Why you SHOULDN’T go to graduate school!

Shane Hummus
24 Aug 202014:12
EducationalLearning
32 Likes 10 Comments

TLDRThe video discusses the drawbacks of pursuing higher education, particularly in fields like psychology, where undergraduate degrees may not lead to lucrative job opportunities. It highlights the student debt crisis, the predatory nature of graduate loans, the lengthy time required to complete advanced degrees, the high attrition rate in graduate programs, and the low return on investment for master's and doctoral degrees. The speaker argues that the current education system can be likened to a pyramid scheme, with few reaching the top and many left with significant debt and limited career prospects.

Takeaways
  • 🎓 Undergraduate psychology degrees are often seen as poor job investments due to limited job opportunities and low pay.
  • 📈 The common belief is that higher-level degrees (master's or doctoral) can compensate for a less marketable bachelor's degree.
  • 💰 The student debt crisis is severe, with over $1.7 trillion in federal student debt, largely driven by graduate school borrowing.
  • 🚀 Liberal arts and arts degrees might actually improve medical or law school admission chances due to quotas.
  • 🔄 The cycle of undergraduate to graduate education can be likened to a sales funnel or upsell, encouraging more expensive education.
  • 📈 Graduate school loans, like Grad PLUS, have higher interest rates and start accruing interest while still in school, leading to significant debt.
  • 🕰️ The time to complete higher degrees is often underestimated; PhDs on average take 8.2 years to complete.
  • 🎓 Many graduate students do not finish their programs; only 57% of PhD students graduate within 10 years.
  • 🧩 The academic job market is structured similarly to a pyramid scheme, with few positions at the top and many overqualified candidates.
  • 💸 Despite the investment, those with higher degrees do not necessarily earn significantly more than those with bachelor's degrees.
  • 🎥 The video encourages viewers to consider the financial and personal implications of pursuing higher education and to make informed decisions.
Q & A
  • What is the main argument the speaker makes about undergraduate psychology degrees?

    -The speaker argues that obtaining an undergraduate degree in psychology is not a good idea because it is difficult to find well-paying jobs with such a degree, and the advice to simply pursue a master's or doctoral degree afterward is misleading and may lead to increased student debt without a guaranteed improvement in job prospects.

  • What is the total federal student debt mentioned in the video?

    -The total federal student debt mentioned in the video is 1.7 trillion dollars.

  • Why does the speaker disagree with the notion that it doesn't matter what undergraduate degree one gets if they plan to pursue higher education?

    -The speaker disagrees because they believe that choosing the wrong undergraduate degree can lead to a cycle of accumulating more student debt by pursuing increasingly expensive higher degrees in the hope of improving job prospects, which often does not solve the issue of employability.

  • What is the average time it takes to complete a PhD?

    -The average time it takes to complete a PhD is 8.2 years, which is in addition to the time spent obtaining a bachelor's degree.

  • What are the characteristics of the student loan debt crisis?

    -The student loan debt crisis is characterized by the total debt being over 1.7 trillion dollars, surpassing credit card and auto debt, with more than half of this debt owed by those with graduate degrees. The crisis is exacerbated by many individuals choosing degrees that lead to poor job prospects and high levels of debt.

  • What type of loans typically have higher interest rates for graduate students?

    -Grad Plus loans and Parent Plus loans typically have higher interest rates for graduate students, with rates as high as 7.6 percent plus a 4.2 percent servicing fee.

  • What is the speaker's view on the length of time it takes to become a doctor?

    -The speaker believes that the process of becoming a doctor takes a very long time, with medical school lasting four years, followed by a residency that can range from three to seven years, and possibly an additional fellowship. This means that doctors may not start earning a significant income until their late 30s and could be in substantial debt by that time.

  • What percentage of PhD students graduate within 10 years?

    -Only 57 percent of PhD students graduate within 10 years.

  • How does the speaker compare the structure of academia to a pyramid scheme?

