism, bypassing the transitional period of Socialism.

Social Democracy is a form of Revisionist Marxism that has adapted to a 'friendly' version of Capitalism, straying from its original Socialistic roots.

Democratic Socialism is distinct from Social Democracy, as it remains anti-Capitalistic and seeks to establish a society with a Socialist mode of production alongside a democratic system.

Orthodox Marxism continues the work of Karl Marx, expanding his theories after his death, while Revisionist Marxism adapts or changes fundamental parts of the original Marxism.

Anarchists and Marxists, specifically Orthodox Marxists, can collaborate toward the common goal of Communism, despite differences in their approaches.

Luxemburgism, Leninism, Trotskyism, Maoism are tendencies within Orthodox Marxism, each with their own nuanced interpretations and applications of Marx's work.

The video provides a resource for further learning about Socialism and its various forms, as well as addressing common arguments and misconceptions.

Socialism101.com is a website created to answer common questions about Socialism and its practical implications, offering an educational resource for viewers.

The transcript encourages viewers to engage in discussions and provide feedback for clarification and deeper understanding of the topics presented.

Transcripts

Browse More Related Video

Communism | The 20th century | World history | Khan Academy

Capitalism, Socialism, and Communism Compared

CAPITALISM, SOCIALISM & COMMUNISM EXPLAINED SIMPLY

What is Marxism? | Marxism Explained | Who was Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels? Communist Manifesto

Socialism Vs Communism | What is the difference between Socialism and Communism?

11 - Why Every Communist Country is a One-Party Dictatorship

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating:

Related Tags
Political IdeologiesEconomic SystemsSocialism ExplainedCommunist ManifestoScandinavian ModelPeople's Republic of ChinaCuban EconomyNazism and SocialismSocial Democratic RevisionismDemocratic Socialism