    -The speaker compares academia to a pyramid scheme because only those at the top, such as university presidents, tend to benefit significantly. Many students invest in higher education degrees with the hope of achieving academic or professional success, but the majority face limited job opportunities, low pay, and high levels of debt, similar to the structure of a pyramid scheme where only those at the top profit.

  • What is the average income difference between those with a bachelor's degree and those with a master's or a PhD?

    -Master's level degrees earn about 23 percent more than bachelor's degrees, and PhDs earn about 26 percent more than bachelor's degrees, despite the significantly higher costs and longer time investment required for the higher degrees.

  • What advice does the speaker give to those who are determined to pursue a doctoral level degree?

    -The speaker advises those who are set on pursuing a doctoral level degree to ignore the warnings about the potential financial and career challenges, as passion and determination for a specific career path may outweigh the risks involved.

Outlines
00:00
🎓 The Pitfalls of Pursuing Higher Education

The paragraph discusses the common misconception that obtaining a higher degree, such as a master's or doctorate, will guarantee better job prospects and financial stability. It highlights the issue of student debt, emphasizing that a significant portion of this debt comes from graduate programs. The speaker argues against the idea that one can simply pursue their passion at the undergraduate level and then easily transition to a higher degree for better job opportunities, as this often leads to increased debt and limited job prospects.

05:01
💰 The Financial Burden of Graduate Degrees

This paragraph delves into the financial implications of taking out loans for graduate studies. It contrasts the relatively lower interest rates of undergraduate loans with the much higher rates of graduate loans, including Grad PLUS and Parent PLUS loans. The speaker points out that the interest starts accruing immediately, even while students are still in school, leading to a potential doubling of the loan amount by the time they start earning a professional income. The paragraph also provides statistics on the average debt for various degrees, highlighting the significant financial burden that graduate students face.

10:02
🕒 The Time Commitment of Advanced Degrees

The speaker addresses the misconception that doctoral degrees can be completed in a short period, often within two years. Instead, the average time to complete a PhD is 8.2 years, significantly longer than commonly believed. This extended timeline, combined with the age at which one enters graduate school, means that the average PhD graduate is 33 years old and carries a substantial amount of debt. The paragraph also touches on the additional time required for residencies and fellowships in professional fields, further delaying financial independence.

🏆 The Reality of Graduating and Finding Success

This paragraph highlights the challenges of completing a PhD program, with only 57% of students graduating within 10 years. It discusses the pressures and exploitation faced by graduate students, including long hours and the potential for advisors to misuse their power. The speaker shares a personal story of a friend whose work was claimed by an advisor, illustrating the power dynamics within academia. The paragraph also points out that even with a doctorate, securing a tenured professorship is not guaranteed, and many end up in the job market with limited opportunities and high levels of debt.

🔄 The Pyramid Scheme of Higher Education

The speaker compares the structure of academia to a pyramid scheme, where only those at the top benefit. The paragraph discusses how the system encourages students to pursue higher degrees with the promise of better job prospects, which often does not materialize. It points out the irony of teachers teaching others to teach and the limited number of academic positions available. The speaker also mentions the subreddit r/gradschool as a resource for those who believe academia operates like a scam, and cautions viewers to be careful when considering graduate studies.

💸 Earning Potential vs. Educational Level

The paragraph challenges the notion that higher degrees lead to significantly higher earnings. It presents statistics showing that master's degree holders earn only about 23% more than bachelor's degree holders, despite the higher cost of education. For PhD holders, the increase is even smaller at around 26% more than bachelor's degree holders, and this comes after an additional eight years of study and a substantial increase in debt. The speaker argues that from a personal finance perspective, pursuing a higher degree is often not a good investment.

Mindmap
Keywords
💡Undergraduate Degree
An undergraduate degree is the first level of higher education that one can achieve, typically requiring four years of study. In the context of the video, the speaker argues that obtaining an undergraduate degree in psychology may not be a good investment due to limited job prospects and lower pay.
💡Graduate School
Graduate school refers to higher education that comes after an undergraduate degree, including master's and doctoral programs. The video discusses the increasing trend of students pursuing graduate degrees due to the belief that higher qualifications will lead to better job opportunities and higher salaries.
💡Student Debt Crisis
The student debt crisis refers to the escalating problem of outstanding student loan debt that has reached unsustainable levels for many individuals and the economy as a whole. The video emphasizes the severity of this crisis, with over $1.7 trillion in federal student debt, much of which is owed by those with graduate degrees.
💡Interest Rates
Interest rates are the percentage of the loan amount that is charged by the lender as a fee for borrowing money. In the context of the video, it is mentioned that interest rates on undergraduate loans are relatively lower compared to the much higher rates on graduate plus loans.
💡Supply and Demand
Supply and demand is an economic principle that describes the relationship between the quantity of a commodity that producers wish to sell at various prices and the quantity that consumers wish to buy. In the video, this concept is used to explain why certain higher degrees do not necessarily lead to better job prospects or higher salaries.
💡金字塔骗局 (Pyramid Scheme)
A pyramid scheme is a fraudulent business model that recruits members with the promise of payments or services for enlisting additional recruits. In the video, the speaker draws a parallel between the structure of academia, particularly the pursuit of higher degrees, and a pyramid scheme, where only those at the top benefit.
💡Completion Rates
Completion rates refer to the percentage of students who start a degree program and successfully finish it. The video emphasizes that many students who begin graduate programs, especially PhDs, do not complete them, leading to wasted time and resources.
💡Advisor
An advisor in an academic context is a faculty member who guides and supervises a student's academic progress, particularly in graduate studies. The video discusses the critical role of a good advisor in the success of a graduate student, contrasting it with the potential negative impact of a poor advisor.
💡Residencies and Fellowships
Residencies and fellowships are advanced training programs that professionals, especially in fields like medicine, undertake after completing their formal education. The video explains that these programs are lengthy and often required before one can practice in their field, contributing to the significant debt and delayed income associated with professional degrees.
💡Personal Finance
Personal finance refers to the management of one's financial matters, including budgeting, investing, and planning for the future. The video critiques the financial decision of pursuing higher education degrees, arguing that from a personal finance perspective, the investment often does not yield a proportional return.
💡Career Prospects
Career prospects refer to the potential opportunities for employment and advancement in a particular field. The video challenges the common belief that higher education always leads to better career prospects, pointing out that overeducation can lead to a mismatch between qualifications and available jobs.
Highlights

Undergraduate psychology degrees are often discouraged due to limited job prospects and lower pay.

Master's or doctoral degrees in psychology are suggested as a solution for better job opportunities and pay.

The student debt crisis is out of control, with total federal student debt at 1.7 trillion dollars.

Over half of the student debt is owed by those with graduate degrees, indicating a potential issue with higher education.

The narrative of getting a bachelor's degree and then pursuing a master's or doctorate to improve job prospects is critiqued.

The system is likened to a sales funnel, encouraging students to pursue higher and more expensive degrees.

Graduate school loans, such as Grad PLUS and Parent PLUS, have high interest rates and fees, making them predatory.

The average time to complete a PhD is 8.2 years, much longer than commonly perceived.

Many professional degrees, like a medical doctor, require additional years of residency and fellowships.

Only 57% of PhD students graduate within 10 years, with completion rates varying by field of study.

Advisors in graduate programs can have significant influence over a student's success and the quality of their experience.

The structure of academia is compared to a pyramid scheme, with few positions at the top and many overqualified individuals at lower levels.

Master's degrees earn only 23% more than bachelor's degrees, despite costing significantly more.

PhDs earn only about 3% more than master's degree holders, despite the additional time and cost.

The video encourages viewers to critically consider their choice of degree and the potential financial burden of higher education.

Despite the criticisms, the video acknowledges that some individuals may still pursue higher degrees due to personal passion or career goals.

The video concludes by encouraging viewers to engage in discussion and share their thoughts on the topic.

Transcripts
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Thanks for rating: